"Am I Dating A Boyfriend Or Raising One?": Why Women Are Tired Of Mankeeping
If modern dating had a tagline, it would probably be: "Now featuring unpaid emotional labour!" Somewhere between decoding the difference between "you up?" texts and reminding grown men that asking "how was your day?" is basic relationship hygiene, women have begun asking themselves a very valid question: Why does loving a man so often feel like managing one?
From planning dates and initiating difficult conversations to coaxing emotional vulnerability and reminding them to text their friends back, women have gradually slipped into a role that feels more like emotional management than mutual connection. And now, they're tired. Very, very tired.
What Is Mankeeping?
The term mankeeping was coined by Stanford researcher Angelica Ferrara to define the unpaid emotional labour women do to sustain men's social and psychological well-being. It's a riff on "kinkeeping", a sociological term from the 1980s referring to the behind-the-scenes work (usually by women) to keep families connected.
But while kinkeeping involved planning birthdays or reminding cousins to call their grandma, mankeeping is more insidious. It involves being the sole emotional sounding board for a partner, orchestrating their social life, and mentoring them in basic interpersonal behaviour, from how to comfort someone to when to apologise.
Psychologist Dr Gunjan Arya puts it simply: "Mankeeping is the emotional equivalent of being tech support, HR, and a life coach for your partner, all rolled into one and doing it for free."
The Emotional Mentor Fatigue Is Real
According to a 2025 survey by the Relationship Wellness Institute, 72% of single women say they are tired of emotionally mentoring the men they date. That statistic isn't just a number, it's an epidemic of exhaustion (quite literally).
"I've dated men older than me, men in therapy, even divorced men-and I've still had to spell out what romantic effort looks like," says 30-year-old Aparna Rao, a communications professional in Delhi, adding "It's like I have to explain that texting back isn't emotional intimacy, it's just basic decency."
It's not uncommon for women to find themselves teaching their partners how to express affection, how to comfort during distress, or even how to carry on a conversation beyond their own thoughts.
"Acts of service, romantic gestures, emotional reciprocity, none of this comes instinctively to many men because they've rarely been expected to offer it," says Dr Arya. "Instead, women are expected to lead the emotional choreography, while also clapping for the smallest moves men make," she adds.
The Shrinking Male Social Circle, Why Does It Matter?
At the heart of mankeeping lies another disturbing trend: men's rapidly deteriorating social networks. In a 2024 report by the Global Mental Health Alliance, over 45% of men between the ages of 25-40 admitted they had no close male friends to talk to about personal struggles.
With Gen Z and millennial men quitting alcohol and smoking, a trend widely linked to smaller, less frequent social gatherings, traditional bonding spaces are vanishing. No longer finding release through bar nights or smoke breaks, men are increasingly turning to their romantic partners as their only outlet. Or in some cases, going silent.
"When men lose these auxiliary emotional ecosystems, they offload everything - stress, fear, joy, resentment-on to one person: their girlfriend," says Dr Rohit Koliyot, a Bengaluru-based therapist specialised in men's mental health. "And while emotional vulnerability is beautiful, making one person your entire support system is unsustainable and often unfair," he adds.
Romance Shouldn't Be An Instruction Manual
Many women today aren't just expressing fatigue; they're reevaluating what they even want in a partner. "Why do I have to explain how to comfort me when I cry? Why do I need to list out what being a good boyfriend looks like?" asks Sana Ahmed, 25, a graphic designer in Delhi. She adds, "At this point, I don't want a relationship, I want rest."
The emotional mentoring women offer often begins subtly: a gentle nudge to hang out with friends, a suggestion to seek therapy, an encouraging word when they open up. But over time, this trickle becomes a torrent.
"You find yourself saying things like, 'Hey, it would mean a lot if you made a plan once in a while,' or 'Maybe try asking me how my day was, too?' Suddenly, you realise you're teaching someone how to be a partner. I always ask myself, 'Am I dating a boyfriend or am I raising one," says 26-year-old lawyer Raksha Agarwal.
A One-Way Street Of Care
This imbalance also has long-term consequences for women's mental health. Several studies have found that women in relationships where they feel they give more emotionally report lower satisfaction, higher stress and a greater likelihood of breaking up or divorcing.
"When care becomes one-directional, it stops being love and starts being labour. And unlike paid labour, there's no time off, no recognition, and no emotional reimbursement," says Dr Arya.
In heterosexual relationships, especially, this pattern often goes unchallenged.
"Women are socialised from an early age to be emotionally intelligent, nurturing, and accommodating. Men are often told that vulnerability is weakness, so when they finally open up, they lean hard on the woman closest to them," adds Dr Koliyot.
The Final Word
To be clear, the goal isn't to shame men for seeking support. The issue is outsourcing the entire job of emotional growth and maintenance to the women in their lives.
"Mankeeping isn't solved by a single deep conversation," says Dr Arya. "It's solved when men begin taking responsibility for their own emotional education. When they build friendships with depth, go to therapy, read books on relationships, not just rely on their girlfriends to summarise it for them."
For now, many women are drawing boundaries. They're recognising that being emotionally available doesn't mean becoming emotionally exploited. Some are pausing dating altogether, embracing solitude or female friendships instead.
Because love, at its best, is about mutuality, not management.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
a day ago
- Indian Express
Patriarchy to Power: The evolving meaning of freedom for Indian women
Written by Neha Mithun Rathod Seventy-eight years after Independence, the meaning of freedom for Indian women has evolved. From mere survival in the shadows of the Partition era to self-expression in the glow of social media, Indian women have come a long way to reclaim their freedom. Women across generations reveal how the times have changed their own perception of independence. Family decided, we obeyed: Nirmala Jain (81) 'We never spoke about self-ambitions and personal goals,' recalls 84-year-old Nirmala Jain, her eyes reflecting years of restraint. Born to Babulal and Jaraviben in Sildar, Rajasthan, Nirmala was the eldest of ten siblings and took charge of household chores from a very young age. Her days began before sunrise—fetching water, kneading dough, helping her mother—before attending lessons with masterji, who taught numbers, letters, and religious texts. By 14, she was married, meeting her husband for the first time at the mandap. 'No one asked whether we were ready. The family decided everything, and we obeyed,' she says. For women of her time, freedom meant small certainties: knowing everyone at home was safe, traditions were upheld, and the household ran smoothly. Now settled in Pune's Timber Market, Jain remains close to the community of families who migrated alongside hers, a living reminder of the shared histories that framed her early years. Raised daughters to think independently: Nirmala Chowhan (71) The next generation widened the definition—cautiously. Nirmala Amin Chowhan, raised in a traditional South Indian home, valued education as a ticket to better living. She graduated, took up a typewriting job, and married by choice. Navigating an interfaith marriage and two cultures, she raised daughters to think independently. At 71, in her Viman Nagar apartment, she still tutors children. 'It keeps me busy and my sense of independence alive,' she says. Living life without asking for permissions constantly: Sunita Muzumdar (57) 'For me, freedom has always meant making my own decisions—living life without constantly asking for permission or fearing judgment,' says Sunita Muzumdar, 57. Knowledge has been her compass, guiding her to stand up for what she deserves. 'Society's pressures have eased, and the new generation of women no longer gives in all the time.' Sunita's perspective is shaped by the life she sees in her daughter, currently studying abroad. 'She's growing up in a world with possibilities my generation could only dream of,' Sunita says. With a husband in marketing and a daughter leading the way as a flagbearer of Gen Z independence, Sunita views the next generation as both inspiration and promise. Children asking for freedom liberated me too: Bhakti Sharma (52) For 52-year-old Bhakti Sharma, freedom arrived as a mid-life awakening. Raised in a traditional Punjabi family in Amritsar, she had wings in education but limits in opportunity. Her husband designs bomb suits for defence, but for years Bhakti did her own kind of shielding—putting her family's needs ahead of her dream to become a chartered accountant. The turning point came when her grown children asked for their freedom. 'It made me realise how much I had surrendered,' she says. At 45, she enrolled in a skills course alongside students her children's age. 'Freedom isn't about breaking away—it's about reclaiming the parts of yourself you left behind.' Today, she trains others in soft skills, helping them overcome self-doubt and step into their full potential. Make safe choices, protect yourself: Poonam Oswal (52) For Poonam Oswal, 52, Chairperson of JITO Ladies Wing, Pune, freedom isn't just a career choice or economic autonomy—it's also knowing how to protect yourself. 'If you're going out alone, learning to make safe choices is freedom. Trusting your instincts and knowing how to protect yourself gives power. Women must learn to read people, to see who is genuine and who isn't. We are in times when being naive is dangerous. Freedom now also means awareness and courage, not just independence.' Physical, mental well-being true freedom: Mona Lodha (40) Mona Lodha, 40, is one of them. 'I grew up in a home where customs prevailed, yet I knew I wanted a career,' she says. From a national rope Mallakhamb player to an interior designer and now a real estate agent, she has learned that freedom isn't always about dramatic leaps—it is the quiet power to shape your own path. She leads platforms like Inner Wheel, Rotary Club, and JITO in Pune, steering community service and national-level networking. A health crisis in her early 30s deepened her understanding of freedom. 'That experience sharpened my belief that my mental and physical well-being is the truest form of freedom—the ability to live fully and on one's own terms.' Earn own money, live my life my way: Diya Bafna (22) And for Gen Z, freedom is a completely different ballgame—louder, bolder, and unapologetically their own. At 22, Diya Bafna isn't waiting for permission—she's claiming her space with flair. A Pune-based YouTuber and influencer with over 145k Instagram followers, she makes waves across fashion, food, and finance, proving that knowledge and style can go hand in hand. 'Freedom? It's about speaking up, doing your thing, and not letting anyone tell you who to be,' she says. 'I want to make my own choices, earn my own money, and live life my way—no approvals, no judgment.' Bafna is pursuing a PG in Luxury Brand Management while completing her Certified Financial Planning certification. She earns over a lakh a month from her content, enough to fully support herself and reinvest in her ventures. 'I set my own rules—and trust me, that's liberating,' she adds. Her content isn't just lifestyle; it's influenced with intention. Diya blends financial advice with relatable stories, empowering other young women to take control of their money, careers, and choices. Over seven decades after Independence, Indian women have moved from survival to self-expression, from silence to voice, from tradition-bound roles to deliberate choices. And while each generation builds upon the gains of the last, the journey toward full freedom—especially financial freedom—is an ongoing one, empowering women not just to live, but to shape the lives they desire. (Neha Mithun Rathod is an intern with The Indian Express)
Time of India
4 days ago
- Time of India
Breaking the cycle: Becoming the parent you once needed
The parenting revolution: Here's how to raise kids without repeating your own childhood pain (Image: iStock) The way we raise our kids often mirrors how we were raised. If you grew up in the '80s or '90s, you might remember a style of parenting that was heavy on rules and light on conversations. Emotions were not exactly welcome at the dinner table and 'because I said so' was a complete explanation. Our parents did the best they could with what they knew but times have changed and so should our approach. Children today are growing up in an entirely different world. Information is everywhere. Independence comes earlier. Influence seeps in from every screen they hold. Gen Z and the ones coming after them are sharper, more outspoken and more aware than we ever were. In an interview with TOI, Dr Sundeep Kochar, Motivational Speaker, Life Coach, TedX Alumnus and Celebrity Astrologer, shared, "If you grew up feeling invisible or misunderstood, you've been handed a rare gift: the chance to stop that cycle in its tracks. You can choose to parent differently. To be more than a provider. To be the guide you wish you had, the friend you could confide in, the mentor who taught without shaming." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like AI now helps people speak languages fast Talkpal AI Undo Growing up invisible? Here's how to be the parent you always needed (Image: TOI) Kids today don't need someone hovering with a rulebook; they need someone who sees them for who they are. They thrive when they have room to explore, knowing there is a steady hand ready to catch them if they fall. Dr Sundeep Kochar suggested, "Your experience isn't meant to fence them in, it's meant to light the path ahead and here's the thing: children reflect back what you give them. If you speak with kindness, they'll learn kindness. If you listen without jumping in, they'll feel heard. If you love without strings, they'll grow into people who trust without fear. That's how respect is built, not demanded. Wisdom isn't something you lecture into them. It's something they absorb when they feel safe enough to learn from you. So, show them by living it. Be the calm in their storm. Be the one they can turn to without hesitation." Your childhood doesn't define your parenting: Here's how to rewrite the script Many adults today are raising children while still recovering from their own upbringing. They find themselves caught in patterns of harsh discipline, emotional distance or neglect, not because they choose to repeat these cycles but because those patterns are deeply ingrained. Talking about how becoming the parent you never had is not just a healing act for your child, it is a rebirth for your inner self, Dr Mickey Mehta, Global Holistic Health Guru and Spiritual Life Coach, said, "Breaking generational patterns requires self-awareness and conscious effort. Today, it is important that you heal before you parent. Unhealed trauma often shows up as overcontrol, emotional unavailability or projection." Studies in neuroscience reveal that early adverse experiences alter brain pathways but the brain remains plastic. Dr Mickey Mehta advised, "Mindfulness, breathwork, therapy and journalling can help rewire these pathways. When we become present, we respond instead of reacting, creating safer emotional spaces for our children. Parenting starts by observing your child with fresh eyes. Instead of imposing what was imposed on you, ask: 'What does my child need at this moment?' Children are not vessels to be filled but seeds to be nurtured. Every word, every gaze is an affirmation or a wound. In earlier times, children were tightly controlled. Parents imposed their will completely but today, there is a beautiful rebellion in children—a revolution for independence. They are asserting: "We are individuals. We want to do what we want. We want to be free, to be liberated, to make our own choices. Even our mistakes should be our own." They want the space to fall, to rise and to learn through their own experience." Your calm is their safe place: The secret to raising resilient kids (Image: TOI) Many parents come into the role by accident. Yet, accidental parents sometimes become the most wonderful ones because nothing is predefined. When there is a strict structure, a plan or a continuous monitoring mechanism, the natural blossoming of a child is affected. Dr Mickey Mehta asserted, "Children should flower freely to be naturally fragrant, naturally sweetened and naturally colourful. In their fragility lies the true fruition of growth. Being vulnerable and being sensitive is essential. Many adults grew up earning love through performance, good grades, quiet behaviour, obedience. This sets a child on a lifelong chase for approval. Offer unconditional positive regard. Let them fail safely. Validate their emotions without rescuing or judging." Stop parenting from your past, start parenting from their future If parents truly understand the elasticity of the brain, they would not rush their children into fixed time frames or force them into boxes of excellence. Instead, they would allow space for exploration. The expression of childhood, its innocence, wonder and curiosity should be celebrated as the true excellence of upbringing. When we drop constant evaluations and comparisons, we allow the child to be like a butterfly, flying freely among flowers, sipping nectar from wherever they feel called. Dr Mickey Mehta highlighted, "Open, non-judgmental environments become the breeding ground for joyful, grounded and successful children. Success, then, is not defined by report cards or rankings but by how enthusiastically a child wakes up, how peacefully they sleep, how eagerly they cuddle their parents. It's in their willingness to play and to study, to laugh freely, to run towards someone who opens their arms and their heart. You may not always have the right words, but your presence, grounded, calm and non-judgmental, heals more than any technique. Tell them, 'I believe in you,' 'It's okay to feel sad,' 'You are safe with me.' Be their secure base, not their supervisor. Hug longer. Listen deeper. Laugh freely. Allow them to be, not who you want but who they are becoming." Breaking the cycle means becoming conscious of what you lacked, acknowledging what you needed and choosing to give your child the emotional nourishment you missed. Parenting then becomes not a task but a sacred journey of evolving together.
India.com
7 days ago
- India.com
Gen Z Reshapes Campus Culture: Five Nope Moments For Traditional College Norms
College life is the golden chapter that shapes the plot of your entire life: follow the rules, sit through endless lectures, and accept whatever came your way because 'that's the only way of being an ideal student.' Generations before wore it like a badge of honour. But Gen Zs? They're flipping this script like it's last semester's notes. Born between the late '90s and early 2010s, this generation grew up with Wi-Fi faster than campus printers, information just a click away, and the confidence to speak up when something doesn't make sense. They have seen enough change in the world to know that 'tradition' isn't always worth keeping, especially when it's outdated, impractical, or straight-up exhausting. Gen Zs are smart, self-aware, and allergic to unnecessary drama. If something doesn't add value to their learning, growth, or happiness, they won't just complain about that, they question that, challenge that, and sometimes even make a meme. Gen Zs believe that college isn't just about grades or degrees; it's about mental health, creativity, real-world skills, and a campus experience that feels relevant to today, not 1990s. So when old-school campus cultures clash with Gen Z's priorities? It's a clear, unapologetic 'NOPE.' From dress codes that make no sense to lectures that feel like Sleep-o-nomics, they're not shy about calling out what doesn't work. And once Gen Zs say No, that means No with a capital 'N'. Here are five college cultures that Gen Zs say 'not my cup of tea' : 1. Strict Dress Codes Blazers in brain-frying heat? Bans on ripped jeans? Rules against hoodies in winter? Gen Z sees clothing as self-expression, not a punishment tool. For them, comfort is key, if they can't breathe, move, or feel like themselves in what they're wearing, it's a big problem. According to them, dress codes rarely improve academics; they just create unnecessary stress. 2. Endless Theory Lectures Try to Picture this: Three hours in a stuffy classroom, a professor reading off slides in a monotone voice, and zero discussion. In this cringe situation gen Zs mentally check out within minutes. They want interactive sessions, real-world case studies, and projects that actually connect to careers. 'If I can learn it from YouTube in half the time, why am I attending this ?' is a common thought. 3. 75% Mandatory Attendance The 'no 75%, no exams' rule feels like a trap for many students. They believe learning should be about understanding concepts, not physically present in class to fill a quota. Hybrid classes, recorded lectures, and assignment-based evaluations are what they always demand for. 4. Mental Health Lectures (Without Real Help) Mental health awareness is great but Gen Zs can spot token efforts instantly. A one-time lecture and a couple of posters in the hallway are like pelting stones. They want accessible counselors, peer support groups, and spaces where it's safe to talk about stress, anxiety, and burnout. 'Don't just talk about mental health. Support it,' is their message to the institutions. 5. Canteen Lacks Favourite Food It might sound small, but food can make or break a day on campus. When the canteen serves the same oily samosas or plain sandwiches every day, the mood drops. Gen Zs want variety from healthier choices to their comfort foods, and yes, lack of a better cold coffee in campus outlets is one of the biggest disappointments for them. Gen Zs aren't being fussy for no reason. According to them, these changes make college life more relevant, healthier, and less stressful. They believe that campuses should adapt to the times from letting students dress freely, to offering engaging learning, to actually listening when students talk about their needs. And honestly? They have a point. A campus that feeds both the mind and the mood might prove to be the best lecture for happier, motivated and productive learning. Until then, don't be surprised if you hear a lot more 'Nope' on campus.
