AI could destroy entire justice system by sending innocent people to JAIL with fake CCTV, Making a Murderer lawyer warns
Jerry Buting, who defended Steven Avery in Netflix hit Making a Murderer, said video doctoring is becoming so sophisticated it is increasingly hard to spot.
Advertisement
3
Deepfake technology is advancing to clone the features of a person and map them onto something else. Stock picture
Credit: Alamy
3
Jerry Buting argued to jurors that Steven Avery had been framed in Netflix documentary Making a Murderer
Credit: NETFLIX
3
Avery remains is prison after being given a lift sentence
Credit: Splash News
He believes advanced AI convincingly fabricating evidence could lead to innocent people being thrown behind bars.
Buting, author of Illusion of Justice, told The Sun: 'More and more people could get convicted.'
Deepfake technology is becoming worryingly advanced and exceedingly more difficult to regulate.
Experts have previously told The Sun that deepfakes are the "biggest evolving threat" when it comes to cybercrime.
Advertisement
More on AI
Deepfakes are fraudulent videos that appear to show a person doing - and possibly saying - things they did not do.
Artificial intelligence-style software is used to clone the features of a person and map them onto something else.
It could see people accused of crimes they didn't commit in a chilling echo of BBC drama The Capture.
The show saw a former British soldier accused of kidnap and murder based on seemingly definitive CCTV footage which had actually been altered.
Advertisement
Most read in Tech
Live Blog
Buting said: "The tricky part is when AI gets to the point where you can doctor evidence without it being obvious, where you can alter videos.
'There are so many CCTV cameras in the UK, virtually every square foot is covered.
Deepfakes: A Digital Threat to Society
'But if that could be altered in some way so that it is designed to present something that's not true, it could be damaging to the defence or prosecution.
"Then what can we believe if we can't believe our own eyes?'
Advertisement
Buting, who defended Avery in his now infamous 2007 murder trial, said AI is now in a race with experts who are being trained to tell the difference.
But the US-based criminal defence lawyer claims that is no guarantee to stop sickos twisting the truth.
Buting claimed: 'It may result in dismissals but I think it's more likely to result in wrongful convictions because law enforcement and the prosecution just have more resources.
"Nobody really knows how AI is going to impact the justice system.
Advertisement
"But there are also very skilled people who are trying to develop techniques of being able to tell when something has been altered, even at a sophisticated level.
"How AI actually affects the legal system is still very much up in the air.
Deepfakes – what are they, and how do they work?
Here's what you need to know...
Deepfakes are phoney videos of people that look perfectly real
They're made using computers to generate convincing representations of events that never happened
Often, this involves swapping the face of one person onto another, or making them say whatever you want
The process begins by feeding an AI hundreds or even thousands of photos of the victim
A machine learning algorithm swaps out certain parts frame-by-frame until it spits out a realistic, but fake, photo or video
In one famous deepfake clip, comedian Jordan Peele created a realistic video of Barack Obama in which the former President called Donald Trump a 'dipsh*t'
In another, the face of Will Smith is pasted onto the character of Neo in the action flick The Matrix. Smith famously turned down the role to star in flop movie Wild Wild West, while the Matrix role went to Keanu Reeves
"If people are able to discover that evidence has been altered, let's say it's a situation where the defence has an expert who can look at the metadata and all the background, then that may very well result in a dismissal of the case, and should.
'Because the evidence was altered, it's original destroyed, how can we believe anything anymore?"
Advertisement
Former White House Information Officer Theresa Payton previously
She said: "This technology poses risks if misused by criminal syndicates or nation-state cyber operatives.
"Malicious applications include creating fake personas to spread misinformation, manipulate public opinion, and conduct sophisticated social engineering attacks."
In Black Mirror style, Payton warned malicious actors could exploit this technology to sow confusion and chaos by creating deepfakes of world leaders or famous faces - dead or alive.
Advertisement
Buting warned that although teams are being urgently equipped with skills to spot deepfakes, the pace at which the technology is advancing could soon become a real issue.
Who is Steven Avery?
STEVEN Avery is serving a life sentence at Wisconsin's Waupun Correctional Institution.
He and his nephew
He has been fighting for his freedom ever since he was found guilty of murder in 2007.
Avery argued that his conviction was based on planted evidence and false testimony.
In 1985,
It took 18 years for his conviction to be overturned and he was given a $36million (£28.2million) payout in compensation.
But days later, he was re-arrested for the murder of
The 62-year-old is continuing serving life in prison without the possibility of parole.
In the 2015 Netflix original series Making a Murderer, Avery documented his struggle for "justice."
In the last episode of the series, viewers were told that Avery had exhausted his appeals and was no longer entitled to state-appointed legal representation.
He added: 'I do fear it could be an issue sooner rather than later.
"There has been a steady erosion in the defence in the UK, for example barristers make very little money, really, for what they have to do.
'There is a real imbalance. The whole idea of an adversary system which the UK employs as do we in the US, is if you have two relatively skilled, equal parties on each side presenting their view of the evidence against the others that the truth will come out.
Advertisement
'Or that the jury will be able to discern the truth or close to it in anyway, whatever justice might be.
'But to the extent that there is this big imbalance and the defence is unskilled or underpaid, then you tend to get lower quality or lower experienced attorneys.
'That's been going on for a long time, so then when you add something like AI to it, it's going to be even harder."
Buting became internationally renowned after appearing on the 2015 Netflix documentary series Making a Murderer.
Advertisement
He alleged Avery had been convicted of a murder he didn't commit, falling foul of a set-up.
But Avery, now 62,
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
43 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
My dad Ian Huntley sends me dark letters from jail & haunts every second of my life – I can't bear looking in the mirror
Daughter of Soham killer reveals how she is even terrified of meeting strangers due to their probing questions - and why she has written to him one last time DEVIL'S DAUGHTER My dad Ian Huntley sends me dark letters from jail & haunts every second of my life – I can't bear looking in the mirror LOOKING in the mirror each morning, Samantha Bryan can barely stand it as she sees the eyes of a murderer staring back. As the traumatised daughter of Soham killer Ian Huntley, just getting through each day is a struggle as she discovers dark new details about her dad and receives twisted letters from him in jail. 8 Samantha Bryan is the daughter of killer Ian Huntley Credit: Glen Minikin 8 Evil Huntley has written to Samantha from his cell Credit: Rex Features 8 The sicko murdered 10-year-olds Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman in 2002 Credit: Collect Desperate for answers over what drove the former school caretaker to kill 10-year-old girls Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman in 2002, Samantha, 28, sent her father a letter over a year ago asking to meet him. Out of the blue, months later, in neat, black biro he wrote back, heartlessly accusing her of "insincere motives", adding: 'You are still my daughter for whom I have much love. With Love, Ian'. Care worker Samantha, of Cleethorpes, North East Lincs, has now written to her 'monster' dad one last time asking to meet, explaining it would help her to process a lifetime of trauma that has left her struggling with anxiety and depression. Speaking to The Sun for our Meeting a Monster series, she says: 'When I first read Ian's letter I was angry, frustrated and upset. "He told me he loved me as his daughter. 'I felt, 'you have no right to say that'. 'At the time it was so difficult to read. I felt so many emotions. 'All I could think about was how many times over the years he's wished me well but he's still denying that one thing that could really help me move forward. 'How can he say that he loves me when he has not done the one thing that will allow me to move forward with my life? 'Which is to finally reveal the truth. 'I hoped he would agree to meet me. I have written one last time to ask for that. It would really help me to process everything and to try to move forward.' Why I want to meet my monster dad Ian Huntley Samantha was 14 years old when she discovered who her father was after she was asked to research "notorious crimes" at school, and stumbled across a pixilated photograph of herself and her mother on Google. In the aftermath of this revelation, she turned to drink for a year aged 17 and was taken to the brink of a breakdown. More than a decade on, she is still haunted "every day" by the murders, which shocked the nation and remain among the most notorious in British criminal history. Samantha says: 'Being the biological daughter of Ian Huntley has impacted my life in ways not many people would understand. 'I've dealt with severe anxiety, depression. I've been in and out of therapy for years. 'I've struggled a lot to come to terms with who I am and where I come from, who Ian is and what he's done. 'It's something that haunts me daily. I think about it all the time and I don't think it's ever something that will leave me. 'Every time I look in the mirror I see how much I look like him. I have his eyes. 8 Huntley worked as a caretaker in the school both girls attended Credit: Alamy 8 The murderer has written chilling letters to his daughter Credit: Supplied 'Someone put up a photo of me next to his online and that's when I realised the similarities. 'People often say to me: 'I know your face from somewhere'. 'My heart sinks when they do, as I know they are referring to him, but they just can't place it. I just say: 'No we haven't met before' but so often they look puzzled. 'I think I have other traits from that side of the family as I'm also the only one in my family that has asthma. It's so hard to be the child of what everyone says is a monster... I know I'm a good person but at night that haunts me 'I found an article talking about his medical history online as I wanted to see if there was anything I should be worried about and I read that he has asthma too. 'That took me to a dark place. 'I had periods of despair where I have struggled with the fact of who my biological father is and that the only thing I know about him is what I've read - and what my mum has told me and that is that he's a monster.' Mum's suffering Samantha's mother Katie first met Huntley when she was a 15-year-old schoolgirl, running away from home to live with him against her parents' wishes. Their relationship descended into violence and he subjected her to humiliation - including making her eat cat food - and rape, before Samantha was born. Katie left him for good when she was pregnant with Samantha and has always told her daughter that becoming pregnant saved her from his abuse. Samantha admitted her mum does not want her to meet him, but has promised to support her in her decision. 8 Samantha's mother Katie Bryan left Huntley after he abused her Credit: Glen Minikin 8 Huntley was sentenced to life with a minimum of 40 years Credit: PA:Press Association 8 His girlfriend Maxine Carr was convicted of perverting the course of justice Credit: Cambridgeshire Police She said: 'When you look so much like someone you desperately want to know there is something good in them. 'I know I don't have evil in me. There is no way to condone what he has done. All I want from Ian is a conversation. 'Even if he doesn't want to talk about the events of that day, I want to see him for who he is. 'My mum's side of the family are amazing people and I'm so lucky to have been brought up around the people that I have. 'I want to know where that other half of me comes from. I want to know that it's not all bad, it's not all evil and that there is even just a glimmer of something good there. 'It's so hard to be the child of what everyone says is a monster. 'I know I'm a good person but at night that haunts me.' But that seemed to contradict it all...I just couldn't fathom why he could do such a thing Samantha reveals the catalyst that led her to make one last attempt to meet Huntley was the death in jail of a killer called Bradley Murdoch, who murdered British backpacker Peter Falconio in 2001. She said: 'He took his secret to the grave. I couldn't face that if that were to happen here.' Just a few weeks ago Samantha was also shown The Sun's exclusive story that Huntley had been wearing Holly and Jessica's football tops in his cell. She tells us: 'It brought it all up again. I was sickened. 'He previously wrote to me hinting at how bad he felt. But that seemed to contradict it all. "I just couldn't fathom why he could do such a thing. "I just thought of Holly and Jessica's parents because if I felt bad, what on earth would they be thinking? "I was upset for weeks and couldn't sleep as it's just so devastating."I was upset for weeks and couldn't sleep as it's just so devastating. 'This has been a constant shadow in my life.'
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Thousands of Guatemalans deported from US with nothing more than the contents of a white plastic sack
'Maybe you have left your family in the US but the same god who is here in Guatemala is there in the US,' says a local church volunteer at La Aurora Air Force Base in Guatemala city. The volunteer is leading more than 90 Guatemalans in prayer. They have just stepped off a US deportation flight and are being processed at the Centre for Returnees. Before being deported, the Guatemalans were held at a US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (Ice) facility in Alexandria, Louisiana. Amid a far-reaching crackdown on immigration by US president Donald Trump , La Aurora base has received more than 266 US deportation flights this year, according to Witness at the Border. More than 24,000 Guatemalans have been deported from the US in 2025, according to data from the Guatemalan Institute for Migration. An official at the state-backed reception centre for returnees at La Aurora base says most people now being deported have spent long periods in the US and often have children with US citizenship. READ MORE Wearing the standard grey tracksuit supplied at US detention centres, 45-year-old electrician Pablo Vélez says he had feared being detained in the months leading up to his arrest by Ice in California. 'My father was murdered in Guatemala and both my mother and brother were granted asylum in the US,' says deportee Pablo Vélez. Photograph: Hannah McCarthy 'A lot of the Guatemalan community in California are staying at home and not even leaving for work right now,' he says. Vélez was detained while attending court to apply for asylum two months earlier. 'My father was murdered in Guatemala and both my mother and brother were granted asylum in the US,' says Vélez. He didn't apply for asylum when they did, but later travelled with a smuggler – known locally as a 'coyote' – to join his family in the US. In California he married an American-born Mexican woman, with whom he has an 18-year-old son. Vélez says he was deported from the US in 2008 but returned in 2015 with help from another smuggler. Now separated from his wife, he's unsure whether he'll find work as an electrician in Guatemala. Vélez says a nephew is going to pick him up and he says he will begin to build a life in Guatemala once again. [ What it would take for America to deport 11 million immigrants Opens in new window ] Under Trump's new Detained Parents Directive , family separations are likely to increase as Ice's obligations to facilitate reunification of parents with their children before deportation are weakened. An official at the airbase recalls one distressed woman arriving earlier this year who had been separated from her young daughter when she was deported from the US. The official says more than 800 Guatemalan minors have been deported this year and the youngest child he saw on a deportation flight was three years old. In July the US Congress passed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which allocated record funding to the US's deportation system, including $45 billion for detention, $14.4 billion for deportation and $10 billion to expand Ice. 'The budget for immigration detention is now more than 62 per cent larger than the budget for the entire Federal Bureau of Prisons,' stated the Washington Office on Latin America, a nonprofit advocacy group. 'With the vast scope and scale of these resources, the number of people removed after long periods in the US is very certain to grow.' Bags containing belongings confiscated in the US and returned via Guatemalan authorities. Photograph: Hannah McCarthy Some Guatemalan deportees are returning with nothing. Most, however, collect a white plastic sack containing belongings confiscated by US authorities and returned via Guatemalan authorities. Guatemala's government has rolled out a new Return Home Plan that offers some services to deportees. But the usual network of NGOs, churches and state agencies is under strain due to USAid cuts imposed by the Trump administration. Begging has visibly increased in the centre of Guatemala City. Marisela Tzul (35), who asks to be referred to by her middle name, was handed a small brown bag of food and a hygiene pack, and is tying her shoes with new laces – it is standard practice in US detention facilities to remove detainee's laces to prevent self-harm. [ US Ice agents took half their workforce. What do they do now? Opens in new window ] Marisela, originally from Totonicapán, travelled to the US with a coyote in 2023. She was working at a garment factory in Los Angeles until 50 days ago when she was detained by IC agents. 'The owner of the factory saw Ice agents entering the factory beside us and she just handed us over to them,' says Marisela. She and nine others – seven Guatemalans and two Mexicans – were arrested. Over the next 50 days she was transferred from California to Nevada, then Arizona, Texas and finally Louisiana. Marisela says she doesn't want to talk about conditions at the centres – 'it was terrible.' She says she was only informed that she would be deported at 3am two days earlier. 'No one in my family knows I'm here,' she says. She has had no contact with them since she was detained. Guatemalan consular officials have reported challenges in accessing Guatemalan citizens in some US detention facilities. Marisela Tzul (35) was handed a small brown bag of food. Photograph: Hannah McCarthy After being processed most deportees board a large yellow bus to either temporary shelter or Guatemala City's central bus station, where they will make their own way home. But some families are waiting outside the airbase for their loved ones. Young men who appeared stoic moments before crumble as they meet their parents who hold them tightly as they sob.
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Bank-emptying Gmail and Outlook attachments overtaken by even WORSE costly email con that's much harder for you to spot
Over 3 billion attacks have been sent out so far CASH KILLER Bank-emptying Gmail and Outlook attachments overtaken by even WORSE costly email con that's much harder for you to spot BRITS are being warned to watch out – because the dodgy email attachments that used to drain your bank account have just been outdone by an even sneakier scam that's much harder to catch. Cyber experts have revealed that online crooks now prefer planting malicious links over using infected attachments - and the results are far worse. 2 The tools are so easy that even low-level scammers are jumping on the trend Credit: Alamy According to a new bombshell report by Proofpoint, the hidden traps are tucked inside emails, buttons, and even PDFs or Word docs, and one wrong click could see your logins stolen or malware silently installed. Advertisement Over 3 billion attacks with dodgy URLs have been sent out and the main goal is to steal passwords. This hacking scheme isn't just being used by criminal masterminds either. The tool are so easy to get hold of that even low-level scammers can launch convincing fakes that bypass security checks like multi-factor authentication and take full control of your account. Proofpoint also uncovered a jaw-dropping 400 percent spike in a sneaky scam called 'ClickFix' – where users are tricked into clicking fake error messages or CAPTCHA boxes. Advertisement These convincing cons trick you into running harmful code, opening the door to remote access trojans, info-stealers, and more. Meanwhile, QR code phishing attacks are exploding, with over 4.2 million attempts spotted in just the first half of 2025. These nasty little codes target your personal mobile – dodging work defences completely. And let's not forget smishing – dodgy texts that try to fool you. Advertisement 2 MM1WHE Internet fraud concept with faceless hooded male person using tablet computer, low key red and blue lit image and digital glitch effect Credit: Alamy More than half of all SMS phishing attempts now come packed with malicious URLs, making it harder than ever to stay safe. Selena Larson, top threat analyst at Proofpoint, gave a stark warning: 'The most damaging cyber threats today don't target machines or systems. They target people.' She added that these new-style scams are designed to exploit human psychology, using trusted brands and familiar tech to lure you in – whether it's a dodgy CAPTCHA, a QR code, or a believable text message. This comes after a devastating con carried out by Chinese organised crime groups was exposed. Advertisement So-called 'pig butchering' is where scammers established fake romantic and trusting relationships with victims before luring them into fraudulent investments or other financial traps. In 2023, Shan Hanes, a banker from Kansas, US, embezzled £34.6million from his bank to cover his losses, having fallen victim to a pig butchering scam. Hanes was later sentenced to more than 24 years behind bars. Usually, a pig butchering scam works in three stages – hunting, raising and killing. This involves a scammer finding a victim online, chatting to them in order to build up trust and then getting them to invest large amounts of money into fraudulent schemes. Advertisement The scam works in a similar way to a traditional romance scam, where scammers approach their victims by posing as a possible romantic partner on a dating app, or as a friend via social media. The big difference though is how the scam is executed. With a romance scam, trust is based on the victim's urge to maintain a romantic relationship with the scammer. In this scenario, the scam can often last for years. Pig butchering scams though, in comparison, generally take place over a much shorter time period. Advertisement The scammer, rather than focusing on trying to extract money through emotional manipulation, leans more on the victim's desire to make money together with the scammer. This can involve just a few months rather than years to take advantage of the victim. Usually, the scammer will present themselves as being financially successful and confident with a broad network and have appealing investment opportunities. Once the victim has made an initial small investment, the scammer will then try to escalate the process and push them into making a much larger financial commitment, reports.
