Bush's Head of Social Security Trashes Musk's Fraud Claims
A former commissioner of the Social Security Administration (SSA) who served under both presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, has slammed Elon Musk's claims that the agency is a hub for financial fraud.
Michael Astrue, who was commissioner for six years, stressed in an interview with NPR published Monday that while the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) can 'go in and put in efficiencies to bring down the size of the agency' there's a 'smart way to do it and there's a stupid way' emphasizing that DOGE is landing on the latter rather than the former.
'We need a perspective other than the DOGE perspective. I'm all for cutting waste, I'm all for efficiencies. And if you look back at the productivity increases in my six years, they were substantial,' Astrue explained. 'If you want to go in and put in efficiencies to bring down the size of the agency, you can do that. But there's a smart way to do it and there's a stupid way to do it. And we're doing it the way that 22-year-old frat boys that have never seen the system think is a good idea, and that's a mistake.'
Musk has rallied a small team—of largely twenty-somethings—to streamline his efforts for government downsizing. A healthy chunk of the work DOGE has been doing has apparently been scouring through federal agencies' records and coding systems to identify potential waste or fraud.
So far, however, the only things they've been able to turn up are lots of line-items that, politically, they disagree with.
In the case of the SSA, the agency relies on a 60-year-old code system—the Common Businesses Oriented Language (COBOL)—which Astrue notes Musk's team likely have never seen before. Misunderstandings likely paved the way for a misunderstanding of the agency's finances, he said.
'You can't fault them for that because they haven't ever seen COBOL code before,' Astrue said. 'But you can fault Elon Musk because, instead of admitting error, he doubled down and had the president of the United States make that claim. And that's a real disservice to President Trump.'
When probed by NPR if the SSA was in fact rife with fraud to the extent that Musk has claimed, Astrue said: 'No, it's not. And the big claims are just flat out wrong.'
'It's just a product of the fact that they sent in a group of 20-year-olds with laptops who are used to seeing certain types of code. They went in without the proper authorities and didn't understand it,' the former commissioner argued.
Musk has repeatedly claimed that the SSA is plagued by 'immense waste' and 'extreme levels of fraud.' These allegations have been swiftly parroted by President Donald Trump, who in a joint address to Congress earlier this month claimed that Musk and DOGE have identified 'shocking levels of incompetence and probable fraud' at the agency.
Some ideas that have been floated to tighten up the agency include mass layoffs and administering stricter protocols, like verifying the identity of Social Security recipients in-person to bestow checks.
'It's at least going to cause delays,' Astrue said of the Trump administration's proposed changes. 'In some cases they may just not get it at all. And to put in this requirement at the same time that you're cutting back staff and office space dramatically is going to compound what is already a big problem.'
A spokesperson for the SSA told NPR that the agency remains focused 'on identifying efficiencies and reducing costs.' The administration currently distributes benefits to more than 70 million Americans.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Chicago Tribune
23 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Terry Savage: AI used to guide seniors to Medicare programs
Does the concept of artificial intelligence intimidate you? Or do you figure it won't have much impact on your life, so why bother learning about it? Well, AI is definitely entering — and improving — your life, whether you choose it or not. When I first wrote about ChatGPT several years ago, AI was viewed as a powerful tool to collect information from huge databases and sort it out to provide answers to questions. Since then, AI has quickly morphed into a useful tool for business and individuals, creating accurate and life-like interactions that make outcomes easier. For example, the new Social Security commissioner, a former tech payments CEO, has announced that Social Security will soon be using AI in its call centers. If the idea of talking to a 'robot' sends chills down your spine, think again. In this column, I'll show you a company that is already using AI in its call center — and generating responses that truly make you think you're talking to a helpful person. A reality check It's a generational thing. When I want help after calling a toll-free number for product information or credit card adjustments or insurance issues, I want to talk to an intelligent human being. I guess there aren't enough to go around! One of my pet peeves is being transferred to a voice messaging system that tries to 'help' me decide how to get answers to a simple question. They offer five choices, none of which is helpful. Representative, please! The only thing worse than a voice-activated decision tree is getting transferred to a live person who just happens to live in a foreign country and who is obviously responding off a script. If I ask to talk to a supervisor, I'm told there is no supervisor available! Don't these companies care about their customers? (Insert your own swear word here!) Artificial intelligence that's real So I must say I was absolutely shocked to hear a demonstration of AI being used by eHealth to start the process of guiding seniors to the appropriate choices for Medicare programs. For many years, eHealth has been a popular health insurance marketplace that helps people find the right insurance coverage by comparison-shopping plans from more than 180 insurers for coverage ranging from Medicare Advantage and supplemental plans to individual and family health policies, along with other benefits such as dental and vision. Many people access eHealth through its website, Others use their toll-free number 1-800-EHEALTH (1-800-343-2584) to reach their licensed and helpful insurance agents. Getting to the agent licensed in your state of residence, and knowledgeable about your specific product request, could take a lot of time during busy days around Medicare enrollment. And what about calls that come in late at night? That's why eHealth created 'Alice' — an AI 'agent' who does not actually sell insurance policies but who asks relevant questions to direct you to the correct licensed agent. You'd swear that you are talking to a live person, since 'her' responses are not only appropriate but friendly. Listening to the demo that eHealth sent me, I was absolutely blown away. I knew that you'd want to hear the same thing, so if you are reading this column online at my website you can click on this link in the article. In this case, an audio demo is worth a thousand words! Even if you're not shopping for health insurance, I recommend listening to this short clip of an interaction between someone calling the toll-free line late at night and the AI agent, Alice. This company has taken AI to the next level. Suddenly, you'll understand how much more helpful an AI agent can be than a call center in the middle of nowhere! And, on a personal level, you'll see how AI has so much potential to change our lives for the better (yes, or for the worse). I spoke with Ketan Babaria, chief digital and AI officer of eHealth. He notes that while AI is not (yet) selling policies, it is making a big difference in their processes: 'Our new AI agents are trained to be patient, caring and sympathetic. As a result, we are making it easier and faster for people to start the shopping process for a Medicare plan, enabling them to more quickly connect with a licensed agent who can help them comparison shop for the right health coverage.' So the next time you hear that your call will be answered by AI, don't hang up in fear, hoping that the next time you'll get a 'real person.' Odds are that soon you'll be connecting with many AI agents. And the odds are even better that you'll get the correct answer from a compassionate robot than you'd get from the overworked and underinformed call center worker. That's The Savage Truth.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Officials approve site for new Tesla factory despite vehement opposition: 'It's not going to be good for anyone'
A South Australian city has approved the use of state-owned land by Tesla to build a factory, despite overwhelming public opposition to the project. According to the Guardian, the city council of Marion, Adelaide, voted to seek state approval to sell land to Tesla on which they plan to build a new factory. The approval came despite overwhelming public opposition to the proposed sale, as 95% of over 1,000 people who submitted statements to the council had objected to the proposal. Marion Mayor Kris Hanna addressed the decision after the vote was taken, saying that denying the project would have no impact on Musk, but would cost the city over 100 potential new jobs. "If we didn't proceed, it would have cost 100 jobs to local residents but it would have had no impact on Elon Musk," Hanna said. "Tesla would almost certainly find somewhere else in Australia to build their factory." The brand perception of Tesla is currently at an all-time low around the globe, and sales numbers have been in a tailspin for several months. In the case of Marion, the vast majority of the backlash centered around Tesla CEO Musk and his involvement in far-right political movements around the globe, but other environmental concerns were levied as well. "Please dear God," one wrote. "It's not going to be good for anyone." "I could not think of a worse developer to sell the land to," said another opponent. "Tesla sales have been plummetting [sic] … this is likely to attract protests and negative attention that the neighbourhood does not need or want." Musk's companies have come under fire before for dodging environmental regulations. In Memphis, his xAI facility has been accused of setting up gas-powered turbines that pump pollution directly out into the city without permits, directly violating the Clean Air Act. Opponents of the proposal note that while the site would be used to recycle batteries, it would only recycle Tesla batteries, and not those made by other companies, limiting its usefulness. "My understanding is Tesla only recycle Tesla batteries and we know most people in SA … have another brand," Sarah Luscombe, a Marion councillor who voted against the approval, said. What do you think of Tesla and Elon Musk? Elon is the man Love the company; hate the CEO I'm not a fan of either I don't have an opinion Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. The deal now advances to the next stage, where it needs approval from the state government of Adelaide. According to the Guardian, the state seems to be in favor of the deal. South Australia Premier Peter Malinauskas said he supported the deal, despite Musk's controversial political positions. "Any time we see any big, major industrial investment in our state, in my view, it is welcome," the premier said. "Mr. Musk's politics, while I violently disagree with them … that's his prerogative." Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Democratic lawmaker looks forward to Elon Musk 'turning his fire against MAGA Republicans' in 2026 midterms
Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., was optimistic on Friday that former Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) leader Elon Musk would be targeting Republicans instead of Democrats in the 2026 midterm elections after his feud with President Donald Trump. In an interview with Semafor, Khanna said that he spoke to some of the Tesla CEO's "senior confidants" about whether Musk would be interested in supporting Democratic candidates in 2026. Based on Musk's recent attacks against the Trump administration and his history of supporting Democrats, Khanna believed a change could be possible. "Having Elon speak out against the irrational tariff policy, against the deficit-exploding Trump bill, and the anti-science and anti-immigrant agenda can help check Trump's unconstitutional administration," Khanna said. "I look forward to Elon turning his fire against MAGA Republicans instead of Democrats in 2026." Booker Won't Accept Money From Elon Musk For Campaign, But Urges Him To 'Sound The Alarm' On Trump-backed Bill Khanna made similar comments to Politico on Wednesday where he implored the party to start trying to embrace Musk after he broke ranks with Trump. "We should ultimately be trying to convince him that the Democratic Party has more of the values that he agrees with," Khanna said. "A commitment to science funding, a commitment to clean technology, a commitment to seeing international students like him." Read On The Fox News App Fox News Digital reached out to a Musk spokesperson for a comment. While Democrats have largely framed Musk as a political enemy because of his support for Trump, Khanna has been a notable exception, calling for "bipartisan cooperation" with DOGE's efforts to cut federal spending prior to Trump taking office for the second time.. Not every progressive has encouraged reaching out to Musk ahead of the midterms. On CNN Sunday, Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., told "State of the Union" host Dana Bash that he didn't believe Democrats should work with the "right-wing extremist." Elon Musk Biographer Believes Billionaire Is 'Frustrated' As He Exits Doge "Musk has evolved over the years. My understanding is he actually voted for Obama in 2008. But over the years, he has developed into a right-wing extremist," Sanders said. While Musk and Trump traded harsh barbs last week over Trump's massive tax and spending package, Musk has since shown signs of reconciling with the Trump administration on social media. On Sunday, Musk shared a Truth Social post from Trump regarding the Los Angeles riots that broke out on Friday. He also re-posted one of Vice President JD Vance's posts on X about the riots, signaling approval of the administration's handling of the article source: Democratic lawmaker looks forward to Elon Musk 'turning his fire against MAGA Republicans' in 2026 midterms