Israel's National Anthem Back In Focus, Internet Can't Unhear Its Likeness To This Bollywood Song
Last Updated:
Many social media users questioned whether one borrowed from the other- or whether the resemblance is purely coincidental.
Social media users believe that there is a striking similarity between Israel's national anthem Hatikvah and the 1996 Bollywood patriotic song Mera Mulk Mera Desh, composed by Anu Malik for the film Diljale- and they are not wrong. Sharing side-by-side audio clips of the two tracks, many users on X (formerly Twitter) questioned whether one borrowed from the other- or whether the resemblance is purely coincidental.
The online debate quickly spiraled into memes as users reacted with a mix of sarcasm and frustration. 'This too? Is anything original?" one wrote while another quipped, 'Anu Malik's Spotify is just international radio with a filter." Several posts resurfaced old clips comparing Anu Malik's work to other global hits, turning the anthem controversy into a moment of deja vu.
While accusations of plagiarism have been aimed at Anu Malik in the past, this particular case is more complicated than it appears. The melody of Hatikvah was adapted in 1887 by Samuel Cohen, who drew inspiration from La Mantovana, a 16th-century Italian folk tune composed by Giuseppe Cenci. The anthem was officially adopted by Israel in 1948.
Anu Malik's composition, which features vocals by Kumar Sanu, appears to echo the same musical structure. This isn't the first time the similarity has drawn attention. In 2023, Naor Gilon, former Israel's ambassador to India, shared an audio clip of Mera Mulk Mera Desh on social media, alongside the flags of both nations. In his post, Naor Gilon noted the uncanny melodic resemblance to Hatikvah, writing that the Indian song had deeply moved him and that its lyrics resonated 'like a beacon of hope and unity."
Anu Malik has previously faced criticism for several songs that closely mirrored international hits- from Wham!'s Last Christmas and Linear's Sending All My Love to Toto Cutugno's L'Italiano.
In the case of Mera Mulk Mera Desh, however, the accusation of plagiarism seems less clear-cut. Both songs appear to draw from the same source- La Mantovana- a melody that has travelled across continents, adapted into classical music, folk traditions and national anthems.
First Published:
June 18, 2025, 21:04 IST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
Host An Italian Soiree With This Menu Complete With Cocktails, Wholesome Mains And Dreamy Desserts
In a rush? Can't cook? Italian food speaks to the soul. With core ingredients like fresh tomatoes, cheese, olive oil, garlic, and basil, it is wholesome, comforting, and full of flavour. The breads are warm, freshly baked, and melt in the mouth with every bite. All we need is some good weather and a cocktail in hand to celebrate Italian food and cry out "Mamma mia!"-with our hearts full of joy and our tummies full of food. If you love Italian cuisine as much as we do, it's a great idea to throw an all-Italian dinner party the next time you host friends or family at home. From freshly baked pizza with gooey cheese to creamy tiramisu soaked in coffee, this dinner menu will leave your guests delighted. From drinks to appetisers, mains and desserts, we have compiled a delicious all-Italian menu for your party. You can prepare these at home if you are in the mood for cooking, or simply order online from your favourite cafe or restaurant using a food delivery app. What's At Our Italian Bar Negroni Negroni is the classic three-ingredient Italian cocktail, made of equal parts gin, sweet vermouth, and Campari. It is typically served on the rocks and garnished with an orange peel. The taste is bold, bitter and citrus. Here's how to make it at home. In a rush? Can't cook? Aperol Spritz This is another popular Italian wine-based cocktail, consisting of Prosecco, soda water, and a flavouring ingredient, which in this case is Aperol. This light and refreshing cocktail is perfect for pre-dinner socialising and relaxation. Learn how to make this drink at your home bar. Appetisers For Munching And Gossiping Bruschetta Bruschetta (pronounced bru'sketta, and not bru' shetta) is the perfect appetiser for your hungry guests. It consists of sourdough bread which is grilled, rubbed with garlic and then topped with fresh tomato and basil. You can also add cured meat or smoked seafood for non-vegetarian guests. Caprese Salad Sometimes, simplicity is the best kind of elegance. Caprese salad is just that, made with fresh mozzarella, juicy tomatoes, basil leaves, olive oil and a touch of balsamic glaze. This vibrant dish brings the colours of the Italian flag to your plate and is best enjoyed cold with a chilled drink. Antipasto Platter An Italian dinner party is incomplete without an antipasto platter. This Italian charcuterie platter has marinated olives, artichokes, roasted red peppers, assorted cheeses, Italian cold cuts like salami and prosciutto, and crunchy Italian breadsticks. This board is perfect to get the guests nibbling and chatting before the main course hits the table. Mains For Full Hearts And Full Tummies Pizza Of course, we are keeping everybody's favourite dish - pizza - on the menu. You can choose a classic fresh Margherita pizza featuring mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce. For the best experience, you can order it online from an authentic pizza place. Alternatively, you can also create a DIY pizza bar where guests can choose their own toppings and then pop the pizza in the oven. Pasta Pasta is hearty and delicious, with so many incredible sauces and shapes to choose from. To create a nice variety, you can order different kinds of pasta in small quantities so that everyone can enjoy Italian food to its fullest. Risotto Creamy, rich, and oh-so-satisfying, risotto is an Italian rice dish cooked with broth. A mushroom risotto with hints of garlic and thyme is a delicious choice for an elegant Italian dinner. There's Always Room For Dessert(s) Tiramisu Tiramisu is the crown jewel of Italian desserts. All your foodie guests will eagerly wait for the tiramisu to be served. It consists of delicious layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream dusted with cocoa powder. It's creamy, dreamy, and just the right amount of sweet. Click here for the recipe. Panna Cotta Light, silky and delicately flavoured, panna cotta is a no-bake Italian dessert that's elegant and delicious. Serve it with a berry compote or drizzle some caramel on top. It's the best way to end a delicious meal. Hosting an Italian dinner party is less about perfection and more about heart. With this incredible menu, you can pull off a fabulous get-together with the best food and great vibes. Have a great time!
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Shah Rukh Khan not in Jailer 2: New Bollywood star joins cast; Rajinikanth returns for high-octane sequel
Shah Rukh Khan Months of speculation suggested that Shah Rukh Khan might make a surprise appearance in Jailer 2, the sequel to Rajinikanth's 2023 blockbuster. But the suspense has now ended — the superstar will not be joining the action this time. According to a post by Box Office South India on X (formerly Twitter), SRK is officially not part of the project, despite earlier discussions. While that may disappoint some fans, there's still a massive surprise in store. A new Bollywood A-lister is set to join the cast Even though Shah Rukh Khan won't be appearing, the buzz around Jailer 2 remains strong. As per a report by News18, the producers are set to cast a major Bollywood star in a pivotal role. Though the name hasn't been revealed yet, an official announcement is expected soon. The secret casting move is aimed at adding more star power to a film already packed with big names. Directed by Nelson Dilipkumar, Jailer 2 picks up immediately after the explosive events of the first film. Rajinikanth reprises his role as Tiger Muthuvel Pandian, the fierce and unforgettable former jail warden. The original film blended a clever heist narrative with themes of revenge, featuring surprise cameos by stars like Mohanlal, Shiva Rajkumar, and Jackie Shroff — all of whom are expected to return for the sequel. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo New additions, new villains? Reports suggest that Telugu cinema legends may also join the sequel. Nandamuri Balakrishna is reportedly set to make a guest appearance, while Nagarjuna Akkineni has been approached to play the main antagonist. However, these casting details are still under discussion and have not been officially confirmed. In parallel, Rajinikanth is in the final stages of shooting Coolie, his much-anticipated collaboration with director Lokesh Kanagaraj. The film, set to release on August 14, 2025, features a star-studded ensemble including Nagarjuna, Upendra Rao, and even a special cameo by Aamir Khan. Shruti Haasan and Soubin Shahir also star, with Pooja Hegde delivering a sizzling dance number. While Shah Rukh Khan may have stepped away from Jailer 2, the film continues to make headlines with its bold casting choices and the promise of another action-packed ride — led once again by the ever-electrifying Rajinikanth.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Athiya Shetty turns cheerleader for husband KL Rahul ahead of his test series against England
Athiya Shetty and KL Rahul Athiya Shetty is in the news not for the release of a film or a red carpet event but for a discreet, warm tribute to husband KL Rahul on the eve of India's Test series against England. While walking through the colorful streets of Leeds, Athiya noticed something she could not help but see Rahul's huge poster for a clothing brand, an upscale Italian fashion house he recently reps worldwide. Sharing the moment on Instagram, she captioned it with a wave emoji and a hearts-in-eyes reaction, best capturing a mix of love and pride. According to Sportskeeda, Rahul's poster is a global campaign for the clothing brand and Rahul becomes the brand's first Indian ambassador. Dressed in a fresh cream ensemble, Rahul combines fashion with height, a style that suits Athiya's fashion-conscious personality too. The timing of Athiya's post could not be more apt, coming just days ahead of the opening Test against England at Headingley. Her narrative has since made waves online, fueling pre-match anticipation. From new mom to cricket cheerleader – Athiya's first outing with Evaarah This trip to the UK also comes as one of Athiya's earliest public appearances since adopting motherhood. On March 24, 2025, she and KL Rahul shared the news of their daughter, Evaarah which is a Sanskrit word that means "Gift of God." The couple's peaceful introduction to their baby girl was a sweet celebration of this new addition, and now Athiya is also showing up for her husband just as elegantly as a wife and a proud parent. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo On the other hand, Rahul is appearing to be in good nick as he gets ready to steady India's middle order. Having scored 116 and 51 on tour against the England Lions in warm-up games, he's taken his IPL form to red-ball cricket. With 955 runs and three centuries against England in Tests, Rahul's exposure will be vital for India in this five-match series. As Sportskeeda pointed out, his recent performances are an indication that he's ready and with Athiya and baby Evaarah at his side in England, he's also got the emotional fuel to go the distance.
