Poorva Choudhary: OBC controversy hits UPSC topper Poorva Choudhary: Rank 533 and a luxury lifestyle—what's the real story?
The accusations and the lifestyle optics
Father breaks silence and explains eligibility
A digital trial by perception
A past case fuels present outrage
Beyond the exam: A bigger debate
A young woman's celebration of cracking one of India's toughest competitive exams has unexpectedly turned into a flashpoint for online outrage, policy scrutiny, and heated debates on reservation. Poorva Choudhary , who secured All India Rank 533 in the UPSC Civil Services Examination 2024, now finds herself at the centre of an OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) quota controversy, with critics questioning whether her family background truly qualifies her for the benefits she received.The storm began after a celebratory Instagram post shared by Poorva's sister Navya went viral. The post, captioned 'Cleared UPSC while serving this face card,' was initially met with praise and admiration. However, attention soon turned to the OBC tag appearing next to Poorva's name in the official results, sparking allegations that she had unfairly availed herself of the reservation quota despite allegedly living a lavish lifestyle.Poorva Choudhary, daughter of a Rajasthan Administrative Services (RAS) officer, was accused by several social media users of misusing the OBC-NCL certificate. A user on X alleged, 'Her father's an ADM... Still, she used OBC-NCL certificate to qualify for exam.' The allegations gained traction due to perceived inconsistencies between her apparent lifestyle and the criteria for OBC-NCL benefits. Several users referenced her now-deactivated Instagram account, pointing to posts that featured luxury items, international travel, and designer accessories.In a post dated shortly after the results, user @Laachar_Man wrote on X, 'Poorva Chaudhary's father is an ADM, owns property worth crores, she spends lakhs every week — yet she gets OBC-NCL. My father earns Rs 40,000 a month, I'm from General category — no reservation, no support. We work hard, someone else takes the seat. Is this what justice looks like?'In response to the growing backlash, Poorva's father spoke to a media house, firmly denying the allegations of quota misuse. He clarified that although he is currently an ADM, he was promoted to the RAS cadre at the age of 44. As per government norms, children of Group A officers are not entitled to OBC-NCL status only if the parent entered the service before the age of 40. 'In the case of direct RAS recruitment before the age of 40, the OBC NCL benefit does not apply. That's not my case,' he stated.He also noted that the family's income remains within the prescribed limit for OBC-NCL eligibility—Rs 8 lakh annually, excluding agricultural income. He urged the public to "understand the rules before jumping to conclusions," as quoted by a media house.Poorva's disappearance from social media platforms, including her deactivated Instagram account, has further fuelled speculation. While no official authority has found her in violation of any eligibility rules, the digital narrative has painted a different picture. The controversy has sparked renewed debate about whether 'lifestyle indicators' should influence one's qualification for reserved categories—a suggestion many policy experts reject.As reported by The Logical Indian, critics highlighted photos of designer bags allegedly worth Rs 4.5 lakh, alongside glimpses of luxury cars and upscale homes. Some netizens also brought up her political connections, noting her family's link to Sanjeev Beniwal, an MLA from Rajasthan.The public reaction has been further intensified by comparisons to the 2023 case of Pooja Khedkar , another UPSC rank holder who was accused of submitting false certificates for OBC and disability quotas. Her case ultimately led to her dismissal from the civil services , and many online users are drawing parallels between the two.However, unlike Khedkar, no evidence of fraudulent documentation has emerged against Poorva Choudhary. Her father's explanations, backed by existing reservation guidelines, appear to support her legal eligibility. The matter, at present, remains a social media storm rather than an administrative or legal one.At the heart of the controversy lies a deeper public sentiment—whether India's reservation system should evolve to better reflect modern socioeconomic realities. For now, Poorva Choudhary's achievement has been overshadowed by the swirling accusations, leaving many to ask: In the age of instant virality, can merit and legality survive the court of public opinion?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
The death of a lake, and recurring flood nightmare in Warangal
In 2010, a shanty settlement sprang up on the south-western edge of Chinna Vaddepalli lake in Warangal. Within three years, the rising waters swallowed it whole, leaving no trace of the colony as the lake reclaimed its space. Years later, another colony emerged in S.R. Nagar, just metres from the same lake. Unlike its predecessor, it flourished into low-income informal group housing with RCC roads. But, on August 11 and 12 this year, torrential rain — 20 centimetres in 24 hours — turned it into an island. Residents fled to the homes of their friends and relatives while some were rescued by emergency teams. The deluge brought back memories of August 2020, when floodwaters had invaded their homes in much the same way. 'Warangal is a region of tanks, nalas and water channels. People have filled up the tanks and occupied the land where nalas used to flow. Earlier, only fringes were occupied; now there is a total occupation of lakes and tanks. Where will the water go,' says K. Venkat Reddy, civil engineering professor at the National Institute of Technology (NIT)-Warangal, who has co-authored a paper on 'Effects of Urbanization on land use land cover of Warangal Region using RS and GIS'. Viral videos from residents showed Hunter Road transformed into a brown, fast-moving river, flanked by shops on both sides. The road starts at Adalath Circle, 275 metres above sea level, and slopes to about 262 metres as it skirts Bhadrakali Lake — a drop of over 13 metres across four kilometres. Water rushing down this gradient, aided by the twin hillocks of Tiger Hill and Padmakshi Temple, should have emptied naturally into Bhadrakali Lake. But the lake, already full, had been constricted by fresh embankments built under the ₹64.90-crore 'Bhadrakali Geo-Bio Diversity and Cultural Park' project, including ₹26 crore for a granite-and-concrete promenade. This promenade, now a leisure space with lawns and play areas, has effectively shrunk the lake and blocked its natural inflow. Satellite images show how the lake has shrunk due to all these beautification initiatives. Between 2010 and 2025, an area of 23 acres has been lost to the promenade that stretches over 3.14 kilometres with an average width of 30 metres. 'The lake should have a demarcated full tank level. Bhadrakali Lake was a drinking water storage tank during summer. Now it has become a cesspool without proper drainage. The Bondivagu drainage system had to be repaired,but that has not been done and all the sewage is flowing into the lake. We are getting our drinking water from Dharmasagar balancing reservoir and the result is that our nearest water source is neglected,' says a former NIT professor, requesting anonymity. 'The planned islands in the lake are the whims and fancies of ill-informed officials,' he adds. 'Whenever there was heavy rainfall in the '70s and '80s, the water from the lake would overflow and reach the Ramannapet area. The Hunter Road was a deserted stretch where people were scared to go beyond the Advocates Colony,' says K. Ram Mohan Rao, an advocate, who lives in Warangal and has seen the changes. There were many small lakes scattered around Bhadrakali Lake and Vaddepalli Lake. But as land prices went up, the lakes got filled, allegedly with political patronage. 'The results indicate a drastic increase in urbanisation and barren land, severe decrease in vegetation and a very slight increase in waterbodies. Increase in urbanisation and decrease in agriculture-cum-forest indicates vegetation reduction and built-up area increment which directly affects the climate and environment,' concludes the study that spanned over a six-year period between 2014 and 2020, showing a 11.04% increase in urbanisation. This rapid urbanisation at the cost of agricultural land impacted areas like Vivekananda Colony, Saiganesh Colony, SR Nagar, and Lakshmi Ganapati Colony in Kashibugga and NTR Nagar, Sainagar Colony, Shivanagar, Balaji Nagar, Ursu Gutta, DK Komuraiah Nagar, Ekashila Nagar, Gokul Nagar and Ambedkar Nagar in Hanamkonda. It was these areas that got flooded in 2020, 2023 and again this year. 'The key to flooding in parts of the city is the encroachment of Bondivagu Nala. Its carrying capacity has declined due to rapid urbanisation. The lakes have to be demarcated clearly to stop encroachments. The nalas are affected as they are choked with plastic waste. Unless the plastic waste is cleaned on a regular basis and a better drainage system is built, flooding in Warangal is not going to go away,' says Mr. Reddy.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Climate change, other issues continue to plague jackfruit production in Goa
Panaji: In a fruitful season, the jackfruit sale ended a few days ago, fetching a good price for farmers. The wet season starting early, rot disease, and other factors, however, caused some disappointment among the farmers. The bulky fruit's visibility — often called 'food of the future' — in market places and roadside stalls even diverted attention from mangoes. 'We almost had more jackfruits than mangoes. I even sold a bigger one for Rs 800 early in the season,' Swapnila Naik, a vendor at Neura said. The jackfruit tree is regarded as a 'kalpa vriksha', like the coconut tree, for its multiple uses. Its consumptive use as a food has massive potential. A hundred sweets, dishes and items can be prepared from it, according to experts, at various stages. Used as fodder for cattle and other purposes, it is gaining respect for its health benefits. Left to rot on trees once, the 'miracle food' however, was hit by climate change. 'This year, we lost 15 peak season days due to intense pre-monsoon rain and early monsoon arrival,' agriculture director Sandeep Faldessai said. In wet weather, rain water seepage may alter its taste and flavour. 'By end of summer, the fruit usually gets mostly consumed,' he said. The late flowering or fruiting, though it is not exactly due to climate change, eats into the farmers' profits. Consumers are wary of the water-soaked bulbs. But more brighter days in June slightly restored the demand. 'The prices dipped to Rs 500 per piece for bigger ones,' Naik, whose roadside house turns into a mango bazaar in summer, said. But rejuvenation of the monsoon in July saw the prices crashing again. 'Even the more popular 'kapo' variety went for Rs 100 per piece,' Naik said. The jackfruit continued to be sold till recently, as the green spiky package of bulbs is valued as an organic fruit. The ripening is without chemicals. Adapting a standardised technology developed by principal scientist Mathala Juliet Gupta and her team at ICAR-CCARI, Old Goa, for a ready-to-eat retort-processed jackfruit xacuti could help boost farmers' profits. Retort processing is a method of heat sterilisation used for food preservation. 'The xacuti stored in cans at room temperature has a shelf life of one year and in retort pouches six months. It has good customer acceptance,' Gupta said. Jackfruit processing, unlike Goa, is a multi-crore industry in some states, generating employment and many food products. The Centre has notified jackfruit as a crop for North Goa under One District, One Product (ODOP) scheme. Goa State Biodiversity Board's successful pilot project — a multi-fruit processing unit at Pale-Cotambi — paved the way for another one at Curchorem. 'Value addition of jackfruit and other produce is done at these centres,' an official said. A few problems, however, persist. Entrepreneurs have not shown much interest in processing. Harvesting jackfruits, even a worse problem than coconuts, becomes costly due to manpower and height of trees. 'Encouraging enterprise should be at the top of the agenda. A count and location of jackfruit trees for sourcing produce and integrating into commercial use are other aspects,' a source said. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Happy Krishna Janmashtami Wishes ,, messages , and quotes !
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
HC quashes 2 maintenance cases under sr citizens act
Panaji: The high court of Bombay at Goa quashed and set aside two cases under the Maintenance and Welfare of Senior Citizens Act. The cases were subsequently remanded back to maintenance tribunals at the deputy collector level, with a direction that they appoint a conciliation officer to mediate a settlement between the parents and their children. Until the cases are resolved, the HC directed the sons in both cases to continue paying monthly maintenance of Rs 10,000 to their parents. In the first case, a 49-year-old son from Panaji went to the HC challenging the order of the maintenance tribunal that directed him to vacate his parents' home within six months and pay them Rs 10,000 per month as maintenance. In the second case, an only son approached the HC challenging the order delivered by the maintenance tribunal that directed him to pay his father Rs 10,000 per month, and restricting him and his wife from interfering with the cultivation of his father's agricultural fields in Bicholim. Justice Valmiki Menezes held that no inquiry was conducted by the maintenance tribunals in both cases and that the orders were passed without referring the parties to a conciliation officer to attempt to mediate a solution to the disputes. The HC directed that conciliation officers under the act be appointed in both cases to attempt to mediate between the parties. If conciliation fails, the maintenance tribunal shall proceed to conduct an inquiry into the matter, if necessary, record evidence, and pass its order, the court held. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Happy Krishna Janmashtami Wishes ,, messages , and quotes !
