Bush's Head of Social Security Trashes Musk's Fraud Claims
A former commissioner of the Social Security Administration (SSA) who served under both presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, has slammed Elon Musk's claims that the agency is a hub for financial fraud.
Michael Astrue, who was commissioner for six years, stressed in an interview with NPR published Monday that while the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) can 'go in and put in efficiencies to bring down the size of the agency' there's a 'smart way to do it and there's a stupid way' emphasizing that DOGE is landing on the latter rather than the former.
'We need a perspective other than the DOGE perspective. I'm all for cutting waste, I'm all for efficiencies. And if you look back at the productivity increases in my six years, they were substantial,' Astrue explained. 'If you want to go in and put in efficiencies to bring down the size of the agency, you can do that. But there's a smart way to do it and there's a stupid way to do it. And we're doing it the way that 22-year-old frat boys that have never seen the system think is a good idea, and that's a mistake.'
Musk has rallied a small team—of largely twenty-somethings—to streamline his efforts for government downsizing. A healthy chunk of the work DOGE has been doing has apparently been scouring through federal agencies' records and coding systems to identify potential waste or fraud.
So far, however, the only things they've been able to turn up are lots of line-items that, politically, they disagree with.
In the case of the SSA, the agency relies on a 60-year-old code system—the Common Businesses Oriented Language (COBOL)—which Astrue notes Musk's team likely have never seen before. Misunderstandings likely paved the way for a misunderstanding of the agency's finances, he said.
'You can't fault them for that because they haven't ever seen COBOL code before,' Astrue said. 'But you can fault Elon Musk because, instead of admitting error, he doubled down and had the president of the United States make that claim. And that's a real disservice to President Trump.'
When probed by NPR if the SSA was in fact rife with fraud to the extent that Musk has claimed, Astrue said: 'No, it's not. And the big claims are just flat out wrong.'
'It's just a product of the fact that they sent in a group of 20-year-olds with laptops who are used to seeing certain types of code. They went in without the proper authorities and didn't understand it,' the former commissioner argued.
Musk has repeatedly claimed that the SSA is plagued by 'immense waste' and 'extreme levels of fraud.' These allegations have been swiftly parroted by President Donald Trump, who in a joint address to Congress earlier this month claimed that Musk and DOGE have identified 'shocking levels of incompetence and probable fraud' at the agency.
Some ideas that have been floated to tighten up the agency include mass layoffs and administering stricter protocols, like verifying the identity of Social Security recipients in-person to bestow checks.
'It's at least going to cause delays,' Astrue said of the Trump administration's proposed changes. 'In some cases they may just not get it at all. And to put in this requirement at the same time that you're cutting back staff and office space dramatically is going to compound what is already a big problem.'
A spokesperson for the SSA told NPR that the agency remains focused 'on identifying efficiencies and reducing costs.' The administration currently distributes benefits to more than 70 million Americans.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Boston Globe
32 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Musk says Tesla's robotaxi service to ‘tentatively' launch in Austin on June 22
Last month, Musk told CNBC that the taxis will be remotely monitored at first and 'geofenced' to certain areas of the city deemed the safest to navigate. He said he expected to initially run 10 or so taxis, increase that number rapidly and start offering the service in Los Angeles, San Antonio, San Francisco and other cities. Advertisement Musk has been promising fully autonomous, self-driving vehicles 'next year' for a decade, but the pressure is on now as Tesla actually begins to operate a self-driving taxi service. Sales of Tesla's electric vehicles have sagged due to increased competition, the retooling of its most popular car, the Model Y, and the fallout from Musk's turn to politics. The Austin rollout also comes after Musk had a public blowup with President Donald Trump over the administration's tax bill. Some analysts have expressed concern that Trump could retaliate by encouraging federal safety regulators to to step in at any sign of trouble for the robotaxis.
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Cybertruck Sales Are So Bad That We Gasped
There's little left for us to say that can further embarrass the Tesla Cybertruck, a vehicle that was supposed to be the culmination of Elon Musk's genius. And maybe this is what Musk's genius looks like. The luckless EV has faced eight recalls so far, and its trademark stainless steel panels, when they aren't flying off, have demonstrated that they're better at serving as a shiny canvas for spray paint than as the armor of an "apocalypse-proof" tank. But somehow, its already dire sales are now even worse than expected. In the entire first quarter of 2025, Tesla has managed to sell just 7,100 Cybertrucks in the US, according to registration data from S&P Global Mobility cited by the Wall Street Journal. It's an astounding and rapid plummet, when in the fourth quarter of 2024, Tesla sold close to double that amount, with roughly 13,000 Cybertrucks. A lot changed between those two quarters — like Musk embarking on a spectacular speedrun to destroy his and Tesla's image, mainly by leading the Trump administration's charge to gut the federal government. These actions, and Musk's personal espousing of far-right politics, sparked worldwide protests against him and his automaker. It has yet to recover, with Tesla's total sales in the US dropping nine percent in the first three months of this year. There are other factors at play, too, like the success of its Chinese competitors and its aging vehicle lineup, but the imploded brand reputation looms largest. And more than any other of its vehicles, the Cybertruck for one reason or another has embodied the public's souring sentiment on Musk, becoming prime targets for vandalism. They're also notoriously unreliable, sold for nothing less than $100,000 before cheaper $70,000 versions were desperately rolled out, and launched with a range over 150 miles shorter than what Musk promised. In all of 2024, the company sold fewer than 40,000 Cybertrucks. The most recent quarter's tally makes Musk previous boast that the automaker would sell up to half a million Cybertrucks per year even more ridiculous. Is it any wonder that buyers are staying away? So few people want to buy these things that in May Electrek reported that Tesla was sitting on an inventory worth $800 million of 10,000 unsold Cybertrucks — an embarrassment as much as it is a logistical headache. Dealerships have resorted to dumping their glut of the unorthodox pickup trucks in deserted parking lots. The pain isn't likely to stop anytime soon. Trump's tariffs, which factored into Musk's fallout with the president, will drive up the costs of car parts. The administration also plans to axe tax credits for purchasing EVs, demolishing a huge incentive for American consumers to buy from automakers like Tesla. More on Tesla: Terrifying Footage Shows Self-Driving Tesla Get Confused by the Sun, Mow Down Innocent Grandmother Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
FAFSA deadline nears: Las Vegas students urged to seek aid now
LAS VEGAS (KLAS) — An important deadline is quickly approaching for Las Vegas valley students heading to college this fall. The FAFSA, or Free Application for Federal Student Aid, must be submitted by the end of the month. The application is the first step to accessing billions of dollars in financial aid. 'FAFSA unlocks federal grants, loans, and work-study as well as many state and college programs aid on a first-come come-first first-served basis,' Shaan Patel, Founder and CEO of an online college prep service, said. The entire application can be completed online. 'Make sure you have all your necessary documents… so you get the maximum financial aid possible for college this fall,' Patel said. Dr. Rhea Watson, also known as The Scholarship Doctor and CEO of Scholarship Solutions, warns that skipping the FAFSA could cost you thousands of dollars. She emphasizes that it's a mistake to assume you won't qualify for financial aid. 'If you don't have a FAFSA application on file, it is nearly impossible, very difficult for your scholarship applications and even those financial aid packages you want to receive from a college,' Watson said. Roughly $3 billion in aid goes unclaimed every year, Watson said. 'Don't leave money on the table… it just goes and recycles through the government versus going to students who can use it to go to school and go without debt,' Watson said. The FAFSA only takes a few hours to complete if one is prepared. Once submitted, one can expect the financial aid award letter within 2 to 3 weeks. However, keep in mind that state and school-specific aid can run out quickly, so it's best to apply as early as possible. Documents needed for filling out the FAFSA include: Social Security number Parents' Social Security numbers (if you are a dependent student) Tax returns Records of child support received Current balances of cash, savings, and checking accounts Social Security card, driver's license, and/or alien registration card (if not a US citizen) Federal income tax returns, W-2s, and other records of money earned For more information on what students need to know before they fill out the FAFSA form, click here. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.