We trapped ourselves: Data scientist's post on middle class spending sparks debate
A LinkedIn post by Mumbai-based data scientist Monish Gosar has triggered fresh debate over how India's middle class manages its money. In his post, Gosar questioned the widely held belief that the salaried class is a passive victim of economic stress, arguing instead that it willingly contributes to its own financial strain.'Unpopular opinion: The middle class is not a victim of the system. They're willing participants,' Gosar wrote, pointing to what he calls a pattern of emotional decision-making and lifestyle inflation.
advertisement
To illustrate his point, Gosar shared an anecdote about a friend earning Rs 15 lakh per annum who chose to buy a Rs 10 lakh car through EMIs instead of opting for a Rs 3 lakh used one. 'I deserve it,' the friend reportedly said, a justification Gosar dismisses as a narrative banks want consumers to believe.India's rising household debt forms the backdrop to Gosar's critique. According to him, credit card debt has nearly doubled to Rs 2.92 lakh crore in four years, while personal loans have grown by 75%. 'But nobody forced us to swipe those cards. We did it willingly,' he wrote.Gosar's argument rests on the idea that many salaried professionals have blurred the line between needs and wants. 'We confused wants with needs,' he said, taking aim at car upgrades, iPhones, and aspirational spending habits driven by social media pressures. 'Instagram made us feel poor while earning in the top 10% of India.'advertisementHe also criticised what he sees as a widespread neglect of basic financial math. '36% credit card interest vs 12% mutual fund returns. We chose to pay banks instead of earning from markets,' he noted, adding that consumers often focus on low EMIs without accounting for the high cumulative interest burden.'The system didn't trap us. We trapped ourselves,' Gosar concluded, calling for greater personal accountability rather than solely blaming economic structures or policy gaps.While the post has struck a chord with many on social media, it has also sparked pushback from readers who argue that Gosar's view overlooks stagnant wage growth, lack of social security, and the pressures of urban life.Nonetheless, his core message, that middle-class spending habits deserve introspection, continues to generate conversation
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
24 minutes ago
- News18
Saudi Arabia Executes Journalist After 7 Years In Prison Over Posts Against Royal Family
Last Updated: Al-Jasser was detained following a raid on his residence in 2018, during which authorities confiscated his electronic devices including phones and computer. Saudi Arabia has executed prominent journalist Turki Al-Jasser, who was arrested in 2018 and later convicted on charges of terrorism and treason. The official Saudi Press Agency confirmed that the execution took place on Saturday after the kingdom's highest court upheld the death sentence. However, activist groups maintain that the charges against him were trumped up. Al-Jasser was detained following a raid on his residence in 2018, during which authorities confiscated his electronic devices including phones and computer. It was not clear where his trial took place or how long it lasted. According to the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists, Saudi authorities maintained that Al-Jasser was behind a social media account on X, formerly Twitter, that levied corruption allegations against Saudi royals. Al-Jasser was also said to have posted several controversial tweets about militants and militant groups. Al-Jasser ran a personal blog from 2013 to 2015 and was well-known for his articles on the Arab Spring movements that shook the Middle East in 2011, women's rights and corruption. Activist groups have condemned the execution, insisting the charges were fabricated to silence dissent. CPJ's program director Carlos Martínez de la Serna condemned the execution and said the lack of accountability in the wake of the killing of Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi at the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul in 2018 allows for continued persecution of journalists in the kingdom. A Saudi assassination team killed Khashoggi at the consulate in Istanbul. The US intelligence community concluded that the Saudi crown prince ordered the operation but the kingdom insists the prince was not involved in the killing. Saudi Arabia has drawn criticism from human rights groups for its numbers and also methods of capital punishment, including beheadings and mass executions. In 2024, executions in Saudi Arabia rose to 330, according to activists and human rights groups, as the kingdom continues to tightly clamp down on dissent. Last month, a British Bank of America analyst was sentenced to a decade in prison in Saudi Arabia, apparently over a since-deleted social media post, according to his lawyer. In 2021, a dual Saudi American national, Saad Almadi, was sentenced to more than 19 years in prison on terrorism-related charges stemming from tweets he had posted while living in the United States. He was released in 2023 but has been banned from leaving the kingdom. (With inputs from agencies) First Published: June 16, 2025, 21:44 IST
Indian Express
28 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Over 100 bike taxis seized in Bengaluru for operating despite Karnataka HC order
Officials of the road transport offices across Bengaluru seized 103 bike taxis on Monday for operating despite the Karnataka High Court's directive to suspend operations in the state. The transport department officials have also booked the riders of the 103 bike taxis across RTO divisions in the central, west, south, north, east, Electronic City, and KR Puram, among others. According to RTO officials, the riders were fined Rs 5,000 for operating bike taxis without permission and additionally for insufficient documentation. 'We have seized their vehicles and fined them for operating without permission, in line with the high court's directive. Following the payment of the fine amount, we will release the vehicle after two days,' said an RTO official. The crackdown comes after the high court on April 2 ordered all bike taxi operators, including Rapido, Uber and Ola, to suspend their operations, pending the formation of rules under section 93 of the Motor Vehicles Act by the state government. The deadline to wind down operation is Monday (June 16), set after the aggregators sought additional four weeks, modifying a single-bench order that had granted them six weeks to suspend operations. The ban came after a division bench of the high court refused to stay the April 2 single-bench order that directed all bike taxi operators to suspend operations within six weeks. Acting Chief Justice Kameswar Rao observed that an interim relief could have been given to aggregators, provided the state government considered drafting a bike taxi policy. 'However, in this case, the state government has clearly made a policy decision (of not being interested to frame a bike taxi policy),' he noted. Transport Minister Ramalinga Reddy has emphasised that the state government is not inclined towards drafting a bike taxi policy and that white-board two wheelers cannot be used for commercial purposes. However, Rapido and Uber continued to offer courier services through bikes, which eventually also drew criticism. Bangalore Central MP P C Mohan wrote on X, 'Karnataka High Court has banned bike taxis. But aggregators continue to operate under the guise of 'Bike Parcel'. Citizens are now being reduced to mere parcels in this legal evasion. Karnataka Government has failed to implement the law. Are aggregators above the law?' He added, 'This isn't about supporting or opposing bike taxis. It's about upholding the law. No aggregator can flout Karnataka High Court orders under the guise of 'Bike Parcel' or 'Moto Courier'. This is not innovation, it is contempt of court and a challenge to judicial authority.' Meanwhile, all three major aggregator platforms–Rapido, Uber and Ola–removed the bike taxi feature from their apps on Monday, in line with the high court's order. Uber's spokesperson said in a press statement, 'Uber has taken the difficult decision to suspend bike taxi operations in Karnataka from June 16 following an order from the Hon'ble High Court. This will negatively impact the many thousands of riders who rely on bike taxis for their daily mobility needs, as well as the many thousands of drivers who rely on the service for their livelihood. We will continue engaging with the Government of Karnataka to help shape a progressive policy framework that enables safe, accessible, and affordable mobility options for everyone.' In a notification to its customers, Rapido said on the app, 'Starting June 16, 2025, our Bike Taxi services in Karnataka will be paused in compliance with recent High Court orders. While we deeply believe in the value bike taxis bring to daily commuters, we respect the law and will fully abide by the directive. We remain committed to the communities we serve and hopeful for a future where convenient, affordable mobility is accessible to all. We are navigating the way forward with the government to bring your favourite bike taxis back on the road soon.' Bike taxi associations also gave a representation to BJP MLA Ravi Subramanya seeking urgent relief from the suspension of bike taxis. The drivers demanded clear rules on licensing, insurance, and safety rather than being criminalised overnight. 'We're part of the same informal economy that Karnataka claims to support. Why are we being shut out without a conversation?' asked Mohammed Salim, president of the Namma Bike Taxi Association. Meanwhile, Shaik Salauddin, National General Secretary of the Indian Federation of App-Based Transport Workers (IFAT) and the Telangana Gig and Platform Workers' Union (TGPWU), and Inayath Ali, president of the Karnataka App-Based Workers' Union, have welcomed the high court's decision declining a stay on the single-judge order that held bike taxis cannot operate in the state unless relevant rules are framed. Shaik Salauddin said, 'We appreciate the Karnataka High Court's order. It underscores the necessity for a clear legal framework for bike taxis and highlights the ongoing violation of regulations by companies like Ola, Uber, and Rapido. These companies have been cheating workers by ignoring the rules and putting their livelihoods at risk.' Salauddin demanded strict action against the aggregator companies for non-compliance and called on the transport department to promptly issue clear guidelines and conduct special camps to convert private two-wheelers into commercial vehicles. 'This will help workers operate legally and safeguard their income and future,' he said. Inayath Ali said, 'We welcome this order as it protects the livelihoods of cab and auto drivers who lose their income due to unfair competition. If bike taxis are allowed in future, they should be permitted only with yellow number plate (commercial vehicle) registration and proper oversight by the authorities.'
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Car rental platform Zoomcar users' data leaked in cyberattack
Car-sharing platform Zoomcar told the US market regulator that a hacker accessed the personal data of at least 8.4 million customers. Names, phone numbers, and car registration numbers, personal addresses and email addresses were compromised in the cyberattack, it said in a filing dated June 13. The Bengaluru-based company told the US Securities and Exchange Commission that the first event was recorded on June 9. The company became aware of the data leak after "certain employees received external communications from a threat actor alleging unauthorised access to company data", the filing noted. Zoomcar said it promptly acted upon discovering the threat, activating its incident response plan.
