'Dramatic Shift' That Could Leave KiwiSaver Members Better Off
The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) released research this week noting the significant shift in risk of KiwiSaver investments.
The proportion of KiwiSaver in funds that are risk category five, with high volatility, has quadrupled from 10 percent in 2021 to more than 40 percent in 2024.
Riskier funds can be expected to be more volatile but over the long term should produce better results. They are generally recommended for investors who still have a significant period of time until they need to access their investments.
Morningstar data shows that aggressive funds have returned 10.89 percent a year over five years, and 9.34 percent over 10 years.
That is compared to 3.07 percent a year over 10 years for conservative funds, 4.47 percent for moderate funds, 6.18 percent for balanced and 7.68 percent for growth.
Data director Greg Bunkall said cash investments' returns had lagged the rate of inflation over that time.
The FMA said the proportion of KiwiSaver investments in lower risk funds dropped from 30 percent to 10 percent over the same 2021-to-2025 period.
Part of this was due to the change to default funds, which now require them to be balanced. But it said there were other factors at play, too.
"In the period prior to the Covid-19 global pandemic, interest rates were historically low, and inflation was low and stable. As a result, many fixed-income assets provided low returns. On the other hand, stock markets have performed very well in most years since 2017, and the few periods of weakness quickly reversed.
"The strong performance and relative stability of stock markets may have therefore made higher-risk investments more attractive to investors. The persistence of this situation over several years may have contributed to the observed shift in preference for higher-risk investments, illustrating adaptive expectations among investors."
It said market performance could also have affected the risk rating of funds. Spikes of volatility in 2020 and earlier this year affect funds' performance history.
A number of providers have recently launched "high growth" funds that invest almost solely in equities.
FMA director of markets, investors and reporting John Horner said the FMA was not necessarily implying that people were in the wrong fund or that providers were advising members towards higher-risk funds.
"The observed increase in the risk categorisation of KiwiSaver funds appears to reflect a combination of factors including policy settings, investor behaviour, and market volatility.
"KiwiSaver is a long-term savings regime for retirement, and for most long term investments a higher risk strategy will be appropriate.
"We note that as KiwiSaver has been in existence for a while and become more mature there are more options available, including higher risk options, and there is also more material available to allow investors to educate or inform themselves about risk vs reward."
Fisher Funds general manager of KiwiSaver David Boyle said the increase in investments in riskier funds was a good thing for investors wanting to grow retirement savings over the long term.
He said consumers knew more about the role of growth assets in a long-term savings scheme like KiwiSaver. Fund mangers were responding to consumer interest and providing education on the risks and benefits of different fund types.
Investors had experienced the Covid downturn and seen the recovery.
"The advent of platforms that allow investors to build their own portfolios allows providers to launch single sector specialist offerings that are often at the riskier end of the spectrum."
He said members still had choice and there were many lower-risk and savings options available.
Booster chief executive Di Papadopoulos agreed New Zealanders were becoming more sophisticated in assessing their time horizons and figuring out if they could handle more risk to target higher returns.
"It appears people are moving to higher risk funds that align with them not needing their KiwiSaver money for retirement anytime soon," she said.
"At Booster, we have seen the benefit of these decisions. Moving from a balanced fund to a growth fund increases projected balances at retirement significantly.
"A key factor is how soon or long in the future your might need to access your KiwiSaver, such as if you want to use it to buy your first home, or for your retirement.
"If you're unsure about whether you are in the right fund it's a good idea to check in with a financial adviser."
How much difference might your outlook be?
Based on Sorted's retirement calculator…
A 20-year-old joining KiwiSaver now with no investment, earning $60,000 and contributing 4 percent of their salary plus an employer's contribution of 4 percent could expect to have at 65:
$381,354 in a balanced fund
$477,814 in a growth fund
$606,456 in an aggressive fund
This accounts for inflation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
NZ sharemarket dips despite strong US and Australian gains
Strength on Wall Street followed stronger-than-expected economic data, including a 0.6% gain in retail sales in June after a 0.9% fall in May, which gave more weight to the view the US Federal Reserve will not change rates any time soon. Australian stocks were also sharply higher towards the end of the New Zealand business day, driven mostly by resource sector stocks. 'It's a bit surprising that Australia is up so strongly, but our market was not participating at all after another quiet news day,' Salt Funds managing director Matt Goodson said. Weighing on the index was Fisher & Paykel Healthcare, which will hold an investor day in Melbourne on Wednesday, the stock finishing 21c or 0.57% down at $36.54. Fletcher Building, despite releasing a downbeat quarterly report, bucked the trend to end 9c or 3.03% higher at $3.06. Goodson said Fletcher's gains showed investors were willing to look through the data and take a long-term view. 'Markets are forward-looking and always trying to look through to a change in the cycle, which will occur at some stage as interest rate cuts kick in,' he said. Auckland International Airport dropped 12c to $7.66 after firming yesterday. Research firm Morningstar noted the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment had been reviewing the regulation of airport services and had said it was not considering a legislative change for the airport. 'The bottom line: we maintain our $9.30 fair value estimate,' Morningstar said. 'Shares are undervalued. 'We think the market is unjustifiably pricing either lower returns on regulated expenditure or weakness in unregulated businesses, like retail and car parks,' Morningstar said. Among the small-cap stocks, the lower-tier aged-care firms performed strongly. Leading the charge was Third Age Healthcare, up 40c or 10.7% at $4.15. Promisia Healthcare gained 5c (9.6%) to 57c after releasing a performance update showing group care occupancy for June 2025 averaged 87%. In the same camp was Radius Healthcare, up 3.5c (9.6%) at 40c. It was the last day of trading for NZ Wind Farms, which is being taken over by Meridian. 'It really continues a trend of smaller companies delisting and of there being no real pipeline of new ones coming on, which has to be a concern,' Goodson said. 'If you're not in the index, it's very hard for these small companies to get attention.' Looking ahead, the Consumers Price Index for the second quarter is due on Monday. ANZ expects the index to have lifted by 0.8% quarter-on-quarter, with annual inflation accelerating to 2.9%. The bank said the data would need to show a 'sizeable upside surprise' for the Reserve Bank to take an expected 25-basis-point rate cut off the table at the release of its Monetary Policy Statement of August 20. Jamie Gray is an Auckland-based journalist, covering the financial markets, primary sector and energy. He joined the Herald in 2011.
Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
Whanganui Heritage Buildings To Make Way For Health Campus
Heritage buildings at a council-owned site in Whanganui will be demolished and the cleared site leased long-term to a local health provider. Whanganui District Council voted 9-4 this week to lease the former St George's School site to iwi-governed Te Oranganui Trust. Mayor Andrew Tripe said the decision supported Te Oranganui's vision for a community-focused health and wellbeing campus. 'This is a community organisation with deep roots in our district. By supporting this partnership, we're making a strong statement – that public land should be used to advance public good.' The decision follows community engagement and an assessment of risks and opportunities for the site at 125 Grey Street. Tripe said the decision balanced community priorities and sound financial stewardship, along with respect for Whanganui's heritage. 'We heard strong arguments to retain the heritage buildings. 'We also had Te Oranganui present a compelling case for a future that supports our community's health and wellbeing and we are confident this will deliver long-term benefits for Whanganui.' The council had not heard any other commercially viable options for the site, Tripe said. There were more than 800 responses to a council survey on the future of the site, with 51% supporting deconstructing the buildings and leasing the site to a private developer. The council would pay the estimated $1.25 million for deconstruction from its property endowment fund, meaning ratepayers would not foot the bill. The council agreed to 'a sensitive deconstruction'. 'Our approach … respects the heritage value of the site by allowing for careful deconstruction, recovery of materials, and heritage-sensitive design in future development. 'It's not just about removing buildings – it's about making space for something new that honours the legacy of the site while creating services that will support people and whānau for generations to come.' The school's original buildings went up in 1927 but most of the buildings on the site are earthquake-prone and contaminated with asbestos, according to council reports. As part of the lease, the newer administration building facing Grey Street will remain, along with the YMCA Early Childhood Centre with access from London Street, while the older surrounding buildings will be deconstructed. Tripe said it was 'a tough decision' but there were no clear plans for future use of the heritage buildings. Bringing the site up to safe, usable standards would have cost more than $12 million. The Grey Street property was home to St George's School from 1927 until the school moved to the Whanganui Collegiate School campus. The site was bought from the YMCA in 2019 by the council's commercial arm, Whanganui District Council Holdings, as an investment. Between 2019 and 2021, it was used by the New Zealand International Commercial Pilots Academy, which proposed expanding aviation-related facilities prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. The council formally purchased the site from its holdings company in 2023. Transitional housing was initially considered for the property, but that proposal was withdrawn after strong neighbourhood opposition. Two buildings are currently leased by the YMCA, but most of the site sits unused. It currently returns a net annual loss of $49,000. The council estimated the long-term lease would deliver a net benefit of $109,000 annually. Te Oranganui is expected to move in by the end of 2027.
NZ Herald
7 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Backing NZ's water reform
This article was prepared by TechnologyOne and is being published by the New Zealand Herald as advertorial. Safe drinking water is something residents of New Zealand take for granted. It is not something, however, that can be taken for granted. Investing in, maintaining and managing the infrastructure to manage water is one of the most important, high-profile and fundamental responsibilities for governments at all levels. It is a challenge local authorities can continue to rise to, but only if they have the right technology at their disposal. The New Zealand Government has recognised the importance of modernising water systems management across the nation with its Local Waters Done Well policy, intended to ensure New Zealanders can have confidence in this essential service into the future. TechnologyOne is proud to have supported local authorities in New Zealand and Australia over many years, providing them with the systems they need to safely and cost-effectively build and manage water services. Our decades of success in delivering solutions to highly regulated organisations including water authorities, NZ electricity distributors and government agencies gives us a depth of experience and a set of integrated, powerful capabilities that water authorities – and residents – need to have full end-to-end confidence in any organisation providing them with their water. Our ERP Solution for Water Utilities solution combines regulatory compliance, real-time financial control and planning, supply chain management, water asset and project lifecycle management, document management, water billing, customer management, HR and payroll systems, delivered on a single platform from a single vendor. Our open platform provides API tools to facilitate GIS and SCADA integration. Even more importantly, it is delivered using TechnologyOne's pioneering SaaS+ approach which means the systems are in place within weeks, not years, with no additional implementation costs. No one does more to take the risk out of technology implementation. TechnologyOne's experience and ability to deliver results quickly is a compelling combination, considering New Zealand's new Water Done Well council-controlled organisations (CCO) are facing tight deadlines from the Government. CCOs must get their plans in place by September 3, 2025, have systems operational by July 2027, and be fully compliant by June 2028. TechnologyOne has been part of communities across New Zealand since 2000, with team members based around the country and offices in Auckland and Wellington.
