Provincial department asked once again to seek help to handle information requests
In a report issued Tuesday, Carmen Stuart was critical of the Department of Opportunities and Social Development's handling of an access request filed on Oct. 3, 2024, which the department had not responded to beyond seeking an extension because of the "unusual size of the record."
The department anticipates it will take until next year to process the more than 4,000 pages of records, Stuart noted in her report.
On Nov. 29, 2024 the department was denied permission by the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner for an extension of 182 days to comply with the request.
Stuart noted her office was unable to resolve the matter informally, which triggered her report. In it, she noted this was "the sixth report that the commissioner has made since August 2023 because the (department) has failed to respond to the applicant within the statutory deadline."
"For this reason, the Commissioner is repeating the recommendation … that senior leadership at the (department) address this problem by ensuring it has sufficient resources to fulfil its legal obligation under FOIPOP."
Tricia Ralph, the information and privacy commissioner at the time, made a similar recommendation on Oct. 23, 2024.
"Within a month of the date of this review report, senior leadership at the public body address this problem by ensuring it has sufficient resources to fulfil its legal obligations under FOIPOP," wrote Ralph. "This includes hiring additional staff and exploring any other avenues that could be capitalized to complete this work."
According to Stuart, the department rejected Ralph's recommendation.
Spring legislation
During the spring sitting of the legislature, the Houston government tabled legislation to amend the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act to allow public bodies to refuse applications that are "trivial, frivolous or vexatious."
The attempt drew a rebuke from Ralph in the last days of her tenure.
The PC government backed off those changes and other controversial measures, including an attempt to gain the power to fire the province's auditor general without cause. That came following public outcry.
The Justice Department launched a review of Nova Scotia's access to information legislation in September 2023 with an anticipated release of a report this spring.
Justice Minister Becky Druhan recently acknowledged that work continues but could not say when it might be completed.
Department responds
The Department of Opportunities and Social Development "receives a large volume of personal and general FOIPOP applications," it said in a statement Friday afternoon. "Some requests span decades and involve thousands of pages of both hard copy and electronic records. Requests may also deal with sensitive personal information and require consultation with third parties.
"As the report states, in this case, it is a 4,000+ page file. Work is underway, and we will issue a decision to the applicant once we have completed the line-by-line review and consultations. The department will continue to work to improve our response times and respond to requests as quickly as possible."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edmonton Journal
2 days ago
- Edmonton Journal
Information and privacy commissioner says Alberta rejected of her two recommendations
Alberta's information and privacy commissioner says she is prepared to investigate the province's response to access to information requests, should it continue to ignore two recommendations her office made earlier this year. Article content In May, Information and Privacy Commissioner Diane McLeod published a report that followed a 21-month investigation into how the province was handling requests made under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FOIP). Article content Article content Article content She found that 27 government departments relied on policies that broke FOIP laws, and issued a report with multiple recommendations to make responses to requests compliant with the legislation. Article content Article content 'I am pleased that the government has accepted most of my recommendations and either has implemented or is in the process of implementing them,' said McLeod. 'However, I was disappointed to read that the government is not accepting two of the recommendations.' Article content Those two recommendations centre around the province's practice of limiting the number of topics in an access to information request, and splitting requests with multiple topics into several new requests at the cost of more fees. Article content Article content McLeod said she wants to know if the government is still pursuing those policies under new legislation, The Access to Information Act (ATIA), which came into force on June 11 and superseded the FOIP Act. Article content 'I will be monitoring requests for review coming into my office concerning Government of Alberta public bodies to determine whether this activity is still occurring under ATIA,' McLeod said. Article content 'If I find this to be the case, I will investigate under ATIA to determine whether the government public bodies are permitted to require applicants to split access requests and their rationale for the same.' Article content In a statement, the office of Service Alberta and Red Tape Reduction Minister Dale Nally said his department respects McLeod's role but that his job is 'to get Albertans the information they request, quickly, lawfully, and efficiently.'
Calgary Herald
2 days ago
- Calgary Herald
Information and privacy commissioner says Alberta rejected of her two recommendations
Alberta's information and privacy commissioner says she is prepared to investigate the province's response to access to information requests, should it continue to ignore two recommendations her office made earlier this year. Article content In May, Information and Privacy Commissioner Diane McLeod published a report that followed a 21-month investigation into how the province was handling requests made under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FOIP). Article content Article content Article content She found that 27 government departments relied on policies that broke FOIP laws, and issued a report with multiple recommendations to make responses to requests compliant with the legislation. Article content Article content 'I am pleased that the government has accepted most of my recommendations and either has implemented or is in the process of implementing them,' said McLeod. 'However, I was disappointed to read that the government is not accepting two of the recommendations.' Article content Those two recommendations centre around the province's practice of limiting the number of topics in an access to information request, and splitting requests with multiple topics into several new requests at the cost of more fees. Article content Article content McLeod said she wants to know if the government is still pursuing those policies under new legislation, The Access to Information Act (ATIA), which came into force on June 11 and superseded the FOIP Act. Article content 'I will be monitoring requests for review coming into my office concerning Government of Alberta public bodies to determine whether this activity is still occurring under ATIA,' McLeod said. Article content 'If I find this to be the case, I will investigate under ATIA to determine whether the government public bodies are permitted to require applicants to split access requests and their rationale for the same.' Article content In a statement, the office of Service Alberta and Red Tape Reduction Minister Dale Nally said his department respects McLeod's role but that his job is 'to get Albertans the information they request, quickly, lawfully, and efficiently.'
Winnipeg Free Press
4 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Manitoba added 201 doctors since NDP took office
Manitoba has seen an increase of 201 net new physicians practising in the province since the NDP formed government. Another 12 have accepted offers and are set to begin their practices in the coming months, Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara said in a statement Wednesday. A contract with Canadian Health Labs to recruit 150 physicians that was signed by former Progressive Conservative health minister Audrey Gordon in 2023 resulted in the hiring of two physicians, each from the United Kingdom. That contract expired on July 24 and will not be extended. 'This was not a good deal for the province of Manitoba and, yeah, we're not going to be renewing it,' Premier Wab Kinew said Wednesday at an unrelated news conference. 'We were looking at the clock waiting for this thing to expire.' MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES Premier Wab Kinew said a contract with Canadian Health Labs to recruit 150 physicians, signed by the former Progressive Conservative government, was not a good deal for the province of Manitoba. MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES Premier Wab Kinew said a contract with Canadian Health Labs to recruit 150 physicians, signed by the former Progressive Conservative government, was not a good deal for the province of Manitoba. The contract with Canadian Health Labs was valued at up to $5.25 million, with $3.75 million allocated for the 2023-24 fiscal year, a provincial government spokesman said in an email. The contract stipulated that the recruiter would be paid between $25,000 and $45,000 for each family doctor recruited, depending on their practice location. On Wednesday, the Tories blamed the NDP for the lack of results. 'This is yet another example of the NDP inheriting a successful PC program, and setting it up to fail,' PC deputy leader Jeff Bereza said in a statement. He called the contract a viable recruitment tool and compared it to the diagnostic and surgical recovery task force the NDP shut down after taking office. 'They didn't try,' Bereza said. 'It's time for the NDP to stop blaming the PCs for their health-care failures, and (start) delivering on their election promises to Manitobans.' Kinew said the deal was bad and his government was taking a better approach to health care. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. 'We've added close to 3,000 new health-care staff, physicians, nurses, health-care aides and we've done that using recruitment and retention services being run out of the department of health. That provides you the best value for your taxpayer dollar but it also makes sure that we have better oversight,' he said. The contract with the private recruiter did little to attract new doctors and nothing to retain them, Asagwara said. 'We are taking a hands-on approach, recruiting directly through the (Health Care Recruitment and Retention Office), which gives health care workers one-on-one support from the time they apply to when they're settled in their new community,' the health minister said. The office, set up last year, lined up 25 of the new doctors, with candidates from a variety of countries including the U.K., United States, Nigeria, Iran, Pakistan, South Africa, Jordan, Egypt, Hungary, Colombia, and across Canada. Doctors Manitoba president and Neepawa family doctor Nichelle Desilets applauded the province's efforts. Tim Smith/The Brandon Sun files Doctors Manitoba president and Neepawa family doctor Nichelle Desilets. Tim Smith/The Brandon Sun files Doctors Manitoba president and Neepawa family doctor Nichelle Desilets. 'Having reliable, consistent contact with people who are going to follow up on those inquiries and make sure that the paperwork's not getting lost and to support physicians through that process — that is absolutely what we need,' said Desilets, who went through the process of getting licensed in Manitoba when she moved from a neighbouring province 10 years ago. Desilets said the increase in doctors is great but many more are needed. Doctors Manitoba launched its own recruitment campaign in the U.S. after the election of President Donald Trump in November. 'Practise where you are valued and trusted as a physician and the government stays out of the exam room,' an excerpt from one of the ads in U.S. medical magazines and newsletters read. The campaign honed-in on health-care providers in North Dakota, Florida and other states where abortion and gender-affirming care have become deeply politicized issues. 'Physicians are in demand everywhere, so they can get offers from anywhere. In fact, other provinces are actively recruiting Manitoba physicians as we speak.'–Nichelle Desilets In Canada, Manitoba ranks second from the bottom compared to other provinces, with 219 physicians per 100,000 residents, Desilets said. 'Physicians are in demand everywhere, so they can get offers from anywhere. In fact, other provinces are actively recruiting Manitoba physicians as we speak,' she said. 'We know that Manitoba is a great place to live and work once you've been here, but sometimes the tough part is persuading doctors and other health-care professionals to check out our province and to come here and see what opportunities are available, despite the cold winters,' she said. Desilets said doctors are the best recruiters. 'If those physicians are saying positive things about their work environment, that's going to go in a positive direction towards recruitment.' The province also must play a part, she said. 'Make sure that we're not getting outperformed or outbid by other jurisdictions that might be offering bigger incentives or more resources.' Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
