CJP-Aurangzeb huddle stirs the pot
In a rare turn of events, Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Yahya Afridi and Federal Minister for Finance and Revenue Senator Muhammad Aurangzeb have met face-to-face, stirring debate in legal circles about the propriety of such an engagement.
The meeting between the judiciary's top office and the government's economic helm underscored the need for "coordinated efforts" between the judiciary and the executive to uphold the rule of law and safeguard citizens' rights.
The unusual interaction, held without the Attorney General for Pakistan (AGP) Mansoor Awan present, was accompanied by an official photograph and press release, a move many lawyers believe was "uncalled for" and fraught with optics that blur the fine line between the judiciary and the executive.
The meeting underscored the importance of coordinated efforts between the judiciary and the executive in upholding the rule of law and safeguarding citizens' fundamental rights.
Some insiders point out that CJP Afridi and Aurangzeb are also former college fellows, stressing that the meeting should be viewed in that light.
Nonetheless, for many lawyers, such engagements are "against judicial norms", particularly when the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), which operates under the finance ministry, is one of the largest litigants before the Supreme Court.
FBR disputes in spotlight
Meanwhile, concerns are already high over the functioning of Alternate Dispute Resolution Committees (ADRCs) — bodies working under the FBR's administrative control to resolve tax-related matters, especially those involving state-owned enterprises (SOEs).
Just last month, a bench headed by CJP Afridi ordered a stay on proceedings in all cases pending before ADRCs. The court also flagged concerns over how ADRC members were appointed, directing the FBR to seek input from all stakeholders before finalising the appointment framework.
The matter will be heard again on September 8.
One lawyer representing an SOE argued that the ADRC mechanism had proven "destructive" for such enterprises. "They are being crushed with taxation and have no remedy against the ADRC," he said, alleging that billions of rupees in taxes had been forcibly recovered in June, without legally required notices, to meet revenue targets.
"All profit-making SOEs are being destroyed," he added, while another counsel argued that the ADRCs must operate independently and free from FBR influence to have credibility.
Judicial independence worries
Since the passage of the 26th Constitutional Amendment, legal experts have expressed unease over what they see as growing executive dominance over the judiciary. Even tax lawyers complain that higher courts were offering little relief to individuals aggrieved by FBR orders.
The Sindh High Court, for instance, has reportedly delivered hundreds of judgments in the FBR's favour. At the SC, judges with expertise in revenue law are often not assigned to such matters.
Against this backdrop, the optics of the CJP meeting the finance minister have unsettled some lawyers, who fear it may send the wrong signal to business stakeholders whose cases are awaiting adjudication in the apex court.
They argue that the country's top judge should avoid creating any perception that the judiciary and executive are "on the same page" when it comes to revenue collection.
However, it is also pertinent to mention that CJP Afridi has shown a willingness to engage across the political spectrum. In recent weeks, he has also met with PTI leader Omar Ayub and Barrister Gohar.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
3 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Aurangzeb vows to close tax loopholes, boost investor confidence
Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb is interviewed during the G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors' Meeting at the IMF and World Bank's 2024 annual Spring Meetings in Washington. PHOTO: REUTERS Listen to article Federal Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb on Wednesday pledged to close tax loopholes, enhance investor confidence, and maintain economic reforms, as he addressed the Rawalpindi Chamber of Commerce and Industry's Independence Day event. Aurangzeb said international institutions had welcomed Pakistan's reform measures, while recent Gallup surveys showed rising economic confidence. He noted a 60% growth in the stock exchange, an increase in new investors, and 250,000 new company registrations. Aurangzeb suggested the key policy rate could be cut further this year, citing falls in average and core inflation. Earlier in May, governor SBP, in a press conference along with other Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) members, announced a 100 bps cut, highlighting an improved inflation outlook and signs of moderate economic recovery. Beating the market expectations of a 0-50bps cut, the central bank reduced the policy rate by 100bps to 11% in a meeting," wrote Topline Securities. "We expect interest rates to come down to 10% by Dec 2025." Read: Policy rate slashed to 11% The minister said the government had finalised economic growth-focused agreements with the IMF, reached a favourable tariff deal with the United States, and was working on key accords with China. Panda bonds would be issued by year-end, and a benchmark for Sukuk bonds had been set, the finance czar. Aurangzeb further highlighted ongoing rightsising of 45 ministries, accelerated privatisation of state enterprises, and reductions in electricity tariffs, with further energy cost improvements expected. He assured that taxation reforms would not burden the salaried class and that the prime minister was personally overseeing FBR's transformation. Monthly meetings with chambers would be held to address business concerns. Read more: PM approves creation of digital ecosystem at FBR Calling for unity, Aurangzeb said the private sector must lead economic growth, with the government's role being to provide a favourable business climate.
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Finance Minister Aurangzeb optimistic on policy rate cut
Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb signalled potential easing of Pakistan's policy rate later this year, noting slowing inflation and stable economic indicators, while addressing the 78th Independence Day of Pakistan and the Marka-e-Haque celebrations at the Rawalpindi Chamber of Commerce & Industry (RCCI) on Wednesday. 'I am always careful that the policy rate and the market-based exchange rate are very much under the purview of the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) and the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC). Having said that, citing core and average inflation, my personal view is that I do think there is room to do more in terms of the policy rate. 'I am very hopeful that during this calendar year, we will see movement on the policy rate going south,' he said. Last month, the MPC of the central bank decided to keep the policy rate unchanged at 11%. The decision contradicted market expectations, which had anticipated a rate cut of around 50 to 100 basis points (bps). The committee, back then, noted that inflation in June 2025 decelerated to 3.2% year-on-year, led mainly by lower food prices, whereas core inflation also declined slightly. During his address, the finance minister said that the international financial organisations have lauded the government's economic reform agenda. 'S&P and Fitch have already upgraded us, and I am very hopeful that soon the third agency [Moody's] will also upgrade us,' he said. Pakistan govt alarmed by over Rs6trn losses in state-owned enterprises Shifting to trade development, Aurangzeb said the recently announced deal with the United States 'provides a fantastic opportunity to capitalise on'. The government believes that Pakistan's exporters are poised to gain a significant competitive edge in the US market after the government successfully negotiated a reduction in reciprocal tariffs from 29% to 19%. This marks the lowest tariff rate in the region and presents a major opportunity to boost Pakistan's exports to the US. Meanwhile, the finance minister elaborated on his government's economic performance, saying that in recent years the size of the economy and overall income have increased, there is stability in the financial sector, a record reduction in fiscal deficit and inflation, the current account is in surplus, and a record rise in remittances is registered. 'National security and economic stability are essential for each other, and it is encouraging that over the past one and a half years, we have made strong progress on the economic front,' said Aurangzeb. He said that last year the government reduced its debt servicing cost by Rs1 trillion. It intends to repeat this feat in the current fiscal year as well, he said. He said that the transformation in the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is underway. 'I am very clear that taxation needs to be brought to a regionally competitive level. We cannot further burden the salaried class and the manufacturing sector,' Aurangzeb maintained.
Express Tribune
8 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Bourse enters consolidation phase
Listen to article The Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) closed marginally higher on Tuesday as it entered a consolidation phase, with the KSE-100 index gaining 75 points to close at a record high at 147,005. Analysts noted that investors adopted a cautious stance amid mixed sentiment, selective buying and profit-taking. Trading volumes registered an uptick, supported by gains in banking stocks, while weakness in fertiliser and energy sectors capped the advance. The market also got support from the ongoing Pakistan-US trade and investment discussions, a stable rupee and corporate earnings. According to Ahsan Mehanti of Arif Habib Corp, stocks closed higher on a strong earnings outlook and rupee stability. Speculation about Pakistan-US trade and investment deals and the government seeking further export incentives, and a rise in business confidence drove the PSX to a record high, he added. At the end of trading, the benchmark KSE-100 index recorded an increase of 75.48 points, or 0.05%, and settled at 147,005.32. In its review, Topline Securities commented that the KSE-100 index wrapped up the trading session at 147,005, marking a modest gain of 75 points. The market saw intra-day volatility as the index surged to the high of 147,977 before retreating to the low of 146,895, reflecting investor-driven profit-taking strategies, it said. Positive momentum in Bank Alfalah, HBL and Systems Limited provided a combined lift of 295 points, offering partial reprieve against the broader market weakness. In contrast, significant downward pressure stemmed from Fauji Fertiliser, Mari Petroleum, Oil and Gas Development Company (OGDC), Pakistan State Oil and Bank AL Habib, which shaved 527 points off the index, added Topline. In its commentary, Arif Habib Limited (AHL) noted that Tuesday marked a flat session, following Monday's surge, with the KSE-100 managing to close above 147,000. Some 47 shares rose while 53 fell, with Bank Alfalah (+5.28%), HBL (+2.04%) and Systems Limited (+1.73%) contributing the most to index gains. On the flip side, Fauji Fertiliser (-1.11%), Mari Petroleum (-2.51%) and OGDC (-2%) were the biggest drags, it said. AHL observed that Pakistan and US officials were in talks to finalise finer details of their trade deal, which included investment commitments from Washington. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb hinted at major US investment in different sectors. Additionally, Barrick Mining was seeking to raise $3.5 billion from international lenders, including US-backed institutions, to fund the Reko Diq copper and gold mining project. "Near-term index support remains at 146,000 points," added AHL. JS Global analyst Muhammad Hasan Ather said that the KSE-100 index closed flattish, inching up just 75 points. Gains were fuelled by strong corporate earnings, robust remittances and optimism about US-Pakistan investment ties following a new trade pact, he said. Institutional buying and improving macro indicators including a stable rupee and progress on circular debt resolution lifted sentiment. While short-term corrections are possible, the outlook remains bullish as foreign inflows, fiscal reforms and export prospects gain traction amid easing geopolitical tensions, he added. Overall trading volumes increased to 691.7 million shares compared with Monday's tally of 611.2 million. Traded value increased to Rs44.6 billion compared to Rs44 billion in the previous session. Shares of 482 companies were traded. Of these, 208 stocks closed higher, 242 dropped and 32 remained unchanged. Yousuf Weaving Mills was the volume leader with trading in 46.3 million shares, gaining Rs1 to close at Rs6.09. It was followed by Kohinoor Spinning Mills with 39.9 million shares, gaining Rs0.24 to close at Rs6.47 and Invest Bank with 34.4 million shares, gaining Rs1 to close at Rs9.68. Foreign investors bought shares worth Rs132.7 million, the National Clearing Company reported.
