Two Auckland PAK'nSAVE supermarkets plead guilty to breaching Fair Trading Act
PAK'nSAVE supermarkets.
Photo:
RNZ / Alexander Robertson
Two PAK'nSAVE supermarkets have pleaded guilty to breaching the Fair Trading Act.
The Commerce Commission said it filed charges against PAK'nSAVE Silverdale and PAK'nSAVE Mill St in the Auckland District Court.
It said they used inaccurate pricing and misleading specials that might have breached the Fair Trading Act.
PAK'nSAVE Silverdale entered guilty pleas on seven charges and was remanded without plea on three further charges.
PAK'nSAVE Mill Street entered guilty pleas on four charges and was remanded without plea on four further charges.
The maximum penalty for breaches of the Fair Trading Act is $600,000 for a business, per offence.
The Commerce Commission said it could not comment further while the case was before the courts.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Ashburton's Market Day to move after retailer complaints
The Ashburton Market Day has historically closed East Street from Havelock Street down to Moore Street, but the Ashburton District Council has now restricted road closures in that area to outside business hours. Photo: LDR / Ashburton Guardian Market days are no longer welcome on a section of Ashburton's main street during business hours. It means a popular annual market day in September has to move - but only just down road. Retailers had argued the town's main street was no place for a market as the road closures hurt local shops. The Ashburton District Council voted last week to ban events on the block of East Street, south of Havelock Street, if they required road closures. The organiser of Ashburton's annual market day sees the decision as positive. Spealing to LDR this week, Carol Johns said she was already looking to move the market day one block north on East Street, in front of Baring Square East. "I was just waiting for the council to make a decision. "I'm not worried, I'll move and the market day will still go ahead. "Nothing changes, we just move down the road a wee bit. "There are more positives than negatives." The move means Johns will have to pay for a new traffic management plan, but only has to contact three businesses about a road closure, rather than 96. Photo: LDR / Ashburton Guardian Baring Square East had a $2.45 million upgrade in 2023 to coincide with the construction of the $62.3m Te Whare Whakatere, Ashburton's library and civic centre. That investment led to the majority of councillors voting to close the southern end of East Street off to market events during business hours, at a council meeting on 18 June. The annual market day attracts thousands of people to Ashburton. It is held on South Canterbury Anniversary Day, on the fourth Monday of September, which is not an Ashburton District public holiday. When discussing the options last week, councillor Tony Todd said historically the local businesses were heavily involved in the market day, previously known as Boulevard Day, but times have changed. "The event was fully supported by local retailers but over time that support has declined, and other operators have been involved," Todd said. "The day still attracts a large number of people to the CBD that mainly walk the street and the vendor stalls have become a barrier to get into retailers stores. "It's time for a change. "The market day is still important to the town so we should support it, but I think a new location will breathe new life back into it." Another issue is Burnett and Tancred streets becoming one way, which means they also close when East Street is closed, Todd said. Councillor Phill Hooper felt no events should occur south of Havelock Street as the council had invested in making Baring Square an event space. "We spent the moolah out here, let's have it out here," Hooper said. The councillors voted 9-1 for the section of East Street south of Havelock Street to be off limits to events 'involving trade and associated equipment' between 8am-5:30pm, Monday to Saturday. Hooper was the lone opposing vote, supporting the alternative option of no events south of Havelock Street. Compliance and development group manager Ian Hyde said a short closure for an event with no stationary caravans, stalls, tents or other structures could still be permitted.
1News
2 hours ago
- 1News
Two Pak'nSave supermarkets plead guilty to Fair Trading Act breaches
Two Pak'nSave supermarkets have pleaded guilty to breaching the Fair Trading Act. The Commerce Commission said it filed charges against Pak'nSave Silverdale and Pak'nSave Mill St in the Auckland District Court. It said the stores used inaccurate pricing and misleading specials that might have breached the Fair Trading Act. Pak'nSave Silverdale entered guilty pleas on seven charges and was remanded without plea on three further charges. Pak'nSave Mill St entered guilty pleas on four charges and was remanded without plea on four further charges. ADVERTISEMENT The maximum penalty for breaches of the Fair Trading Act is $600,000 for a business, per offence. The Commerce Commission said it could not comment further while the case was before the courts. Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy said he was pleased to see the issue getting traction. "Consumers deserve clear, honest information when making purchasing decisions. Misleading pricing not only erodes trust, but it also unfairly disadvantages shoppers amidst an ongoing cost of living crisis," he said. "We urge all supermarkets and retailers to take this as a wake-up call: Misleading promotions and systemic pricing are unacceptable." Duffy said Consumer NZ would continue to monitor the supermarket sector closely. He said work was being done to "sort out supermarkets" as two-thirds of shoppers reported regularly noticing pricing errors. "We understand that more investigations are underway, and we really hope to see meaningful action as a result of our complaint and the commission's work." ADVERTISEMENT
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Florist told to stop the music: 'No one out front can hear it'
Francie Croy says she normally listens to talkback radio on her phone in the backroom of her flower shop, but Onemusic says she still needs to pay. Photo: 123rf A Hawkes Bay florist has had her music listening habits nipped in the bud, after a licensing organisation told her to turn the tunes off at the shop or buy a licence. Francie Croy listens to the tunes on her phone while she works at her Waipukurau store, but was contacted by Onemusic, which issues licences for certain music to be played in a commercial setting for a fee, so artists get their royalties. That includes music played while people are on hold on the phone, at a hairdressing salon, music radio in the background at the office or thumping tunes on the factory floor - there is a cost to anything outside of personal use. The E-Central Flowers owner told Checkpoint that she received a phone call from OneMusic, after failing to respond to an email from the company. "This girl just started to say to me, 'do you play music in your shop?', and I said it's not very often, and she said 'whatever music you play, you're gonna have to have a licence for it'. " When Croy asked what the cost of the licence would be, she was told it would depend on the square footage of her shop. "I thought, well, hang on a minute love, you're in Auckland, are you going to send someone down here to measure up my shop and then charge me the appropriate licence?" Croy said it was rare for her to play music in the store, normally only listening to talkback radio on her phone, mostly in the backroom. "No one out front of the shop can hear it, but she said to me that I would still have a licence to have to do that because sometimes Newstalk ZB plays music." She said after the phone call she was sent another email from OneMusic. "It was a certificate thing, saying this is confirmation that you have advised us that you do not play music in your business and will not play music represented by this place. "It includes television, radio stations, apps, digital music services, Spotify, Apple, YouTube, CD's, DVD's, Blu-ray, vinyl and cassette tapes, and the list goes on." Croy said she had no idea that being charged for playing music at her business was even a possibility. "It's just on my phone, you know, it's just out the back... I just got such a surprise." She said she had spoken to multiple other small businesses in the same area who had received the same message from OneMusic. The Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment said OneMusic licensed copyright works and MBIE did not have oversight of the scheme. It said businesses that play music for their staff and/or customers need a licence and the licensing fees paid are distributed to producers and recording artists. "If a business does not wish to pay any licensing fee to play music, they should not play music. To do so without a licence means the copyright owner may sue the business and award damages. "A business who wishes to dispute the terms and conditions of the scheme may make an application to the Copyright Tribunal. If the Tribunal determines that the licensing scheme is unfair it may order changes," it said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
