BYD shares extend losses as price cuts throw spotlight on sales
[HONG KONG] BYD shares extended losses in Hong Kong trading on Tuesday (May 27) – taking their two-day slide to more than 10 per cent – as last week's sweeping price cuts stoked concern of another wave of discounting in China's cutthroat electric car market.
The stock fell as much as 4 per cent in morning trading, following Monday's 8.6 per cent drop. The sell-off was sparked after the electric vehicle giant announced cuts of as much as 34 per cent on 22 electric and plug-in hybrid models in China until the end of June.
The move came after the company last month posted its slowest year-on-year growth in vehicle deliveries in more than four years. While April sales rose 21 per cent from a year earlier, that was the smallest monthly gain since August 2020, except for a drop in deliveries in February last year, when the Chinese New Year holiday saw nationwide industry sales contract 22 per cent.
Rival Geely Automobile Holdings's compact hatchback Xingyuan last month became the top-selling model in China, overtaking BYD's popular Seagull, according to data from the China Automotive Technology and Research Center.
Morgan Stanley analysts said the price competition sparked by BYD is likely to drag on, with ripple effects into the second half of the year.
The steep price cuts have taken some of the gloss off what has so far been a stellar year for BYD. The stock hit a record high last week, it posted its best month of sales in China and outsold Tesla in Europe for the first time in April, and raised HK$43.5 billion (S$5.5 billion) in a Hong Kong share sale in March.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Before this week's slide, BYD Hong Kong-traded shares had surged almost 75 per cent this year, and with a market value equal to around US$158 billion, is bigger than Ford Motor, General Motors and Volkswagen combined.
On the technology front, it has unveiled a lineup of cars it says can charge in five minutes, and started to make its God's Eye advanced driver-assistance system standard in vehicles priced from 100,000 yuan (S$13,900) and include it in several lower-cost models such as the popular Seagull hatchback.
Some of the recently discounted models include those equipped with God's Eye.
Investors will get more insight into how BYD is tracking when monthly sales for May are released on Sunday. BLOOMBERG
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
8 hours ago
- Business Times
China warns BYD, rivals to self-regulate as price war heats up
[BEIJING] Chinese officials summoned the heads of major electric vehicle makers, including BYD, to Beijing earlier this week to address concerns about the long-running price war, according to people familiar with the matter. The meeting was hosted by the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, the market regulator and the top economic planning agency, said the people, who asked not to be identified discussing private information. The gathering was attended by senior executives from more than a dozen manufacturers that also included Zhejiang Geely Holding Group and Xiaomi, the people said. Officials told EV makers to 'self-regulate,' and that they should not sell cars below cost or offer unreasonable price cuts. They also addressed issues such as 'zero-mileage' cars and mounting bills owed to suppliers that are squeezing cash flow along the supply chain and acting as quasi-debt financing for automakers, the people said. It is rare for China's market, industry, and economic regulators to jointly host a meeting with the car industry on operational matters like pricing. The move shows how much scrutiny the nation's top leadership is paying to the sector, amid concerns the price war is becoming unsustainable and could send weaker companies into bankruptcy. However, the gathering did not result in a mandatory directive and it's not clear what consequences manufacturers would face if they don't follow the verbal warnings, the people said. BYD and Xiaomi did not respond to requests for comments. A representative from Geely referred to a recent speech by chairman Li Shufu who said the company resolutely rejects price wars and will compete on technology and its values. The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, the State Administration for Market Regulation and the National Development & Reform Commission did not reply to faxed questions. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The warnings come after BYD kicked off the latest round in the price war late last month with discounts of as much as 34 per cent, leading to criticism from industry bodies and state media. Without naming BYD, the China Automobile Manufacturers Association released a statement saying the move by a certain company started a new round of 'price war panic' that was plunging the sector into a 'vicious cycle' and threatening supply chain security. 'Disorderly price wars intensify vicious competition, further compressing corporate profit margins,' the association said. Media outlets directly controlled by the Communist Party leadership including Xinhua, the People's Daily and state broadcaster CCTV have all published reports in recent days that called for automakers to stop discounting and restore order to the industry. Otherwise, this could lead to low-priced and low-quality products that will damage the international reputation and the image of 'Made-in-China,' the People's Daily said. This week's meeting marked the second time in recent days that industry leaders have been rebuked over 'zero-mileage' cars – a practice in which automakers that have failed to meet their sales targets offload new vehicles to supply chain financing companies or used car dealers. These essentially new cars then appear on the resale market with no mileage, while manufacturers record them as sales despite them not having reaching the end-consumer. The Ministry of Commerce also met with at least two major carmakers and online used cars platforms last week on the issue. Carmakers have been trying to pass on the hit from the price war to suppliers, demanding lower prices for parts and delaying bill payment by months. A price cut demand by BYD to one of its suppliers late last year attracted media coverage and scrutiny of how the EV behemoth may be using supply chain financing to mask its ballooning debt. A report by accounting consultancy GMT Research puts BYD's true net debt at closer to 323 billion yuan (S$57.8 billion), compared with the 27.7 billion yuan officially on its books as of the end of June 2024, through delaying its payments to suppliers and other related financing. BLOOMBERG
Business Times
10 hours ago
- Business Times
Why property giant New World's debt woes have Hong Kong on edge
[HONG KONG] Bankers in Hong Kong are on edge as New World Development, one of the city's top real estate developers, attempts to pull off an HK$87.5 billion (S$14.3 billion) refinancing deal by the end of the month. Once among the most deep-pocketed property giants in the city, New World has faced mounting liquidity pressure over the past couple of years. Its net debt reached 96 per cent of shareholder equity at the end of 2024, according to Bloomberg Intelligence, making it one of the most leveraged developers in Hong Kong. Investors are growing increasingly sceptical of the firm's ability to manage its debt burden, after it reported its first loss in two decades in the 2024 financial year. Confidence was further eroded when New World opted to defer interest payments on some perpetual bonds to postpone its debt obligations. As of early June, the company's shares had slumped more than 90 per cent from their peak in 2019. If New World is unable to secure its multibillion-dollar loan deal, the fallout of its cash crunch could ripple across Hong Kong's already beleaguered real estate market, which has been in the midst of a downturn for several years. Founded in 1970 by Cheng Yu-Tung, a former gold shop apprentice from mainland China's Guangdong province, New World is one of Hong Kong's 'Big Four' property developers. The family-owned company has built scores of apartment blocks throughout the city and owns iconic assets including the sprawling commercial complex Victoria Dockside along Hong Kong's famous harbor. A decades-long property boom propelled the Cheng family into the financial hub's wealthiest echelons. Now worth US$22.6 billion, they're one of the richest families in Asia, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Tuesday, 12 pm Property Insights Get an exclusive analysis of real estate and property news in Singapore and beyond. Sign Up Sign Up Management of New World was gradually handed over to Adrian Cheng, the grandson of the founder, across the 2010s. He made his mark by infusing art elements into the residential towers and offices that New World built, as well as bidding for mega projects like the city's largest stadium, the Kai Tak Sports Park. Under his leadership, the firm transformed into a brand that appealed to the sophisticated middle class and amassed multiple trophy properties in town. But after overseeing the plunge of New World's earnings into the red, Cheng stepped down as chief executive officer in September – a rare abrupt departure in Hong Kong's property industry, where the biggest players are all controlled by families that carefully plan their succession. Adding to the turmoil, his replacement, Eric Ma, only lasted two months before departing, and Echo Huang was promoted to the top job in November. The company's strategy of debt-fuelled expansion wasn't so much of a problem when the property markets in both Hong Kong and mainland China were booming. However, Hong Kong's real estate market entered an unprecedented downturn in 2021. The combination of anti-government protests several years before that, as well as a controversial national security law and strict Covid-19 restrictions that followed, prompted an exodus of local residents and made the international community think twice about the city's business environment. This weighed on demand for residential and commercial properties. Compounding those challenges, Hong Kong's interest rates move in step with the US Federal Reserve. As the Fed raised rates across 2022 and 2023 to combat spiking inflation, elevated borrowing costs increased New World's financial burden and made investments in real estate less attractive to regular homebuyers and investors. Home sales and rental income from offices and shopping malls are a major source of revenue for developers like New World. But home prices in Hong Kong are hovering at their lowest in nine years and office rents have plunged 40 per cent since their peak in 2019. Malls are also struggling with higher vacancies and lower rents, particularly as the slowdown in mainland China's economy means there are fewer tourists visiting Hong Kong who are willing to splurge. The rush to build more apartment blocks and skyscrapers during the height of the market has left a glut of properties that are further suppressing prices as demand slows. New World's mega projects – from Victoria Dockside to the city's largest shopping mall, 11 Skies – now face a very different reality to when they were planned. The company is also being squeezed by its relatively high exposure to the property market in mainland China, which has experienced a steep decline in home values over the past few years. The mainland represented more than half of New World's contracted sales for the 12 months through June 2024. For Sun Hung Kai Properties, another top firm in Hong Kong, just 30 per cent of its property sales came from the same region over this period. Saddled with around HK$210.9 billion in liabilities as of the end of last year, New World has been negotiating with banks since January to refinance HK$87.5 billion of loans – one of the biggest refinancing efforts ever by a Hong Kong company. As of May 30, New World had received written commitments from banks for 60 per cent of that amount and is hoping to secure the total by the end of June, people familiar with the matter told Bloomberg News. The urgency to wrap things up is because a covenant waiver on the firm's existing loans is set to expire on June 30. Without refinancing in place, some banks could, in theory, call in their loans. New World has pledged around 40 properties as collateral, including its crown jewel, Victoria Dockside. A successful deal would help alleviate the liquidity concerns that have long dogged the company. But if the refinancing fails to materialise, there's a risk New World could default if any of its creditors demand immediate repayment. At the very least, lenders may have to take a haircut on their loans, if any fraction can be recouped. The developer's credibility in capital markets would be heavily damaged and in a worst-case scenario, New World may need to undergo restructuring like embattled peers in the mainland. A potential fire-sale of New World's assets could trigger a domino effect in the city's property sector, putting further pressure on the already fragile market. In the event of a high-profile default or restructuring by a major Hong Kong real estate developer, S&P Global Ratings estimates that homebuyers' confidence would suffer, leading to sales of newly built residences halving in 2025 and prices falling by as much as 7 per cent. A decline in prices would hit other developers' margins and their debt-to-Ebitda ratio – a measure of leverage – could rise as a result. In addition, if Hong Kong home prices continue to drop this year, S&P anticipates funding conditions would tighten, triggering a credit squeeze. Banks are one of the largest sources of funding for property developers, and such lending is highly correlated with home values. The level of exposure of various banks to New World is unclear, but they're likely to be intertwined given New World is one of Hong Kong's biggest businesses. If the developer failed to honour its debt obligations, most banks would likely see a sharp increase in their volume of non-performing loans – debt that's considered unlikely to be repaid – and more pressure on their balance sheets. The non-performing loan ratio of Hang Seng Bank, one of New World's creditors, more than doubled in 2024, to 6.12 per cent, and a failure of the real estate giant would likely push this number even higher. BLOOMBERG
Business Times
12 hours ago
- Business Times
Laopu Gold's 2,300% rally faces test after stock hits HK$1,000
A BREATHTAKING rally in Laopu Gold is facing a critical test after its stock price hit HK$1,000 (S$164), a rare milestone that may deter retail investors due to the steep price tag. The jewellery maker soared more than 2,300 per cent since its listing in late June 2024 to set a new record earlier on Thursday (Jun 5), emerging as the new face of Chinese luxury and outperforming over 500 peers in the Hang Seng Composite Index. Its share price far surpasses the second-most expensive stock in Hong Kong: bubble tea maker Mixue Group which is trading at around HK$580. While Laopu's ascent underscores market zeal towards China's new consumption stocks catering to Gen Z demand, investors will likely demand more to purchase shares at this level. With a minimum trading unit set at 100 shares by the company, it means a buyer must shell out HK$100,000 – the equivalent of US$12,750 – to gain exposure to Laopu. Share price moves on Thursday illustrate the point. The stock fell as much as 8.5 per cent after reaching HK$1,015 earlier in the session. Peer Chow Tai Fook Jewellery Group slid more than 1 per cent in Hong Kong while Chow Tai Seng Jewellery slumped 8.2 per cent on the mainland. Another crucial test will be a Jun 27 lockup expiry of 121.4 million shares. That's more than double the current number of free-float shares. The stock posted its worst weekly drop since its listing in December last year, just before the expiry of a six-month lockup on 10.8 million shares. 'Laopu is excessively expensive in my view, based on cash flow, even though growth looks promising,' said Yu Dingheng, fund manager at Shenzhen Flying Tiger Investment & Management. 'HK$1,000 is going to be a tough hurdle.' BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Companies listed in Hong Kong can set their own minimum trading units – known as a 'board lot' – ranging from dozens to thousands of shares. While investors can place orders for odd lots including a single share through brokerages, these transactions typically take longer to match and can incur higher fees. Bloomberg reported in March that the financial hub's exchange was discussing options to lower the threshold for investors to buy some of the most expensive stocks to boost trading activity. The retail portion of Laopu's initial public offering was nearly 600 times oversubscribed, prompting the company to increase the number of shares allocated to individual investors by six times to 11.2 million. Laopu currently trades at nearly 32 times forward earnings, above Chow Tai Fook's ratio at around 16. Laopu has yet to indicate any plans for a stock split, a common strategy taken by high-flying firms to cheapen the value of each share and make it more affordable. Tencent Holdings performed a five-for-one split in 2014, shortly after share prices peaked at above HK$600. Zai Lab divided each share into 10 in 2022, lowering the price to around HK$35. BLOOMBERG
