Watchdog may compel Peter McVerry Trust to come before it amid growing anger over finances
The Dáil's most powerful public spending watchdog will consider compelling the
Peter McVerry Trust
(PMVT) to appear before it to answer questions about its
€15 million State bailout
.
Sinn Féin
TD John Brady, who is chair of the
Public Accounts Committee
(PAC), expressed 'dissatisfaction and anger' towards the housing charity which has now twice refused to appear before the committee.
Mr Brady said the PAC would now consider 'what options are open to us at this point', which could include compelling the trust to appear.
At a meeting in public session on Thursday morning, a number of cross-party TDs expressed anger at the PMT for refusing to answer questions about its financial troubles. It came after serious governance failings by the trust came to light in investigations by two State regulators.
READ MORE
The trust has so far failed to file its company accounts for 2023.
In early 2024, it told the PAC it could not appear before it due to ongoing investigations.
In a letter to the PAC this week,
the trust again refused to make itself available
for public questioning, claiming it was not in a position to attend 'at this time'.
'There's a real level of dissatisfaction and anger here by members, and I include myself in that,' Mr Brady said.
He added that he was also aware of attempts over the last year by the Oireachtas housing committee to invite PMVT to appear before it. Mr Brady said the trust had received 'huge' sums of public funding and 'there needs to be accountability'.
'I propose that we write immediately to PMVT imploring them to come in at the earliest opportunity,' Mr Brady said.
He said PAC will be seeking guidance from the Oireachtas standing orders committee to see what options it had to expand its remit and bring PMVT before it.
'It is deeply unsatisfactory and disheartening, as members said, when an organisation such as PMVT does not actually take cognisance of the last word in that – trust,' he said.
'Public trust is foremost here and people cannot have trust in how public money is being spent and the governance around that. I think that is deeply concerning.'
PMVT said in a statement: 'At this time, PMVT is not in a position to take part in the committee's meeting. We are currently awaiting the completion of our audited financial statements for the year ended December 31st, 2023.
'Once these audited accounts are available, they will be published and we will share relevant information with our stakeholders and the public as appropriate, including making representatives available for the appropriate Oireachtas committee in due course.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Paul Coulson offered $250m to walk away from Ardagh amid crunch debt talks
Businessman Paul Coulson has been offered $250 million (€218 million) by bondholders in Ardagh Group to walk away from the packaging empire he built over the past 25 years, as debt restructuring talks enter a crunch phase. The offer would see Mr Coulson cede control of the glass and metal containers giant, which has about $12.5 billion of borrowings, and abandon previous notions of retaining control of its prized Ardagh Metal Packaging (AMP) arm, the sources said. The proposal is one of a number of potential debt solutions under discussion in parallel with the company, a source said. All involve substantially addressing about $2.5 billion of bonds that fall due in August 2026 and would involve the injection of new money into the business, the source added. Bloomberg first reported the offer for Mr Coulson to hand over entire control of Ardagh Group to certain bondholders, indicating it is the most likely outcome even as a number of alternatives remain in play. READ MORE Under the proposal, unsecured creditors would take a majority stake in the group after the overhaul, Bloomberg reported. Secured creditors would have their debt reinstated at par, and receive a double-digit coupon, it said. A spokesman for Ardagh Group declined to comment on the current state of talks. [ Ardagh talks with creditor group break down over improving cans unit Opens in new window ] The development comes weeks after Ardagh Group walked away from talks with unsecured bondholders, who were being asked by the group to write off much of the $2.32 billion they are owed in exchange for taking full ownership of the glass containers part of the business. Mr Coulson had envisaged Ardagh Group spinning its shares the valuable AMP division into a new company (NewCo) that would be 80 per cent owned by Mr Coulson and other existing Ardagh Group shareholders. He proposed that unsecured creditors would only receive 20 per cent of the division. Ardagh Group currently owns 76 per cent of New York-listed AMP. Bobby Healy on why Manna drone delivery could be the 'biggest technology company in the world for its space' Listen | 67:08 Ardagh Group, which Mr Coulson built into one of the world's largest packaging companies through a series of debt-fuelled acquisitions, said more than a year ago that it was considering options to lower its $12.5 billion debt pile. The burden had become increasingly unsustainable in recent years amid weaker-than-expected earnings. Talks with the senior unsecured creditors became more complicated when Ardagh Group said in April that the beverage cans unit had turned a corner', helped by a rebound in activity across the energy drinks, sparkling water and health and wellness categories. [ Ardagh enlists restructuring experts to board as it looks to cut €12bn debt Opens in new window ] AMP reported its revenues grew by 11 per cent year-on-year in the first quarter to $1.27 billion and upgraded its full-year earnings forecast. However, Ardagh Group's legacy glass business saw its revenues drop 6.7 per cent to $961 million during the quarter as this arm of the group continued to struggle. Meanwhile, holders of some $1.8 billion of risky bonds issued by a holding company above the operating Ardagh Group are expected to lose almost all of what they are owed. These bonds are currently trading at about 4 per cent of their original value. Mr Coulson controls Ardagh Group through an 18.8 per cent direct stake in its ultimate parent company and a 52.4 per cent interest in a vehicle called Yeoman Capital, which owns 33.9 per cent of the group. He effectively owns 36.6 per cent of the equity in a business that traces its roots to the Irish Glass Bottle Company, founded in Dublin in 1932.


Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
EU's failure to propose ways to cut trade with illegal Israeli settlements criticised by nine foreign ministers
The European Commission's failure to bring forward proposals to 'discontinue' trade between the EU and illegal Israeli settlements in Occupied Palestinian Territories has been criticised by Spain, Ireland and seven other member states. The nine foreign ministers, in a joint letter seen by The Irish Times, take aim at the slow progress in cutting off indirect economic support for Israeli settlements in the West Bank and other Palestinian territory. They say firmer action is needed from the EU in response to findings of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) last year, that Israel's occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem was unlawful . In their June 16th letter, the ministers say the ICJ opinion put greater obligations on governments to make sure they were not entrenching the illegal settlements through trade links or other ties. READ MORE They criticised the commission, the EU's executive arm, which sets trade policy, for not doing enough in response to the court's decision. 'We have not seen a proposal to initiate discussions on how to effectively discontinue trade of goods and services with the illegal settlements,' the letter states. The nine ministers call for the commission to carry out an 'in-depth analysis' into the implications the ICJ opinion had for other governments' relations with Israel. The letter was signed by the foreign ministers of Belgium, Spain, Ireland, Finland, Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia and Sweden. It was sent to commission president Ursula von der Leyen , EU foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas and EU trade commissioner Maroš Šefčovič. 'We are committed to respect, and where relevant, implementing the conclusions put forward by the [ICJ] in its advisory opinion on the legal consequences arising from the policies and practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory,' the letter says. [ EU should consider ending visa-free travel for Israeli settlers, academics say Opens in new window ] Several governments are to push for Israel to be penalised for its conduct during its 20-month invasion of the Gaza Strip , when the 27 EU foreign ministers meet in Brussels on Monday. A review into whether Israel's war in Gaza has breached human rights commitments it made in a free-trade agreement with the EU will be presented to ministers at the meeting. Some ministers are expected to call for action to be taken against Israel, to pressure the Israeli government to stop choking off the flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza, where aid agencies continue to warn the civilian population still lacks food, fuel and medicine. More than 55,000 Palestinians have been killed during Israel's military campaign in Gaza, which began after the deadly Hamas attacks of October 7th, 2023. While a growing number of EU states have been advocating for the EU to take a stronger stance against Israel, others, such as Hungary, Germany and Czechia, have pushed back in support of Israel.


Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
European shares hit one-month low amid rising Middle East tensions
Escalating tensions in the and fears over potential US involvement in the region led to European shares falling to its lowest point since early May. S&P 500 futures fell 0.5 per cent despite US markets remaining closed on Thursday for a public holiday. DUBLIN The Iseq All-Share index ended the session down 1.96 per cent to 11,172.87, with losses led by Kenmare Resources. READ MORE Kenmare Resources fell 21.12 per cent to €3.66 following news it had walked away from takeover talks with its former managing director Michael Carvill and an Abu Dhabi private equity firm. The consortium made it clear it would only be willing to proceed with a bid that was below its initial £473 million (€553 million) proposal. Shares in the titanium minerals miner returned to near the levels the stock was trading at before news of the bid. Middle East uncertainty saw most Dublin-listed stocks close in the red, with just Irish Ferries owner Irish Continental Group, up 0.37 per cent, and Agriculture group Origin Enterprises, up 0.82 per cent, improving on the day. Gains made on Wednesday by airliner Ryanair on the back of a drop in oil prices were wiped out, and the share 2.63 per cent to €22.97 on Thursday as oil prices rose. In banking stocks, AIB fell 1.91 per cent to €6.70, and Bank of Ireland tumbled 2.40 per cent to €11.61. LONDON The FTSE 100 closed lower on Thursday amid ongoing Middle East concerns, after the Bank of England left interest rates unchanged at 4.25 per cent and policymakers said trade policy uncertainty would continue to hurt the economy, triggering a drop in the pound. The FTSE 100 index closed down 0.6 per cent at 8,791.80, with the mid-cap FTSE 250 ending down 1.0 per cent, at 21,073.99. Oil rose again amid concerns the situation in the Middle East could worsen. That boosted oil majors and FTSE 100 heavyweights BP and Shell, which rose 1.4 per cent and 1.1 per cent respectively. British Airways owner IAG, however, fell 3.2 per cent and low-cost airline EasyJet, was down 3 per cent at close, on concerns of rising fuel costs and travel disruption. Similarly, fears that the Middle East conflict will lead to higher inflation and slower economic growth weighed on mining stocks. Anglo American fell 3.3 per cent, Antofagasta declined 3.4 per cent and Rio Tinto dipped 2.5 per cent. Whitbread fell 1.6 per cent after reporting total group sales fell by 3.8 per cent in its first quarter. On the FTSE 250, Hays plunged 10 per cent after saying it expects annual profit to be below market consensus, as the staffing firm grapples with challenging market conditions. Shares fell in other recruitment businesses, PageGroup, down 8.8 per cent, and Robert Walters, which dropped 4.8 per cent. European recruiting shared similarly fell. EUROPE The pan-European Stoxx 600 closed down for the third consecutive day with a 0.8 per cent drop to its lowest level since May 9. US President Donald Trump kept markets guessing about American involvement in air strikes on Tehran, though markets were hopeful of potential de-escalation of tensions over upcoming EU and US talks with Iran. Much of the recent nervousness has been in markets centred around crude oil supply shocks, triggered by tensions in the oil-rich Middle East. Oil prices rose on the day and boosted the energy sector by 0.8 per cent, emerging as the session's top performer. Healthcare and utilities were the only other sectors in the green. Conversely, travel and leisure stocks led broader declines and finished 2.3 per cent lower, taking a hit from the soaring oil prices. Among stocks, Stora Enso jumped 14.7 per cent to top the Stoxx 600 after the Finnish forestry group said it was initiating a strategic review of its Swedish forest assets. – Additional reporting, Reuters, PA.