logo
No joke. Opposition says Labor's $217 million Burswood budget must be put to the test

No joke. Opposition says Labor's $217 million Burswood budget must be put to the test

West Australian4 days ago
The State Government has laughed off a reporter's threat to run a lap fully nude around the future Burswood race track, while insisting its $217 million budget for the track and amphitheatre is realistic.
The Opposition has poured doubt on the Government's costings for the controversial project, which was announced in February during the election campaign and doesn't yet have a formal business case.
The West Australian's Ben Harvey, in his Sunday Times column, said he was 'so certain the race track won't come in on time and budget' that he pledged to run a lap fully nude on the race track's opening day if he was wrong.
Government Minister Jackie Jarvis suggested the tongue-in-cheek bet would be extra motivation to keep spending in check, before realising he was betting the budget would blow out.
'It's an entertainment precinct, I'm not sure that's the type of entertainment we had in mind,' she told reporters on Sunday.
'It's a quandary. I mean we want to be careful with taxpayers' money, we might just have to have a closed track option that day!'
Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas is confident the nude run won't happen, declaring the project will run over budget.
'The Minister admitted to me the $217 million dollar cost of the project is a guess based on draft assessments,' he said.
'This is a Government who don't listen and don't care, they do what they want and spend what they want. And they don't follow the rules.
'Minister Saffioti couldn't even confirm in estimates if the race track will be assessed by Infrastructure WA.'
Labor confirmed a business case for the Burswood entertainment precinct is 'in development' during Budget estimates, when the Premier was put under pressure to explain why the plan has not been submitted to Infrastructure WA for independent assessment.
'I can confirm that the proposal has not been submitted, and Infrastructure WA has not yet been provided with a business case for assessment,' Mr Cook said.
'Obviously it is a project that at this stage is estimated to be over $100 million once the design and business case has been completed. It would, as a matter of course be referred to Infrastructure WA for its views.'
A group of companies was awarded the contract to design and build the project this month, as the Cook Government aims to finish the racetrack in time for the opening round of the V8 Supercars in 2027.
The consortium that includes Seymour Whyte, Civmec and Aurecon was the same group behind Perth's Boorloo pedestrian and cycling bridge that opened in East Perth in December and was $50 million over budget.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘I know there's concern' says Alcoa Australia president Elsabe Muller as US miner fights for South West mine
‘I know there's concern' says Alcoa Australia president Elsabe Muller as US miner fights for South West mine

West Australian

time6 hours ago

  • West Australian

‘I know there's concern' says Alcoa Australia president Elsabe Muller as US miner fights for South West mine

Alcoa's new local chief Elsabe Muller insists the US bauxite giant is putting 'all effort in' to win approvals to keep mining the State's Jarrah Forest as the plans undergo lengthy public scrutiny. The Pittsburgh-headquartered miner and alumina refiner is fighting to secure two environmental ticks from the State Government to expand its bauxite mine in the South West, and to increase production capacity at the Pinjarra Alumina Refinery. Asked whether she was confident Alcoa would get the green light for its expansion plans, Ms Muller told a WA Mining Club event the miner was 'putting all effort in to make sure that we're getting the support to get approval.' Alcoa's existing approvals were locked in under a State agreement in 1961 and therefore have not gone through WA's current environmental assessment regime to make sure they meet modern standards . 'For any mining company, you tend to mine where the deposit can be economically extracted. Now, in our case in WA, you find it in the Jarrah Forest,' operations president Ms Muller said on Thursday. She referenced research from the Global Aluminium Council that claimed demand for the metal would increase between 30 per cent and 40 per cent by 2030. 'It will double by 2050 because you do need it to decarbonise. There's no substitute,' she said. 'We obviously need to enter new mining areas so that our refineries can keep operating for decades to come.' WA's Environmental Protection Authority launched a 12-week public comment period for the plans at the end of May, a move Alcoa said earlier this month would mean it was unlikely a Ministerial decision would be made by early 2026, as had been anticipated. The miner has also faced substantial community concern since it was served an official notice by the Department of Water and Environmental Regulation in 2023, after inspectors found Alcoa had built a pipeline and funnelled toxic PFAS-contaminated waste over Samson Brook dam despite a works application still being 'under assessment'. Asked how it would address these concerns during the public feedback period, Ms Muller said on Thursday that Alcoa had 'never impacted drinking water' and had implemented a reservoir protection zone 'to absolutely make sure we will not'. 'I know that there's concern. We've never impacted drinking water.'

Trish Cook: Bullwinkel MP uses first speech to honour ‘nursing hero'
Trish Cook: Bullwinkel MP uses first speech to honour ‘nursing hero'

West Australian

time8 hours ago

  • West Australian

Trish Cook: Bullwinkel MP uses first speech to honour ‘nursing hero'

WA Labor MP Trish Cook, who claimed victory in Australia's newest electorate, has used her first speech to honour the legacy of the seat's namesake WWII nurse Vivian Bullwinkel. In a historically-heavy speech to Parliament, Ms Cook — a former nurse herself — spoke of Lieutenant Colonel's incredible tale of survival in the 1942 Banka Island massacre. She thanked Australia's military nurses and soldiers for their 'incredible sacrifices and services' to 'fight for democracy' Australia holds today. Ms Cook said her aspirations to become a Federal MP came after watching the first term of the Albanese Government. She said it had been solidified after the new seat was created in her Perth Hills area and when she heard it would be named after the 'nursing hero.' 'Suddenly, here was a brand new electorate of Bullwinkel, which encompassed my home of Darlington for 17 years and was named in honor of World War Two nursing hero, Lieutenant Colonel Vivian Bullwinkel,' she said. 'I took this optimistically as a sign of encouragement. I ignored my campaign naivety, threw my nurse's cap into the ring, and to my delight, the Labor Party embraced my candidacy.' Prior to her candidacy, Ms Cook had been deputy Shire president of Mundaring. In her address, Ms Cook spoke of her experience working as a nurse across remote and regional Western Australian and a stint in the Solomon Islands. The fresh face said she wanted to fight for fairness, injustice and better health outcomes across her term. 'The professions of nursing and politics both require great commitment honesty and a great sense of wanting to help people and communities,' she said. 'As a federal Labor member, I pledge to care and advocate for the fair and equitable allocation of resources to target the social determinants of health, the factors which will improve life for those in Bullwinkel and for all Australians.' Ms Cook also declared she wants to support Bullwinkel farmers in the wake of the live sheep export phase out, an issue which had caused her some controversy ahead of the May 3 poll. Fifteen per cent of constituents in her electorate, stretching from Perth's metropolitan fringe out to the Wheatbelt, fall outside of the metropolitan region. 'The rural area of Bullwinkel consists of four historic Wheatbelt towns. As well as the townspeople, these rural communities include passionate farmers who produce our food and our agricultural exports,' she told Parliament. 'They see the ever changing impact of climate change, and while they have thankfully and recently got their barley markets back they are still transitioning to the ban on live sheep export by sea.' Among those watching on was new State secretary Mark Reed in the gallery and former secretary Ellie Whiteaker on the outskirts of the chamber in her new role as WA senator. WA Scarborough MP Stuart Aubrey and Nedlands MP Katrina Stratton were among her supporters also listening in. After her address Ms Cook was embraced by several WA MPs, including Assistant Minister Patrick Gorman who had been her campaign director during the Federal Election.

MARK RILEY: Barnaby Joyce says net zero promise ‘insane', but ditching the plan is not an option
MARK RILEY: Barnaby Joyce says net zero promise ‘insane', but ditching the plan is not an option

West Australian

time8 hours ago

  • West Australian

MARK RILEY: Barnaby Joyce says net zero promise ‘insane', but ditching the plan is not an option

Restraint is a rare and elusive quality for an opposition leader to exercise in the early days of a new parliament. But Sussan Ley has done that this week. And not everyone is happy about it. It is natural that some in the Coalition would feel uncomfortable about not being able to dive hell-for-leather into the Government trenches with all guns blazing. It has been a painful, frustrating 11 weeks since they were so comprehensively smashed at the ballot box. And it is only natural that they would want to take out their anger and frustration on someone. Preferably the Government. But in politics, as in life, you only get one chance to make a first impression. And Sussan Ley is intent on making a positive one. She has maintained since becoming leader that the Liberal and National parties must demonstrate that they have not only heard the messages from the people but are responding to them. One of those messages was that voters have had enough of the reflexively confrontational model of politics. Our 'Washminster' system of democracy is fundamentally adversarial in nature, but not every idea has to be contested in a bare-knuckled fight. Sometimes being supportive is the best option. That doesn't mean simply saying 'yes' to everything. Oppositions can still say 'yes, but.' They can support an issue in the broad but still propose ways of making it better. And they can and should still say 'no'. But just not to every issue for the hell of it. It is about choosing your battles wisely. Matters of principle need to be defended. There are times when oppositions must go to the mat to demonstrate to voters what they really stand for. But if they do that on every issue, they will only be seen to stand for one thing — standing in the way. And that won't work. Figuratively or practically. The Labor Party has a 51-seat majority in the House of Representatives. The Coalition parties cannot stand in the way of any measure against that weight of numbers. But they can make statements of principle that can be defended more effectively in the Senate, where the Government needs either their numbers or the Greens' to pass legislation. Barnaby Joyce is taking a different approach, as is his want. His view, explained in multiple interviews this week, is for the Coalition to pick one big point of difference with Labor and then pull on a big fight over that. The issue he chose didn't surprise anyone who has been around Parliament House for the 20 years that he has walked its halls. He wants yet another episode of the climate wars. And he wants to apply the same template he used to fight Kevin Rudd's Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme and Julia Gillard's Emissions Trading Scheme. Remember his startling claim that pricing carbon would send the cost of a leg of lamb skyrocketing to $100? More than a decade later, it's still $35 at Coles or Woolies. This time Joyce is going after the shared commitment by the Government and the Opposition to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2050. According to him, the promise is 'insane.' But arguing to ditch that commitment doesn't just establish a point of difference between Labor and the Coalition. It also has the potential to split what is left of the Liberal and National parties. Again. Not everyone on the conservative benches buys into Joyce's almost religious zeal to smite the 'climate crusaders.' A backyard brawl over the issue won't just pit the Coalition against Labor. It will also set Nationals against Nationals, Nationals against Liberals and Liberals against other Liberals. At a time when Sussan Ley desperately requires unity, a Barnaby barney over net zero would give her net zero chance of achieving it. And the potential consequences of that for a new Opposition Leader are the opposite of restrained.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store