logo
The Department of Homeland Security embraces a socialist anthem

The Department of Homeland Security embraces a socialist anthem

CNN2 days ago
People in entertainment
Music
Federal agencies
Donald Trump
FacebookTweetLink
The Trump administration recently presented a vision for the country's future in song and video.
'The Promise of America is worth Protecting. The Future of our Homeland is worth Defending,' the Department of Homeland Security wrote on X. In the accompanying vintage-filtered montage, families gaze out wondrously at our national parks, Mount Rushmore and the Statue of Liberty stand tall in all their glory, and law enforcement officers salute a horse-carried American flag.
What caught some attention, though, was the music: The video was set to Sam Hunt's country cover of Woody Guthrie's 'This Land Is Your Land.' This version appeared on the soundtrack to 'Bright,' Netflix's 2017 Will Smith-fronted buddy cop movie about orcs and elves.
The Promise of America is worth Protecting. The Future of our Homeland is worth Defending. pic.twitter.com/wkpSvZZlT7 Woody Guthrie fans who know the song's origins as a socialist protest anthem would find the Trump administration's embrace of 'This Land' an odd choice.
Guthrie — a lifelong socialist, anti-capitalist and communist sympathizer — penned 'This Land Is Your Land' in 1940, irritated by what he felt was the blind patriotism of Kate Smith's late '30s hit recording of 'God Bless America.' He was also motivated by the stark poverty and social injustices that he witnessed during his travels throughout the country, as evidenced by the original lyrics that include two verses critiquing widespread hunger and the concept of private property.
'This Land Is Your Land,' was not — as it's often understood today — a paean to the country's natural beauty, said Will Kaufman, author of 'Woody Guthrie, American Radical' and two other books on the artist.
'Woody is writing about a different America,' he told CNN. 'He's writing about cops and vigilantes and barbed wire and bread lines.'
CNN reached out to ask if the government was aware of the song's radical roots and history. DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin answered in a statement that read, in part: 'Loving America may be a radical or foreign concept for CNN, in fact we're quite confident it is.'
The song's final two verses weren't frequently reprinted nor did they make it to the more circulated recording of the song, Kaufman said. Over the years, as the shortened version made its way to elementary school classrooms and the greater national consciousness, it became increasingly divorced from its beginnings. (To that end, when Guthrie was honored by the US Department of the Interior in 1966, Kaufman said the artist's friend Irwin Silber retorted that 'they've taken a revolutionary and turned him into an environmentalist!')
Though the more political verses made a resurgence in the 1960s and have been performed by such artists as Bruce Springsteen and Pete Seeger, 'This Land Is Your Land' is now embraced by both liberals and conservatives. It's also worth noting that many Indigenous people understand it to be a celebration of the dispossession of Native American lands.
When asked about the Trump administration's use of 'This Land,' Guthrie's family replied in an email: 'Boy, did the DHS ever get it wrong! If they want to get it right they should watch Pete Seeger and Bruce Springsteen's performance at Obama's inaugural concert. That's the gold standard. So now, it looks like we'll all have to sing This Land Is Your Land right back at 'em, so they can re-learn it and get it right.'
Over the years, Guthrie's estate has also resisted attempts to make the song public domain precisely over fears it would be used in ways he wouldn't wish.
'Our control of this song has nothing to do with financial gain,' the singer's daughter, Nora Guthrie, told The New York Times in a 2016 interview. 'It has to do with protecting it from Donald Trump, protecting it from the Ku Klux Klan, protecting it from all the evil forces out there.'
There's plenty of reason to suspect Guthrie might have revolted at the Trump administration's use of 'This Land Is Your Land.' In his songs and his writings, the folk singer paid tribute to Mexican laborers who died on a deportation flight and criticized an illegal police blockade to keep Dust Bowl migrants out of California, Kaufman writes in 'Woody Guthrie, American Radical.' His guitar bore the inscription 'This Machine Kills Fascists,' and he even railed against Trump's father and his discriminatory housing policies.
'There is a personal venom that Woody Guthrie has for everything that Donald Trump represents,' Kaufman said.
From Beyoncé to Celine Dion to The Rolling Stones, the list of artists who have objected to Trump's use of their work is so long that there's an entire Wikipedia page devoted to the subject. Just last week, Jess Glynne said she felt 'sick' over the White House using her song 'Hold My Hand' in a cruel meme about deporting migrants. And in another recent example, the Thomas Kinkade Foundation denounced DHS for using the artist's painting to promote the administration's immigration crackdown.
'We strongly condemn the sentiment expressed in the post and the deplorable actions that DHS continues to carry out,' the foundation wrote in a statement on its website. 'We stand firmly with our communities who have been threatened and targeted by DHS, especially our immigrant, BIPOC, undocumented, LGBTQ+, and disabled relatives and neighbors.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump administration to scale back annual human rights reports
Trump administration to scale back annual human rights reports

NBC News

time26 minutes ago

  • NBC News

Trump administration to scale back annual human rights reports

WASHINGTON — The Trump administration is scaling back the State Department 's annual Human Rights Report and placing a new focus on restrictions on freedom of expression by U.S. allies as well as adversaries. The reports, which are widely anticipated and read around the world, have been composed by U.S. diplomats under congressional mandate for almost 50 years as a measure of countries' adherence to internationally recognized human rights. The report for last year, which normally would have been released in the spring, has already been delayed by months. 'The 2024 Human Rights Report has been restructured in a way that removes redundancies, increases report readability and is more responsive to the legislative mandates that underpin the report,' a senior State Department official said Wednesday in a briefing to reporters. 'We call out certain abuses that we think deserve highlighting, but just because we focus on one instance does not mean that we are not aware of other instances of human rights abuses,' the official added, noting that all 198 countries and territories were listed in the reports. The delay follows dramatic cuts to the State Department's Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, including the elimination of almost every office as part of the mass reorganization of the agency earlier this year. The official dismissed concerns about staffing shortages and said the draft version that had been received from the Biden administration prioritized things 'the American people rejected,' noting that 'the process of revising and ensuring that the report is readable and is factually based took several months.' The official said the report is still being finalized but would be transmitted to Congress 'in the near future.' When the 2024 report is released it will reflect the values of this administration, the official said, including concerns about a global threat to freedom of expression. 'Governments around the world continue to use censorship, arbitrary or unlawful surveillance and restrictive laws against disfavored voices, often on political and religious grounds,' the official said. The official cited Vice President JD Vance's controversial speech to the Munich Security Conference in February, during which he accused European Union leaders of suppressing free speech, particularly that of far-right groups. 'We are committed to having frank conversations with our allies, our partners and also our adversaries, to promote freedom of expression around the world,' the official said. The report will also focus on the right to life, 'the most cherished fundamental human right of all,' the official said. 'When governments are using means to hurt life, to destroy life, whether that be through war, whether that be through transnational repression, whether that be through extrajudicial killings, those are issues that we're going to raise.' The official declined to directly address whether the report would address other human rights concerns such as government corruption and restrictions on participation in the political process, the denial of freedom of movement or peaceful assembly and access to free and fair elections.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store