Indonesian Shoemakers Fear Trump Tariffs Despite Lower Levy
The United States is Indonesia's biggest market for footwear exports and the American president announced Tuesday he would impose 19 percent tolls on top of a baseline 10 percent for Southeast Asia's biggest economy.
The measure was lower than the initial extra 32 percent Trump threatened in April, and better than the 20 percent he imposed on Vietnam.
But Etnawati, who had plans to expand her business to the United States, said her focus would now shift to other markets.
"I have to develop a new strategy. Perhaps we have to diversify our markets, products, and so on. If it's possible to enter (the US market), but... not in large quantities at first, that's it," she told AFP.
"We can't rely solely on the US. There's still many markets in the world. We can still shift.
"I plan to shift focus to Japan and Russian partners."
In return for a lower tariff, Indonesia pledged billions to increase energy, agriculture and merchandise imports from the US and Trump said Jakarta had pledged to buy 50 Boeing jets.
It remains unclear when the new tariff rate Trump announced will come into effect and reaction from Indonesian officials has been muted while President Prabowo Subianto travels home from a Europe visit.
But chief negotiator Airlangga Hartarto, after meeting top US officials in Washington, said last week that the talks had been "positive".
Prabowo suggested after the initial tariff threat in April that Trump was maybe helping Jakarta by causing it to re-think its trade surplus with the world's top economy.
Data from the US Trade Representative office shows Washington's goods trade deficit with Indonesia was $17.9 billion in 2024, up 5.4 percent from the year before.
Indonesia is the third-largest footwear exporter to the US behind China and Vietnam, according to the Observatory of Economic Complexity.
So any new tariff was likely to damage business -- particularly in Bandung, where its shoe scene is well-known internationally for beautifully hand-crafted quality leather boots.
Economists in Indonesia hit out at the deal with Washington, which Trump says would get tariff-free access in return.
"This is not an agreement. It's... a one-sided agreement," Jakarta-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) executive director Yose Rizal Damuri told AFP on Wednesday.
But he predicted American consumers would likely bear the costs more than Indonesian businesses, with Trump's tariffs sweeping across many countries.
"The United States itself will be the one more affected. Prices will rise," he said.
Data on Tuesday showed US inflation spiked in June as the tolls kicked on.
The shop's more seasoned workers such as Jajang -- who goes by one name -- have already experienced the ups and downs of business, with the Covid-19 pandemic hitting sales, and seeing dozens of colleagues laid off and several dying.
"I don't know about that issue, the important thing is that I work here," said the 53-year-old when asked about Trump's levies.
Others aware of the Trump threat to Indonesian exports were more concerned.
One of Etnawati's workers, Lili Suja'i, chipped away at a new set of boots for the three-pair Texan order -- riding boots, medium casual boots and loafers -- in a workshop adjacent to the store.
He said he feared US customers would be put off by higher costs, with the shop his main income for his family of three.
But the shoemakers are ready to fulfil any orders from Americans willing to pay the extra price.
"I'm worried, yes, but before placing an order, we negotiate the shipping costs and prices with the customer," the 38-year-old said.
"So, we've already made a deal. If they're OK with it, we'll do it." An artisan works on a pair of leather boots at the workshop of Tegep Boots in Bandung, West Java AFP The United States is Indonesia's biggest market for footwear exports and the American president announced Tuesday he would impose 19 percent tolls on top of a baseline 10 percent for Southeast Asia's biggest economy AFP An artisan works on a pair of leather boots for the US market at the workshop of Tegep Boots AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
an hour ago
- Int'l Business Times
Russian Deputies Back Fines For Clicking On 'Extremist' Content
Russian lawmakers on Thursday advanced a bill that would outlaw opening or searching for content online judged "extremist", such as songs glorifying Ukraine and material by feminist rock band Pussy Riot. Critics say the planned law, which has drawn rare criticism from across Russia's political spectrum, would stifle internet freedom. Russian authorities already block access to thousands of websites accused of hosting "extremist" content. The latest proposed legislation threatens fines of up to 5,000 rubles ($64) on anyone found to have deliberately searched for or gained access to material listed as extremist by the justice ministry. More than 5,000 entries are on the list, including web pages, political slogans, books, artworks and music albums. Among them are songs glorifying Ukraine, blog posts by feminist rock band Pussy Riot and information on the Wikipedia page for dynamite. Deputies in the lower house State Duma backed the bill by 283 votes to 22 in its second reading. It is not clear whether the bill has the support of the government. The Kremlin said the proposal needed "more detailed explanations" to allay people's concerns. "I am not familiar with the initiative by the deputies," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said in response to a question from AFP. The bill requires three readings and approval by Russia's upper house before President Vladimir Putin can sign it into law. During Thursday's second reading, lawmaker Alexander Teterdinko of the governing United Russia party said the legislation would only affect those who "deliberately" search for extremist material. "That is to say, if you Google something and material appears in the search results, but you do not click on it, do not read it, do not use it in any way... you will not fall under this article," he said. Other lawmakers, however, expressed concern over the apparent lack of safeguards. The bill was originally about tightening regulation over shipping clerks, but evolved as lawmakers inserted amendments. Deputy State Duma Speaker Vladislav Davankov called components of the bill an "attack on the basic rights of citizens". Russia's internet safety tsar warned the legislation would stifle her department's work. The bill would also ban advertising for virtual private networks (VPNs) and impose fines for transferring SIM cards to another person, both ways of browsing with more privacy. Margarita Simonyan, the editor-in-chief of pro-Kremlin broadcaster Russia Today, said the legislation would make it impossible to investigate and expose extremist groups. "I hope there will be amendments," she said on Telegram.
Int'l Business Times
an hour ago
- Int'l Business Times
Ukraine's New PM: A Deal-maker As Head Of Wartime Government
Yulia Svyrydenko, Ukraine's new prime minister, represents a generation of young Ukrainian politicians who have steered their country through the turmoil of war. The 39-year-old, who was appointed economy minister just months before the Kremlin launched its full-scale assault in February 2022, shot to international prominence this year when she championed a vital economic accord between Kyiv and Washington. "It is a great honor for me to lead the Government of Ukraine today," Svyrydenko said on social media, adding that "war leaves no room for delay. We must act swiftly and decisively". Svyrydenko led fraught negotiations around a minerals and investment agreement with the United States that nearly derailed ties between Kyiv and its most important military ally. The deal was central to a disastrous televised spat between Zelensky and US President Donald Trump in February 2025. Not long after, Svyrydenko travelled to Washington to finalise an agreement that many Ukrainians hoped would placate Trump by giving him a sellable victory and ensure more critical US support for Kyiv. "She was the key and the only person leading these negotiations. She managed to prevent them from unravelling," said Tymofiy Mylovanov, a former economy minister who worked with Svyrydenko. She earned the respect of US partners during the negotiations, according to several analysts, including Mylovanov, who described Svyrydenko as preferring a level-headed, non-confrontational approach in politics. Svyrydenko is also viewed as loyal to the powerful head of Zelensky's office, Andriy Yermak, with some seeing her nomination as another attempt from the presidency to consolidate power. She is taking the helm at a precarious moment, in a country exhausted by more than three years of war and dependent on its foreign allies for survival. The role of prime minister does not typically include a say on military strategy or frontline operations, where Zelensky and his military chiefs call the shots. Yet Svyrydenko is central to a young generation of Ukrainian leaders, like Zelensky, who have guided the country through the Russian invasion and contrast starkly with the Soviet-styled elites that dominate in Russia. She was not yet 30 when the Kremlin helped foment a violent overthrow of authorities in eastern Ukraine, as popular protests demanded that Kyiv pursue closer integration with Europe. And her native region of Chernigiv, which borders Russia and its war ally Belarus, was briefly occupied at the start of the invasion launched in February 2022. Despite being ravaged and facing a potentially crippling recession, she kept Ukraine's economy afloat during the war, including by pushing for some businesses to have exemptions from key staff being mobilised into the armed forces. Keeping businesses going will be "her legacy as the wartime economy minister," Andy Hunder, president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Ukraine, told AFP. "Svyrydenko is emblematic of the Ukrainian people's resilience," then-US Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo wrote of her in Time Magazine in 2023. Svyrydenko, who mostly avoids the press, moved through the ranks of government quickly after graduating with honours from the National University of Trade and Economics and a brief spell in the private sector. She held a variety of posts in her native Chernigiv region before being appointed by presidential decree as deputy head of the president's office in 2020. Less than a year later, she became deputy prime minister and economy minister. Svyrydenko has said that civil service was a part of her life since childhood, as both her parents worked in government. "I saw how they devoted themselves to serving the community, how their hometown and its improvement were their core values," she recently told Ukrainian media.
DW
2 hours ago
- DW
Trump tariffs: SE Asia worried as US targets transshipments – DW – 07/17/2025
The US wants to crack down on Chinese goods in disguise — and Southeast Asian countries are caught in the crossfire. Earlier this month, Washington announced a new US–Vietnam trade deal, under which Vietnamese exports to the US will face a 20% tariff, down from the threatened 46%. However, "transshipped" goods would be subject to a 40% levy. In international trade, this refers to goods that are shipped from the origin country to an intermediate location, only to be relabeled or tweaked and exported again to the final destination. The US tariffs on transshipments are widely seen as a push to curb other countries' economic relations with China. For years, Bejijng has been accused of re-routing goods through Southeast Asian countries before export to the US to dodge high tariffs. This week, US President Donald Trump announced that he had also reached an agreement with Indonesia's President Prabowo Subianto that would see the tariff rate on Southeast Asia's largest economy drop from the previously threatened 32% to 19%. Commenting on the Indonesia agreement on social media, Trump noted that "if there is any Transshipment from a higher Tariff Country, then that Tariff will be added on to the Tariff that Indonesia is paying." In April, Trump's influential trade adviser Peter Navarro dubbed Vietnam "essentially a colony of communist China." "Vietnam sells us $15 for every $1 that we sell them and about $5 of that is just Chinese product that comes into Vietnam, they slap a 'Made in Vietnam' label on it and they send it here to evade the tariffs," Navarro added. In 2024, Vietnam imported $144 billion (€124 billion) worth of goods from China and exported $136.6 billion worth of goods to the US. The Vietnam agreement was the third trade deal the US president has reached, after deals with the UK and China. Several Southeast Asian states reliant on exports to the US, such as Thailand and Cambodia, are racing to finalize terms before the new deadline of August 1 arrives. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Much depends on how Washington defines transshipment. In one scenario, Washington could use a narrow classification and apply it only to Chinese products imported into a country solely for relabeling and re-exporting to the US. In other words, the more egregious cases involve Chinese goods being shipped into Southeast Asian ports, literally labeled as "Made in Vietnam" or "Made in Cambodia," and then re-exported. If this definition is adopted, analysts agree that it would have little impact on Southeast Asian countries, as they derive almost no financial benefits from these types of zero-value-added goods and are also interested in ending this practice. Vietnam had already established new mechanisms to combat fraud and illegal transshipment before the US agreement was announced. In May, Thailand's Department of Foreign Trade announced that it would strengthen inspections for transshipment and expand the watch list of products at risk of circumvention from 49 to 65 to address US concerns. However, Washington could also decide to be punitive and define "transshipment" as any good that contains a certain percentage of inputs and components from China. This could spell economic calamity for Southeast Asian nations. Given that most Vietnamese-manufactured goods contain some percentage of Chinese inputs, a low threshold definition could mean that most exports are subject to the 40% tariff rate, rather than the lesser and more internationally competitive 20%. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Moreover, many US companies like Apple, Google, Nike, and Gap with factories in Vietnam also still rely on Chinese inputs. "If a Samsung phone assembled in Vietnam is comprised of 75% imported components, is it a Vietnamese product?" pondered Zachary Abuza, a professor at the National War College in Washington. "The Trump administration clearly wants to target China, but the reality is Vietnam is highly dependent on inputs from China for its manufacturing sector," he told DW, adding that while Hanoi also wants to reduce this dependency, it cannot achieve that in a year or two. Le Hong Hiep, a senior fellow at the ISEAS — Yusof Ishak Institute's Vietnam Studies Program in Singapore, believes that a very broad definition of transshipment is not likely. Vietnamese officials and US importers, as well as US multinational corporations with manufacturing operations in Vietnam, have strong incentives to oppose a strict or overly broad definition, he noted. He says that the US is targeting transshipments for two main reasons. "Economically, they aim to gradually decouple China from the global economy, or at least from the Southeast Asian countries that maintain robust trade ties with Washington," he told DW. "In the long run, this is expected to weaken China's economy and constrain its rise," he added. For instance, the threat of higher tariffs for transshipments will pressure Southeast Asian manufacturers to diversify their sources of inputs and components away from China. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The second objective, said Hiep, is to generate diplomatic tensions between Southeast Asian nations and China, especially if these countries comply with the US' imposition of higher transshipment tariff rates. "Such frictions may work to Washington's advantage by strengthening its position in the ongoing competition with China for regional diplomatic and strategic influence," said Hiep. After the US and Vietnam reached an agreement earlier this month, Beijing responded by saying that Southeast Asian countries shouldn't agree to terms that come at the expense of China. "Should such a situation arise, China will never accept it and will take resolute countermeasures to safeguard its legitimate rights and interests," a spokesperson for the Chinese Ministry of Commerce said at the time, according to the Reuters news agency. It remains unclear what countermeasures Beijing had in mind, but an aggressive response could harm the interests of Southeast Asian states, including Vietnam, that are engaged in escalating territorial disputes with Beijing over the South China Sea.
