'Log kisi ko bhi, kuch bhi keh dete hain': Supreme Court on PM's objectionable cartoons
Supreme Court
on Tuesday granted protection from coercive action to a cartoonist accused of sharing alleged
objectionable
cartoons of
Prime Minister Narendra Modi
and
RSS workers
on
social media
.
A bench of Justices Sudhanshu Dhulia and Aravind Kumar, however, cautioned if he continued to share offensive posts on social media, the state was free to take action against him under law.
"We will have to do something about it," the bench said as it mulled passing orders on abusive social media posts.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
This Is How Much New Windows Should Cost In Round Rock
westshorehomeremodel
Learn More
Undo
Miffed over the alleged abusive online posts, it added, "Log kisi ko bhi, kuch bhi keh dete hain (People say anything to anyone)'."
Cartoonist Hemant Malviya
challenged in the apex court a
Madhya Pradesh
High Court order passed on July 3 refusing to grant him anticipatory bail.
Live Events
He was booked by Lasudiya police station in Indore in May on a complaint filed by lawyer and RSS worker Vinay Joshi.
Malviya hurt religious sentiments of Hindus and disturbed communal harmony by uploading objectionable material on social media, Joshi alleged.
Advocate Vrinda Grover, representing Malviya, on July 14 argued the issue related a cartoon made in 2021 during the Covid-19 pandemic.
"It may be unpalatable. Let me say it is in poor taste. Let me go to that extent. But is it an offence? My lords have said, it can be offensive but it is not an offence. I am simply on law. I am not trying to justify anything," she said.
Grover agreed to delete the alleged offensive post.
"Whatever we may do with this case, but this is definitely the case that the freedom of speech and expression is being abused," Justice Dhulia then observed.
Additional Solicitor General K M Nataraj, appearing for Madhya Pradesh, said such "things" were repeatedly done.
When Grover said there should be some maturity, Nataraj said, "It is not the question of maturity alone. It is something more."
The FIR mentioned various "objectionable" posts, including allegedly inappropriate comments on Lord Shiva as well as cartoons, videos, photographs and comments regarding Modi, RSS workers and others.
Malviya's lawyer in the
high court
contended that he only posted a cartoon, but he could not be held responsible for the comments posted on it by other Facebook users.
The FIR accused him of posting indecent and objectionable material with the intention of hurting religious sentiments of Hindus and tarnishing the RSS's image.
The police invoked
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita
Sections 196 (acts prejudicial to maintenance of harmony between different communities), 299 (deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings) and 352 (intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of the peace) as well as section 67-A (publishing or transmitting in electronic form any sexually explicit material) of the Information Technology Act against the accused.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
Belur criticises MP over Sigandur bridge inauguration row
Shivamogga: A day after the launch of India's second-longest cable-stayed bridge at Sagar in Shivamogga, Sagar MLA Belur Gopal Krishna criticised Shivamogga MP BY Raghavendra. He accused him of having a "fox mentality" and deliberately scheduling the event hastily to exclude state govt representatives. He urged CM Siddaramaiah to take disciplinary action against govt officials who attended the Sigandur bridge inauguration on Monday, despite the CM's instructions. The 2.44 km-long cable bridge, built at a cost of Rs 473 crore, was opened to traffic by the Union road transport and highways minister Nitin Gadkari on Monday amidst political rumblings over protocol lapse. Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, the Congress MLA attacked Raghavendra, who is a MP and son of former CM BS Yeddiyurappa and brother of BY Vijayendra, state BJP chief. Velur noted that the BJP's late invitation to the CM, merely five days before the event, suggested a deliberate attempt to prevent the CM's attendance. He clarified that while Congress supports regional development, they questioned the breach of the CM's protocol, explaining their absence from the event. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Unsold 2021 Cars Now Almost Free - Prices May Surprise You Unsold Cars | Search Ads Learn More Undo However, Raghavendra expressed his discontent with Congress functionaries. Speaking to reporters here, he said: "I must express my disappointment and frustration over the petty behaviour displayed by some politicians from our district. Their desperation was palpable." He noted that rising water levels would affect barge operations, and his request for an earlier inauguration was disregarded. He expressed satisfaction at ministers and MLAs visiting the bridge, but criticised attempts to diminish the event's importance. Employment opportunities Belur discussed the Sharavathi Pumped Storage Project, which aims to generate 2000 MW of electricity to address state power shortages. The project promises employment opportunities and compensation for affected families, with assured implementation, he said.
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
US secondary tariff threat may sour India's love affair with Russian oil
President Donald Trump on Tuesday announced 100% tariff on Russian exports, including oil, and an equivalent secondary tariff on countries importing Russian shipments to be imposed after a 50-day deadline for Moscow to end the war with Ukraine. NEW DELHI: The US threat to slap penal tariffs on countries buying Russian oil may sour India's love affair with those barrels as the benefit of discounts would be far outweighed by the cost to its merchandise exports to America at a time both countries are discussing a trade deal. President Donald Trump on Tuesday announced 100% tariff on Russian exports, including oil, and an equivalent secondary tariff on countries importing Russian shipments to be imposed after a 50-day deadline for Moscow to end the war with Ukraine. The fine print of Trump's plan and how it will pan out remain sketchy at this point. But the oil market took the announcement calmly as the long deadline dispelled worries over immediate supply disruption, leaving benchmark Brent crude below $70/barrel. Indian refiners have been lapping up Russian oil at discounts since February 2022 as others shunned those barrels due to Western sanctions on Moscow imposed after its invasion of Ukraine. Russia currently accounts for a third of India's oil imports, against less than 1% before the war. Things may be different this time if Trump carries through with his threat. This is because, as reports in western media said, secondary tariff will apply to the country and affect all merchandise exports, unlike in the case where only the entities doing business with sanctioned Russian entities are penalised. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Jag stänger ner. 70% rabatt - Utförsäljning (sista kollektionen) Handmakarens rapport LÄS NU Undo If that is the case, Indian refiners will have no other way than pivot towards its traditional West Asian and suppliers and new players such as Brazil to make up for lost Russian supplies. These new barrels will, however, come at a higher cost — ranging between $4-5/barrel. Arranging alternative supplies will not be difficult as 'there is enough enrgy available in the world,' according to oil minister Hardeep Singh Puri . 'Oil prices are still between $65 and $70,' he said on the sidelines of a seminar on education on Tuesday. The government had approached two major West Asian oil producers to examine additional supplies through their alternative evacuation routes if the fear of disruption in shipping through the Strait of Hormuz came true during the recent Israel-Iran war. Industry watchers said Indian refiners are likely to tank up on cheap Russian oil during the deadline period the way they had done during the srael-Iran conflict while tying up alternative supplies. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
No saffron agenda from Delhi will succeed in TN as long as we stay united: Stalin
CUDDALORE: As long as the Dravidian, Marxist, Gandhian and Ambedkar ideologies stay united in Tamil Nadu, no saffron agenda from Delhi (referring to BJP and RSS ideologies) will succeed in Tamil Nadu, said chief minister M K Stalin . Speaking after inaugurating the centenary auditorium with a life-size statue of the late social justice warrior L Ilayaperumal, constructed at a cost of Rs 6.39 crore at Lalpuram in Chidambaram, Stalin pointed out that leaders of the Dravidian, Marxist, Gandhian and Ambedkarite movements were on the stage united. 'This unity is Tamil Nadu. Thirumavalavan (VCK President Thol Thirumavalavan) emphasised this, and I reaffirm it. When Tamil Nadu is united like this, no saffron agenda from Delhi will succeed here," he said. You Can Also Check: Chennai AQI | Weather in Chennai | Bank Holidays in Chennai | Public Holidays in Chennai Stalin said the Dravidian model govt implemented the highest number of welfare schemes for the scheduled caste and scheduled tribe communities. 'I say with pride and confidence that in the history of Tamil Nadu, it is the Dravidian model govt that implemented the highest number of welfare schemes for scheduled caste and scheduled tribe communities. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Dallas: Here's The Average Price of a 6-Hour Gutter Upgrade Read More Undo But is that enough? No. To build a society of self-respect, we must continue our long journey — and we are. That's why we've decided to remove the word 'colony' from govt documents,' he said. 'We've requested the Prime Minister that the caste suffix 'in' used to denote SC/ST in official names be changed to 'ir' as a mark of respect. We've renamed school and college hostels as 'Social Justice Hostels', removing caste identifiers," Stalin said. Stalin admitted that everything would not change overnight. 'The journey toward social liberation is long, and it takes time. But change will come. It will come. And I, Muthuvel Karunanidhi Stalin, will be the one to bring that change. The Dravidian model govt will play its role with absolute commitment," he said. He said the govt launched the 'Ungaludan Stalin' (Stalin with You) scheme to act swiftly on the public's petitions on late chief minister and Congress stalwart P Kamaraj's birth anniversary. 'Before the 2021 assembly elections, I promised under the 'Stalin in your constituency' scheme that I would resolve petitions within 100 days. After becoming chief minister, I created a separate department named 'Chief minister in your constituency' to fulfil that promise. Because of that, people trusted the govt and began submitting petitions. To support that, we created another department - 'Chief minister's address'. Through the 'CM with people' initiative, we've conducted more than 5,000 camps across Tamil Nadu and resolved lakhs of petitions," he said. He said the govt launched the next phase of the 'Ungaludan Stalin' (Stalin with You) campaign. 'Around 10,000 camps will be held throughout the state. Volunteers will visit every household and inform people about the time and place of the camps. Applications can be submitted for 46 govt services, including the Rs 1,000/month Kalaignar women's entitlement scheme. If eligible women haven't received the amount yet, they can apply at the camp, and it will be provided. The purpose of this initiative is to take the govt to where the people are. Govt officers and officials will now come looking for you. Health camps will also be held alongside. This is what defines the Dravidian model govt — identifying the people's needs and solving them," he said. A release from the DIPR later in the evening said Stalin announced that a new bus stand at Rs 20 crore would be established at Chidambaram, a new residential school for tribal students would be set up at Ariyankuppam in Cuddalore district, a new Srimushnam taluk would be carved out from Kattumannarkoil taluk to serve the Cauvery delta region better, a boating jetty including pathways and other facilities would be set up at a cost of Rs 10 crore at Veeranam lake, and a non-leather footwear components manufacturing cluster would be developed in 150 acres at Sakkarakuppam at a cost of Rs 75 crore to provide employment opportunities for women from Cuddalore, Kurinjipadi and Panruti constituencies.
