No joke. Opposition says Labor's $217 million Burswood budget must be put to the test
The Opposition has poured doubt on the Government's costings for the controversial project, which was announced in February during the election campaign and doesn't yet have a formal business case.
The West Australian's Ben Harvey, in his Sunday Times column, said he was 'so certain the race track won't come in on time and budget' that he pledged to run a lap fully nude on the race track's opening day if he was wrong.
Government Minister Jackie Jarvis suggested the tongue-in-cheek bet would be extra motivation to keep spending in check, before realising he was betting the budget would blow out.
'It's an entertainment precinct, I'm not sure that's the type of entertainment we had in mind,' she told reporters on Sunday.
'It's a quandary. I mean we want to be careful with taxpayers' money, we might just have to have a closed track option that day!'
Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas is confident the nude run won't happen, declaring the project will run over budget.
'The Minister admitted to me the $217 million dollar cost of the project is a guess based on draft assessments,' he said.
'This is a Government who don't listen and don't care, they do what they want and spend what they want. And they don't follow the rules.
'Minister Saffioti couldn't even confirm in estimates if the race track will be assessed by Infrastructure WA.'
Labor confirmed a business case for the Burswood entertainment precinct is 'in development' during Budget estimates, when the Premier was put under pressure to explain why the plan has not been submitted to Infrastructure WA for independent assessment.
'I can confirm that the proposal has not been submitted, and Infrastructure WA has not yet been provided with a business case for assessment,' Mr Cook said.
'Obviously it is a project that at this stage is estimated to be over $100 million once the design and business case has been completed. It would, as a matter of course be referred to Infrastructure WA for its views.'
A group of companies was awarded the contract to design and build the project this month, as the Cook Government aims to finish the racetrack in time for the opening round of the V8 Supercars in 2027.
The consortium that includes Seymour Whyte, Civmec and Aurecon was the same group behind Perth's Boorloo pedestrian and cycling bridge that opened in East Perth in December and was $50 million over budget.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
14 hours ago
- ABC News
Tough WA fishing rules fail to protect 'sustainability' of dhufish
Despite two years of tough fishing restrictions along the West Australian coast, a confidential report has revealed the population of demersal fish has not improved and even declined for the dhufish. In 2022, the McGowan Labor government introduced new fishing rules and catch restrictions in the West Coast Demersal Scalefish Fishery (WCDSF) in a bid to boost the recovery of key species such as snapper, baldchin groper and dhufish. The Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) has not publicly released a stock assessment report on the fishery since its 2021 report, which looked at the coastline from Kalbarri to Augusta. Managing director of think-tank Sustainable Seafood Australia, Darryl Hockey, supplied the ABC with a briefing note he secured under Freedom of Information, sent by the state's scientists to the then Fisheries minister Don Punch in February 2024, on the WCDSF. The briefing note from DPIRD said the status of dhufish had "escalated from high to severe risk," while snapper remained at severe risk and baldchin groper at high risk. The government has not publicly released the referenced stock assessment report. Mr Hockey said the government must act swiftly and further cut fishing catch limits to protect dhufish, such as slashing boat limits from four per day to one. And he said the government needed to be transparent and release the stock assessment, which is regarded as a key "health check" of the fishery. "The alarm bells should be ringing," Mr Hockey said. The 2021 stock assessment report states that DPIRD tracks recovery progress by undertaking weight of evidence every three to five years. Mr Hockey has also accused the government of "sitting on" its latest recreational fishing survey. This survey is also conducted by DPIRD and estimates the recreational sector's catch through measures such as phone surveys, boat ramp surveys and remote camera monitoring. In the same briefing note sent to the previous minister in February last year, it flags the recreational boat fishing survey to be finalised in early 2025. Mr Hockey said with the information in hand, the new Fisheries] Minister Jackie Jarvis was in a position to to make an important decision of the sustainability of this fishery,. "The management settings put in place by Minister Punch were ridiculous," he said. "It's most important that we have mandatory real-time electronic reporting of [recreational] catches because if you can't measure it you can't manage it. "If you're going to make decisions to protect the fishery, surely you need to have accurate measurements, and that can only be done electronically through an app." Calls for mandatory electronic reporting of catches have been backed by groups such as the WA Fishing Industry Council and the Western Rock Lobster Council, but are opposed by recreational groups such as RecFish West. Jackie Jarvis was appointed as the Fisheries Minister in April this year. She was unavailable to speak to the ABC. In a statement, she said the DPIRD undertook ongoing stock assessments to monitor WA's fish resources. "I am awaiting updated stock assessments, including commercial and recreational catch information, and have committed to industry and stakeholders that there will be broad consultation once this assessment data has been finalised," Ms Jarvis said.
West Australian
14 hours ago
- West Australian
NAPLAN 2025: WA Education Minister Sabine Winton says teachers facing more students with complex needs
WA Education Minister Sabine Winton has defended WA's performance in NAPLAN, saying teachers were grappling with an increase in primary school children with developmental delays and complex needs. The results, released today, found about one in three children across Australia did not meet the proficiency benchmark, meaning they were unable to read, write or solve maths problems at the basic level for their age. WA's Year 3 performance prompted concerns from education analysts, with 37.6 per cent failing to meet expectations for children their age in reading, and 38.5 per cent failing to meet the proficiency benchmark in numeracy. WA Education Minister Sabine Winton said it was pleasing to see the results remained stable compared to last year, and highlighted improvements in the Year 5, 7 and 9 cohorts from their average scores two years ago. 'And that really is where the power of NAPLAN, from my perspective, lies in terms of assessing improvements made over time,' she said. 'In all of our year levels, that has occurred.' On the Year 3 results, Ms Winton said schools were most focused on the students in the lowest band, who needed additional support. In Year 3 reading, the percentage of students needing additional support increased from 11.3 to 13.9 in two years. She said the WA Government was supporting early intervention through its Phonics Initiative, which includes a requirement introduced in 2023 for all public schools to undertake a Year 1 phonics assessment. The Government has also selected 350 schools to take part in a new small group tuition initiative for students who need extra support. 'We know that if we support and invest in the early years of education, it will have lifelong benefits, and that's why we will continue to drive change that will support that,' she said. 'Whether it's through trialling full time free kindy, providing more supports to schools, and I know personally as a teacher and anecdotally talking to many, many teachers in schools, we are seeing more children in the young years presenting to school with development delays, more complex needs, and that's why our government is investing in early childhood education.' This year marked the third NAPLAN (National Assessment Program — Literacy and Numeracy) under a new reporting system which scores students across four bands; needs additional support, developing, strong and exceeding. Students in the top two bands are considered to have met expectations for their age. Children in the 'developing' band have not met expectations for their age group but are working towards it. Ms Winton said WA's results were on par with the national average. 'I think it's a development that you're seeing right across Australia in terms of children with complex needs, with development delays, all sorts of things happening,' she said. 'We have had the COVID experience, and many kindy teachers tell me that that is also having an impact. So there's something happening at the national level, and I don't accept it's more exposed in Western Australia than anywhere else, but having said that, I accept that it is an area that governments need to continuously invest in.' Ms Winton said there was also a role for parents to play in connecting with teachers and reading to children from an early age. 'We have the conversation about getting back to basics in school, but we also need to get back to basics with our children in our community.' 'It's around, actually, all of us acknowledging there are many, many things that go into that magic pot in a child that then results in them achieving great outcomes in literacy and numeracy testing. 'Schools and the work that teachers do each and every day in their classrooms is critically important, but there is so much more.' Federal Education Minister Jason Clare said the national results showed encourage signs but there was more work to do. The Commonwealth has signed a $16 billion agreement with all states and territories to fix school funding, which is tied to reforms such as Year one phonics and numeracy checks. WA is the only State that has not signed up to numeracy checks.
West Australian
14 hours ago
- West Australian
Albanese talking to Starmer about recognising Palestine but says it will depend on advancing ‘two states'
Anthony Albanese has reiterated Australia's decision to recognise a Palestinian state will depend on 'circumstances where recognition will advance the objective of the creation of two states' and will not be tied to a specific timeline. The Prime Minister's comments followed a statement overnight from British Prime Minister Keir Starmer that the UK would recognise Palestine in September if Israel did not make significant progress in ending in the war in Gaza. The Prime Minister said he had spoken with Sir Keir overnight and would continue that conversation over the next few days but did not directly answer a question about whether the UK's decision would influence his thinking. 'I've said for a long time, my entire political life, I've said I support two states, the right of Israel to exist in secure borders, and the right of Palestinians to have their legitimate aspirations for their own state,' he said. 'That's my objective, not making a statement, not winning a political point, but achieving that. That's very much my focus.' World leaders were continuing to engage with each other 'both informally and formally' on the situation, Mr Albanese said. The world had been 'horrified by the terrorist act and atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7' and the world 'looks at what is happening in Gaza and expresses that it is unjustified and that it is a tragedy that (there is) ongoing loss of innocent life, the ongoing impact of the decisions to restrict aid,' he said. There was growing opposition to Israel's actions, Mr Albanese added. 'People who are friends of Israel have to be able to say what you are doing is losing support.' Earlier on Wednesday, the Government announced it had signed up to a new multinational statement on the Israel-Palestine conflict calling for an 'immediate ceasefire' in Gaza, joining foreign ministers from countries that had already recognised or expressed a willingness to recognise the State of Palestine. This was 'an essential step towards the two-State solution', it said, urging all countries that had not done so to join this call. It also called on countries who had not done so to 'establish normal relations with Israel, and to express their willingness to enter into discussions on the regional integration of the State of Israel.' The statement, signed by 15 nations including Canada, France and New Zealand, also demands 'the immediate and unconditional release of all hostages of Hamas, including the remains, as well as ensuring unhindered humanitarian access', to the strip. It expressed 'grave concern over the high number of civilian casualties and humanitarian situation in Gaza' as well as stressing 'the essential role of the United Nations and its agencies in facilitating humanitarian assistance.' Mr Albanese also highlighted the statement's recognition of the Palestinian Authority's condemnation of the October 7 terrorist attacks and its call for the liberation of hostages and the disarmament of Hamas alongside a commitment to schooling reform and triggering an election within a year. 'Clearly one of the things that the Palestinian Authority have said is to speak about a demilitarised Palestinian state. What that implies is not just no military in the conventional sense but also obviously no paramilitary,' he said. 'Sometimes out of a crisis comes a moment of opportunity to actually advance forward, in a real way, advance forward for Israelis and Palestinians,' added the Prime Minister.
