
J.P. Nagar residents raise red flag over Metro Phase 3 double-decker flyover alignment
Residents of J.P. Nagar have raised serious concerns about the proposed double-decker flyover under Namma Metro Phase 3, warning that its alignment could worsen traffic congestion near the already-busy Vega City Mall junction on Bannerghatta Road.
The flyover, part of Corridor 1 from JP Nagar 4th Phase to Kempapura, is set to land just 130 metres away from the Vega City Mall signal, a move locals believe could lead to severe gridlock.
The Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Limited (BMRCL), which has already begun land acquisition for the 32.15-km Corridor 1, has proposed a signal-free flyover as part of the metro alignment. While residents have welcomed the project's potential to decongest the city, they say the current design needs urgent revision.
'The problem is not with the metro but where the flyover ends. Ending it so close to the Vega City Mall signal will only shift the bottleneck, not eliminate it. We have already written to BMRCL and met our area's elected representative in March to highlight this issue,' a resident of J.P. Nagar 3rd Phase, who doesn't want to be named, told The Hindu.
He further explained, 'We residents of J.P. Nagar have shared our concerns, particularly about the ramp landing close to the junction. Adding ramps and expanding roads are not long-term solutions. They simply displace traffic rather than reduce it. We've urged BMRCL and BBMP officials to conduct detailed traffic simulation studies before finalising the alignment.'
Residents seek shift in flyover landing
The J.P. Nagar 4th Phase Dollars Layout Residents' Welfare Association (RWA) has also formally communicated its apprehensions to BMRCL. In a letter, the association noted: 'We wholeheartedly welcome Namma Metro Phase 3, recognising its potential to ease Bengaluru's traffic woes. However, the proposed 32-km signal-free double-decker corridor is expected to funnel traffic from Hebbal and Tumakuru Road directly to an area barely 130 metres from the J.D. Mara signal and the Vega City Mall. This could create massive congestion and spillover effects into nearby residential areas, impacting local schools, hospitals, businesses, and residents.'
To mitigate these risks, the RWA has suggested a shift in the alignment. 'A constructive alternative, unanimously resolved by residents, is to have the flyover land before the Kanakapura Road signal. This would create a 2.5 km buffer zone for better traffic dispersal and improve connectivity to the Silk Board flyover near Raghavendra Swamy Temple. Such a change would serve the project's goals while minimising disruption to sensitive residential zones, including the 15th Cross area,' the letter stated.
Meanwhile, residents say their appeals remain unanswered. 'Despite a series of meetings with BMRCL officials, the latest one being on May 12, there has been no concrete response from their side. We want development, but it must be thoughtful and sustainable. This project, if not planned properly, will turn Vega City junction into another nightmare for commuters.'
When The Hindu contacted BMRCL officials have not responded to the concerns raised by residents. A senior official said the matter is still under review. All about Namma Metro Phase 3.
Corridor 1, which will also feature major interchange stations at JP Nagar and Peenya (on the Green Line), Mysuru Road (on the Purple Line), and Sumanahalli (on the Hosahalli–Kadabagere Corridor 2), aims to expand the reach of Bengaluru's metro network. JP Nagar Phase 4 will also be linked to the Pink Line at Bannerghatta Road, while Hebbal will function as a key interchange connecting the Blue Line (to the airport) and the Red Line (to Sarjapur).
Phase 3, also referred to as the Orange Line, will be fully elevated and is expected to serve underserved areas along Magadi Road and the western portion of the Outer Ring Road (ORR). Once completed in 2029, it is projected to accommodate 7.85 lakh daily commuters, extending the city's metro network to 222.2 km.
While the project has received all mandatory approvals, including a Union Cabinet nod in August 2024, officials admit that design adjustments required for the double-decker viaduct have delayed the construction timeline.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
NCRTC moots Namo Bharat semi-high speed rail corridor connecting B'luru & Mys
Bengaluru: Even as the state govt accelerates efforts to expand Namma Metro to neighbouring districts like Tumakuru and key satellite towns such as Harohalli, Bidadi, Devanahalli, and Jigani, the National Capital Region Transport Corporation (NCRTC) proposed a plan to introduce semi-high speed Namo Bharat trains to enhance regional connectivity. In a proposal to the state govt, NCRTC suggested developing a Regional Rapid Transit System (RRTS) along four key corridors. These include Bengaluru–Hoskote–Kolar (65km), Bengaluru–Mysuru (145km), Bengaluru–Tumakuru (60km), and an inter-state corridor from Bengaluru to Hosur, Krishnagiri, and Dharmapuri (138km). The proposed corridors aim to provide faster and efficient connectivity between Bengaluru and its rapidly growing outskirts and neighbouring districts. The estimated travel time between Bengaluru and Kolar, and Bengaluru and Tumakuru is around 46 minutes. The Bengaluru–Mysuru route is expected to take approximately one hour. NCRTC, which is implementing the country's first Namo Bharat corridor between Delhi, Ghaziabad, and Meerut, designed the system for a maximum operational speed of 160 km/h, capable of covering 90km in an hour. Since Oct 2023, 55 kilometres of the total 82-km Delhi–Meerut corridor was operationalised. In May, NCRTC wrote to the chief secretary of the state govt, proposing the development of RRTS corridors. The corporation also invited state officials to visit the operational corridor from Sarai Kale Khan (Delhi) to Modipuram. The letter stated that NCRTC is willing to undertake the preparation of detailed project reports (DPRs) for these or any other corridors as assigned by the Karnataka or Central govts. NCRTC claims that Namo Bharat is distinct from Metro systems, as it caters to passengers travelling relatively longer distances with fewer stops and at much higher speeds. Namo Bharat trains are designed for a speed of 180 km/h, with an operational speed of 160 km/h and an average speed of 90 km/h—nearly three times faster than a typical Metro. It also claims that unlike conventional railways, the system is designed to provide reliable, high-frequency, point-to-point regional travel along a dedicated pathway. Meanwhile, the Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Limited (BMRCL) recently submitted a feasibility report for extending Namma Metro from Madavara to Tumakuru over a stretch of 59 km. The proposed line, featuring 25 stations, is estimated to cost Rs 20,650 crore under a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) model and Rs 18,670 crore if implemented through a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV). The feasibility report is under way for extending Namma Metro to Attibele, Jigani, Devanahalli and other towns on the outskirts.


Hans India
5 days ago
- Hans India
Bengaluru Metro Phase 3A: Sarjapur–Hebbal Red Line Faces Cost Review by Centre
The metro line from Sarjapur to Hebbal, known as the Red Line under Phase 3A of the Bengaluru Metro project, is facing fresh challenges. With an estimated cost of ₹28,405 crore, this line is being dubbed the most expensive metro project in the city's history. As a result, the Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Limited (BMRCL) has been instructed to re-evaluate the project. Central Government Raises Concerns Over Cost of Sarjapur–Hebbal Metro Line According to initial estimates, the cost per kilometer of this corridor could be as high as ₹776.3 crore. The central government has expressed concern over this high per-kilometer cost, which is significantly above national benchmarks. Hence, a more thorough assessment of the project is now required. Re-evaluation by Independent Experts Even though Phase 3A was approved by the state cabinet in December 2024, the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs is now carefully scrutinizing the project's cost. The Ministry believes that the projected cost exceeds acceptable standards. New Cost Evaluation Standards The revised cost estimates for metro projects now depend on 13 key factors, including alignment and construction, station buildings, power and traction systems, signaling, depots, train sets, etc. In particular, challenges in tunneling and fluctuations in equipment supply have been identified as reasons for cost escalation. Expert Report Expected in Three Months A report by independent experts is expected to be submitted to the central government within three months. Based on this report, a decision will be made regarding whether to approve Phase 3A as is, or propose modifications. This could lead to delays in the expected central clearance, which was originally anticipated by December 2025. The project completion deadline remains 2031. Costly Features of the Underground Metro Section Around 14.44 km of Phase 3A is planned to be underground. Construction costs for underground stations, tunnels, power systems, depots, and traction systems significantly increase the overall cost per kilometer. Typically, underground platforms are 240 meters long, but there is a proposal to reduce this to 190–200 meters to save on civil construction expenses. Speculations Regarding Tunnel Route Some recent statements by Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar sparked speculation that the route alignment might be changed. However, two senior BMRCL officials have clearly denied any such changes, affirming that the alignment remains intact — from Sarjapur to Iblur (14 km) and Agara to Koramangala 3rd Block (2.45 km) as originally planned. Double-Deck Flyovers According to officials, the changes mentioned by the Deputy CM refer only to the double-deck flyovers included in the Phase 3A plan. These flyovers are limited to elevated segments and do not affect the overall metro alignment in any way. With inputs from GoodRetruns.


Time of India
6 days ago
- Time of India
Steep power bill increase comes as shock for Pkl residents
Residents of Panchkula have received electricity bills showing increase of 100% to 400% for the period from mid-April to mid-May, compared to the previous year, despite minimal changes in unit consumption. While the Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission implemented a rate increase of 20 to 30 paise per kWh/kVAh for domestic and industrial categories, an analysis of various bills reveals disproportionate charges despite marginal increase in consumption. This has had a particularly adverse effect on middle-class families, the economically disadvantaged and pensioners. S K Nayar, Citizens' Welfare Association president from Sector 15, experienced a 145% increase in charges while maintaining similar consumption. His bill rose to Rs 2,042 for 210 units, compared to Rs 833 for 216 units in April 2024. "It is a loot of public money, and a wrong step was taken. Earlier, there used to be a minimum charge, and even if you went out of the city for a few months, the bill amount would not pinch you. But they are imposing fixed charges, which have burned a hole in the pockets of the common man," he rued. Sector 25 resident Mohit Gupta received a bill of Rs 5,641 for 668.25 units, while last April's bill was Rs 2,673 for 496.23 units. Despite lower consumption previously, this year's rate increase has resulted in substantially higher charges. Sant Singh Gill, former RWA president of Sector 25, saw his bill increase to Rs 3,745, as compared to Rs 1,286 last year, representing a 191% rise in charges against a 47% increase in consumption. Analysis shows varied impacts: Cases with abnormal consumption increases saw 430% higher bills, while 38% consumption increases resulted in 111% higher bills. Even with 21% reduced consumption, bills increased by 87%. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam (UHBVNL) chief engineer (Operations) Chandan Singh said, "The bills have been generated as per HERC's current rates. Some may have felt bills are higher because consumption has increased. As far as fixed charges are concerned, it is a certain amount for certain uses." The 2025-26 electricity order confirms rate increases of 20 to 30 paise per kWh/kVAh for both domestic and industrial categories in Haryana.