DoT's demand survey for private 5G networks finds few takers
private 5G networks
has turned out to be a damp squib with just a few enterprises showing interest, people aware of the details told ET.
A demand study conducted by the
Department of Telecommunications
(DoT) to understand the spectrum requirement for direct allocation attracted only a few applications, including incomplete ones that didn't have the requisite details, they said.
'We will study and take a call around direct allocation of spectrum for captive private networks,' an official said on condition of anonymity.
Telecom service providers
have been opposing the move to give spectrum directly to enterprises, arguing that such private networks can be rolled out through airwaves allocated to telcos.
The technology industry, on its part, is questioning the need for a fresh demand study as one such study was done a couple of years ago.
'Another demand study for private
5G
seems a pointless exercise, serving only to further delay the introduction of a product globally proven with thousands of CNPN (
captive non-public networks
) and India trailing by three years,'
Broadband India Forum
(BIF) president TV Ramachandran told ET.
'India needs CNPN for
Industry 4.0
, digitalisation and improved global competitiveness in many sectors,' he added.
The previous demand study drew applications from over 20 players including Infosys, Tata Communications, Tata Power, GMR, and Larsen & Toubro, but nothing much happened after that.
This time, however, there was no such interest from these players.
The DoT in June 2022 had notified guidelines for establishment of CNPNs or private networks. These guidelines allow enterprises to set up their own captive private 4G or 5G networks by either utilising spectrum from telcos or direct assignment from the department.
The DoT felt there was a need for another demand study as certain spectrum bands that were initially identified for direct assignment to private networks lack device ecosystem.
READ MORE |
Direct spectrum allocation for enterprise 5G not tenable in India: Telcos
'During a recent analysis, it was observed that the device ecosystem for CNPN is mostly available in IMT bands and 5G technology has also considerably advanced with different use cases,' DoT said while seeking applications for the demand study. 'Also, system integrators are keenly interested in establishing CNPN-based networks,' it said.
However, BIF felt demand for such a private network, for example, at Maruti, can only be singular because of relevance only to Maruti for internal efficiency improvements and a captive network with no services to the public and revenue therefrom.
'Hence, no need for demand study, or onerous license. Spectrum should be given directly to enterprises at cost to just cover the cost of administration and regulation and no further delay to boost the economy,' Ramachandran said.
Under private networks, corporate houses can set up their own Wi-Fi and data networks instead of taking the services from a telecom service provider as is the norm currently.
The telcos, however, feel direct spectrum allocation to enterprises is not tenable because of various reasons pertaining to the country's telecom ecosystem, national revenue, and security architecture.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
27 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Aurobindo Pharma leads $5 billion race to acquire Prague-based Zentiva
Aurobindo Pharma has emerged as the leading contender to buy Prague-based drugmaker Zentiva from private equity (PE) firm Advent International in a deal estimated at $5-5.5 billion, The Economic Times reported on Wednesday, citing sources. If the deal goes through, it would mark the biggest acquisition by an Indian pharmaceutical company globally. Another firm in the fray includes the United States (US)-based private equity firm GTCR, the report added. 'No binding agreement' yet: Aurobindo However, soon after the report surfaced, Aurobindo issued a clarification stating that "no binding agreement or definitive decision" has been made yet regarding the deal. "The Company regularly explores various strategic opportunities in the ordinary course of its business, including potential acquisitions and partnerships, to enhance long-term shareholder value. However, at present, no binding agreement or definitive decision has been made by the board of directors of the company in relation to the transaction referred to in the said article(s). Accordingly, the said news item is premature and should not be relied upon," the company said in a BSE filing. European push The deal could further expand Aurobindo's presence in the European market, where the firm is already performing well. In the first quarter of the financial year 2025-26 (Q1 FY26), it reported an 18 per cent year-on-year (Y-o-Y) revenue growth in European markets, which stood at ₹2,338 crore, driven by a strong performance across all key segments. Similarly, revenue from growth markets formulations increased by 8.8 per cent Y-o-Y to ₹772 crore in the June quarter, compared to ₹709 crore in the same period last year. Overall, Aurobindo Pharma reported a 10.2 per cent Y-o-Y drop in consolidated profit after tax (PAT) for Q1 FY26, which stood at ₹824 crore. The decline was attributed to a drop in sales in its active pharmaceutical ingredients business and the US market. However, the drugmaker recorded a 4 per cent rise in revenue from operations, reaching ₹7,868 crore in the June quarter, up from ₹7,567 crore in Q1 FY25. Shares of Aurobindo Pharma fell almost 4 per cent to ₹1,047 apiece on the BSE at 2:14 pm following the report.
Economic Times
27 minutes ago
- Economic Times
As AI eats some IT jobs, Bengaluru NIT-IIM graduate remembers his Kerala uncle who told him 'no scope for computer science' 20 years ago
iStock In India, one thing that is never in short supply is free advice, often offered generously by neighbors and relatives who claim to know best In India, if there's anything given away for free, it's an unsolicited opinion, especially from self-proclaimed well-wishers. A Bengaluru-based entrepreneur recently reminisced about how he was heavily discouraged by a neighbourhood uncle from taking up computer science in the early 2000s, as he speculated that the dot-com craze would demolish a lot of engineering that time, he was preparing to pursue computer science at the National Institute of Technology, Calicut. Despite securing an excellent All India Engineering Entrance Examination rank, he faced sharp disapproval from a neighborhood elder who warned him that computer science had little future. The man, still influenced by the aftermath of the dot-com bubble burst, argued that technology careers were on shaky ground and unlikely to provide job security. — abidsensibull (@abidsensibull) Hassan acknowledged the suggestion with courtesy, though he was determined to follow his own path. Over the following two decades, his decision proved prescient. The technology landscape transformed rapidly with the growth of the internet, the dominance of IT services, the rise of digital advertising and search engines, the smartphone revolution, and the expansion of e-commerce and logistics. Emerging innovations like cryptocurrency, blockchain, artificial intelligence, and machine learning further reshaped the professional world, opening countless opportunities for those in the field. The sector that was once dismissed as unstable grew into one of the strongest pillars of the global economy. Today, however, a new shift is underway, he explained. The expansion of generative AI tools and advanced automation has started to reduce the need for certain low-skill IT roles. Hassan wryly notes that the same elder who once dismissed computer science might now feel vindicated, ready to remind him of those early warnings. Yet the reality is that technological progress has historically created far more opportunities than it has displaced, and those willing to adapt continue to thrive. Abid Hassan leads Sensibull, a trading platform headquartered in Bengaluru, as its Chief Executive Officer. He graduated from the National Institute of Technology, Calicut, and later from the Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad.
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
India's SDV roadmap moving in three distinct tracks: Continental
New Delhi: The global auto industry's view of software-defined vehicles (SDVs) contrasts with India's more fragmented approach, according to Continental . With time-to-market emerging as a critical factor, China already has SDVs on the road, while Europe and the US are expected to catch up by 2027-28. India sits in the middle of this transition, making steady progress. The German Tier-1 supplier is of the view that at least some high-end models are expected to feature integrated SDV capabilities by the next two years, as OEMs balance cost pressures with their ambition to move toward fully software-defined architectures. 'By then, I'm confident that even the more conservative OEMs in India will have moved into the SDV space- at least with high-performance computers (HPCs) as a starting point. We started a little later compared to China, but we are catching up very fast,' Harikrishna Khandavalli, Head of Engineering- Bangalore and Head of Engineering Software- APAC, Architecture & Networking at Continental Automotive India, said in an exclusive interaction with ETAuto. He pointed out three distinct tracks emerging in the country's technology roadmap. The first is a conservative approach, largely driven by cost considerations. At the other end are OEMs making bold moves with high ambitions, while a middle path is also taking shape, with players gradually catching up by balancing innovation with affordability. Among the OEMs, Mahindra & Mahindra's BE 6 and XEV 9e models are a case in point, showcasing a vehicle architecture that is entirely software-led. SDVs and virtual HPCs According to Khandavalli, while SDVs may be the industry's latest buzzword, the concept is often misunderstood. Many associate it simply with having a central cockpit domain or HPCs that integrate infotainment and instrument clusters. 'In reality, that represents only a progression toward SDVs, not a full-fledged transformation.' For a vehicle to be considered a true SDV, he said, multiple domains including connected vehicles, ADAS, safety, and autonomous mobility, must converge. Explaining the long-term value of SDVs, he said the approach is not about one or two integrations, but about building a robust hardware platform designed to last eight to ten years, with the flexibility to be upgraded over time. On top of this hardware, an infrastructure is layered, enabling future functions to be added as needed. 'That is the beauty of SDVs- you can select the functions, download them, and make the vehicle future-ready. A feature you don't have today can be purchased or even subscribed to temporarily,' he noted. While this model is still evolving, China is expected to move quickly, potentially bringing such subscription-based SDV features to market within the next couple of years. The Bengaluru-based company is also exploring the concept of virtual HPCs, where not all processing needs to happen within the vehicle itself. Instead, certain functions can be computed in the cloud and then integrated with the vehicle's systems. 'Safety-critical functions will always need to remain close to the sensors, but mid-level processing can be distributed, and non-critical functions can be managed in the cloud,' Khandavalli explained. This layered approach, combining in-vehicle computing with cloud-based capabilities, is seen as a way to optimise cost and performance for future vehicle architectures. Challenges remain While the SDV transition is gathering pace globally, India still lacks the supporting infrastructure to fully enable it. Cost is another defining challenge in the domestic market, where OEMs push for advanced features and high-end functions, but only at price points that align with market realities. 'The question is not just about what can be engineered, but what is affordable for the market,' said Khandavalli. Beyond cost, another major challenge in the shift toward SDVs is large-scale integration, particularly when it involves third-party applications. Standardisation, too, remains a critical issue. For instance, there may be multiple suppliers today, with one developing HVAC, another working on passive keyless entry, another on reverse parking assistance. All of these need to be integrated into the central compute unit. 'For seamless integration, standard protocols and respect for defined interfaces are essential, but these practices are still evolving.' Cybersecurity is emerging as another major challenge. 'If you compare last year to now, the number of cyberattacks has risen sharply with more than 60 per cent of them falling into the black-hat category, creating serious risks. Such attacks are already causing an estimated 15-20 per cent impact at scale,' he said. Safeguarding increasingly connected and SDVs remains an evolving area requiring constant vigilance.
