How NFL talent evaluators, coaches rank the top players 25 and under entering 2025 season
Another NFL season brings with it the evolution process that sees intriguing prospects develop into solid contributors and legit difference-makers. Eventually, they firmly entrench themselves as some of the games' brightest stars. For some, it's a gradual process. Others morph into household names in no time.
Advertisement
Once again, we're examining and ranking those young players on the sharpest and most rapid ascents. We call it the Top 25 players 25 and under.
For consideration, players must have one season of experience, and they can't be any older than 25 by Week 1. That meant stars such as Justin Jefferson, Micah Parsons, CeeDee Lamb, Tristan Wirfs and Jordan Love all aged out this season after making the list in previous years.
Keeping with tradition, we reached out to a collection of front office members, scouts and coaches — nearly two dozen in all — for insight. All were granted anonymity so they could speak freely about the players. The participants were given a list of 35 potential players (many of whom had received All-Rookie or Pro Bowl honors) for inclusion. The experts were asked for feedback on where each might rank. The participants were encouraged to nominate any players that they believed had been left out. They also were free to suggest eliminating players they deemed unworthy of inclusion, even if they had made the cut last year.
This year's original list featured 18 returning players and 17 new entries, but wound up with 16 familiar faces and nine impressive newcomers.
Here's who made the cut and where they rank:
One of the top two or three most dominant receivers in the game, Chase led the league with 1,708 receiving yards and 17 receiving touchdowns and has eclipsed the 1,000-yard mark in each of his four NFL seasons. He's also a four-time Pro Bowl selection and took home first-team All-Pro honors last season.
After a promising rookie campaign, Carter established himself as a true game-wrecker last season. Look no further than the Super Bowl and preceding postseason games for proof. Carter should only become even more dominant with time.
Advertisement
The 2024 AP Offensive Rookie of the Year led a long-awaited revival in Washington last season by repeatedly delivering late-game heroics and confounding defenses with his arm and legs as Washington reached the NFC Championship Game for the first time since the 1991-92 season.
After following up a strong rookie season with his first Pro Bowl campaign in 2023, Hutchinson led the NFL in sacks (7 1/2) through his first five games of 2024. A broken leg ended his season prematurely, but Hutchinson has made a full recovery and should return to terrorizing quarterbacks in Week 1.
Move over George Kittle and Travis Kelce. Bowers burst onto the scene in Las Vegas last season and racked up 1,194 receiving yards on 112 catches (both NFL records for rookie tight ends). Bowers' yardage total last season tied Dallas wide receiver CeeDee Lamb for eighth in the league among all players.
Already a three-time Pro Bowl and two-time All-Pro selection, the fourth-year veteran earned AP Defensive Player of the Year honors after a season that saw him record four interceptions and 45 tackles even though quarterbacks do their best to avoid throwing his way.
Sewell continues to help anchor the line of one of the most potent offenses in the league. Last season, Sewell earned first-team All-Pro honors for a second straight year, and Pro Bowl honors for the third time in his four-year career.
Offensive line struggles and injuries at wide receiver both contributed to a slight decline for C.J. Stroud in Year 2. However, he remains one of the most gifted quarterbacks in the league with an ability to deliver from the pocket, extend plays, improvise and throw with accuracy.
The two-time Pro Bowl selection ranks among the best safeties in the league thanks to a blend of size, athleticism and versatility. He's all over the field, also lining up at slot corner, inside linebacker and edge rusher at times. Hamilton earned first-team All-Pro honors in 2023 and was second-team All-Pro in 2024.
Advertisement
A two-time All-Pro selection and three-time Pro Bowl pick, St. Brown has topped the 1,100-yard mark in three straight seasons and last season ranked third in the NFL with a career-high 12 touchdown catches.
A true dual-threat running back, Robinson last season rushed for 1,456 yards (third most behind Saquon Barkley and Derrick Henry) and 14 touchdowns. He also recorded 61 catches for 431 yards and a touchdown. The young Falcon enters Year 3 aiming to deliver more explosive plays both on the ground and through the air.
The fourth-year pro has quickly ascended to elite ranks, recording five interceptions in both his second and third NFL seasons while breaking up 13 and 18 passes, respectively. Last season's Pro Bowl and All-Pro selections resulted in a three-year, $90 million extension this offseason, $89 million of which is fully guaranteed.
He has already won two Super Bowls and earned first-team and second-team All-Pro status and he's only entering his fourth NFL season. McDuffie is one of the best and most physical cover men in the league. McDuffie recorded 13 pass breakups and two interceptions last season, and also proved himself as a sure tackler with 59 (six for a loss).
The Georgia Tech product turned heads as a rookie in 2023 when he rushed for 945 yards and 10 touchdowns while splitting time in Detroit's backfield. Last season, he took another leap forward by rushing for 16 touchdown carries and 1,412 yards while again sharing the rushing load. Gibbs also recorded 517 receiving yards and four touchdowns on 52 catches. Gibbs received 95 fewer carries than Barkley and 75 fewer attempts than Henry, yet still ranked tied Henry in touchdown runs and was just behind them with his 5.6 average yards per carry (Henry had 5.9, Barkley 5.8).
Mitchell faced a who's who list of wide receivers as a rookie and more than held his own. Chase, Lamb, Malik Nabers, Mike Evans, Terry McLaurin, Drake London and Chris Olave, to name a few, all had some of their quietest days of their respective seasons (and for some, their careers) on Mitchell's watch. It's scary to think that Mitchell could be even better in Year 2.
One of the few bright spots for the Giants last season, Nabers had 109 catches for 1,204 yards and seven touchdowns. Nabers' 109 receptions ranked fifth in the league and his 170 targets finished second behind Chase's 175. Chase was catching passes from bonafide star Joe Burrow. Nabers caught passes from four different quarterbacks last season.
Advertisement
Despite a lack of stability at quarterback, Wilson has shined, recording 1,000-yard seasons in each of his three years in the league. The 101 catches in 2024 tied for seventh in the league and marked a career high.
Even though a knee injury limited him to 11 games in 2024, Nacua nearly topped the 1,000-yard mark, finishing with 990 yards and three touchdowns on 79 catches. The year before, Nacua used textbook route running, versatility and sure hands to take the league by storm by recording 105 receptions for 1,486 yards.
Gardner seemed to regress a little last season and said his play wasn't up to standards. But he remains one of the brightest young DBs in the game. He's hoping new defensive coordinator Steve Wilks and new head coach Aaron Glenn can help him rebound and regain the Pro Bowl and All-Pro status that he earned in his first and second seasons in the league.
The LSU product made his presence felt immediately last season, setting a Jaguars rookie record for receptions (87), receiving yards (1,282) and receiving touchdowns (10). He also joined Chase, Odell Beckham Jr. and Randy Moss as the only rookies in the Super Bowl era to record at least 1,200 receiving yards and 10 touchdowns.
After impressing and earning Pro Bowl honors as a rookie, Anderson upped his production and finished with 11 sacks and 37 tackles (16 for a loss). Paired with veteran Danielle Hunter, Anderson helped lead a Houston pass-rush that ranked fourth in the league in sacks and was sixth best against the pass.
With a huge hole in their defensive line left by Aaron Donald's retirement, the Rams drafted Verse in the first round out of Florida State last season. Verse delivered in the form of a banner year that included Defensive Rookie of the Year honors after generating 76 pressures (second most in NFL history by a rookie behind Nick Bosa's 81 in 2019), 4 1/2 sacks and 66 tackles.
The third-year pro last season anchored the line that paved the way for Derrick Henry's 1,921 rushing yards, and Lamar Jackson's MVP-caliber season and went onto reach the Pro Bowl for the second time in as many seasons.
Advertisement
The Tulsa product has quickly established himself as one of the best interior linemen in the game. Size, strength, athleticism, versatility … he has it all, and two Pro Bowl nods to prove it.
Injury and organizational instability have combined to somewhat diminish the shine of the No. 1 pick of the 2021 draft. But there's a belief around the league that Lawrence has a chance to bounce back this season and achieve his potential as a leading quarterback thanks to a fresh start under new head coach Liam Coen and surrounded by weapons like Thomas and Travis Hunter.
Joe Alt, OT, Los Angeles Chargers, age: 22 (2/28/03)
Nik Bonitto, LB, Denver Broncos, age: 25 (9/26/99)
Cooper DeJean, DB, Philadelphia Eagles, age: 22 (2/09/03)
Bucky Irving, RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, age: 22 (8/19/02)
Sam LaPorta, TE, Detroit Lions, age: 24 (1/12/01)
Ladd McConkey, WR, Los Angeles Chargers, age: 23 (11/11/01)
Marvin Mims, KR/PR, Denver Broncos, age: 23 (3/19/02)
Brock Purdy, QB, San Francisco 49ers, age: 25 (12/27/99)
And now, let the debates begin.
(Top illustration: Will Tullos / The Athletic; photos of Ja'Marr Chase, Aidan Hutchinson and Brock Bowers: Candice Ward, Michael Owens, Wesley Hitt / Getty Images)
Spot the pattern. Connect the terms
Find the hidden link between sports terms
Play today's puzzle
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a minute ago
- Yahoo
Collingwood coach's sad confession about Bobby Hill as fellow Pies star returns
Collingwood coach Craig McRae has admitted time is running out for Bobby Hill to play again this season, but the Magpies will be boosted by the return of Jeremy Howe against Melbourne on Friday night. Hill is a premiership player and Norm Smith Medal winner, but has only made one senior appearance in the past two months as he deals with personal issues. The 25-year-old flew to Adelaide last week to be around his teammates for their trip to face the Crows, however he didn't play. He also didn't train this week and won't play against the Demons at the MCG on Friday night. Speaking to reporters on Wednesday, McRae said he had dinner with Hill on Tuesday and is focusing on the small forward's welfare rather than a potential return. McRae said Hill asked him to leave the door ajar for a possible return in September, but the 25-year-old is an unlikely participant in the Pies' finals campaign. "There's high performance and there's love and care, and I've just sort of left the high performance for now and I'm just making sure the young lad's OK," McRae said. "Time's running out in the season and maybe the high performance might be a bit far at the moment, but we'll just take that off the table for now. Hopefully he can get back in the club and be happy, and then we'll see where we go from there." RELATED: Wanganeen-Milera could be forced to take pay-cut as Hird floats theory Family dilemma as Geelong premiership hero on cusp of changing clubs McRae specifically asked Hill what to tell the media when inevitable questions arose as to his absence. "He goes, 'Please just leave a little bit of hope there for me'," McRae said. "But he's well aware that time's running out for getting enough load and then to be available. I stepped straight back into love and care and said, 'Nah, let's just get him right day by day'." Teammate Brayden Maynard said on Monday: "We are a lot better team with him, so hopefully he does turn up and get the ball rolling. It's an ongoing process, day-by-day process. He knows that he's got our full support, and we believe that he will get the ball rolling with a few things that he's got going on." Jeremy Howe's timely return for Collingwood While Hill won't be available, the Pies will get premiership defender Howe back for their tussle with the Demons. The 35-year-old was knocked out and concussed in a sickening collision with Hawthorn player Jai Newcombe in round 22, but is back after missing last week's three-point loss to ladder-leaders Adelaide. Howe has been given the green light to return in a massive boost to Collingwood's flailing campaign. McRae's side have lost four of their last five and are in serious danger of dropping out of the top-four before the finals. "Howey will come back and his experience is important to us. I think he'll play our system really well," McRae said. Collingwood's forward-line connection wasn't up to scratch against the Crows, with the Magpies dominating the inside-50 tally (71-37) but unable to make it count. McRae said he'll consider recalling ruck-forward Mason Cox, with Daniel McStay potentially making way after some quiet performances. "We're working hard with Dan to get him moving and be part of our best team," McRae said. "There's a lot of work behind the scenes to work on his craft, jump at the ball well and fit into our patterns." with AAP
Yahoo
a minute ago
- Yahoo
Abdul Carter had an Embarrassing 'Welcome to the NFL' Play on Saturday
Abdul Carter had an Embarrassing 'Welcome to the NFL' Play on Saturday originally appeared on Athlon Sports. All eyes were on Abdul Carter and the New York Giants on Saturday afternoon in Week 2 of the preseason as they hosted the New York Jets. After an impressive NFL preseason debut against the Buffalo Bills a week ago, Carter — the former No. 3 overall pick in the 2025 NFL draft — did what he could to hype up his fans, posting a Star Wars video on his social media to build the hype. Unfortunately, things played out differently against the Jets. In the first half of the game, Carter had his first big "welcome to the NFL" moment, getting chipped to the ground by tight end Stone Smartt, and then pancaked by right tackle Jay Tufele. For someone who stands 6-foot-3, 250 pounds, it was a rather surprising thing to see, especially as talented as Carter is. What Fans Are Saying About Abdul Carter's Mishap There are multiple videos on social media of Carter's unfortunate play, one of which has 1.2 million views already. Others have upwards of 400k views, so you can easily say that this play is going viral. Here's a look at what some fans are saying: "Welcome to the league, young fella," one fan wrote. "Hit the gym, young fella," another added. "Abdul Carter is gonna have his flashy sacks, but he is also gonna have a lot of these plays," said another. "Good player, but not a savant like Micah Parsons." "Abdul Carter is an objectively incredible physical specimen and he just got de-cleated by a TE," one fan said. "NFL talent is so different man. Happens to the best of them." Abdul Carter Stats and Outlook Carter ended up recording just a single tackle in this game, which was a 31-12 win for the Giants. Going forward, there are high expectations for the rookie on New York's front line, especially playing alongside the likes of Kayvon Thibodeaux and Dexter Lawrence. The Giants are hopeful that they can be a decent team in 2025, but there are major questions to answer at the quarterback position. Right now, Russell Wilson is projected to be the starter, but guys like Jameis Winston, Jaxson Dart, and Tommy DeVito are all in the mix as story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Aug 17, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
a minute ago
- Yahoo
The Royals' Bobby Witt Jr. hits 100th homer, joining some select company in MLB history
KANSAS CITY, Mo. (AP) — Bobby Witt Jr. knew the ball was gone the moment it left his bat. Only later did the young Kansas City Royals star realize what kind of company it allowed him to join. The two-run shot in the eighth inning against Texas on Tuesday night merely padded the lead for Kansas City, which went on to a 5-2 victory. It was the fifth straight win for the Royals, who closed to within 2 1/2 games of an AL wild-card berth. But it also was the 100th career homer for Witt, making him the youngest in franchise history to reach that mark. He made it at the age of 26 years, 66 days, or more than a year earlier than Carlos Beltran when he accomplished it during the 2003 season. 'I want him up there every inning,' Royals manager Matt Quatraro said. "I mean, you look at the lineup and you're trying to figure out, 'How many times can we get to the plate? How many guys can we keep on base for him when he does come to the plate?' 'I mean, that's an immense amount of pressure on a younger player to understand that's how everybody feels about him," Quatraro said. "But he has the physical ability, the makeup and the mental capacity to handle it.' The latest no-doubt shot, which came off Texas reliever Cole Winn and landed an estimated 449 feet to dead center field, made Witt only the fourth player with at least 100 homers and 100 stolen bases through his first four big league seasons. The others are Julio Rodríguez, Darryl Strawberry and Bobby Bonds — some pretty select company. Witt also become one of six shortstops in the last 95 years to hit at least 100 homers through his age-25 seasons. That list of luminaries includes Alex Rodriguez, Cal Ripken Jr., Francisco Lindor, Carlos Correa and Hanley Ramirez; of those players, only Rodriguez and Ramirez also had 100 steals by the time they were 25 years old. 'It was special,' Witt admitted, 'just seeing the kind of names on the list or whatever they showed. But now, it's just kind of on to the next. It was special. We enjoy it. And now it's just onto the next game.' They keep getting more important for the Royals, who have won five straight and seven of their last eight. They head into the third-game of their four-game set against the Rangers on Wednesday night with a chance to inch closer to a wild-card spot, and they proved last year that they could do some postseason damage if they can only get in. Witt continues to be the catalyst of their second-half surge, too. He's hitting .291 with 18 homers and 69 RBIs. 'It's special when he goes out there,' said the Royals' Seth Lugo, who allowed just two runs on three hits while pitching into the seventh inning Tuesday night. 'I've been saying it for two years: He goes about his business the same way. He doesn't get up or down on himself. He's a master of consistency. That's what he does.' Witt also happens to be a slick fielder with a Gold Glove in his trophy case. But at the plate is where Witt has become a bona fide star. He led the majors with a .332 average last year, when he hit 32 home runs, stole 31 bases and finished with 109 RBIs. And while he may not quite replicate the average, homer total or RBI numbers in this campaign, he already has 32 stolen bases while getting caught just seven times. 'There's not too many guys that get to 100 (homers),' said Vinnie Pasquantino, who also homered Tuesday night. "And the fourth player in MLB history with 100 stolen bases? It's not a list I'll ever be on. I mean, it's kind of unbelievable. 'He's one of the best players in the league for a reason," Pasquantino said. 'A superstar.' ___ AP MLB:
