Fury among Canadian Sikhs as Modi invited to G7 despite alleged threats
PM Carney invites Modi to G7 as guest; first Canada visit in 10 years seen as diplomatic test for the new leader. PHOTO: REUTERS
Listen to article
Members of Canada's Sikh community who were warned by police that their lives were at risk and allege the Indian government is responsible for the threat are incensed by Ottawa's invitation to Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the G7 summit in Alberta.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney invited Modi, although India is not a G7 member, to attend the summit that starts on Sunday as a guest. It will be Modi's first visit to Canada in a decade and a diplomatic test for Carney, a political neophyte.
Canada's relationship with India has been tense since former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2023 accused India's government of involvement in the June 18, 2023, murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Sikh separatist leader in Canada.
Modi's government has denied involvement in Nijjar's killing and has accused Canada of providing a safe haven for Sikh separatists.
"'Outrage' is the kind of term that I've heard from people," Sikh activist Moninder Singh, a friend of Nijjar, said of the invitation.
He and other Sikh leaders plan to hold a protest in Ottawa on Saturday.
Carney, locked in a trade war with the United States, is trying to shore up alliances elsewhere and diversify Canada's exports. Carney told reporters he invited India due to its importance in global supply chains.
India's Foreign Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said in a Thursday press briefing that a meeting between Modi and Carney "will offer an important opportunity for them to exchange views on bilateral and global issues and explore pathways to set or reset the relationship."
Sikhs faces threats
That rationale rings hollow for Singh, who lives in British Columbia. He has received multiple warnings from police that his life was at risk. One such warning forced him from his home for months in 2023 for his children's safety.
"On a personal level, and on a community level, as well, it was deeply insulting ... Sikh lives aren't as important as the fifth-largest economy in the world that needs to be at the table," he said.
A spokesperson for Carney did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police said in October they had communicated more than a dozen threats to people like Singh who are advocating for the creation of a Sikh homeland carved out of India.
In October, under Trudeau, Canada expelled six Indian diplomats, linking them to Nijjar's murder and alleging a broader government effort to target Indian dissidents in Canada through killings, extortion, use of organized crime and clandestine information-gathering. India retaliated by ordering the expulsion of six Canadian diplomats and called the allegations preposterous and politically motivated. Canada has said it does not have evidence linking Modi to the threats.
The tension has thrust Canada's Sikh community - the largest outside India's Sikh-majority Punjab state - into the spotlight.
Singh said there should have been conditions on Modi's invitation.
"Any meetings with them should have been under the conditions that Mr. Modi and his government would take responsibility for what has been uncovered and cooperate, but none of that happened."
Carney told reporters Modi had agreed to "law enforcement dialogue."
Jaiswal said Indian and Canadian law enforcement agencies will continue to cooperate in some ways.
Some activists and politicians in Canada have accused Carney of putting economic issues ahead of human rights concerns.
But Sanjay Ruparelia, a Toronto Metropolitan University politics professor, said the prime minister is simply being practical.
"(Carney's) watchword since he's come to office is pragmatism. And this is very much a pragmatic, realpolitik decision."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
5 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PPP distances itself from budget prep
The Pakistan People's Party (PPP) has rejected the federal budget and voiced strong reservations over the Punjab government's alleged disregard of the party in the budget-making process, sparking a war of words between PPP's Hassan Murtaza and Punjab Information Minister Azma Bukhari. Speaking at a press conference at the PPP Model Town Secretariat, Hassan Murtaza, General Secretary of PPP Central Punjab, said the party was neither consulted nor were its suggestions included in the budget. "The people will receive no relief from either the federal or the expected Punjab budget," he said, criticising the government's economic policies and claiming that the region's peace was being threatened by a 'Modi-style' mind-set. Murtaza also used the occasion to launch a scathing critique of international powers, particularly the US and Israel, and questioned the credibility of global institutions like the United Nations. "The Muslim Ummah is being forced to recite verses of jihad; this is the same strategy Modi used against Pakistan," he said, adding that Pakistan must strengthen its economy as much as its defense. He lambasted the imposition of heavy taxes on agriculture, calling it a death knell for farmers. "From petrol to fertilisers and seeds, everything has been taxed. And yet, wheat is being sold cheap while sugarcane is purchased on credit and sugar is sold in cash," he said. Murtaza accused the Punjab government of operating a sugar mill mafia and claimed that rose water worth Rs320 million was sprayed on Lahore's roads while basic facilities remained unavailable to the poor. He also criticised Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz for allegedly misusing public funds for personal branding. "Maryam Nawaz is so obsessed with self-promotion that even dustbins carry her picture. But she can't include the Prime Minister, her own uncle, in those images," he said. Hitting back at the provincial government's performance, he said it had failed to deliver during its 16-month tenure. "If you're putting your face on dustbins, then own up to the inflation too," he remarked. He also condemned the recent imposition of 18% tax on solar panels and said future taxes on essentials like oxygen would be the logical next step if such policies continued. Murtaza criticised the 10% salary hike for government employees, terming it insufficient and demanded a 50% increase instead. He also denounced what he called the humiliation of medical professionals and accused the government of pushing various departments to protest at Charing Cross rather than enabling them to serve in offices. While reiterating the PPP's commitment to institutional reform, Murtaza said his party was ready to work with the government to fix the system but would not support exploitative policies. He also opposed the proposed advertising bill and urged Pakistan to align itself more strongly with neighbouring Iran. In a sharp rebuttal, Punjab Information Minister Azma Bukhari dismissed Murtaza's remarks, saying, "A person who couldn't even win his own seat shouldn't be lecturing us." She claimed that in private gatherings, even Murtaza admitted that Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz's governance was the real reason PPP lost ground in Punjab. "Maryam Nawaz is not just making promises, she is fulfilling them. She's delivering real relief to people and translating dreams into reality," Bukhari said. Referring to Murtaza's recent visit to Sambrial, she said he had witnessed the government's work firsthand. Bukhari further slammed the PPP leader for rejecting a budget that hadn't even been presented. "This shows the state of your political judgment," she added. She emphasised that governments with vision can show results even in 16 months, while those lacking direction fail even after 16 years.
Express Tribune
8 hours ago
- Express Tribune
UK to deploy fighter jets to Middle East amid Iran-Israel tensions, says Starmer
Britain is deploying assets, including fighter jets, to the Middle East amid tensions between Iran and Israel, UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer said Saturday while heading to Canada for G7 talks. "We are moving assets to the region, including jets, and that is for contingency support," Starmer told reporters travelling with him on his plane to Ottawa. The UK leader said he had spoken with both US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu since Israel launched its first attacks on Iran early Friday, hitting military and nuclear sites. According to officials, dozens have been killed, including top army and Revolutionary Guards commanders, as well as civilians. Iran has responded with barrages of drones and missiles fired at Israel overnight Friday into Saturday. Starmer said the situation was "fast moving" as well as "intense." "We're having ongoing discussions with our allies all of the time, both myself and (Foreign Minister) David Lammy... who also spoke to the Iranians," he said. "Our constant message is de-escalate, and therefore everything we're doing, all discussions we're having are to do with de-escalation." The UK leader said his talk on Friday with Netanyahu had been "good and constructive" and had "included discussions about the safety and security of Israel." Foreign Secretary Lammy said earlier Saturday that he was "alarmed" by further strikes overnight. "We must urgently de-escalate & prevent any further harm to civilians," Lammy said in a post to social media, adding he had spoken to his Iranian counterpart Abbas Araghchi "to urge calm."
Express Tribune
11 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Fury among Canadian Sikhs as Modi invited to G7 despite alleged threats
PM Carney invites Modi to G7 as guest; first Canada visit in 10 years seen as diplomatic test for the new leader. PHOTO: REUTERS Listen to article Members of Canada's Sikh community who were warned by police that their lives were at risk and allege the Indian government is responsible for the threat are incensed by Ottawa's invitation to Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the G7 summit in Alberta. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney invited Modi, although India is not a G7 member, to attend the summit that starts on Sunday as a guest. It will be Modi's first visit to Canada in a decade and a diplomatic test for Carney, a political neophyte. Canada's relationship with India has been tense since former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2023 accused India's government of involvement in the June 18, 2023, murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Sikh separatist leader in Canada. Modi's government has denied involvement in Nijjar's killing and has accused Canada of providing a safe haven for Sikh separatists. "'Outrage' is the kind of term that I've heard from people," Sikh activist Moninder Singh, a friend of Nijjar, said of the invitation. He and other Sikh leaders plan to hold a protest in Ottawa on Saturday. Carney, locked in a trade war with the United States, is trying to shore up alliances elsewhere and diversify Canada's exports. Carney told reporters he invited India due to its importance in global supply chains. India's Foreign Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said in a Thursday press briefing that a meeting between Modi and Carney "will offer an important opportunity for them to exchange views on bilateral and global issues and explore pathways to set or reset the relationship." Sikhs faces threats That rationale rings hollow for Singh, who lives in British Columbia. He has received multiple warnings from police that his life was at risk. One such warning forced him from his home for months in 2023 for his children's safety. "On a personal level, and on a community level, as well, it was deeply insulting ... Sikh lives aren't as important as the fifth-largest economy in the world that needs to be at the table," he said. A spokesperson for Carney did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police said in October they had communicated more than a dozen threats to people like Singh who are advocating for the creation of a Sikh homeland carved out of India. In October, under Trudeau, Canada expelled six Indian diplomats, linking them to Nijjar's murder and alleging a broader government effort to target Indian dissidents in Canada through killings, extortion, use of organized crime and clandestine information-gathering. India retaliated by ordering the expulsion of six Canadian diplomats and called the allegations preposterous and politically motivated. Canada has said it does not have evidence linking Modi to the threats. The tension has thrust Canada's Sikh community - the largest outside India's Sikh-majority Punjab state - into the spotlight. Singh said there should have been conditions on Modi's invitation. "Any meetings with them should have been under the conditions that Mr. Modi and his government would take responsibility for what has been uncovered and cooperate, but none of that happened." Carney told reporters Modi had agreed to "law enforcement dialogue." Jaiswal said Indian and Canadian law enforcement agencies will continue to cooperate in some ways. Some activists and politicians in Canada have accused Carney of putting economic issues ahead of human rights concerns. But Sanjay Ruparelia, a Toronto Metropolitan University politics professor, said the prime minister is simply being practical. "(Carney's) watchword since he's come to office is pragmatism. And this is very much a pragmatic, realpolitik decision."
