[Editorial] Beef and barriers
As the Aug. 1 deadline for US reciprocal tariffs approaches, South Korea faces intensifying pressure to make politically sensitive trade concessions. Nowhere is this tension more visible than in the dispute over American beef.
On July 24, US President Donald Trump took to social media to praise Australia's decision to open its beef market — including imports of cattle over 30 months old — and warned that countries refusing 'magnificent' US beef were 'on notice.' Among major US trade partners, South Korea now stands alone in maintaining such restrictions.
What's at stake is more than beef. South Korea is racing to avert the imposition of 25 percent reciprocal tariffs on a range of exports. These duties would hit at a precarious moment for its manufacturing base, already strained by stagnant domestic demand and mounting global uncertainty.
In recent talks in Washington and New York, South Korean officials proposed a revised investment package totaling over $100 billion and offered limited concessions on rice and beef — areas long deemed untouchable. Yet US negotiators, emboldened by recent deals with Japan and the UK, are demanding more.
The comparison with Japan has become particularly thorny. Tokyo secured a reduction in reciprocal tariffs to 15 percent in exchange for a $550 billion investment commitment and broader market access for US agricultural and auto exports. South Korea's proposed investment, though substantial, remains well short of that mark.
More troubling, if South Korean exports are hit with 25 percent tariffs while Japan's face only 15 percent, Korean manufacturers would suffer an immediate and damaging competitiveness gap. Recent earnings reports from Hyundai and Kia already show steep profit declines, driven in part by early US tariffs on automobiles. Extending such disadvantages across additional sectors could deepen South Korea's growth malaise and leave long-term economic scars.
The options are narrowing, but not yet exhausted. Seoul has signaled a more flexible posture, suggesting it may allow partial openings of the beef market and step back from earlier prohibitions.
Unlike Japan's investment-heavy deal, however, South Korea is positioning its offer around industrial cooperation, particularly in shipbuilding — a sector President Trump has prioritized for revival. With China expanding its maritime footprint, Washington may be receptive to deeper strategic ties with Seoul in shipbuilding, semiconductors and batteries.
South Korea has framed these offers not merely as trade-offs, but as building blocks of a broader manufacturing alliance aligned with US supply chain objectives.
Still, the outlook remains uncertain. Trump and key trade officials are now in Europe for parallel negotiations, leaving only July 30 and 31 as viable windows for a final agreement. Absent a breakthrough, the tariffs will take effect on Aug. 1.
Analysts warn that if the US proceeds with a 25 percent tariff, South Korea's real gross domestic product could decline by as much as 0.4 percent, even under a gradual adjustment scenario. Medium-sized exporters would be hit hardest, lacking the scale to shift production or absorb the cost shock.
South Korea's negotiators must weigh the costs of limited market concessions against the broader fallout of failure. While agricultural sensitivities are real, clinging to legacy protections may imperil national economic interests. Other countries have accepted sectoral compromises in return for tariff relief and market stability. South Korea must now craft a tailored approach that secures similar benefits without replicating others' terms.
Avoiding a blanket concession is essential, as is avoiding blanket resistance. If Seoul cannot match Tokyo's dollar commitments, it must compensate with industrial leverage, strategic alignment and diplomatic finesse. These final days of negotiation will test its ability to safeguard the economic base while sustaining political and public consensus at home. Never has it been clearer that small concessions now could prevent far greater losses later.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Korea Herald
9 minutes ago
- Korea Herald
S. Korea to resume inter-Korean projects when contact with N. Korea reestablished: unification minister
Unification Minister Chung Dong-young said Monday the government plans to resume using the Inter-Korean Cooperation Fund for humanitarian projects in North Korea once bilateral contact is restored. "It is shocking that none of the Inter-Korean Cooperation Fund was executed last year," Chung said during a meeting with the NGO Council for Inter-Korean Cooperation. The fund, established in 1991, supports economic cooperation as well as social and cultural exchanges between the two Koreas. Its budget peaked at 439.7 billion won ($317.4 million) in 2007 but has since sharply declined amid North Korea's continued nuclear and missile provocations. The most recent use of the fund was in 2023, when 900 million won was allocated to a child nutrition program. Chung recently approved revisions to ministry guidelines governing declarations of contact with North Koreans. Under the new rules, South Korean nationals may freely engage with North Koreans, as long as they report the contact in advance. "Just report it and meet them freely," Chung said, encouraging civic groups to play a more active role in improving frosty inter-Korean relations. In response, Choi Chang-nam, vice chairman of the NGO Council, said the eased restrictions were a relief for activists. According to the ministry, there were no government or civilian-led humanitarian aid projects carried out for North Korea in 2024. (Yonhap)
Korea Herald
5 hours ago
- Korea Herald
Seoul shares end higher on bargain hunting, US rate cut hopes; won sharply up
South Korean stocks closed higher Monday as investors purchased blue chip shares at bargain rates after a steep fall last week and on heightened expectations for the US Federal Reserve's pivot to monetary easing. The Korean won rose sharply against the US dollar. The benchmark Korea Composite Stock Price Index climbed 28.34 points, or 0.91 percent, to close at 3,147.75. Trade volume was a little slim at 291 million shares worth 9.66 trillion won ($6.98 billion), with winners outnumbering losers 677 to 209. Monday's gain came after the Kospi fell at the steepest pace in nearly four months on Friday amid investor sentiment dampened by the government's proposal for a tax revision aimed at raising taxes on corporations and stock investors. Institutions and foreigners bought local shares worth 131.8 billion won and 83.3 billion won, respectively, while retail investors sold a net 300 billion won. "The Kospi rebounded after a 3.9 percent drop last Friday on bargain hunting," Lee Kyoung-min, an analyst at Daishin Securities, said. News reports on the ruling party's possible reconsideration of the tax revision proposal also boosted investors' risk appetite, he added. Lee noted weaker-than-expected US jobs data earlier spread woes over a possible economic recession in the world's biggest economy but also fueled hopes the Fed may go for multiple rate cuts later this year. On Friday, Wall Street lost ground following the release of the US jobs report for July, which indicated the Donald Trump administration's tariff policies were weighing on employment in America. The Dow Jones Industrial Average closed 1.23 percent lower Friday, with the tech-heavy Nasdaq composite sliding 2.24 percent. The S&P 500 index fell 1.6 percent. In Seoul, market top-cap Samsung Electronics rose 1.16 percent to close at 69,700 won, while chip giant SK hynix remained unchanged at 258,000 won. Top internet portal operator Naver jumped 3.11 percent to 232,500 won amid expectations for the country's push to foster the artificial intelligence industry, and leading nuclear power plant builder Doosan Enerbility soared 4.72 percent to 64,300 won. The state-run Korea Electric Power Corp. climbed 2.9 percent to 37,200 won, and major defense firm Hyundai Rotem escalated 3.09 percent to 200,000 won. Bio and auto shares also gained ground. Samsung Biologics climbed 1.35 percent to 1.05 million won, and Celltrion advanced 1.52 percent to 173,900 won. Top automaker Hyundai Motor added 0.48 percent to 211,000 won, and its sister Kia increased 1.98 percent to 102,800 won. In contrast, shipbuilders fell sharply after last week's rally. Shipbuilders had soared on the back of South Korea's pledge to invest $150 billion in the US shipbuilding industry as part of a tariff deal with the Trump administration. HD Hyundai Heavy lost 2.73 percent to 463,500 won, Hanwha Ocean tumbled 2.64 percent to 114,300 won, and HD Korea Shipbuilding dropped 1.6 percent to 337,500 won. The local currency was quoted at 1,385.2 won against the greenback at 3:30 p.m., sharply up 16.2 won from the previous session. (Yonhap)
Korea Herald
5 hours ago
- Korea Herald
South Korea begins dismantling border loudspeakers to ease tensions with the North
South Korea on Monday began dismantling its loudspeakers near the border used for anti-Pyongyang propaganda, in a "practical step" to ease tensions with North Korea, Seoul's Defense Ministry said the same day. 'The removal is a follow-up measure to the suspension of loudspeaker broadcasts in June,' said Col. Lee Kyung-ho, vice spokesperson of the Defense Ministry, during a press briefing. 'It is being carried out within a scope that does not affect our military's readiness.' The ministry's vice spokesperson added that the latest move was a result of discussions within the Lee Jae Myung administration and was not pre-negotiated with North Korea. Seoul has dismantled and reinstalled loudspeakers near the border repeatedly since the 1960s, depending on the status of inter-Korean relations. The most recent suspension occurred under the 2018 Panmunjom Declaration during the liberal Moon Jae-in administration. The system was reactivated in June 2024 under the conservative Yoon Suk Yeol administration in response to North Korea's launch of waste-carrying balloons over the border. President Lee Jae Myung, who took office on June 4, ordered broadcasts to be halted on June 11 in an effort to thaw inter-Korean relations. He also cited stress caused to residents near the border as an additional reason to stop the broadcasts. North Korea ceased its own broadcasts towards the South the following day. All fixed loudspeakers are expected to be removed within a few days, according to the ministry. Mobile and vehicle-mounted units were withdrawn following the June 11 suspension. A Seoul-based expert projected the decision to be effective in reducing border tensions. 'This is not a reciprocal move, but a preemptive action that enhances South Korea's image as a peace-loving nation,' said Yang Moo-jin, president and professor at the University of North Korean Studies. He added that the move could mark the beginning of efforts to restore the 2018 inter-Korean military agreement. The accord was nullified after North Korea unilaterally withdrew from it in November 2023. South Korea later suspended the deal in June 2024 in response to North Korea's launch of trash-filled balloons across the border. Yang also stressed the importance of reviewing the scale and nature of joint South Korea-US military drills going forward. 'Military training is natural for any nation with armed forces. However, for progress toward a peace-based economic model on the Korean Peninsula, we must limit operations to defensive drills and halt retaliatory or large-scale punitive responses,' he said. North Korea has yet to take corresponding steps. 'We've observed signs of maintenance work on some of their loudspeakers, but not removal,' said Joint Chiefs of Staff spokesperson Col. Lee Sung-jun during Monday's briefing. He noted that North Korea is believed to operate slightly more loudspeakers than South Korea, which reportedly had about 20 in use before June. Meanwhile, Seoul's Defense Ministry confirmed that annual joint military drills with the United States will proceed as scheduled in mid-August.
