Dying toddler waited 90 minutes for ambulance after call deemed 'not critical'
A critically ill toddler spent 90 of his remaining minutes before dying of sepsis waiting for an ambulance that could have come sooner if an emergency call was upgraded, an inquest has heard.
Theo Tuikubalau, three, was suffering from a high temperature, flu-like symptoms, breathing issues, and a loss of appetite when his mum, Kayleigh Kenneford, called 111 on the evening of July 7, 2022. The tot, who had already been admitted and discharged from Plymouth's Derriford Hospital with a suspected upper respiratory infection the day prior, was becoming increasingly unwell. But when Ms Kenneford placed the call to the service, the 111 differently appraised a critical symptom.
Jurors participating in an inquest at Devon Coroner's Court heard that the South West Ambulance Service Trust's Advanced Medical Priority Dispatch System (AMPDS) graded Theo's breathing difficulties as a category one - indicating "life-threatening illnesses or injuries" - on July 6.
But the 111 service's NHS Pathway - which uses a different method for grading emergencies from 999 calls - ranked similar symptoms as a category two the following day. The alternate appraisal meant crews took 90 minutes to reach Theo after Ms Kenneford first phoned for an ambulance shortly before 11pm on July 7.
Theo was taken back to Derriford – arriving shortly after 1am – where he died a few hours later from sepsis, caused by an 'invasive' Strep A infection. Jon Knight, head of emergency operations at the South West Ambulance Service Trust, reviewed the 111 call and was asked what would have happened if it had been made to his employers.
He said the childs' breathing difficulties would have triggered a category one through SWAST system. He said: "My belief is based on the trigger phrase that the patient was fighting for breath at the time, it would have triggered a cat one through the AMPDS system."
Mr Knight said he was dealing with 'hypotheticals' as to how quickly a category one ambulance that night would have reached Theo, but added it would have "certainly" arrived fewer than 90 minutes earlier. He said: "It is really hard to commit to a time. It certainly would have been quicker than 90 minutes, would be my belief.
'I think with the right set of circumstances – if you didn't have an ambulance available in the area and you were bringing one from Derriford Hospital – you are probably looking at 30 minutes.'
Mr Knight told the inquest that ambulance crews "made all the appropriate and correct decisions", however, with staff ready and waiting for the ambulance's arrival. Having reviewed documents relating to Theo's care that evening, he said the ambulance crew recognised he was seriously unwell and immediately took him to Derriford Hospital.
He said: 'I think the crew made all the appropriate and correct decisions in their decision to leave the scene and take Theo to hospital." He added: "I absolutely support all of the decision-making that was made at the time."
Andrew Morse, representing Theo's family, suggested if the call on July 7 had been assessed as a category one then he could have potentially arrived at the hospital by 11.45pm. He said: "On balance, given the testimony I've already given to the coroner, I think that that's a reasonable assumption."
The inquest heard there was a paramedic crew who could have reached Theo within 33 minutes had his call been graded as category one.
Megan Barker, Mr Knight's deputy, said: 'At best guess, if we compared that to the resource that did go approximately an hour and a bit later, it would have taken them around 30 to 33 minutes to get to Theo. We can guess that they would have spent a similar amount of time with Theo, so likely have had a hospital arrival time of about 30 minutes later.
'That puts us around maybe 12.10am.' The inquest before a jury at County Hall in Exeter continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
7 days ago
- Scottish Sun
Mum died at home an HOUR after medic said she looked ‘normal' – but missed key warning sign on her lips
After her death, it emerged Charlotte had group A streptococcus, a common but potentially deadly bacterial infection VITAL SIGNS Mum died at home an HOUR after medic said she looked 'normal' – but missed key warning sign on her lips Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) CHARLOTTE Alderson died of an infection at home hours after medics missed a key warning sign on her lips, an inquest heard. The mum-of-three from Suffolk had been vomiting and complained of excruciating headaches before she died on December 21, 2022. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Charlotte Alderson was not taken to hospital and died hours later, an inquest is told **TAKEN WITHOUT PERM** Credit: Family Handout An emergency medical technician (EMT) who attended the scene spoke to a GP on the phone about the 34-year-old's condition. Both decided Charlotte, a swimming instructor, did not need hospital treatment. After her death, it emerged Charlotte had group A streptococcus (Strep A), a common but potentially deadly bacterial infection. Her husband, Stuart Alderson, told Suffolk Coroner's Court that he had noticed a blue tinge on her lips, a classic warning sign of sepsis, a life-threatening infection. He said he called NHS 111 after Charlotte had been vomiting and suffering diarrhoea all night, and that she lacked energy, which was 'really unusual' for her. An ambulance was sent out, and Stuart said that the staff told him there was a 14-hour wait at the hospital and that Charlotte would "just get a blood test". "To my mind, I thought, 'Well if you think she's OK, we're happy to accept that decision not to go,'' the husband said, according to BBC reports. The inquest heard that Charlotte first fell ill on 15 December 2022 with cold symptoms and an earache. She saw her GP, who diagnosed an outer ear infection and prescribed a topical spray. Medical staff used a clinical scoring system called Centor, which suggested no antibiotics were needed. The signs and symptoms of sepsis to look out for, according to The UK Sepsis Trust The coroner later said another system, Feverpain, might have recommended antibiotics and potentially changed the outcome. EMT Morgan Burt said she did not see the blue tinge on Charlotte's lips, but if she had, it would have been treated as a 'high priority' case. A recording of a phone call between EMT Burt and on call GP, Dr Emma Ayers, was played in court. Dr Ayers said she thought Charlotte might have a viral infection and advised plenty of fluids and a Covid test. But she added: 'When I said it could be viral infection, that was only half of the sentence. I was thinking this could be bacterial and she could be septic.' Dr Ayers said she was not informed about the blue lips during the call and that had she known, she would have sent Charlotte straight to hospital as an emergency. 2 She also said that if she could change her advice, she would have invited Charlotte for an appointment that afternoon. Ambulance staff found Charlotte's temperature and heart rate slightly elevated but other signs 'generally within normal range.' With no immediate hospitalisation needed, the ambulance left at around 1pm. Charlotte's condition got worse that afternoon. Her husband went out to buy pain relief, but when he came back, he found her collapsed, unconscious but still breathing. He called 999 again at around 2pm, during which time Charlotte stopped breathing. Paramedics arrived just before 2:30pm and despite resuscitation efforts, she sadly passed away. A post-mortem confirmed the cause of death as multi-organ failure due to septic shock from the rapid spread of the bacterial infection. Sepsis spotting Suffolk Coroner Darren Stewart raised 'several matters of concern' about Charlotte's death. He warned the NHS's Feverpain and Centor scoring systems for infections can give conflicting results, and said using Feverpain might have led to antibiotics being prescribed earlier, possibly saving her. 'There is a need to review these scoring systems to provide guidance on a single system clinicians can rely on,' he said. He called for faster sepsis tests like CRP, finger prick, and lateral flow, stressing: 'The risks of sepsis and rapid deterioration are well known. We need urgent tools to help spot and treat it early.' The coroner also slammed the 111 call system for delays when ambulances must be booked manually, not automatically. The inquest is ongoing.
The Sun
7 days ago
- The Sun
Mum died at home just HOURS after medic said she looked ‘normal' – but missed key warning sign on her lips
CHARLOTTE Alderson died of an infection at home hours after medics missed a key warning sign on her lips, an inquest heard. The mum-of-three from Suffolk had been vomiting and complained of excruciating headaches before she died on 21 December 2022. An emergency medical technician (EMT) who attended the scene spoke to a GP on the phone about the 34-year-old's condition. Both decided Charlotte, a swimming instructor, did not need hospital treatment. After her death, it emerged Charlotte had group A streptococcus (Strep A), a common but potentially deadly bacterial infection. Her husband Stuart Alderson told Suffolk Coroner's Court that he had noticed a blue tinge on her lips, a classic warning sign of sepsis, a life-threatening infection. He said he called NHS 111 after Charlotte had been vomiting and suffering diarrhoea all night, and that she lacked energy, which was 'really unusual' for her. An ambulance was sent out, and Stuart added that the staff told him there was a 14-hour wait at the hospital and that Charlotte would "just get a blood test". "To my mind, I thought, 'Well if you think she's OK, we're happy to accept that decision not to go,'' the husband said, according to BBC reports. The inquest heard that Charlotte first fell ill on 15 December 2022 with cold symptoms and an earache. She saw her GP, who diagnosed an outer ear infection and prescribed a topical spray. Medical staff used a clinical scoring system called Centor, which suggested no antibiotics were needed. The signs and symptoms of sepsis to look out for, according to The UK Sepsis Trust The coroner later said another system, Feverpain, might have recommended antibiotics and potentially changed the outcome. EMT Morgan Burt said she did not see the blue tinge on Charlotte's lips, but if she had, it would have been treated as a 'high priority' case. A recording of a phone call between EMT Burt and on call GP Dr Emma Ayers was played in court. Dr Ayers said she thought Charlotte might have a viral infection and advised plenty of fluids and a Covid test. But she added: 'When I said it could be viral infection, that was only half of the sentence. I was thinking this could be bacterial and she could be septic.' Dr Ayers said she was not informed about the blue lips during the call and that had she known, she would have sent Charlotte straight to hospital as an emergency. 2 She also said that if she could change her advice, she would have invited Charlotte for an appointment that afternoon. Ambulance staff found Charlotte's temperature and heart rate slightly elevated but other signs 'generally within normal range.' With no immediate hospitalisation needed, the ambulance left at around 1pm. Charlotte's condition got worse that afternoon. Her husband went out to buy pain relief, but when he came back, he found her collapsed, unconscious but still breathing. He called 999 again at around 2pm, during which time Charlotte stopped breathing Paramedics arrived just before 2:30pm and despite resuscitation efforts, she sadly passed away. A post-mortem confirmed the cause of death as multi-organ failure due to septic shock from the rapid spread of the bacterial infection. Sepsis spotting Suffolk Coroner Darren Stewart raised 'several matters of concern' about Charlotte's death. He warned the NHS's Feverpain and Centor scoring systems for infections can give conflicting results, and said using Feverpain might have led to antibiotics being prescribed earlier, possibly saving her. 'There is a need to review these scoring systems to provide guidance on a single system clinicians can rely on,' he said. He called for faster sepsis tests like CRP, finger prick, and lateral flow, stressing: 'The risks of sepsis and rapid deterioration are well known. We need urgent tools to help spot and treat it early.' The coroner also slammed the 111 call system for delays when ambulances must be booked manually, not automatically. The inquest is ongoing.
Daily Mirror
08-07-2025
- Daily Mirror
Mum died of sepsis after 'GP said it was ear infection and prescribed a spray'
A coroner has called for more to be done to spot the warning signs of Sepsis after Charlotte Alderson's tragic death A mum-of-three died of sepsis after she was diagnosed by a GP as having an ear infection and sent home with a topical spray to treat it, an inquest heard. Two days later, having called an ambulance, a medic failed to notice a blue tinge on Charlotte Alderson's lips and said she didn't need to go to hospital as her symptoms were 'generally within normal range'. The swimming instructor, from Suffolk, collapsed an hour later and despite the efforts of paramedics died at her home. Her inquest heard she had suffered from multi-organ failure due to septic shock, due to the bacterial infection Strep A. Now, Darren Stewart - area coroner for Suffolk - has called for the 'expeditious development' of measures which assist medics in the early identification and treatment of sepsis. The inquest was told that Mrs Alderson first reported feeling unwell on December 17, 2022. Some two days later, she visited her GP surgery, but medical professionals observed that her symptoms were 'within normal range'. A clinical scoring system, called Centor, to test for Strep A was used but this indicated that no antibiotics were required. Mrs Alderson was diagnosed with an outer ear infection and was given a prescription for a topical antibiotic spray. The swimming instructor was told to return to her GP if her symptoms worsened. On December 20, Mrs Alderson reported feeling better, but then in the evening her condition deteriorated and she suffered bouts of sickness and diarrhoea throughout the night. The following morning, at around 11am, her husband Stuart Alderson checked on her and observed a 'blue tinge' on her lips. He called 111 and an ambulance was dispatched. While the service was en route, Mrs Alderson's symptoms again worsened, which prompted Mr Alderson to make an additional call to 999. The ambulance arrived at 11:57am and a senior emergency medical technician carried out a clinical assessment on Mrs Alderson. The responder did not see blue-tinged lips and found that apart from a 'slightly elevated' temperature and heart rate, observations were 'generally within normal range'. The coroner said: "With no requirement identified for immediate hospitalisation, the ambulance left at 13:15." "Mrs Alderson's conditioned worsened further and her husband left to purchase pain relief. Upon his return, he found Mrs Alderson in a state of collapse. She was unconscious but breathing." Mr Alderson immediately called 999 at 14:09 and during this call, his wife had stopped breathing. An ambulance arrived at 14:26 and despite attempts to resuscitate Mrs Alderson, the swimming instructor sadly passed away. A post-mortem examination carried out after her death revealed she had group A streptococcus, a common type of bacteria infection. A jury inquest concluded Mrs Alderson died of natural causes. The medical cause of death was multi-organ failure due to septic shock, arising from the rapid progression of a bacterial infection into the bloodstream. Mr Stewart said he has several 'matters of concern' regarding the circumstances of Mrs Alderson's death. He said there are two scoring systems - Feverpain and Centor - used by clinicians to assess infections in patients and these can produce different outcomes. The coroner said: "It is possible in Mrs Alderson's case that the use of the Feverpain scoring system (as opposed to Centor) may have made a difference by indicating a prescription for antibiotics, which if taken on the day she was assessed by her GP, may have resulted in a different outcome. "There is a need to review these scoring systems, drawing upon the most effective elements of each, with a view to providing guidance on a single scoring system that can consistently be applied by clinicians." He continued: "Evidence received during the Inquest indicated that a number of existing measures within the National Health Service are capable of modification to provide testing tools for the early identification of sepsis/risk of sepsis and which would better inform decisions to prescribe antibiotics. These include CRP, finger prick and lateral flow tests. "The risks associated with sepsis and the speed with which a rapid deterioration can occur in patients without clear warning signs of sepsis being present, are well known. There is therefore a need for the expeditious development of measures which assist clinicians in the early identification and treatment of sepsis." The coroner also raised concerns about the system used by 111 call handlers. This was after hearing of how it can fail on occasion and mean that ambulances need to be booked manually over the phone rather than automatically.
