Stirlingshire villagers slam auctioneer for 'disingenuous' housing claim on £46k green space
Future Property Auctions claims the 1.6-acre plot opposite former forestry workers' houses on Keip Road has been earmarked for new homes.
Ben View plot three is currently listed with an opening bid of £46,000.
Accompanying literature says it is a 'potential development site' yet no planning permission is in place.
It adds: 'Site has been identified in consultations with the National Park planning authorities as a viable site for 100% affordable housing.'
However, according to Freedom of Information documents, the authority gave no such indication in pre-application discussions.
The documents, seen by The Courier, showed Line Architecture's design for eight affordable homes on the plot.
They also outlined a proposal for six bothies for holiday use on two smaller plots in nearby woodland.
In November 2023, an officer from Loch Lomond and Trossachs responded.
They wrote: 'Further information on siting, affordable housing, transport (including safe walking/cycling access to school), flooding and loss of open space would be necessary.
'No further assurances can be offered on the basis of the information currently submitted.'
However, Future Property Auctions continues to advertise the land for residential development.
The plot is regularly on the auction list since first going under the hammer on February 15 2024.
Residents claim the advertising is 'misleading'.
They say nothing can be built on the land as their title deeds state it will be 'retained as open space for recreational purposes' for residents.
The stretch of road leading to the properties is also owned and maintained by the locals.
One resident, Michael McGregor, told The Courier he had contacted the auction house to tell them the listing was 'disingenuous' but it was not changed.
He said: 'As far as we know, there's no planning permission and they won't get it.
'We all think it's a misrepresentation and that the advert is falsely claiming you can build there.'
His wife Angela says she and their neighbours found out on February 14 last year, the day before the first auction, and had no prior warning.
The current auction is for May 29 with an opening bid of £46,000.
'I can't see it ever getting permission,' she said. 'There's no amenities, there's nothing on that site. And we're in charge of the upkeep of the road.'
Helen Hunter has lived opposite the land since the 1990s and agrees the land can't be built on.
A plan to erect four houses on the land was refused in 1999.
She said: 'That has to be kept for the use of the people of Keip Road. It's in our lease.'
Allan McGregor believes the advert is 'spreading misinformation'.
He says the previous owner of the land was happy for Keip Road residents to use it in exchange for its upkeep.
Mr McGregor told The Courier: 'If someone put forward a planning application to put something there they wouldn't get it because 90% of us would say 'don't'.
'It's never going to happen and it's as simple as that.
'If someone buys it on an auction site, they're going to have a huge problem.'
A spokesperson for the national park authority said: 'No planning application has been submitted to the national park authority for development on this site.
'A pre-application enquiry was received in 2023.
'It confirmed that housing policies of the local development plan give support to affordable housing adjacent or close to towns where there are no other opportunities for housing development within the town or village.
'However, there is no 'allocated' sites for housing in the local development plan for Strathyre.
'Any future planning application would be assessed against all relevant policies of the development plan, including those relating to open space, flooding, landscape and the natural environment.
'These considerations were also highlighted in the pre-application response.'
Future Property Auctions was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
2 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Inclusive design is essential for Scotland's active travel
The 'bus stop boarder' type of floating bus stop places a cycle lane between the pavement and the point where buses pick up passengers. In some cases, passengers must board or alight directly from a cycle lane. In others, cycle lanes run behind the bus stop shelter. While the aim is to improve cycling flow and road safety, the unintended consequence is a frightening obstacle course for blind and partially sighted bus users. Bus stops are only part of the journey for people with sight loss and other disabilities. Advertising boards, street café furniture, wheelie bins, and cars parked on pavements all add to the hazards. A third of blind and partially sighted people surveyed by RNIB said they had been injured by pavement obstacles when walking outside. Some felt so intimidated they ended up isolated in their homes. James Adams (Image: RNIB) The result of the bus stop boarder design means anyone stepping off a bus is stepping into a live traffic lane. For someone blind or partially sighted, the journey is even riskier. Bikes approaching at speed often cannot be detected by sound, and the fear of collision forces some people to avoid certain routes altogether. Poor layouts can also pose risks for cyclists, as conflicts can occur when people step into the cycle lane unexpectedly, increasing the likelihood of collisions for everyone. Public transport is a lifeline for people with sight loss, connecting them to society- employment, healthcare, and social opportunities. When street layouts create barriers, the impact is severe. Impacting on the confidence of blind and partially sighted people engaging in society be that for employment, socialising, shopping or accessing public services. To understand the scale of the issue, RNIB Scotland submitted a Freedom of Information (FOI) request to all 32 Scottish local authorities asking for the total number of bus stops and details on floating bus stop and bus stop boarder plans. What we learned is that floating bus stop designs are no longer a future idea, they are here, and more are on the way. Read more: According to figures received, there are 99 floating bus stops in place across Scotland, with plans for at least 149 more while there are 42 bus stop boarders in place and 56 more planned. Several councils indicated that floating bus stops form part of wider active travel plans, meaning hundreds more could follow in the next few years. These designs now form part of the urban landscape in Scotland's busiest cities. Yet it is rare that these expansion plans have been matched by meaningful consultation with disabled communities, despite a legal duty under the Equality Act 2010 to consider accessibility and prevent discrimination. Stopping places should be designed so that all passengers can continue their journey without crossing a live cycle lane. Currently, there are no designs that enable blind and partially sighted people to safely cross the cycle lane to access buses. Accessibility cannot be an afterthought or a 'nice to have' when rolling out active travel infrastructure. This issue rightly sits at the heart of Scotland's wider transport and environmental ambitions. However, the Scottish Government's commitment to sustainable and inclusive travel, as outlined in its Net Zero and Active Travel Strategies, must extend to protecting the rights of disabled people. Inclusive design is essential to ensure that sustainable transport does not come at the cost of accessibility or safety. Unless action is taken, thousands of blind and partially sighted people could soon face even greater risks when trying to use public transport. Over many years, RNIB Scotland and many other sight loss charities have demonstrated to politicians at all levels, and from all parties, the complexities and dangers faced by blind and partially sighted people engaging with floating bus stops. Most of them could understand the concern, see the danger and agree that they need properly reviewed – but there has been no actual action to address the growing problem. Politicians of all parties must show leadership on this – for the next Parliament, commit to a pause on future bus stop boarder and floating bus stop schemes, ensure a genuine review of safety, and the equality of the schemes. The Scottish Government must also show leadership by issuing clear guidance to local authorities to immediately pause all floating bus stop projects until a full accessibility review is completed. This review must be genuinely informed by disabled people's organisations. If blind and partially sighted people cannot travel independently because of street design, then we have knowingly and willingly built inequality into our transport system. We need street designs that work for everyone and that protect the independence and safety of all users and uphold Scotland's commitment to accessible and sustainable transport. James Adams is the director of RNIB Scotland
The Courier
2 days ago
- The Courier
Inside the stunning Newport converted church apartment on sale for £450k
An apartment in a stunning church conversion on Newport's waterfront has gone on the market for £450,000. Apartment 8 in Trinity Free Church, has three bedrooms spread across two levels, is up for sale. Located on Boat Road looking over the Tay, the church sits next to the Newport Inn. Trinity United Free Church dates from 1881 and was designed by architects Charles and Leslie Ower. Its foundation stone was laid by Admiral Maitland-Dougal of Scotscraig Estate. The church opened in 1882 after being built at a cost of £3,000. At the opening ceremony a sealed bottle containing copies of The Courier, the Dundee Advertiser, the Scotsman and the Daily Mail was laid in the foundations. Trinity Church closed its doors for the final time in 2016. In 2017 it was put on sale for offers over £280,000. It was sold to a developer who turned it into luxury apartments that were completed in 2019. Occupying part of the ground and first floors, Apartment 8 has 175sqm of living space, making it bigger than the average four-bedroom detached house. This translates into huge, airy rooms that give a wonderful impression of space. A beautiful arched doorway opens into a vestibule with a bench and coat hooks. A reception hall has a magnificent stained glass window and a glass staircase. Without doubt the finest space in the house is the amazing open plan living/dining/kitchen area. This enormous space has a vaulted ceiling and a mezzanine level. On the ground floor there is a modern German kitchen and an impressive dining area. A set of stairs leads up to the mezzanine living room, which has a glass balustrade. Huge arched windows give fantastic views across the river. The main bedroom is on the ground floor. It has three arched windows and an en suite shower room. A second double bedroom is located on the ground floor and also enjoys Tay views. There's a family bathroom and a utility area at ground floor level. On the upper floor there is a family bathroom, another double bedroom, a home office and a door that opens into the mezzanine living room. Many of the B listed church's original features have been refurbished and retained when the building was converted into flats. As well as arched windows and stained glass the ceiling showcases exposed timber beams. The walls, meanwhile, are made of 600mm thick solid stone. Gas central heating helps keep running costs low. Apartment 8 is owned by Ronny and Keeley Bogani, who have lived there for the past five years. Ronny, 50, is from Florida and spent 20 years working as a trial attorney before moving to the UK in 2018. He now works in Artificial Intelligence, specialising in AI and children's rights. He's completing a PhD at Edinburgh University. He works with the Turing Trust, a charity that supports education in Africa, and social enterprise NPACT. 'Basically I made my money in America as a trial lawyer and now I'm turning against the organisations I used to defend,' he smiles. 'I've dedicated the rest of my life to human rights.' When Ronny and Keeley bought Apartment 8 in Trinity Free Church it was on sale as an unfinished shell. They worked with the builders to complete the apartment to their specification. 'We spent an extra £40,000 getting the spec we wanted,' Ronnie continues. 'We put in a German kitchen and speciality cast iron radiators. My favourite place to go on vacation is the Graylyn Estate in North Carolina. The bathrooms have these amazing showers with six or eight nozzles that blast water at you from all directions. We had one of those showers fitted in our en suite.' Separation has led to Ronny and Keeley putting their flat in Trinity Free Church on the market. 'It was too big for me on my own,' Ronny says. 'I now live in a flat on Thistle Street in Edinburgh, which is fantastic – although it's dangerously close to the best French restaurant.' Apartment 8, Trinity Free Church, Boat Road, Newport is on sale with Brikk for offers over £450,000.
Leader Live
3 days ago
- Leader Live
The ongoing cost of looking after Groves School, Wrexham
Groves School closed back in 2003, with demolition of the newer science tower taking place later in 2012. The school was also earmarked for demolition by Wrexham Council, but was then listed by the Welsh Government in 2016, following a community campaign to protect it. Several proposals to redevelop the building have been brought forward over the years, including plans to convert it into a new primary school or medical training facility, but none have successfully moved forward. Last year, the council was urged by the Save Our Heritage Wrexham group to take action to revive the old school amid claims it has been left to rot. In a recent update, Wrexham Council said that the building's future 'remains under consideration', with any proposed decision to be 'reported through Executive Board'. With delays ongoing, the Leader recently submitted a Freedom of Information (FOI) request to Wrexham Council. In that, we asked; "How much has it cost Wrexham Council financially year on year to look after Grove's School site since it closed in 2003?' In their reply, they said: "The headline summary costs since closure are for the Groves site are £821,255." In a further response, the council called the situation surrounding the school 'frustrating'. They added that they have 'worked tirelessly' to find a solution. Alwyn Jones, Wrexham Council's Interim Chief Executive, said: 'We have worked tirelessly to find a solution for the Groves, and will continue to do so. We did originally hope to build two new schools on the site, but the building was listed by Welsh Government and we were unable to progress these plans. Read more "We've been close to finding other solutions on a number of occasions, but these didn't come to fruition, which has been frustrating. 'In the meantime, we're faced with the ongoing cost of insurance and security to keep the Groves safe from issues like vandalism and adverse weather, so we want to find a use for the site more than anyone. "It's a complex and challenging situation, but we'll keep working hard with partners to explore different options and find a way forward.'
