Why value investing has worked better outside the US
I was intrigued by this observation. So, I looked at Morningstar's indexes. Sure enough, value investing has prospered beyond American shores—this year, as well as over the past three-, five-, and 10-year periods.
'Magnificent Seven' vs. 'Granolas'
US stocks of all styles have beaten international stocks for years, due to a strengthening dollar, superior returns on invested capital, and expanding price multiples.
Morningstar's US growth index is dominated by the ' Magnificent Seven.' But internationally, the scale is far smaller. There is not a single public company outside the US currently worth $1 trillion.
There was a time when the ' Granolas ' stocks were being promoted as Europe's answer to the Magnificent Seven (names like GSK, Roche, Nestle, L'Oreal and AstraZeneca). But don't blame yourself if you haven't heard of the Granolas. They never really rivaled the Magnificent Seven from a performance perspective.
So, what has boosted value investing internationally? Largely, the financial-services sector (which was lifted by higher interest rates) and energy stocks.
Looking beyond Europe with style
While value has outperformed growth in Europe over the past five years, Europe now represents less than half of equity market capitalization outside the US.
Rather, value stocks in emerging markets (like China, India, and Brazil) and developed Asia have outperformed by an even larger margin than in Europe.
The decline of Chinese internet companies, which were once big growth stocks, helps explain why value investing has triumphed over growth investing in emerging markets in recent years.
On the developed-markets side, Japan has seen rising interest rates and improved economic and investment conditions disproportionately benefit financial-services stocks, which tend to reside on the value side of the market.
Value's underperformance in the US: Is it macro or micro?
While I have mentioned some macroeconomic factors above, I am generally skeptical of attempts to explain style leadership from the top down. Back in 2022, when sticky inflation prompted the largest interest-rate hikes in a generation, US growth stocks fell much further than value. A popular narrative arose: Growth stocks are more sensitive to interest rates.
But then growth bounced back in 2023 despite high rates. The Magnificent Seven and others rode a wave of enthusiasm for AI. Growth stocks' thriving amid higher rates is hardly unprecedented. Between 2015 and 2018, the US Federal Reserve hiked rates several times, yet growth beat value by a wide margin.
Ultimately, I agree with Rasmussen that the triumph of growth over value in the US has more to do with 'historically unique and rare circumstances.'
I've been following markets long enough to know that style leadership can be cyclical. Right now, it's value investing that's being fundamentally questioned.
Value stocks have been called 'structurally challenged,' in 'secular decline,' and 'value traps.' But the value side of the market has always been home to troubled companies. Value investing is about stocks that under promise and overdeliver.
Perhaps the long-term cycle will turn again in value's favor. AI could be revolutionary, but, like the internet, ahead of itself from an investment perspective. We could look back at 2025 as a historical inflection point, as marking a new market regime.
The problem is that these things are only clear in retrospect. It will take time to know if the rotations we've seen in early 2025 will last, or if they're just head fakes.
____
This article was provided to The Associated Press by Morningstar. For more markets content, go to https://www.morningstar.com/markets.
Dan Lefkovitz is a strategist for Morningstar Indexes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Wire
25 minutes ago
- Business Wire
Rio Tinto approves US$180 million Norman Creek project, securing long-term future for Amrun bauxite operations on Queensland's Cape York Peninsula
MELBOURNE, Australia--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Rio Tinto has approved investment of US$180 million and commenced work on the Norman Creek access project at the world-class Amrun bauxite mine on Queensland's Cape York Peninsula. The Norman Creek access project will enable mining of the Norman Creek region of Amrun, which holds approximately half of the currently declared Amrun Ore Reserves of 978 million tonnes. [1] Construction is underway on key infrastructure, including a 19-kilometre haul road, camp accommodation and a communications tower. First production from Norman Creek is targeted for 2027, with full construction completed in 2028. Rio Tinto Pacific Operations Aluminium Managing Director Armando Torres said: 'Norman Creek is another important step in securing the long-term future of our Weipa operations, and the benefits that mining brings to communities in the region, Queensland, and the nation. 'It will maintain jobs in the region through to at least the middle of this century, ensuring continuity for our people and the Weipa community. 'The decision to approve Norman Creek reflects the quality of Western Cape York's world-class bauxite deposits, combined with the strong operational improvements our people are making at Amrun that are bolstering our confidence to invest for the long-term.' In addition to the Norman Creek project, Rio Tinto recently announced it had started early works and a final feasibility study on the Kangwinan project, which includes early works and final engineering studies to increase production capacity at the Amrun bauxite mine. If approved, Kangwinan would increase annual bauxite production capacity from Rio Tinto's Weipa Southern operations, by up to 20 million tonnes, in addition to the current 23 million tonnes, and expand export capacity through the Amrun port. The project was named Kangwinan at the request of Traditional Owners, the Wik Waya people. Production from the Kangwinan project would replace output from the Andoom mine on Cape York and the Gove mine in the Northern Territory, which are both expected to close toward the end of the current decade. First output from the Kangwinan project could be as early as 2029. The Norman Creek investment is expected to be classified as replacement capital and has been factored into the Group's capital guidance. [1] These Ore Reserves were reported in accordance with the Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves, 2012 Edition (JORC Code) and the ASX Listing Rules in a release to the ASX dated 19 February 2025 titled 'Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves updates: supporting information and Table 1 checklists' (Table 1 release) which is available at The Amrun Ore Reserves comprise 466 Mt of Proved Ore Reserves @ 54.6% Al 2 O 3 and 8.8% SiO 2 and 512 Mt of Probable Ore Reserves @ 54.3% Al 2 O 3 and 9.1% SiO 2 for a total of 978 Mt @ 54.4% Al 2 O 3 and 9.0% SiO 2. The Competent Person responsible for the information in the Table 1 release that relates to Amrun Ore Reserves is William Saba who is a Member of the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy (MAusIMM). Rio Tinto confirms that it is not aware of any new information or data that materially affects the information included in the Table 1 release, that all material assumptions and technical parameters underpinning the estimates in the 2024 Annual Report continue to apply and have not materially changed, and that the form and context in which the Competent Person's findings are presented have not been materially modified. Ore Reserves are reported on a 100% basis
Wall Street Journal
26 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Oil Edges Higher, Supported by Unexpected Fall in U.S. Crude Inventories
0010 GMT — Oil edges higher in early Asian trade, supported by an unexpected fall in U.S. crude inventories. EIA data released Wednesday showed commercial crude oil stocks excluding the Strategic Petroleum Reserve fell by 3 million barrels in the week ended Aug. 1. Analysts surveyed by the WSJ had predicted crude stockpiles to be up by 100,000 barrels. Oil-price movements seem limited ahead of a potential meeting between U.S. President Trump and Russian President Putin. Traders are positioning themselves for the possibility of a softer stance on Russia than the White House previously telegraphed, ANZ Research analysts say in a note. Front-month WTI crude oil futures are 0.2% higher at $64.42/bbl; front-month Brent crude oil futures are 0.1% higher at $66.94/bbl. (
CBS News
26 minutes ago
- CBS News
Fed official says last week's jobs revisions could signal an economic turning point
A Federal Reserve official on Wednesday called last week's tepid jobs report "concerning," and said its significant downward revisions could signal an economic shift in the U.S. Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook highlighted the report's sizable downward revisions to jobs created in May and June, saying that they are "typical of turning points" in the economy. Friday's report showed that employers added a weaker-than-expected 73,000 jobs in July. The Bureau of Labor Statistics, or BLS, also sharply revised its job estimates for May and June, saying that the U.S. added 258,000 fewer jobs than previously reported. After Friday's report, President Trump fired the BLS commissioner of labor statistics, claiming that the revisions undermined the data's accuracy. He added that "Economy is BOOMING under 'TRUMP'." Revisions are a common feature of the monthly jobs reports from the BLS, which updates its data after receiving new information from businesses and other sources. Some economists said the July jobs report reflected that some companies are scaling back hiring plans amid a slowing U.S. economy and uncertainty surrounding the Trump administration's tariffs. "There were two major revisions to May and June, and these revisions are somewhat typical of turning points, which again speak to uncertainty," Cook said during a Wednesday discussion with other Fed officials on the global economic outlook. She later added, "When we get the GDP numbers later this year, we're going to see, I can imagine, lower activity." Crafting effective economic policies is dependent on understanding where the economy is heading, said Cook, who prior to her appointment in 2022 as a Fed governor was an economics professor at Michigan State University. She has also served on the faculty of Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government and worked as a senior economist on the Council of Economic Advisers under President Obama, according to her biography. "We want to know not just where we've been, but where we're going. So if we're at an inflection point, we want to look at data that speak to inflection points," she added. Other Fed officials said the July jobs report may not necessarily reflect a long-term direction. On Friday, Atlanta Fed president Raphael Bostic said he had questions about whether the report was a one-time issue or a trend, and added that he believes the labor market still has "a lot of strength." The downward revision to May and June's hiring data marked the largest two-month downward revision outside of a recession since 1968, according to an analysis from Goldman Sachs. Cook also discussed what she referred to as an "uncertainty tax" that she said is weighing on businesses across industries. She said that executives at "all kinds of organizations" are spending more time on preparing for and responding to macroeconomic uncertainty. That includes discussions about pricing based on anticipated cost increases from the new tariffs. When executives spend their time this way, it's a "deadweight loss, we're not going to see that in GDP," she explained. "So there's just uncertainty across the board, but I think it's really interesting that no matter what the sector, no matter what kind of businesses they're in, they're talking about the uncertainty tax," Cook said.
