How 'violence' narratives threaten South Africa's tourism industry
Tourism experts have warned that South Africa's hospitality and business sectors must move away from a mindset of underselling their brand to the world, especially in light of recent comments at the White House claiming the country is a 'violent nation.'
Last week, the world watched as President Cyril Ramaphosa's delegation to the Oval Office sought to counter narratives suggesting genocide in South Africa.
During the meeting, delegation members took turns explaining the country's ongoing violence, a move that some believed complicated Tourism Minister Patricia de Lille's efforts to attract more visitors and boost the nation's economy.
The meeting followed controversial allegations by then-President Donald Trump, who linked South Africa to 'genocide' and made a decision to offer refugee status to minority Afrikaners, claiming they faced persecution.
Some experts and organisations, including the MK party and the EFF, have said these statements have contributed to the negative perception of South Africa internationally.
In response to questions from IOL about the potential impact of these comments on tourism, the Department of Tourism declined to comment directly.
De Lille's spokesperson, Tasneem Carrim, stated that only the department's marketing unit would respond, but despite numerous attempts by IOL, no response was received.
Professor Christopher Isike of the University of Pretoria pointed out the missed opportunity to clarify key issues.
'There was a chance to state clearly that there's no evidence linking political land reform or social unrest to violence or genocide,' he said.
Addressing concerns about false narratives affecting South Africa's global image, Michael Delaney, General Manager of Radisson RED Johannesburg-Rosebank, cautioned against narratives seeking to make South Africa look bad and argued the importance of highlighting the country's positive attributes.
'Many of the misconceptions can be countered by showcasing the friendliness of its people, natural beauty, and cultural diversity,' he said.
He also stressed the need to reassure visitors that robust safety measures are in place.
In what appeared to be a response to the images of white people being targeted in South Africa during the Oval meeting, Delaney expressed grave concern.
' he hospitality sector has expressed concern over the increasing use of AI-generated images and out-of-context, outdated photographs that portray South Africa as a land plagued with insurmountable problems.
'These misleading portrayals could damage the country's tourism industry.
Delaney noted that most international visitors' perceptions of South Africa tend to improve significantly once they arrive.
'They often find the country welcoming and beautiful,' he explained.
Having traveled extensively for work, he observed that people overseas are keen to experience South Africa firsthand.
Furthermore, he said that many hotels host guests from the United States, Asia, Europe, and Africa, including airline crews and delegations, ensuring their safety is in the industry's best interest.
'Travelers can be great ambassadors for South Africa because they move around the world and share their experiences.'
Delaney also encouraged the amplifying messaging around tourist safety in overseas markets.
'All our hotel groups prioritise the safety of visitors and staff. We have comprehensive security measures and provide guests with safety tips during check-in - such as using our complimentary shuttle services, utilising hotel safes, and avoiding wearing jewellery or carrying passports openly.'
According to the Tourism, 2024 report released by Statistics South Africa (Stats SA), South Africa remained a top destination in 2024, with a total of 8,9 million tourists arriving in the country - up 5,1% from the previous year - but still falling short of the 10,2 million tourists recorded before COVID-19 disrupted global travel.
In 2024, around 30,8 million travellers were recorded, a 23,7% drop from the 40,4 million in 2015. Arrivals reached 16,1 million, departures totalled 14,3 million, and transits stood at 469 000—significantly lower than the 20,5 million arrivals, 19,1 million departures, and 824 000 transits recorded in 2015.
[email protected]
IOL Politics
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
2 hours ago
- The South African
Afrikaner refugee reveals car wash job: 'Be prepared to work!'
Afrikaner 'refugee' Errol Langton has advised South Africans hoping to resettle in the US to accept low-paying jobs. He's also warned them not to have unrealistic expectations about their new lives abroad. The IT business owner and part-time 'leafy green farmer' swapped his life in Johannesburg to live in Birmingham, Alabama. He now works at a local car wash. Langton was amongst the first group of white South Africans who applied for the refugee resettlement programme. In February, President Donald Trump signed an Executive Order, granting refuge to Afrikaners or 'minorities', over his claims of 'racial discrimination' and 'persecution' in South Africa. Speaking in an interview with US intelligence expert Chris Wyatt, Errol Langton revealed that he had taken a job at a local car wash in Birmingham. Langton, who owned an IT business in South Africa, advised fellow refugee applicants to 'come over and be prepared to work.' He said, 'Take what you can get now and work on what you want later. Don't get here and want the $50-an-hour job; take the $15-an-hour job so that you can get on your feet. 'Take the low-paying job to start with and then build to what you want. I promise you, in a year's time, you will be there.' Errol Langton stated that the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) had given resettled refugees a 'starter loan' and aid to get on their feet. Several of his family members had already secured jobs just days into their stay, he claimed. He continued: 'If you play the victim card, you will not fit in. You will not be a part of society. 'It's not discrediting what has happened to you. If you get that out of your system and show that you've taken the opportunity that you've been given, and you go work hard on it, you can open any door. The opportunities are endless.' He also warned South African 'refugees' not to expect the same lifestyle in the US either. He said, 'There is nobody to clean up after you. If you make a mess, you clean it up. 'I don't care if you're 18 or 80, if you've got to do something, you do it. You can pay someone else to do it, but that is going to cost you'. According to various immigration and recruitment agencies, South African migrants flock to countries like Canada, Australia, the UK, the US, and New Zealand. These first-world countries offer the prospects of high living standards, thriving economies and job markets, and communities of South African expats. For immigrants, or refugees, there is a high demand for skilled labour in sectors like engineering, construction, IT, healthcare, finance, and education. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Three months later Trump's Afrikaner ‘refugees' knuckle down to hard reality in US
Three months after the first group of Afrikaner 'refugees' left for the US, many have gone to ground. A handful are speaking openly about their new lives. 'In the US, I had to face this painful truth: I don't know where I fit in anymore. Can I work for someone else? Will I ever feel 'capable' again in this new place?' This anonymous comment from one of the Afrikaner 'refugees' in the US was shared by the @amerikaners2025 X account — the closest thing to an official mouthpiece for the group — on 4 August. The account has repeatedly advised the Afrikaners, brought over in at least two groups on 11 and 31 May, to avoid sharing much about their lives due to media interest: hence the anonymity of the post. The author, identified only as a mother of five in her 'late fifties — emphasis on very', writes that she came to the US with qualifications including 'courses in Psychology, English, Geography' and 'Trained CADD [computer-aided design and drafting] & surveyor draughtsman'. In South Africa, she had 'owned businesses in sales, publishing, estate sales; revived an arts festival, designed logos and ads; trained marketers, did admin, managed charity projects' and more. In the US, she described getting 'rejected for entry-level hotel jobs for being 'overqualified''. She writes, however, that she has been hired by a care agency to 'care for a few select seniors', while also being shortlisted for an interview with a business consulting agency. Much speculation about lives of 'refugees' A great deal of speculation — and lashings of schadenfreude from some quarters — has been attached to how the lives of the Afrikaner 'refugees' are playing out stateside since US President Donald Trump made his controversial decision to prioritise them for resettlement in the US, while official channels seem to have gone entirely silent on the topic. In the absence of much formal communication, a whole community has sprung up online, with would-be 'refugees' — often attaching 'MAGA' or American flags to their X bios in the apparent belief that this could aid their chances — swapping information about what to expect from the process. Several online figures have emerged as beacons — some of whom are Afrikaners based in the US who are happy to offer advice. One is Sonell van Niekerk, a Biblical content creator based in North Dakota, who gives candid warnings to would-be 'refugees' about the challenges of the uprooting — such as 'the constant missing of your friends and family that you need to live with'. Says Van Niekerk in one recent video: 'It's almost like there's a limb on your body that's missing… You go through stages of grief. You get angry, you get depressed, you get sad.' Van Niekerk has also warned followers that upon arriving in the US she had to work three jobs to survive, one of which was cleaning houses. She advises that the support of a church is indispensable. Another online guide has emerged as fellow expat Andrea Shea, who recently published 'a guide to help you build your refugee case', covering 'how to present a well-founded fear of future persecution using both personal experiences and objective evidence'. However, the towering figure in this community is Chris Wyatt, a former US military YouTuber whose following has almost doubled over the last few months as his content has increasingly focused on offering advice to would-be Afrikaner 'refugees'. Farmer sent to NY flees to South Dakota Wyatt has, in the last two months, posted video interviews with two of the 'refugees', the first being farmer Charl Kleinhaus. Kleinhaus told Wyatt in late July that the refugee programme sent him to Buffalo, New York, somewhat to his horror: 'I thought I'd go to Texas, Montana, somewhere like that where there's farming, but it didn't happen like that.' As a result, he chose to leave the assistance programme after eight days and make his own way, having made contact with a farmer in South Dakota through another South African who had worked on the same farm. The farmer bought plane tickets for Kleinhaus and his family to South Dakota and supplied them with a fully furnished house. Kleinhaus said: 'The biggest challenge is here you work, hey. There's no kitchen lady you call to sweep the house, or clean the house, or stuff like that. You do the work yourself.' He said that even farm owners worked from 'morning till 11pm at night' with no farm labourers to call for help. 'You guys work,' Kleinhaus told Wyatt. 'You play, but you work much harder.' Kleinhaus also expressed apprehension about the upcoming winter in South Dakota, in which temperatures will drop to -30°C. Because the original group of refugees is spread across a vast country, there seems to be little contact among them. Kleinhaus told Wyatt that the '59ers', as the original group call themselves, have a WhatsApp group but 'don't chat much any more'. Alabama 'refugee' had three jobs In late June, Wyatt interviewed another 59er, Errol Langton, whose family group accounted for nine of the original 59, and whose stepdaughter — back home in South Africa — has accused him of rank opportunism, including not being an Afrikaner. Langton now calls home Alabama, which he says he requested. He told Wyatt that he had a gig selling life insurance, which kept him busy driving all over the state — but clarified that he hadn't earned anything yet, as it was commission only. Langton said he was interviewing for another job and starting a third job. 'You're not given a job, you're not given anything,' warned Langton. 'This is the last month we have [state-sponsored] accommodation.' In a subsequent interview with Wyatt in July, Langton said he had secured a job at a car wash. An anonymous refugee X account, @AfrikanerPOV, posted a video on July 12 of 'the accommodation that we were placed in from our arrival in the USA', showing a basic two-bedroom apartment. This is the accommodation that we were placed in from our arrival in the USA. It was a 2 bedroom 1 Bathroom apartment. We had basic furniture (some of which we could have taken with us when we moved) that was provided as well as linens,towels,kitchen utensils. #afrikanerrefugee — AfrikanerPov (@AfrikanerPov) July 12, 2025 The same account has posted: 'We are working and staying on a farm at the moment', and advises that 'refugees' do not need to inform employers about their refugee status, 'if you do not want to'. The account also informed one would-be 'refugee' that it is possible to return to visit South Africa: 'Your case worker will discuss it with you as well when you get like the initial rundown as well after you arrive — you will just need to apply for a travel document and you will need to inform them why you want to go back.' However, he or she strongly advised against this: 'Why would you want to visit a country you fled for your safety but I know for some people it is a make or break subject but I will definitely not be going back for any reason whatsoever.' Despite the work and cultural challenges of their new lives, all the accounts mentioned have stressed the transformative nature of the feeling of safety in the US. 'More important than anything money can buy?' posted the 50-something woman on the Amerikaners account.
IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
'Technical challenges' blamed for delayed SAAF response to Eastern Cape floods
The South African Air Force receiving the second request for assistance to the floods in Eastern Cape on 16 June 2025 and one Oryx helicopter became available for deployment the following day Image: SANDF/Dean Wingrin Defence Minister Angie Motshekga has blamed technical challenges for the delayed deployment of the South African Air Force (SAAF) to assist during the devastating floods that took place in the Eastern Cape last month. This emerged when Motshekga was responding to parliamentary questions from the EFF and the DA amid the continued underfunding of the SAAF. DA MP Patrick Atkinson said it took a full week after the onset of the devastating floods in the Eastern Cape for the SAAF to deploy a single Oryx helicopter to assist with flood relief efforts. EFF MP Carl Niehaus noted with concern that the SAAF was not deployed during the critical early stages of the floods in Mthatha and other parts of the Eastern Cape, and that the response was limited to one helicopter two weeks later. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Niehaus and Atkinson asked for the reasons and an explanation for the SAAF's failure to respond in a timely and adequate manner when over 100 people had died and hundreds were displaced. 'The challenges were technical. However, they were corrected, hence we managed to send assistance in the form of an Oryx. 'Upon receiving the second request for assistance on 16 June 2025, one Oryx helicopter capability became available and was tasked to deploy on 17 June 2025,' Motshekga said in her response. Niehaus pressed the minister on whether the late response by the SAAF was due to the failure to maintain the Oryx fleet by state-owned enterprises Denel Aeronautics. Motshekga said state-owned enterprises' arms manufacturer Denel only played a very minor part in the lack of Oryx helicopters. 'They are unable to continue with servicing and repairs due to a lack of funding for spares and the long lead time (up to two years) that it takes the original equipment manufacturers (Airbus and Safran) to deliver ordered spares,' she said. She was asked about measures that have been implemented to ensure the readiness of the SAAF for future disasters. In her response, Motshekga also said there were no spares of major components, and the SAAF experiences a very long lead time when ordering spares from the original equipment manufacturers. 'Currently, there are no measures in place as the SAAF continues to be underfunded, and the flow of spares from overseas original equipment manufacturers remains extremely low.' Her response comes hot on the heels of a presentation by Denel to the Joint Standing Committee on Defence last month. Regarding the Oryx, the entity complained about the reduced budget for on-demand funding on the rotary-wing aircraft over the past five years. 'The 15-year calendar limit (major components and engines overhaul) has been reached and will lead to the imminent grounding of the fleet,' reads the document. Motshekga would not be drawn into commenting on the number of qualified flight engineers and how that compared to serviceable helicopters and trained pilots, as well as urgent steps taken to address the shortage of flight engineers. 'The detailed impact on national security can only be discussed in an appropriate closed setting,' she said. Last month, Armscor told Parliament that a staggering budget shortfall of more than R7 billion threatened the maintenance of the SAAF aircraft fleet. 'There is a shortfall of approximately R7.7 billion to fund the current fleet. If you average it in terms of an annual basis, it is R2.56 billion, and this implies that the SAAF maintenance is currently at two to three times less than what we are currently funded.'
