Supreme Court Stays Calcutta HC Order Pausing West Bengal's Attempts to Notify New OBC List
The high court's order passed last month is 'surprising' and 'prima facie erroneous', the top court has been quoted as saying.
New Delhi: The Supreme Court has put on hold a Calcutta high court order staying the West Bengal government's attempts to notify a new list of OBC communities, finding the lower court's reasoning 'surprising' and 'prima facie erroneous'.
A bench of the Supreme Court comprising Chief Justice B.R. Gavai as well as Justices K. Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria on Monday (July 28) passed an interim order staying the Calcutta high court's judgment passed last month.
'Reservation is part of the executive functions. This is the settled law right from Indra Sawhney; the position is that the executive can do it … legislation is not necessary,' the bench, which called the high court's order 'surprising', said per LiveLaw.
It was also quoted as saying that the high court's reasoning was 'erroneous' at first glance.
A copy of the apex court's interim order in the matter is awaited.
The high court on June 17 had stayed the West Bengal government's attempts to notify a new list of OBC communities, finding that it had on the face of it 'proceeded in hot haste' to try and bring back the same communities and quotas that the court had struck down in May last year.
Justices Rajasekhar Mantha and Tapabrata Chakraborty of the high court added that the government had done so 'by executive orders and not in exercise of state's legislative functions'.
The government ought to have placed the relevant reports before the legislature 'for amendment and introduction of classes in the schedule' of the West Bengal Backward Classes Act, 2012, the high court had said, which LiveLaw cited Justice Gavai as disagreeing with on Monday.
Last week too the chief justice while listing the case for hearing had indicated that the executive can indeed classify communities for reservation as has been the case since the top court's Indra Sawhney judgment of 1992, which among other things upheld quotas for OBCs.
West Bengal's Trinamool Congress-led government decided to prepare a new list of OBC communities after the Calcutta high court in May last year struck down lakhs of OBC certificates it had issued since 2010.
In that judgment the high court, which had also struck down some sections of the 2012 Backward Classes Act, said that the government's decision to notify 77 Muslim communities as backward amounted to an 'affront to the Muslim community as a whole'.
'This court's mind is not free from doubt that the said community has been treated as a commodity for political ends … Such reservation is therefore also an affront to democracy and the Constitution of India as a whole,' the bench comprising Justices Mantha and Chakraborty had ruled.
The state government challenged this judgment in the Supreme Court and ultimately withdrew it. It later challenged the high court's June 17, 2025 judgment in the top court.
The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
11 minutes ago
- India Today
Inside the Indira years and the Emergency
(NOTE: This article was originally published in the India Today issue dated August 11, 2025)It is not easy to find words that will do justice to Srinath Raghavan's book on how the decisions that Indira Gandhi took during her two stints as India's prime minister—from 1966 till 1977, and 1980 till October 31, 1984—shaped India's development as a democracy. Mrs Gandhi became PM when the country was in the grip of an unprecedented crisis. India had run out of foreign exchange a decade earlier, suffered a severe failure of the southwest monsoons in 1965, and a second failure in 1966 was on the decisions she had to take—a 57 per cent devaluation of the rupee, and asking the US to back a loan of almost a billion dollars—put her at odds with the seasoned leaders of the organisational wing of the party, known as the leaders, who later became the Congress (O), did not understand the magnitude of the crisis and resented her taking critical decisions without consulting them. This led to the party splitting in 1969. Raghavan's description of how and why this took place—based on a penetrating study of recently declassified documents and Mrs Gandhi's personal correspondence—will probably never be bettered. This is also true of his analysis of Mrs Gandhi's reasons for declaring the Emergency in 1975. Although he disapproves of her decision, he is scrupulous in describing the chain of events, beginning with the drought of 1972, and culminating in the assassination of railway minister L.N. Mishra in Bihar in January 1975. Of infinite value is Raghavan's detailed description of the correspondence between Mrs Gandhi and her principal advisors, and her correspondence with various opposition leaders, particularly Jayaprakash Narayan. These highlight her keenness to work with, rather than against him. It was JP's failure to suggest a way to meet the students' demands without endangering the State's stability, and his admonition to the army and police to disobey 'illegal orders' that pushed her to declare the analysis of the four years of Mrs Gandhi's rule that ended with her assassination is less compelling. This could be because the documents and correspondence of this period have not yet been de-classified. Hence, Raghavan did not know that it was not army commander General Vaidya who instigated the army's invasion of the Golden Temple but the Western Command chief, General Sundarji, who persuaded Mrs Gandhi that 'his' army would clean out the Bhindranwale rebels in did Raghavan find that, in January 1984, Mrs Gandhi had set up a 'high level' committee headed by her former intelligence chief R.N. Kao, to find a way to clear the Golden Temple with minimum casualties to civilians, and that this committee had almost finalised its plan when Kao was ordered to abandon it as the army had been given the job. That plan was used to drive Khalistani rebels out of the Golden Temple after they occupied it a second time in 1988. It succeeded after causing only 14 Ends
The Hindu
11 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Top news of the day: Rahul Gandhi alleges ‘massive' voter fraud; Indian exporters react cautiously as Trump tariffs take effect, and more
Rahul Gandhi alleges 'massive' voter fraud, says ECI colluding with BJP to steal elections Congress leader and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, on Thursday (August 7, 2025), alleged large-scale voter fraud in electoral rolls since the 2024 Lok Sabha elections in collusion with the Election Commission of India (ECI). Last week, Mr. Gandhi said he had 'atom bomb' evidence on 'vote chori' (vote theft) while not revealing much about the evidence he has. Indian exporters react cautiously as Trump tariffs take effect Amid the ongoing row over the tariffs and penalties imposed by the Trump administration on India, citing India's trade relations with Russia, the US-India Business Council (USIBC) said on Thursday (August 7, 2025) that it is 'time to redouble our efforts, not pull apart.' U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday (August 6) signed an executive order imposing an additional 25% tariff on imports from India, in response to India 'directly or indirectly' importing oil from Russia. This is over and above the 25% tariff on Indian imports that Mr. Trump approved on July 31. Russian President Putin to visit India soon, says NSA Ajit Doval Russian President Vladimir Putin will visit India soon, said National Security Adviser (NSA) Ajit Doval in an opening statement during a meeting in Moscow on Thursday (August 7, 2025). 'We are very excited to learn about the visit of President Putin to India... I think the dates are almost finalised. Summit-level meetings have always been watershed points for the relationship,' Mr. Doval said. Uttarkashi flash floods: Army says rescue operations intensified, ad-hoc aviation base set up at Matli Helipad The Army, in close coordination with other authorities, continues to intensify Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Relief (HADR) operations in the flash flood-affected area of Dharali, near Harsil in Uttarakhand, according to an official statement. Over 225 troops, including specialised engineer and medical teams, are on the ground conducting rescue and relief tasks under extremely challenging conditions, the statement said. U.S. tariffs: 'We should also raise it to 50%,' says Shashi Tharoor Congress leader Shashi Tharoor on Thursday (August 7, 2025) said that India should also raise tariffs on American goods to 50% in response to the U.S. imposing an additional 25% tariff on Indian exports. Mr. Tharoor questioned why India should stop at the current 17% tariff and emphasised that the country should not be intimidated by such actions. He also said that no country should be allowed to threaten India in this manner. BJP's only national spokesperson from Northeast resigns Mmhonlumo Kikon, national spokesperson of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), resigned from the primary and active membership of the party on Thursday (August 7, 2025). Mr. Kikon, an ethnic Naga and a former Member of the Legislative Assembly in Nagaland, was the only national spokesperson of the BJP from the Northeast. Pakistan Army chief Munir expected to visit U.S. again: Report Pakistan Army chief Asim Munir is expected to visit the United States this week for consultations with top American officials, his second trip to Washington since the four-day conflict with India, a media report said on Thursday (August 7, 2025). In June, travelled to the U.S. on a rare five-day trip during which he attended a private luncheon with President Donald Trump. That meeting culminated in Trump's announcement of enhanced U.S.-Pakistan cooperation in various fields, including an oil deal. Kerala HC orders interim stay on proceedings in FIR against actor Shwetha Menon Kerala High Court on Thursday (August 7, 2025) stayed the proceedings in connection with the FIR lodged against Malayalam film actor Shwetha Menon for allegedly publishing or transmitting obscene scenes of some of her past movies and advertisements. The interim order was passed by Justice V.G. Arun on a plea moved by the actor to quash the FIR against her. 'Unequal growth post the globalisation boom of the 1990s and 2000s led to the current inward looking trade policies' The increasingly inward-looking attitude of countries around the world didn't happen overnight, and is a result of the unequal growth that emerged from the 'golden' period of globalisation in the 1990s and 2000s, according to Scott Wang, Vice President, Asia Pacific, for the World Trade Centres' Association. Trump-Putin meeting agreed for 'coming days', venue set: Kremlin The Kremlin said Thursday (August 7, 2025) that a summit between U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin was set for the 'coming days', with the two sides already having agreed the venue 'in principle.' The summit would be the first between sitting U.S. and Russian Presidents since Joe Biden met Mr. Putin in Geneva in June 2021, and comes as Mr. Trump seeks to broker an end to Russia's military assault on Ukraine. Shubman Gill to lead North Zone in Duleep Trophy Having enjoyed a stupendous run with the bat on the just-concluded tour of England in his first Test series as India captain, Shubman Gill's next assignment will be as North Zone skipper in the Duleep Trophy starting on August 28 in Bengaluru. In the series against the Englishmen that finished 2-2, Gill was in regal touch, amassing 754 runs at an average of 75.4, including four hundreds.
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Trump calls on Intel CEO to resign: ‘There is no other solution to this problem'
US President Donald Trump on Thursday called for the immediate resignation of Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan, citing alleged ties to China that he claimed pose a national security risk. 'The CEO of INTEL is highly CONFLICTED and must resign, immediately. There is no other solution to this problem. Thank you for your attention to this problem!' Trump wrote on Truth Social. His remarks follow heightened scrutiny from Republican lawmakers, including Senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas, who earlier this week raised alarm over Tan's reported financial involvement in Chinese companies. In a letter to Intel board Chair Frank Yeary, Cotton referenced a Reuters report from April which revealed that Tan, both personally and through venture funds, has invested in hundreds of Chinese firms, including some with links to the Chinese military. 'The new CEO of @intel reportedly has deep ties to the Chinese Communists. US companies who receive government grants should be responsible stewards of taxpayer dollars and adhere to strict security regulations. The board of @Intel owes Congress an explanation,' Cotton posted on X, sharing a copy of his letter. The new CEO of @intel reportedly has deep ties to the Chinese Communists. U.S. companies who receive government grants should be responsible stewards of taxpayer dollars and adhere to strict security regulations. The board of @Intel owes Congress an explanation. — Tom Cotton (@SenTomCotton) August 6, 2025 As per reports by CNN, shares of Intel (INTC) fell nearly 5 per cent in premarket trading.
