Big business beat out independent films. All we have left is an indie vibe.

Boston Globe

4 days ago

On the face of it, the idea that Marvel could make something 'indie' seems ludicrous. Independent films refer to those made outside the Hollywood studio system. Disney, owner of everything from
Toy Story
to Luke Skywalker to
The Simpsons,
is the system. But maybe it's not so simple.
By using the term indie, both A24 and Disney not only appeal to the celluloid-worshiping film bros of today, but are feeding off the nostalgia from a different age in American cinema: When
Stranger Than Paradise
using leftover black-and-white film stock from another movie, or when Robert Rodriguez
El Mariachi
in the early '90s.
Advertisement
'Independent filmmakers,' Quentin Tarantino once said, 'spend all the money they have to make the movie. Money they don't have. ... The movie can be as good as it's gonna be, or as bad as it's gonna be, but it's theirs.'
Faced with no stars and no budget for the kind of spectacles produced by Hollywood, the indie filmmakers of yesteryear focused on telling riskier and more personal stories. Often in art, outsider status evolves into signatures that connect with an audience. But the truth is, we don't really take no-budget films like
Stranger Than Paradise
and put them on the big screen anymore. That world no longer exists.
A24, with a sequence of interesting and genre-defying winners such as
Everything Everywhere All At Once,
has become the heir of that certain kind of auteur-driven filmmaking, giving space to younger directors such as
Hereditary
's Ari Aster to take risks. But A24 itself was
If you want to see a true indie, someone creating what they want with a camera and no money, just pull up any person making day-in-the-life videos for TikTok or YouTube. The latter, of course, is owned by Google, which is now worth $2.1 trillion. All are huge corporations. A filmmaker working today has to pick their poison.
Advertisement
Indeed, audiences have been rushing to
.
But for him to get here, Coogler made his indie debut,
Fruitvale Station,
Black Panther
films for Marvel (which grossed more than $2 billion) and the
Rocky
spinoff
Creed.
It took Coogler more than 10 years of proving his bankability to tell an original, big-budget story not connected to a franchise.
When Disney does work with directors outside the system, it doesn't know what to do with them. They are often reduced to making generic work for hire; think Barry Jenkins going from a James Baldwin adaptation to
The Lion King
prequel
Mufasa: The Lion King,
or Chloé Zhao, from the tender
Nomadland
to Harry Styles cameos in
The Eternals.
The fantastic Argentine director Lucrecia Martel was approached about directing Marvel's
Black Widow,
only to find the studio was seeking another woman to direct the movie's star. 'Don't worry about the action scenes, we will take care of that,' Martel,
later recalled studio representatives telling her. 'I was thinking,
Well I would love to meet Scarlett Johansson but also I would love to make the action sequences.
'
Lost amid debate of what's indie and what isn't are the filmmakers themselves. For those who are still independent, life is harder than ever. Brady Corbet spent seven years raising the $10 million needed to make
The Brutalist.
Only after the hard work was done was the film picked up by A24. Corbet says he
Advertisement
The eventual winner of Best Director this year, Sean Baker for
Anora,
has talked about how he can only make his films because he does not have children or expect to own a home.
So why does he do it? 'Some of us want to make personal films that are intended for theatrical release with subject matter that would never be greenlit by the big studios,'
There, at last, is an honest definition of 'indie.'
Kabir Chibber, a writer and filmmaker who lives in New York, was a 2019 Nieman Fellow at Harvard University. Send comments to [e-mail].