New York Giants wrap offseason workout program: Winners and losers from spring practices

Yahoo

18 hours ago

The New York Giants have officially wrapped their offseason workout program, culminating with a three-day mandatory minicamp that came to a close on Thursday with exit interviews.
The team will now break for five weeks before returning to East Rutherford for training camp on July 22. But in the meantime, coaches will continue to evaluate their 90-man roster with cutdown day inching ever closer.
Advertisement
Here's a look at some winners and losers from the team's spring workouts.
Winners
QB Russell Wilson - There is no question Wilson will start in 2025 after taking the majority of first-team reps throughout the spring. He looked crisp and comfortable, drew praise from his coaches and teammates, and demonstrated much-needed leadership.
QB Jaxson Dart - There were some expected rookie hiccups throughout the spring, but it's easy to see why the Giants preferred Dart to other available quarterbacks in the 2025 NFL draft. He may not start in 2025 but if things get hairy, don't be surprised if Daboll turns to the rookie. He loves the kid.
Advertisement
WR Jalin Hyatt - Before suffering an undisclosed leg injury at minicamp, Hyatt was having a spring that renewed hope for his career. He returned to the team sporting an additional 15-20 pounds of muscle and had rededicated himself to the game of football. He developed an obvious rapport with Wilson, aided by private offseason workouts, and looked very much like the speedy deep threat everyone expected him to be.
WR Ihmir Smith-Marsette - With so many other receivers shining, it's easy to overlook Smith-Marsette. However, in addition to his special teams prowess and leadership, which drew praise from special teams coordinator Michael Ghobrial, he also had the opportunity to make some plays at wide receiver -- something he wants more of in 2025.
S Dane Belton - Ballhawking Belton was at it again all spring, totaling at least four interceptions, two of which were returned for touchdowns. He's on a path to solidify himself not only as safety No. 3, but as a player who warrants more time on the field alongside Jevon Holland and Tyler Nubin.
OL Evan Neal - Precious few gave Neal a chance when the team shifted him from right tackle to guard, and while it's unfair to say he's taken to the position like a fish to water, Neal has performed admirably. He's not likely to earn a starting job, but he's added to his versatility by playing both guard positions. He's also earned the respect of his coaches and teammates for his willingness to do whatever the team needs.
Advertisement
WR Beaux Collins and WR Dalen Cambre - Collins and Cambre (and other UDFA receivers) were having a solid spring before Hyatt was injured. After the third-year wideout went down, Collins and Cambre stepped up in a big way, earning first-team reps and making plays while on the field. There are precious few spots available at the position, but both will enter training camp on the radar of the coaching staff.
EDGE Abdul Carter - What even needs to be said? Carter is as advertised and maybe even better than expected. He's been completely dominant, especially against the second team, and never takes a play off. The more he settles into his new surroundings, the more game-wrecking he becomes.
CB Cor'Dale Flott - Daboll refuses to say Flott and Deonte Banks are in a competition, but it's evident they are. Flott has split first-team reps with Banks and has a chance to secure the starting job, although this really just seems like a reality check and motivational tactic to get the most out of Banks.
Losers
QB Tommy DeVito - There is nothing that DeVito has done wrong on the field. That's the unfortunate reality facing him right now. He's clearly buried on the depth chart behind Wilson, Jameis Winston, and Dart, and it's unlikely he'll be able to climb that ladder no matter what he does. He's in place as the statesman of the quarterback room -- he knows the offense inside and out, and that's about it.
Advertisement
LB Victor Dimukeje - Already facing an uphill battle along the edge, Dimukeje's spring was cut short before it even began. He suffered a torn pec in March and is out for up to six months (September). He'll likely start training camp on the physically unable to perform (PUP) list.
S Anthony Johnson - With Belton lighting the world on fire, it effectively leaves only one safety spot open for the taking. Unfortunately for Johnson, he's missed time this spring due to a lingering shoulder injury.
RB Cam Skattebo - The rookie was immediately met with excitement from fans for his violent play style, but it wasn't on display this spring. Skattebo was largely sidelined by an undisclosed injury, although it does not seem to be serious in nature. Still, any rookie missing time is a negative considering the transition that needs to take place from college to the NFL.
DL Darius Alexander - See above.
Advertisement
K Graham Gano - The veteran kicker may be back and healthy, but the path to the starting job is anything but secure. The Giants have been relatively open about Jude McAtamney having a chance to compete, and that will continue throughout training camp.
Mixed
CB Deonte Banks - While Flott is considered a winner for earning a split of first-team reps, it would be unfair to call Banks a loser for the position he's in. Yes, he lost the CB1 job and his stranglehold on the CB2 job, but he arrived for spring workouts in great shape and with a renewed dedication to the team, the sport, and his position. He's come in humble and with a strong work ethic, earning the praise of coaches for his effort both on and off the field.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Giants wrap offseason program: Winners/losers from spring practices