Dáil is expected to pass Bill reforming defamation law this week
A number of government and opposition amendments are to be considered in the Dáil, with Sinn Féin seeking to have the Bill amended to allow the retention of juries in defamation cases.
Abolishing juries in these cases is one of the key provisions of the Bill and is a move long sought by media organisations keen to reduce the cost and length of defamation actions. Juries in personal injury cases were abolished many years ago.
The Bill also introduces protections for media organisations against strategic lawsuits against public participation – or 'Slapps' – which are defamation actions taken by usually rich or powerful individuals designed to intimidate media organisations in their coverage of such people.
READ MORE
The amendments introduce a power for the High Court to award damages against a party which takes a 'Slapp' action against a media outlet.
Having been initiated by the previous government, the Bill was reintroduced to the Dáil order paper in spring and is now expected to passed by the Oireachtas this year.
The Bill also contains measures to reduce legal costs in defamation cases as well as provisions designed to make it less costly for plaintiffs to obtain the identity of people who post defamatory content online.
There is also a new defence for retailers subjected to defamation claims for challenging people on whether they have paid before leaving a shop.
Sinn Féin amendments seeking the retention of juries in defamation cases were previously put during the committee stage of the bill in April, but were rejected by the Government.
When opposition TDs pointed out to the Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan that he had cautioned against the abolition of juries when he was a backbencher in the last government, Mr O'Callaghan said 'one of the consequences of membership of a political party is the need for compromise'.
Mr O'Callaghan said he supported the Fianna Fáil manifesto of the last general election supporting the proposed legislation.
'A programme for government was agreed between the two parties. I am a minister in that government,' he said.
'I am bound, because of the principles of compromise and collective responsibility, to give effect to what was agreed in the programme for government.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
18 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Unity must be part of presidential election debate, says former SDLP leader
The unification of Ireland debate will be a key issue in coming years and must be part of the presidential campaign because the next officeholder could serve for 14 years, former Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) leader Colum Eastwood has declared. The Derry MP has made clear his interest in running in the October election, though an overture to Fianna Fáil leader, Micheál Martin , in June met with a cool response, and no action since by the party. However, Mr Eastwood appears still to believe that a nomination could be secured from four city and county councils in September, perhaps with a signal from Mr Martin to Fianna Fáil councillors to support him. 'We've had a lot of potential candidates and a lot of people talking about how great they would be as individuals, but not a lot of people are talking about their vision for the country,' he told The Irish Times. READ MORE 'The next president could be there for 14 years. We need somebody in post who is prepared to talk about, think about and lead on the issue of bringing the people of Ireland back together again. 'Given how long the term is, potentially if it's two terms, the idea of not having somebody who has thought about that deeply, or is not prepared to lead on it as our president, would be pretty bizarre,' he said. Speaking at the Féile an Phobail festival in west Belfast last weekend, Mr Eastwood said 'the cat is out of the bag' on the constitutional question: 'In my view, the United Kingdom is disintegrating before our very eyes.' [ Irish unification would cost €152m annually to give Northern Irish civil servants pay parity, report says Opens in new window ] The biggest lesson he has learned from his time as an MP in Westminster is that large elements of British political and public opinion 'care if Scotland goes, but they don't care if we go'. 'In fact, if we left in the morning and caused no trouble, they'd be happy enough. I just don't believe that there is anything that can be done by any British government to stop that momentum,' he went on. Saying that he wanted a united Ireland even if it meant he had 'to eat grass', Mr Eastwood accepted that middle ground opinion in Northern Ireland must be convinced that they are not putting their futures at risk by voting for it. 'There is a significant number of people in the middle who are unsure, or undecided, or just curious about it. We need to know who they are, and who they might vote for. We need to know what makes them tick, and what convinces them. 'We need to speak to them relentlessly over a period of years to convince them. If they tell us that they have concerns about pensions, we need to take that concern away by having the answer,' he said. Mr Eastwood, who leads the SDLP's New Ireland Commission, added that unless they looked at 'every single thing that makes them worried or concerned and have an answer for that', they would lose. Meanwhile, the Alliance Party , which declares itself as neutral on the constitutional question will 'not count' in future, even though people who currently vote for it will be central to the outcome of any referendum held, he said. 'I think their voters are the most important people in this conversation. But I think the Alliance Party, if they continue to say they have no position on the future of this island, will not count,' he declared. Political parties 'have to have positions' on the important issues facing society: 'I don't think it's good enough, actually, to say that they are going to decide at some point in the future.'
Extra.ie
3 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Presidency odds don't look good for pharma tycoon Gareth Sheridan
Businessman Gareth Sheridan is in contention for the Irish presidential race, but only just, according to Ladbrokes. The US-based millionaire is leading a charge at the presidency with a spokesperson recently saying he expects at least four county councils to back him to allow him to run. The 35-year-old is a distant 22/1 to end up in the Phoenix Park following the election after making a surprise announcement that he would run. Gareth Sheridan announced his candidacy at the Tullamore Show. Pic: Alf Harvey However, it may be noted that millionaires have not had huge luck in the past with the likes of Peter Casey, Gavin Duffy and Sean Gallagher all having mounted unsuccessful campaigns. Alex Apati of Ladbrokes commented: 'Gareth Sheridan is not a name many would have heard of before, but he certainly seems to back himself and some are starting to believe he may have what it takes to move into Áras an Uachtaráin.' Despite having some potential of running a strong campaign, Sheridan is still ranked outside the top 10 presidential candidates when it comes to the bookmaker's odds. Independent Seanad member Michael McDowell and Dr Mike Ryan of the World Health Organisation are both thought to have a slightly better chance than Sheridan with Ladbrokes setting both of the potential candidates at 20/1. Another Seanad member, Frances Black, is then thought to have a 16/1 chance at the presidency and former Fine Gael politician Heather Humphreys is listed at 14/1. Getting into the top six, Deirdre Heenan is tipped at 12/1. The Derry-based professor has been rumoured to be a possible Fianna Fáil candidate after reports stated she was Micháel Martin's preferred pick due to her political likeness to Mary McAleese. Deirdre Heenan with President Michael D Higgins in 2018. Pic: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland Bertie Ahern is also listed at 12/1. The former Taoiseach has repeatedly been tipped for a run at Áras with a recent opinion poll ranking him ahead of Heenan as Fianna Fáil's preferred candidate. The Lord of the Dance star Michael Flatley is supposedly seen to have a better chance at the presidency than some would have expected. Ladbrokes have listed the American-born celebrity at 8/1. Flatley, who is eligible to run as an Irish citizen, moved to Ireland this month as he does not believe the Irish people 'have a voice – not a true proper deep voice that speaks their language'. Michael Flatley fancies his chances at Áras. Pic: Ken McKay/ITV/REX/Shutterstock Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has been given odds of 6/1 to replace Michael D Higgins. While a campaign has not been confirmed, McDonald didn't rule out a run at Áras when asked by reporters earlier this summer. However, she did previously remove herself from consideration back in March, but that position seems to have changed. An internal process is said to be underway at Sinn Féin, with a decision expected in the near future. Mary Lou McDonald could be Sinn Féin's candidate. Pic: Pool Via Independent TD Catherine Connolly is seen by Ladbrokes as the second-favourite to land the presidential gig. She is listed at 5/2. Connolly launched her bid for Áras last month and has been steadily gaining support from left-leaning parties and TDs She also received the backing of the Social Democrats, People Before Profit, the Labour Party and a number of independents. Catherine Connolly has received plenty of backing. Pic: Eamonn Farrell/ The Galway West TD said she had already received the 20 nominations from Oireachtas members needed to stand in the election. Connolly and the Labour Party have had 'differences' in the past and she left the party in 2007. However, last month Labour formally agreed to back her campaign, adding that they believe she is 'the left' candidate. Finally, at 11/10, the current Ladbrokes favourite to be Ireland's next President is Mairead McGuinness. Mairead McGuinness is Fine Gael's chosen candidate. Pic: Julien Warnand/EPA-EFE/REX/Shutterstock The former EU Commissioner was confirmed to be Fine Gael's chosen candidate in the election after Seán Kelly ruled himself out of contention. McGuinness' candidacy will not be ratified until a party event in early September.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
India Day in Dublin's Phoenix Park postponed following ‘spate of attacks' on community
India Day in Ireland has been postponed following a 'spate of violent attacks' on members of its community in recent months. The co-chairman of the Ireland India Council, Prashant Shukla, said making the decision was 'very difficult' and 'emotional', but that the safety and security of the community was more important. He said the event has been held in Ireland since 2015 and this had never happened before. Hundreds of performers had been preparing for the event at Farmleigh House in the Phoenix Park on Sunday. READ MORE 'We are not too much concerned about the safety at the event, we are more concerned about the perception on social media,' he said adding that they had created a perception that Indians had 'taken over the state' and had caused housing problems. 'So we want to actually balance these counter narratives, they are very very negative. 'We will review the situation and we will announce new dates for India Day this year.' The announcement was made after representatives of the Indian community met with Tánaiste Simon Harris at Government Buildings on Monday. Mr Shukla said he raised their concerns about what he said was 'organised propaganda' online targeting the Indian community in Ireland. [ The Irish Times view on racist attacks: no place for hate on our streets Opens in new window ] He said incidents of violent assaults began after the Dublin riots in November 2023, but had increased significantly since January this year. Mr Shukla said the ministers in the meeting outlined actions they would take in the next two weeks. 'The Dublin riots was actually the first time when these things actually started,' he said. 'But I feel after actually January this year, there's a lot of propaganda going on. So social media accounts created and closed in a few days. 'That gives me the indication that it is some sort of organised agenda, organised propaganda, that is specifically targeted to Indians, because whenever we have the situation, this time only, the Indians are attacked and identified. 'In the past, there was casual violent incidents, that I can understand, they can happen anywhere in the world. But behind there was no such campaign of hate and incitement of the violence.' Attacks against members of the Indian community in Ireland have been highlighted in recent weeks after an Indian man was the victim of an unprovoked attack in Tallaght, Dublin, last month. A silent vigil was held outside the Department of Justice by Friends Of India in response. The Indian embassy in Dublin has also issued a warning that there has been 'an increase in the instances of physical attacks reported against Indian citizens in Ireland recently'. They said Indian citizens in Ireland should take 'reasonable' precautions and avoid deserted areas. Mr Harris said on Sunday that he was 'deeply concerned' about the incidents and that one of the most concerning things was the 'very young age of those that have been involved in some of this racist activity'. The Ireland India Council said it wanted assaults on members of the Indian community to be recognised and recorded as hate crimes, to ensure the offences are 'appropriately recorded and addressed'. It has called for a cross-departmental taskforce on hate crime and youth violence and 'legislative reform' to hold parents more accountable for the actions of their children. It also called for enhanced policing, swift prosecution of offenders, and an outreach programme to affected communities. On Sunday, Minister of State with responsibility for migration Colm Brophy said he wanted the incoming Garda commissioner Justin Kelly to prioritise addressing these incidents. 'We actually have seen a drop in serious crime, but in this particular area, we have seen a rise in the type of attacks,' he told RTÉ Radio. 'I think there needs to be a stronger policing response in this area because there's two aspects to these attacks which I think are very very unacceptable. 'The first is obviously the attack itself, and the second then is the recording and videoing of it and the disseminating of it on social media and there's a role that has to be dealt with there as well.' - PA
