Foreign debt inflows
In this context, it is relevant to note that in spite of a recent upgrade by one of the three international rating agencies, a rating guided by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) which noted in the first review documents of the ongoing Extended Fund Facility dated May 2025 that external and internal risks would 'quickly eviscerate Pakistan's hard won economic stability' one may safely assume that the interest rate agreed would be higher than the market rate and, additionally, given that commercial banks typically lend for short periods the principal due may have to be factored in as repayment in the current year's reserves. In other words, the actual debt servicing for 2025-26 may already be lower than what was budgeted for the year.
The budgeted amount under Naya Pakistan Certificate was 464.9 million US dollars, and it reached a high of 1,918 million US dollars July-June 2025 which accounted for market borrowing inflows, including commercial borrowings, of 5439.34 million US dollars, higher than the budgeted 5049.26 million US dollars — a rise in spite of one billion US dollars budgeted bonds not issued, due perhaps to lack of market interest.
Time deposits cited in the statistics were 9 billion US dollars — budgeted though the corresponding disbursed column (provisional) has not been filled but the total bilateral and multilateral inflows of 5,439.34 million US dollars plus 4,297.83 million US dollars foreign commercial bank borrowings plus 1,918.06 million US dollars from Naya Pakistan Certificate gives a grand total of 11,655.23 million US dollars, which requires a clarification from EAD as to how it reached a total of 12,138.24 million US dollars as adding on the time deposit would give a grand total of 20,655 million US dollars — higher than the budgeted 19,393 million US dollars.
The EAD does not factor in the IMF disbursements; however, two observations are critical. First and foremost, the capacity of the administration to secure commercial loans from abroad has no doubt been strengthened due to the country being on an IMF programme; however, budgetary support amounted to 8,602.96 million US dollars (provisional) last year and yet this was only 54 percent of the budgeted amount of 15,965.94 million US dollars. One would hope that the government had instead opted to slash its major current expenditure components, some of which required reforms like the pension budget while others required sacrifice (salary budget of the 7 percent employed by the government). And secondly, the shortfall was filled by a rise in domestic borrowing that was accommodated by the 10 percent decline in the discount rate that led to a decline in mark-up on domestic debt by about 830 billion rupees.
To conclude, there is little evidence of the country moving towards ending the toxic tendency to borrow from abroad to meet the budgeted outlay as repeatedly stated by the Prime Minister and one can only hope that in the current year the budgeted current expenditure is slashed, which is not attributable to a lower discount rate but to actual savings by improving governance.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
17 minutes ago
- Express Tribune
SBP bought $7.2b from Jun'24-Apr'25
Listen to article The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) purchased $7.2 billion from the inter-bank market between June 2024 and April 2025, according to data compiled by Taurus Securities Limited. This substantial intervention reflects the central bank's strategy to rebuild foreign exchange reserves and ensure macroeconomic stability amid an International Monetary Fund (IMF)-supported economic reform programme. The monthly data shows strong buying in late 2024, peaking in November with $1.15 billion, followed by $1.02 billion in October and $946 million in September. Activity eased in early 2025, with only $154 million in January, $223 million in February, a rebound to $860 million in March, and a drop to $473 million in April. This accumulation of dollars helped SBP reserves rise from $13.5 billion in June 2024 to nearly $16.5 billion in November 2024. However, reserves started falling from December and settled at around $14.5 billion by April 2025, likely due to debt repayments or weaker net financial inflows. The business community has raised serious concerns over the exchange rate, alleging that the rupee is being held at an artificially strong level. SBP remains the largest dollar buyer, keeping demand high and the rupee undervalued. Rising imports and declining exports have worsened the imbalance. The Pakistan Business Forum (PBF) claimed that the dollar's actual market value should be closer to Rs260, while it is currently around Rs283. "The dollar is being controlled through artificial means. The prime minister must take immediate notice," the Forum said in a statement. PBF Chief Organiser Ahmad Jawad said Pakistan's policies have historically failed to restore the rupee after depreciation. "Unfortunately, whenever the rupee has fallen, it has never been brought back to its previous strength," he noted. He warned the economy cannot operate sustainably at Rs283 per dollar, warning that meaningful relief will only be possible through a stronger rupee. Meanwhile, the rupee appreciated by Rs1.92 against the US dollar over the last five trading sessions. It closed at Rs283.05 on July 29, compared t to 283.21 on July 28, a 0.06% gain, according to SBP data compiled by AKD Research. Gold prices in Pakistan also declined on Tuesday, tracking a cautious tone in the international market as investors awaited key developments, including US-China trade talks and the upcoming US Federal Reserve policy decision. According to the All-Pakistan Gems and Jewellers Sarafa Association (APGJSA), per tola gold fell by Rs1,600 to Rs354,700, while 10-gram gold dropped by Rs1,372 to Rs304,098. The decline followed a Rs100 fall on Monday. Global prices remained steady with traders adopting a wait-and-see approach ahead of major economic signals that could influence monetary policy and global risk sentiment.
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
IMF puts growth below govt target
Listen to article The International Monetary Fund (IMF) on Tuesday projected Pakistan's economic growth rate at 3.6% for the current fiscal year, below the government's official target of 4.2%. The projection was released in the IMF's latest World Economic Outlook Update report which kept Pakistan's growth forecast unchanged. The government had set a higher growth goal based on expected recovery in agriculture and industrial sectors. However, the World Bank recently estimated that poverty in Pakistan affects nearly 45% of the population. Official data on poverty and unemployment is currently unavailable, though the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) is said to be updating relevant surveys. Due to outdated data, the provisional GDP growth rate of 2.7% for FY2024-25 has been disputed by independent economists. The PBS plans to release findings of the latest Agriculture Census next month, which may address some of these queries. On the same day, the federal government also briefed foreign diplomats on recent economic developments and sought support to increase foreign direct investment (FDI), which remains low. The diplomats raised concerns over rising debt costs, heavy reliance on costly commercial loans, tax relief measures, and the sustainability of the Power Division's plan to cut circular debt through Rs1.25 trillion in fresh domestic borrowing. Finance Minister of State Bilal Azhar Kayani and Power Minister Sardar Awais Ahmad Khan Leghari led the briefing for diplomats from the US, UK, EU, Italy, Germany, Canada, Australia, Switzerland, Japan, the Netherlands, and Saudi Arabia. According to a finance ministry press release, officials outlined reforms in taxation and the power sector. Kayani said Pakistan's macroeconomic strategy had shifted from stabilisation to sustained reform. He noted that GDP growth was 2.7% in FY2024-25, and per capita income increased by 10% to $1,824. However, this was based on old and relatively low population estimates. The finance ministry claimed a 3.1% primary surplus in GDP, the highest in 20 years, though it did not clarify in the press note whether this was for the full year or only the first 11 months. Inflation dropped to 4.5%, a nine-year low, while the central bank's policy rate was halved from 22% to 11%. The debt-to-GDP ratio also reportedly declined to 69%, indicating improved fiscal management. Diplomats asked how the government planned to reduce the high cost of external debt. Officials said that the strategy had already been finalised with both the IMF and the World Bank. The finance ministry said the external sector showed resilience, recording a $2.1 billion current account surplus, the first in 14 years and the highest in 22 years. This was supported by strong remittances, higher exports, rising FDI, and stable foreign reserves of over $14.5 billion. Officials claimed this performance was achieved without heavy reliance on foreign borrowing. However, the central bank purchased at least $7.3 billion from the local market between July and April, which kept the rupee artificially low. This sum exceeded the entire three-year size of the IMF bailout package. Diplomats were also told that two credit rating agencies had recently given Pakistan positive reviews, and Moody's is expected to upgrade the country soon. S&P upgraded Pakistan to 'B negative' last week, advising further political and security stability for continued progress. In the energy sector, Leghari told diplomats that significant milestones had been achieved, although questions remained over their long-term sustainability. He said the circular debt, now around Rs2.4 trillion, was being addressed under a plan agreed with the IMF. The government has secured Rs1.25 trillion in commercial loans to pay down a large portion of this debt. The repayment will be funded through a Rs3.24 per unit electricity surcharge, ultimately borne by consumers. Diplomats questioned whether this approach was sustainable. Leghari acknowledged structural problems such as high tariffs and inefficient pricing, which had made electricity unaffordable for households and industry. These issues had also created fiscal pressures. To address them, the government has undertaken broad-based reforms centred on tariff rationalisation, fiscal responsibility and operational improvement. Leghari said progress had been made in stabilising circular debt in FY2025. He also pointed out the need to modernise energy planning to account for seasonal demand shifts, regional supply gaps, and the rising role of distributed generation. Distribution company performance was another key focus. Leghari said infrastructure upgrades and strengthened governance were underway to reduce losses, with reforms implemented to ensure regional equity and institutional coordination. He called on foreign governments and global investors to invest in the energy sector, citing $2-3 billion in potential across grid modernisation, renewable energy, distribution efficiency, and energy services. He also noted that the government aims to privatise electricity distribution companies, with three companies being restructured for privatisation by early 2026. Chairman FBR, Rashid Langrial, briefed diplomats on the FBR Transformation Plan, built on three pillars: people, process, and technology. He claimed that real tax collection had increased by 46% due to improved compliance and enforcement. He also stated that the tax-to-GDP ratio rose to 10.24% in FY2025, up from 8.8% in FY2024. However, Pakistan still missed its IMF revenue target by 0.3% of GDP, despite levying record-high taxes last year.
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Iron ore stays above $100/t amid Sino-US trade talks
BEIJING: Iron ore futures prices held well over the key psychological level of $100 a metric ton on Tuesday, while investors closely monitored the renewed Sino-US trade talks for signs of progress. The benchmark September iron ore on the Singapore Exchange was 0.61% higher at $101.4 a ton, as of 0205 GMT. The most-traded September iron ore contract on China's Dalian Commodity Exchange (DCE) traded 0.57% lower at 788.5 yuan ($109.86) a ton. Talks between top US and Chinese officials in Stockholm, who met on Monday, are expected to continue on Tuesday to resolve longstanding economic disputes between the world's top two economies. Although the two superpowers have no deep ties in terms of direct trade in steel and its feedstock iron ore, trade frictions could blur demand outlook in top consumer China, said analysts. Underpinning prices of the key steel feedstock were also falling iron ore arrivals, with those at the major ports slipping by 7.6% week-on-week to 23.2 million tons in the week as of July 27, data from consultancy Mysteel showed. 'Fundamentals of iron ore are relatively healthy amid falling arrivals and resilient hot metal output, supporting prices,' analysts at Shengda Futures said in a note. Markets also awaited details of a Chinese Politburo meeting by July-end that is expected to set the country's economic policy for the rest of the year. Prices of coking coal and coke, also steelmaking ingredients, extended their slump for a second straight session, falling 11.54% and 4.83%, respectively. Both had surged in the past week, fueled by the anticipation of a potential supply cut after the government planned to inspect mines at eight key coal production hubs to check for excess production. Most steel benchmarks on the Shanghai Futures Exchange subsided. Rebar dipped 0.67%, hot-rolled coil fell 0.47%, stainless steel lost 0.62%, while wire rod added 0.63%.
