&w=3840&q=100)
Delhi HC pulls up Wipro: What a company can't say in employee's dismissal letter
Wipro has been asked to pay compensatory damages to its former employee. Representational Image/Reuters
Can employers use harsh language against an employee in a termination letter? The Delhi High Court has come down heavily on IT major Wipro Limited for remarks against the professional character of a former employee in his dismissal letter.
The court has asked the company to pay compensation to the man and issue a fresh termination letter. The ex-employee had filed a defamation suit and sought damages of over Rs 2.10 crore.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Let's take a closer look.
What did Wipro say in the pink slip?
Abhijit Mishra worked as a principal consultant at Wipro between 2018-2020.
In his termination letter, the company used phrases like 'malicious conduct' and 'complete loss of trust.'
He then moved the Delhi High Court against Wipro and sought compensation.
Delhi High Court pulls up Wipro
The Delhi High Court has ordered Wipro to pay Rs 2 lakh in compensatory damages to Mishra over the termination letter that it said was replete with 'stigma and insinuations.'
Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav asked Wipro to expunge defamatory remarks made against the professional character of its ex-employee.
'Further, a fresh termination letter shall be issued to the plaintiff devoid of any defamatory content, and consequently, the impugned termination letter shall cease to be of any effect insofar as the defamatory content is concerned,' the Delhi High Court said, as per LiveLaw.
The court found that Wipro's termination letter contained unsubstantiated negative remarks against Mishra.
'The remarks therein, couched in the use of the term 'malicious conduct', not only lack substantiation but also have a direct and deleterious impact on the future employability and professional dignity of the plaintiff,' the judge noted.
Ruling in favour of the ex-employee, the High Court said that there was a 'clear mismatch' between the comments in the dismissal letter and consistent positive feedback in several official documents.
The court observed that the remarks were 'demonstrably false and defamatory in nature' and that Wipro did not establish a valid defence.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
ALSO READ: Why Karnataka is probing mass layoffs at Infosys
It asked Wipro to pay compensation to Mishra 'to redress the reputational harm, emotional hardship, and loss of professional credibility'.
Justice Kaurav said that the tenor of the communication reflected a noticeable 'intent to carry out a form of character assassination by Wipro under the semblance of administrative formality, thereby compounding the damage to Mishra's reputation and standing,' as per an Economic Times (ET) report.
The Delhi High Court also interpreted the doctrine of 'compelled self-publication' in matters related to defamation, ruling that 'employers cannot evade liability' under defamation law by using 'confidential correspondence as a shield'.
Justice Kaurav said about the doctrine, 'It ensures that employers cannot evade liability by using confidential correspondence as a shield when, in substance, their actions set in motion the very harm the law seeks to redress.'
He concluded that the defamation law cannot allow reputational harm, arising out of unsupported claims, to continue, especially when it significantly impacts a person's career and prospects, reported LiveLaw.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
What did Wipro argue in court?
Wipro had argued before the High Court that Mishra, who worked in a senior, creative, and managerial position that required highly creative and original work, focused more on his self-styled identity as a 'crusader for social change,' rather than his professional duties, as per the ET report.
The company claimed Mishra's behaviour showed his 'lack of interest' in improving his professional performance, which ultimately resulted in his termination.
With inputs from agencies
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
AI 171 crash: Interim compensation released to families of 147 of 229 deceased passengers, 19 persons who perished on ground
Following the tragic crash of Air India flight AI 171 on June 12, the Tata group airline has so far released the Rs 25-lakh interim compensation to the families of 147 of the 229 passengers who perished in the crash and 19 who were killed at the accident site. The crash claimed a total of 260 lives–229 of the 230 passengers on board the Boeing 787-8 aircraft, 12 flight and cabin crew personnel, and 19 persons on the ground. It was the worst aviation disaster involving an Indian airline in four decades. 'Air India has, so far, released the interim compensation to the families of 147 of the 229 deceased passengers and also the 19 who lost their lives at the accident site. In addition, the requisite documents of 52 others have been verified, to whose families the interim compensation will be released progressively,' Air India said in a statement Saturday. This interim payment will be adjusted against any final compensation that may be announced for the next of kin of the crash victims. The exact compensation and legal proceedings vary depending on the jurisdiction and whether the flight was domestic or international, according to experts. Airlines typically maintain liability insurance that covers passengers or their families in the event of injury or death, regardless of the cause of the accident. Compensation is largely governed by international or national aviation laws and the airline's own policies. Under the Montreal Convention, applicable to most international flights, airlines are strictly liable for damages up to a certain threshold — currently around SDR (special drawing rights) 128,821 or approximately Rs 1.50 crore per passenger — and can be held liable for higher amounts if negligence is proven. In cases where foreign nationals are among the deceased, their families have the option to file claims in jurisdictions such as the country of the carrier, the place where the ticket was purchased, or the home country of the victim. Since nationals from Britain, Canada, and Portugal were among the victims, compansation-related legal proceedings in courts of various international jurisdictions cannot be ruled out. According to insurance industry sources, the crash is expected to result in total claims of around Rs 4,000 crore (approximately $470 million), making it one of the most significant insurance events involving an aircraft accident. The aircraft hull alone is estimated to cost insurers and reinsurers about $80 million, with the engines valued at an additional $45 million. Liability claims related to passenger deaths are expected to reach approximately $350 million, though the final amount may vary depending on the number and nature of claims filed and the jurisdictions involved. Apart from the interim payout announced by the airline after the crash, its parent Tata Sons also pledged an ex-gratia payment of Rs 1 crore for each of the deceased. The payment will be through the Rs 500-crore AI-171 Memorial and Welfare Trust set up by Tata Sons. Apart from the ex-gratia compensation, the trust will support the rebuilding of the BJ Medical College hostel infrastructure that was badly damaged in the accident. 'The Trust will also provide aid and assistance for alleviation of any trauma or distress suffered by the first responders, medical and disaster relief professionals, social workers, and governmental staff who provided invaluable institutional support and service in the aftermath of the accident,' Air India said. Sukalp Sharma is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express and writes on a host of subjects and sectors, notably energy and aviation. He has over 13 years of experience in journalism with a body of work spanning areas like politics, development, equity markets, corporates, trade, and economic policy. He considers himself an above-average photographer, which goes well with his love for travel. ... Read More
Indian Express
13 minutes ago
- Indian Express
India-UK trade deal enables duty-free exports, China's mega dam causes fresh unease, Gaza at breaking point
India signs its first landmark trade deal with the UK, secures enhanced market access in export-oriented and job-creating sectors; During Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to the Maldives, New Delhi launches talks on FTA, announces a Rs 4,850-crore line of credit to the maritime neighbouring country; amid reports of India-China thaw, Beijing's mega-dam project on the Brahmaputra (Yarlung Tsangpo) raises hackles in New Delhi; India calls for ceasefire in Gaza, where starvation deaths and killings seem to have crossed a critical threshold; as the clash between Thailand and Cambodia entered its third day, Indians in Cambodia advised to avoid travelling to border areas – here is weekly roundup of key global news. Enhanced market access in export-oriented and job-creating sectors, and duty-free access for 99 per cent of India's exports to the UK are among the major benefits New Delhi bagged as part of its first landmark trade deal with London. The Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), signed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his British counterpart Keir Starmer in London on Thursday (July 24), comes as India seeks to integrate more closely with developed countries. Notably, India's exports to the UK rose by 12.6 per cent to $14.5 billion, while imports grew by 2.3 per cent to $8.6 billion in 2024–25. Bilateral trade between the two nations increased to $21.34 billion in 2023–24 from $20.36 billion in 2022–23. Let's explore the key aspects of the trade deal. Major highlights of the trade deal include: 📌 The trade deal paves the way for 'unprecedented duty-free access for 99 per cent of India's exports to the UK', covering almost the entire trade basket. This includes key job-creating sectors such as textiles, leather, footwear and gems and jewellery, as well as sectors like engineering goods and automobile components. 📌 For instance, the UK will eliminate duties of up to 20 per cent on textiles, giving a competitive edge to India – the fourth-largest textile supplier to the UK – over other competitors like China and Bangladesh. Micro, Small and Medium-scale Enterprises (MSMEs), which have a dominant presence in the sector, are also expected to benefit from the agreement. 📌 India extracted enhanced market access in export-oriented sectors such as marine and animal products, including seafood, dairy, and meat products, with tariffs reduced to zero from up to 20 per cent. Tariffs on tea and coffee have also been scrapped. 📌 For the first time, India has allowed firms from the UK to participate in government tenders, giving them Class Two status under 'Make In India' rules, which require 20-50 per cent domestic value addition. However, experts warned that the 20 per cent local content rule, which allows UK firms to use up to 80 per cent inputs from third countries while still receiving preferential treatment, dilutes the benefits that programmes like Make in India and Atmanirbhar Bharat were designed to protect. 📌 Experts also indicated that the access granted to the UK could set a precedent for future Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) with larger economies like the European Union (EU) or the United States (US), potentially eroding India's ability to use public procurement as a lever for policy goals such as import substitution, domestic capacity-building, and employment generation. 📌 Moreover, as part of the new deal, average tariffs on British products will also fall from 15 per cent to 3 per cent, potentially leading to a large increase in exports from the UK. Britain's large and varied manufacturing sectors will also benefit from tariff cuts on aerospace (reduced from as high as 11 per cent to 0 per cent), automotives (from up to 110 per cent down to 10 per cent), and electrical machinery (from up to 22 per cent). 📌 For the first time, India also halved the import tariffs on UK-origin alcohol, including whisky, brandy, rum, vodka, liqueurs, mead, cider, and tequila from 150 per cent to 75 per cent. However, these products are expected to meet a Minimum Import Price (MIP) threshold of $5 per litre or $6 per 750 ml bottle, effectively shielding India's domestic liquor market from low-cost imports while giving premium UK spirits a competitive edge. 📌 Duties on internal combustion engine cars have also been slashed to 30-50 per cent, paving the way for more British luxury vehicles to enter India, although the benefit will be quota-based and apply to a limited number of vehicles. Zero-emission cars will also see reduced tariffs, depending on their cost, benefiting automakers like Jaguar Land Rover, a manufacturer of SUVs. No concessions were given to electric, hybrid, and hydrogen-powered vehicles in the first five years. 📌 The UK and India have also agreed to ease the exchange of services. They will now require temporary employees to pay social security contributions only in their home countries, which would mean greater take-home salaries. The agreement increases market access in critical areas such as IT and IT-enabled services as well as financial, legal, professional and educational services. 📌 But experts said that India seems to have conceded much when it comes to Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), as UK patent holders are now allowed to give voluntary licences as opposed to compulsory licences, representing a marked shift. Soon after concluding his two-day visit to the UK, PM Modi arrived in the Maldives, where India also launched talks on FTA and announced a Rs 4,850-crore line of credit to the maritime neighbouring country. 'Peace, stability, and prosperity in the Indian Ocean Region are our shared goals…,' PM Modi said in his remarks after holding talks with Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu, focusing on consolidating cooperation in areas of trade, defence and infrastructure. This marked a significant turnaround in the relationship which had seen some unease at the beginning of last year. That apart, it is noted that the prevailing situation, marked by US President Donald Trump's tariff policies upending the global trading architecture, incentivised countries to swiftly secure new markets. In that context, the India-UK trade deal could set the template for the negotiations that New Delhi is currently having with the EU. India and the EU have agreed to seven out of 23 chapters in their agreement, even as India-US trade talks drag on. India-US trade talks Negotiations over the India-US trade deal will continue as American trade negotiators are expected to visit India mid-August – well past President Donald Trump's August 1 deadline, after which reciprocal tariffs are set to take effect. While India and the US have agreed on a wide range of tariff lines, the negotiations — which currently only involve market access for goods — appear to be stuck on sensitive sectors such as agriculture and automobiles, both of which are key job creators in India. In the meantime, Trump has announced new deals with Japan, the Philippines and Indonesia, after similar agreements with Britain and Vietnam, with the tariffs ranging between 10 and 20 per cent. Experts have warned that the Japan deal offers a cautionary tale for India, because as part of it, the US gained market access for American agricultural products, including politically sensitive items such as rice. In the case of India, reliance on agriculture remains critically high, with over 700 million Indians dependent on it. Meanwhile, the Indian Coordination Committee of Farmers Movements – a network of farmers' organisations across 11 states – has urged the government to exclude all aspects of agriculture from the proposed trade deal with the US in order to safeguard Indian farmers' interests. Amid efforts to restore India-China ties ruptured by the LAC military standoff and Galwan clash of 2020, Beijing's mega dam project on the Yarlung Tsangpo River in Tibet (which flows down to India as Brahmaputra) has raised hackles in New Delhi over potential downstream impacts, with Arunachal Chief Minister Pema Khandu describing the project as a 'ticking water bomb'. The massive $167 billion hydropower project on the Yarlung Tsangpo River, just before it bends and enters Arunachal Pradesh, where it is called the Siang, will be China's largest since the Three Gorges Dam (completed in 2012) in Sandouping. Capable of generating 60 gigawatts (GW) of power, the project is expected to boost China's domestic economy. While around 30 per cent of the Brahmaputra's waters originate in China, the majority comes from rainfall within India's catchment areas. As a result, the Chinese dam's immediate impact is expected to be felt the most in Arunachal Pradesh – particularly in the Siang region. In addition to flooding concerns, the Chinese dam could also disrupt water flow to proposed downstream hydro projects. The Northeast holds nearly half of India's 133 GW hydropower potential, over 80 per cent of which remains untapped. Of the 60 GW estimated potential, about 50 GW lies in Arunachal Pradesh alone. In 2013, India and China signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on sharing information on river flows. But, by all accounts, Beijing has not always been open to sharing hydrological data. India has proposed the 11.2 GW Upper Siang Multipurpose Project – a massive storage-based dam in the Siang district – to counter China's upstream development, but progress has been slow. Such developments come close on the heels of a reported thaw in India-China ties, evident in the resumption of the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra, an understanding to resume direct flights, and ease visa restrictions. This week, India said it will resume issuing tourist visas to Chinese nationals after a five-year pause, beginning Thursday. The 34th meeting of the Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on India-China Border Affairs (WMCC) held on Wednesday (July 23) in Delhi also discussed the preparation for the next round of the Special Representatives' Talks on the India-China Boundary Question to be held in India later this year. However, such efforts towards normalisation come as the de-escalation process – the withdrawal of troops from forward positions that would lead to restoring patrolling to pre-2020 levels – is yet to begin at the border. In addition, Beijing's role during Operation Sindoor has also impacted India-China ties. In the meantime, a statement issued by the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR), the media wing of the Pakistan military, over Army chief Asim Munir's visit to China this week said that in their talks with Munir, 'the Chinese leadership lauded the Pakistan Armed Forces as a cornerstone of resilience and a vital contributor to peace in South Asia'. Pakistan has extended the closure of its airspace for Indian aircraft and airlines by a month, till the morning of August 24, following which India also announced an extension of its ban on Pakistani airlines and aircraft from entering the nation's airspace for the same period. Following the Pahalgam terror attack in April, as diplomatic relations between Delhi and Islamabad deteriorated, Pakistan on April 24 shut its airspace to Indian aircraft for at least a month, banning them from overflying its airspace. On April 30, India, too, closed its airspace to Pakistani aircraft. While starvation deaths and killings at aid points seem to have crossed a critical threshold in Gaza, reports of Israel and the US recalling their negotiating teams from Qatar further deepened fears of a worsening crisis. Amid this, France's decision to recognise the state of Palestine might be seen in the context of the 'two-state solution' but is unlikely to bring any relief to the 2 million people in Gaza who have been grappling amid months of Israeli atrocities. At least 48 people died of causes related to malnutrition, including 28 adults and 20 children, in the last three weeks, the Gaza Health Ministry said Thursday. A total of 17,000 children in Gaza suffer from severe malnutrition, Al Jazeera cited the director of Medical Relief in Gaza, Dr Mohammed Abu Afash, as saying. Israel imposed a total blockade in Gaza in March and allowed only a trickle of supplies the past two months through the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), which replaced the 400 UN-run sites shut down by Israel over unproven claims that aid is being diverted by Hamas, causing the dire humanitarian crisis and mass starvation. The United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA) warned on Thursday (July 24) that 'families are breaking down' amid the hunger crisis. The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) added that Israel has been preventing it from verifying aid waiting at distribution centres. A joint letter signed this week by 109 aid agencies, including Doctors Without Borders, Oxfam and Amnesty, has accused the Israeli government of deliberately obstructing the flow of aid. Gaza's Health Ministry also called for an immediate end to famine and held 'the Israeli occupation, the US administration, and other states complicit in this genocide – such as the UK, Germany, and France – as well as the international community at large, fully responsible for this historic crime,' Al Jazeera reported. Meanwhile, leaders of Germany, France, and the UK called on Israel to immediately lift its blockade on aid supplies entering the famished Palestinian territory. India also voiced strong concern over the current situation in Gaza at the UNSC, and called for an immediate ceasefire, uninterrupted humanitarian aid, and the release of Israeli hostages by Hamas. However, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Friday (July 25) that his government was considering 'alternative options' to ceasefire talks with Hamas. US President Trump blamed Hamas for the apparent collapse of Gaza ceasefire talks and warned that the group would be 'hunted down'. Nonetheless, Hamas responded by saying that it had submitted a positive and constructive response to the latest proposal it was offered. Israel's war on Gaza has killed at least 59,676 people and wounded 143,965. An estimated 1,139 people were killed in Israel during the Hamas-led October 7, 2023, attacks, and more than 200 were taken captive. In the meantime, Iran's president Masoud Pezeshkian said that while Tehran remains wary of its current ceasefire with Israel, it won't rule out diplomacy, Bloomberg reported. His statement came as Iran and European nations, the UK, France, and Germany, often referred to as the E3, held talks in Istanbul on Friday and agreed that they need to hold another round of nuclear talks soon. Friday's talks broke a deadlock over Iran's nuclear programme, after Israeli and US strikes on Iran in June derailed previous negotiations. Clashes on the Thai-Cambodian border continued for the third day on Saturday, prompting tens of thousands to flee their homes and aggravating fears of an extended conflict, with the total death toll reaching 32. The two countries have engaged in standoffs since the killing of a Cambodian soldier late in May during a brief skirmish, with both sides claiming to act in self-defence. More than 130,000 people have been displaced in the worst fighting between the two Southeast Asian neighbours in 13 years, Reuters reported. The UN Security Council held an emergency meeting behind closed doors late Friday in New York, but didn't issue a statement. A council diplomat said all 15 members called on the parties to de-escalate, show restraint and resolve the dispute peacefully, Reuters reported. The council also urged the regional bloc, the Association of Southeast Asian Nations known as ASEAN, to help resolve the border fighting, the diplomat said, speaking on condition of anonymity because the meeting was private. Thailand and Cambodia have bickered for decades over the jurisdiction of various undemarcated points along their 817-km (508-mile) land border, with ownership of the ancient Hindu temples Ta Moan Thom and the 11th century Preah Vihear central to the disputes, according to Reuters. Preah Vihear was awarded to Cambodia by the International Court of Justice in 1962, but tension escalated in 2008 after Cambodia attempted to list it as a UNESCO World Heritage site. That led to skirmishes over several years and at least a dozen deaths. India on Saturday (July 26) advised its citizens in Cambodia to avoid travelling to border areas as the clash between Thailand and Cambodia over a disputed border entered its third day. Send your feedback and ideas to Ashiya Parveen is working as Commissioning Editor for the UPSC Section at The Indian Express. She also writes a weekly round up of global news, The World This Week. Ashiya has more than 10 years of experience in editing and writing spanning media and academics, and has both academic and journalistic publications to her credit. She has previously worked with The Pioneer and Press Trust of India (PTI). She also holds a PhD in international studies from Centre for West Asian Studies, JNU. ... Read More
News18
27 minutes ago
- News18
'India Our Closest Partner, It Is Even Better Now': Maldives President Muizzu
Last Updated: News18 spoke with Mohamed Muizzu at the Republic Square in Malé, soon after PM Modi left following a two-day state visit Maldives President Mohamed Muizzu told News18 in an exclusive conversation on Saturday that India is his country's 'closest partner" and the new Rs 5,000 crore credit line announced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his visit will greatly help the archipelagic country. News18 spoke with Muizzu at the Republic Square in Malé, soon after PM Modi left following a two-day state visit. 'India is our closest partner, of course. I'm sure it is even better now," Muizzu said. The President said that the Maldives was looking forward to the completion of the free trade agreement (FTA) with India. Both countries announced during PM Modi's visit that they will begin negotiations over the FTA. 'Once completed, the FTA will be very beneficial for traders of both countries. We are looking forward to it," Muizzu told News18. He also described the new Rs 5,000 crore credit line from India as a big help. Muizzu, in fact, told News18 how his government plans to utilise this aid. 'We have earmarked a lot of crucial projects to carry out with that. For example, hospitals, housing development, infrastructure, schools. So, it will definitely help," Muizzu said in the interview. The Maldives President also expressed his 'utmost thanks" to PM Modi for coming on this visit. 'We are very grateful to the PM," Muizzu told News18. These comments from Muizzu are a remarkable turnaround from 2023, when he came to power in the Maldives on an 'Out India" plank, and some of his ministers made uncharitable remarks on India in 2024. Muizzu also made state visits to Turkey and China before India, changing an old convention where a Maldives President always paid his first visit to India. But foreign minister S Jaishankar's visit to the Maldives last year, followed by Muizzu's state visit to India in October, brought bilateral relations back on track. view comments First Published: July 26, 2025, 19:13 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
