Infrastructure, governance failures limit growth of agriculture and development in rural areas
On 6 August, I had an opportunity to deliver the
Among other things, I emphasised that the rural economy should not be forgotten in South Africa's economic growth agenda, where there tends to be a strong urban bias in policy discussions. The rural areas are still a significant segment of society and the economy, though 68% of the population now lives in urban areas.
Apart from the rural areas' reliance on remittances and social transfer payments, the one outstanding characteristic of the rural economy is its dependence on a few key industries, all of which are typically resource-based, such as agriculture, mining, fishing, tourism and forestry.
With rising unemployment and low economic activity, policymakers are searching for areas of growth and job creation. For many rural areas, agriculture and tourism are the only industries that still have the potential to generate livelihoods and employment.
But, for these industries to perform better, we must address the various infrastructure and governance constraints that have limited the development and growth of agriculture to its potential levels. Indeed, the sector has more than doubled since 1994, but it is not yet at capacity.
We have detailed many growth-constraining issues in our latest joint work with Professor Johann Kirsten,
These include:
Market failures (high transaction costs, remote location);
Government failures (inefficiencies, poor service delivery and corruption);
Community failures (poor local institutions, vested interests of traditional leaders); and
Poor land governance (lack of secure tenure).
These constraints cause many rural communities to be caught in a poverty trap from which they cannot escape. What's worse, rural areas have less access to public services and infrastructure than urban areas due, partly, to the higher per-unit cost of infrastructure investment and service delivery in rural areas.
This extends to 'soft' infrastructure such as healthcare centres as well as 'hard' infrastructure such as road networks, rail, silos, irrigation systems, water and electricity. This leads to low agricultural productivity and poor linkages to markets for farmers.
What should be done differently to address these problems so that economic activity and employment can take off in rural areas?
To an extent, these problems are well understood and were highlighted in
The lack of implementation of agricultural government policy and infrastructure-related constraints comes down to the following reasons:
Weak coordination and misalignment of functions and priorities between different government departments and different spheres of government.
A misallocation of the budget by the national and provincial governments; and
Poor coordination between the government and the private sector has led to a misalignment of transformation programmes, incentives and in some cases, vision.
I won't delve into further details, especially as my book,
This is a challenge that the government and the private sector should address, and refocusing on the
Wandile Sihlobo is the chief economist of the Agricultural Business Chamber of South Africa. You can watch the lecture
. I speak at 1:10:10 minutes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
2 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Africa-Japan: Reflections on Tokyo International Conference on African Development
Japan went through a process of transforming from a country with a weak agricultural base to the success that it is today. Photo: File The Japanese have a saying: 'Shippai wa seiko no haha.' It translates as 'Failure is the mother of success.' In other words, never give up! Next week, African leaders will assemble in Japan for the 9th Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD) — 32 years after its birth. This is therefore a good time to reflect on how the political and economic experience of The most essential lesson Africa can learn from Japan is political, because what Africa needs most today is peace and stability, which can only be achieved in the political realm. It is important to note that, unfortunately, Africa's level of conflict was the Conflict resolution In my judgment, politics in Japan has at least four interrelated dimensions. First, there is the widespread perception that politics is not a zero-sum game. The best way to achieve a compromise is to ensure that today's political loser can be tomorrow's winner. This eliminates the need to resort to any means necessary to usurp power or cling to it until forcibly removed. The unwritten rule of politics in much of Africa today seems to be different — one loses a political contest, often a violent and sometimes bloody contest, then that marks the end of that person's political career, or even of his life. In such a contest, one, therefore, has two choices: either to win and exterminate his opponent or to lose and be exterminated. As the Kenyan scholar Ali Mazrui once put it: 'In many African countries, presidential power is a zero-sum game. Either one is head of state or a figure of fun and derision, if not vulnerable to imprisonment or death. This state of affairs encourages some heads of state to cling to power indefinitely. They have everything to lose by giving up the state house.' The second dimension of politics in Japan pertains to the phenomenon of political recycling, the idea that politicians, especially those holding higher offices, should expect to be called back to service after their term of office ends. The premise is that the old order need not be wiped clean by a new order. The net effect of this approach in Japan has been to institutionalise a positive-sum game of politics, foster the desire among political contestants not only to be good losers but also gracious winners and, above all, to induce the desire to cooperate. In Africa, it is fair to say that political recycling is almost unknown. Third, there is, in Japan, the idea of the victor without the vanquished. I was a young graduate student from Africa in Japan in the 1990s. In that decade, the country changed its prime ministers nine times, needless to say, always peacefully. Both the winner and the loser could continue to co-exist. It is not a coincidence that Japan today has 11 former prime ministers, who are aging gracefully, some of whom, possibly, may also be waiting in the wings for another call to service. And finally, there is the notion that an effective politician is one who can successfully make a compromise in the face of conflicting positions. The origin of this win-win approach can be traced back to the Meiji period and beyond. In 1877, a regional lord named Saigo Takamori rose against the Meiji reformers in a rebellion that ultimately claimed thousands of Japanese lives. The rebellion itself grew out of the disaffection of those whose influence was declining as a result of the reform. After the conflict ended, Takamori came to be described by the victorious reformers as a 'misguided patriot' and, years later, was officially elevated to the position of a 'national hero'. The reformers did not doubt the genuineness of Takamori's concerns for the welfare of his fellow Japanese, even though his vision of how it was to be achieved differed from theirs. A statute was subsequently erected in Takamori's name, which stands to this day in Tokyo's Ueno Park. In a sense, Takamori may be more remembered in Japan today than the Meiji reformers themselves. He was also the inspiration behind the 2003 popular American film, The Last Samurai . Serious political disagreements do arise in contemporary Japan, too, but they never lead to mutual annihilation. The Japanese have learned how to flexibly accommodate each other and change their positions when circumstances dictate. Africa, too, could perhaps take a leaf out of Japan's book. Sustained economic development On balance, Japan's experience in economic modernisation reveals that it successfully pursued three strategies: diversification, domestication and indigenisation. First, Japan's Meiji reformers proclaimed in 1868 that 'knowledge shall be sought throughout the world', and absorbed Western skills and adopted Western institutions from as many and diverse sources as possible. The second strategy was what the Japanese economic anthropologist Keiji Maegawa called translative adaptation, the making of foreign products, institutions and ideas more relevant or more useful to local needs. It is worth noting that the Japanese were less concerned about whether what was modified had or did not have a close resemblance to the original. Third, Japan pursued indigenisation, the fuller use of its human and material resources. This process also entailed the use and idealisation of what was indigenous. Japan's modernisers never sought to transform their culture radically. Instead, they successfully indigenised modernity. In each of the above areas, Africa's experience was decidedly different. In general, why does Africa appear to be a less efficient learner? We can refer to a scene from Mazrui's The Africans, the internationally acclaimed documentary, to illustrate this point. Holding in his hand a crude homemade gun that the liberation fighters in East Africa had used in the 1950s, Mazrui says in This issue takes us to another matter Africa has to come to grips with. Technological self-reliance Let us consider Mazrui's comment above in connection with the observation made by the American historian, George Basalla. It was about what happened in the 16th century when Portuguese adventurers brought to Japan two handguns made in Europe. At the time, guns were unknown in Japan. Basalla wrote: 'The Japanese were so impressed by these primitive firearms that they purchased them on the spot and set their swordsmiths to work duplicating them. Within a decade, gunsmiths all over Japan were turning out firearms in quantity.' Far from Japan, the Portuguese also took the same objects, guns, to another place in almost the same period, and introduced them to another group of people in Africa. The new weapon also had a similar practical appeal to the Africans as the Japanese. The idea of making guns spread rapidly in one society (Japan), as indicated above. In the other, however, the idea did not gain any traction. For the succeeding centuries, in the latter, the spear continued to play its traditional role in warfare. The place in question is 16th-century Ethiopia, at the time a Northeast African Christian kingdom in the Northern part of present-day Ethiopia. Even long before Mazrui and Bassalla, the prominent Meiji-era intellectual Yukichi Fukuzawa wrote in 1899: 'It was not until 1853 that a steamship was seen for the first time [in Japan]; it was only in 1855 that we began to study navigation from the Dutch in Nagasaki; by 1860, the science was sufficiently understood to enable us to sail a ship across to the Pacific. This means that about seven years after the first sight of a steamship, after only about five years of practice, the Japanese people made a trans-Pacific crossing without help from foreign experts.' What, then, explains the difference? Why did Africa and Japan react to contacts with the West so differently? The answer to this question is complex, for sure. But it would have also to include the divergence in the way the challenges of modernisation were perceived in the two societies, as urgent and stark in one case and less so in the other. In the case of Meiji Japan, the need to catch up with the West was framed in existential terms — as a matter of survival of the nation. With the persistent threat from the major powers of the time, and with the country open to seeing and interacting with the external world, Japan realised that it was lagging behind these powers in some areas and that it must catch up with them if it was to safeguard its national security. At this crucial moment in history, the belief that national improvement was achievable through determined effort also became widely and firmly accepted in Japan. In Africa's case, the question of catching up with the West, as vital as it was, was never framed in this way, as a matter of 'do or die'. It was probably not a coincidence that Ethiopia, under Emperor Tewodros in the 19th century, should be the only African country to seek Western weapon technology, though unsuccessfully, as it was seen as essential for the country's survival. All in all, there is a key takeaway from a comparative examination of the political and economic experience of Meiji Japan and postcolonial Africa. Japan can offer valuable lessons to Africa on what to learn, how to learn and how to learn quickly. And, why to never give up. Dr Seifudein Adem is a research fellow at JICA Ogata Research Institute for Peace and Development in Tokyo, Japan.
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Mama Shelter Residences Cape Town, New Branded Residences Rising in the City Centre
Located on Bree Street – named one of the world's coolest streets by Time Out in 2024 – Mama Shelter Residences Cape Town features 62 fully serviced studio, one-, two-, and three-bedroom residences, alongside a vibrant 127-key hotel, all under one iconic roof. This launch marks Mama Shelter's first residential and hotel offering in South Africa. The Mama Shelter brand was born in 2008, when the Trigano family (co-founders of Club Med) opened the first hotel in Paris' vibrant east, giving birth to a fresh way of hosting modern travelers. It combined design-led interiors with lively restaurant and bar spaces, knowledgeable staff and the care that only your Mama could provide – all with an affordable price tag. Since then, the brand has become a dynamic market leader in partnership with Ennismore – the world's largest and fastest-growing lifestyle hospitality company. The residences are part of a landmark mixed-use redevelopment at 111 Bree Street, led by Kasada – a pan-African real estate private equity firm focused on hospitality – in partnership with Western Cape-based property and development company, Ingenuity. Sales are managed locally by Pam Golding Properties and globally by Savills. Here's the Lowdown: 62 Residences For Sale 111 Bree Street, Cape Town Selection of Studio, 1, 2 and Grand Mama 3 Bedrooms Prices range from R3,025 to R23,4 million Sales launch online on 27 August 2025 at 1pm Estimated completion scheduled for Q3 2026 It's all happening at Mama's As far as amenities go, Mama's got it all, and then some. From Italian bites at Il Bambini Club to all-day rooftop dining with skyline views, this is a place made for indulgence, inspiration and connection. Dip into the rooftop pool, work from stylish co-working spaces or kick back on your private terrace. With three restaurants, a fitness centre, meeting rooms, concierge service and secure parking with direct lift access, everything you need and everything you love is right here, under one very playful roof. Mama's always at your service At Mama Shelter Residences Cape Town, we offer on-demand services that turn everyday living into a haven of warmth and welcome. From Essential* Services to Mama Magic, Mama redefines residential life with a touch of playfulness, creativity and boldness. Mama looks after everyone like family. Mama Essentials* (Included in your service charge) 24/7 concierge team High-speed WiFi in common areas Manned reception desk, day and night Doormen and valet service On-site security Owner support services General admin and management Building-wide property insurance Annual membership to the Accor Ownership Benefits Program Mama Cares (Additional charge) Chauffeur/private transportation In-residence housekeeping Laundry and dry-cleaning Nanny services Pet pampering by Mama Co-working space bookings* * This is an à la carte service, but as a resident you always get priority – just ask your concierge. Mama Magic (Additional charge) Mama party planner Mama's home chef experience Graphic design logo services Tattoo artist on-demand Your own personalised Mama playlist Yoga & pilates instructor sessions Mama's seasonal/holiday home decor Live music & artist bookings *Service Included in the service charge assessed to the homeowners annually A Word from our Experts Dr Andrew Golding, chief executive of Pam Golding Properties, says: 'The unique appeal of prestigious branded residences is growing globally as property purchasers recognise the benefits of buying into a luxury lifestyle backed by a strong global brand. This offers the potential for sound return on investment, coupled with the advantage of having a reputable hotel group oversee their investments in their absence.' Why Mama Mama has spread her wings all over the world, with hotels and residences in Dubai, France, Italy, Portugal, Singapore, the UK, the USA, and more on the way. Mama Shelter Residences Cape Town follows closely after the brand's new residences in Dubai and marks its first venture into sub-Saharan Africa. With eclectic, culture-blending architectural design and world-class hospitality, Mama is bringing the party to Cape Town. Go Mama. Buyers of residences receive Gold Status in the Accor Ownership Benefits Program, which offers VIP privileges and benefits at up to 5,700 hotels and resorts worldwide. …but wait, there's more! Mama's not just about good vibes and great views. She's smart with the numbers too. Located in Cape Town's Urban Development Zone (UDZ), Mama Shelter Residences may qualify for generous tax perks from both UDZ and Section 13sex allowances (where applicable and subject to the fine print, of course). Ready, Set, Click – Mama's Going Live Mama Shelter Residences is launching online. No queues. No stress. Just pure digital ease. From your sofa, your office or your favourite wine bar, you can secure your slice of Mama magic with the click of a button. It's first-come, first-served, so bring your A-game and your R10,000 reservation fee to lock in your dream residence. Sales go live at 1PM CAT (Central Africa Time) sharp on Wednesday, 27 August 2025. And word is, buyers are already circling. Here's how to be launch-day ready: Create your secure buyer profile Unlock a R100,000 launch discount Shortlist your faves Mama says: don't wait. Be early. Be ready. Be quick. For more information, visit Mama Shelter Residences. DM
TimesLIVE
4 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Epstein partner Ghislaine Maxwell's grand jury records to remain sealed
A US judge denied on Monday the justice department's bid to unseal records from the grand jury that indicted the late financier Jeffrey Epstein's partner Ghislaine Maxwell on sex trafficking charges, writing that the records did not answer lingering questions from the public about their crimes or Epstein's death. Manhattan-based US district judge Paul Engelmayer, who reviewed the transcripts of the witness testimony heard by the grand jury and other evidence the panel saw, wrote the government's assertion that the materials would reveal meaningful new information about Epstein's and Maxwell's crimes was 'demonstrably false'. 'A member of the public familiar with the Maxwell trial record who reviewed the grand jury materials the government proposes to unseal would learn next to nothing new,' Engelmayer wrote. 'Insofar as the motion to unseal implies that the grand jury materials are an untapped mine lode of undisclosed information about Epstein or Maxwell or confederates, they are definitely not that,' the judge wrote.
