‘Extortion, not connectivity': Telecom body COAI accuses Mumbai metro of blocking fair access to mobile network
COAI
) has launched a sharp attack on
Mumbai Metro
, accusing the public transport body of creating a 'monopolistic and extortionate' environment for mobile network access within metro premises. The COAI alleges that instead of allowing
telecom operators
to install
In-Building Solutions
(IBS) directly, at their own cost, the Metro has handed over exclusive rights to a third-party vendor, demanding exorbitant charges in return.
The move, COAI claims, flies in the face of the new
Telecommunications Act
and Right of Way (RoW) rules, which prohibit public authorities from denying telecom infrastructure access in public spaces.
'Telecom Service Providers are always willing to provide connectivity through IBS. However, Mumbai Metro has created a monopoly… and is now trying to extract monopolistic and extortionate rents,' said COAI director general S P Kochhar.
Kochhar compared the situation with Delhi's Pragati Maidan tunnel and Central Vista, where telcos have set up infrastructure free of cost and without bureaucratic obstruction.
'Deploying networks in high-footfall public infrastructure is standard practice, and doesn't cost the public authority anything,' he said.
In a bid to avoid service disruption for lakhs of daily commuters, telecom firms, including Jio, Airtel, and Vodafone Idea, jointly offered to provide connectivity free of cost during the trial phase, pending a formal agreement. That April 7 proposal, COAI said, was ignored by Mumbai Metro.
COAI also rejected the Metro's claim of following precedent, saying, 'Wrong precedent does not make a legitimate one. The industry is addressing such monopolies with a view to stop these extortionate practices.'
With commuter connectivity hanging in the balance, the COAI's message is clear: allow fair access, or risk denying Mumbai its rightful digital infrastructure.
Stay informed with the latest
business
news, updates on
bank holidays
and
public holidays
.
AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
CM to inaugurate slew of projects today; Metro-3 may launch by Aug end
MUMBAI: On the eve of Independence Day and with local body polls approaching, chief minister Devendra Fadnavis will preside over a string of infrastructure inaugurations in Mumbai — from flyovers and bridges to a motormen training centre and redeveloped housing. But the much-awaited third phase of Metro-3, between Worli and Cuffe Parade, will not be part of the current spree, with officials indicating a launch towards the end of August. CM to inaugurate slew of projects today; Metro-3 may launch by Aug end The 9.1-km stretch, part of the Aqua Line, had initially been expected to open on August 15, but a Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation (MMRC) official said work on two Kalbadevi stations — slowed by the area's dense and congested layout — is still being completed. 'We are targeting an inauguration by the end of August,' the official added. On Tuesday, Fadnavis will attend three separate functions organised by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA). These will include the inauguration of the 2.75-km flyover connecting Mumbai University to Vile Parle, aimed at easing the notorious Santacruz bottleneck; a new bridge between Kalanagar and Dharavi to improve east-west connectivity; and a Metro motormen training centre at Mandale, which will save operators the trouble of travelling to Hyderabad and other cities for training. The chief minister will also inaugurate MMRDA staff quarters at Malvani. Another key highlight will be the symbolic handover of keys to 556 tenants from the redeveloped BDD chawls in Worli — marking the completion of the project's first phase — followed by the opening of the International Experience Centre at the Dabbewala Bhavan in Bandra West.
Business Standard
4 hours ago
- Business Standard
Telecom firms oppose direct spectrum allocation plan for pvt 5G networks
Indian telcos have opposed a proposal from the department of telecommunications (DoT) on allotting airwaves for private 5G networks through direct allocation. According to them, such a move would be detrimental to national security and result in exclusion of revenue that would have come from auctioning these airwaves. Reiterating their views on the matter, the carriers have argued that deployment of private 5G networks independently would be costlier for companies. This is because they would have to spend significantly on equipment, spectrum management, security, network maintenance and skilled personnel, besides regular upgradation of technology, which would again require investments. They added that captive non-public 5G networks (CNPNs) should be permitted through licensed telecom operators only through spectrum leasing or network slicing. A CNPN is a communication network meant for an enterprise or entity's own use and not for public use. Having little to no latency, the solutions were first mooted when 5G auctions were held in 2022, with the intent of offering dedicated and glitch-free connectivity to industries like manufacturing, fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) and others. 'All enterprise 5G needs must be fulfilled through licensed telecom service providers (TSPs) via spectrum leasing or network slicing as this would ensure national security, revenue protection and regulatory parity in this rapidly-evolving ecosystem,' said SP Kochhar, director general at the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI), in a statement on Monday. ALSO READ: Tata group's Nelco, Eutelsat tie up for OneWeb LEO satellite connectivity COAI represents leading telcos Reliance Jio, Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea that together cater to over one billion mobile phone users in the country. 'One must also consider the significant loss to the government exchequer in case of private networks as the national auction of spectrum generated ₹1.5 trillion in 2022 alone,' the industry body added. It added that such a move from the government would create an uneven playing field between telcos and private entities. These entities enjoy infrastructure benefits without comparable regulatory or financial obligations. 'Private networks managed by unlicensed or foreign entities raise serious national security concerns as these players are not bound by the same compliance, interception and regulatory obligations as TSPs,' the COAI argued further. It noted that without a clear regulatory framework, there would be no accountability in case of misuse, breach or attack. It could also hinder the government's ability to ensure lawful interception, user traceability and emergency response coordination. It would thus open up the country to cybersecurity, surveillance and diplomatic risks. The industry said that CNPNs would work for countries like the US, Finland, Germany and the UK, where there were geographically secluded areas with limited public network coverage. This was not the case for India which had no coverage deficit. It also warned that unlicensed private networks could cause signal interference and disrupt public networks. COAI's views come at time when DoT has asked for opinion on whether the spectrum should be given directly, which means not through the regular mechanism of auctions. The government assessed the demand for direct spectrum allocation for private networks in July. If approved, enterprises or companies could get spectrum directly, bypassing telcos. Back in 2022, carriers had pegged CNPNs as potential revenue generators as they could charge enterprises for leasing spectrum or even put up their 5G networks for a fee.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Nelco signs pact with Eutelsat to deliver OneWeb LEO services pan-India
NEW DELHI: The Tata group's satellite communications ( satcom ) firm, Nelco , signed an agreement with French Eutelsat to deliver OneWeb low-Earth orbit (LEO) services across India. Under the agreement, Nelco will partner with OneWeb India Communications, Eutelsat's local operating entity, to deliver secure, low-latency LEO connectivity for terrestrial, maritime and aviation sector customers, covering government and enterprise applications. These capabilities will strengthen India's digital infrastructure and national security, while ensuring reliable connectivity in underserved areas, the companies said in a joint statement. Nelco said it is well geared to offer services to its customers as soon as the OneWeb LEO services become commercially operational in the country. 'We are pleased to partner with Eutelsat to bring OneWeb LEO satellite connectivity services to India. This partnership marks a significant step in enabling reliable, secure, and high-speed communication solutions based on LEO services for critical sectors across land, sea, and air,' said PJ Nath, MD & CEO of Nelco. Nath added that the agreement is aligned with Nelco's strategy to provide multi-orbit satellite connectivity services for driving India's digital ecosystem and supporting the country's strategic communication needs. 'We are proud to partner with Nelco to deliver advanced LEO connectivity services in India. This agreement strengthens our strategic footprint in one of the world's most dynamic and fast-growing connectivity markets and underscores our commitment to supporting India's digital and security ambitions,' said Neha Idnani, regional vice president for APAC & director of OneWeb India. Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel, part of the Bharti Group, which is a large shareholder in Eutelsat OneWeb , signed marketing tie-ups with billionaire Elon Musk's Starlink earlier this year. India's space economy has the potential to hit $44 billion by 2033 and account for about 8% of the global share, as per IN-SPACe. The country's annual satcom business revenue opportunity is pegged at $1 billion.
