Police 'unreasonably' seize vehicle during operation, IPCA finds
Police seized the vehicle in the aim of preventing a woman from re-offending.
Photo:
RNZ / Angus Dreaver
The police watchdog has found Wellington officers unreasonably seized a vehicle in the early hours of the morning during an ongoing police operation against gangs.
Four complaints were made in 2022 and 2023 during Operation Cobalt, which aimed to disrupt gang activity by using police powers to apply for warrants and seize property for unpaid fines.
In its report, the Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA) found police failed to follow the law and didn't understand to properly execute warrants regarding three of the cases reviewed.
In one of the cases, officers were searching for a woman suspected of stealing petrol and her car had been involved in multiple offences over previous months.
Police wanted to prevent her from re-offending that evening and found her vehicle at her partner's grandmother's house.
The woman wasn't there but the car was so police had the vehicle towed at 1:30am and searched the house for the key when her partner didn't comply.
It found police failed to ask for payments before a vehicle was seized, which made three of the seizures unlawful because demanding payment is a legal requirement.
Some of the complainants expressed concern about not being given information on the seizure at the time the warrant was executed.
In two cases, the officers told the complainant the vehicle was to be seized about 10 minutes before they had even got the warrant that would allow them to so.
The report said officers should have warrants before telling someone their property or vehicle was being seized so complainants have legal information they're entitled to.
The summary said none of the officers considered clamping the vehicles, which could have prevented an unnecessary disturbance such as the case where a woman's car was located at her partner's grandmothers place.
The IPCA recommended police have specific training in the law around executing warrants if there's no bailiff present.
Police have acknowledged the findings and have addressed the recommendation by requiring a bailiff to be present during seizures.
Only exception would be unless there is urgency and/or good reason for police to execute the warrant as part of a major event operation or criminal investigation.
Police said in March 2024 it updated its search instructions for officers so they knew and understood their obligations.
The other recommendation was for police to propose to the Minister of Justice that the form of the 'Warrant to Seize Property for Unpaid Fines' be amended accurately to better reflect the law.
Police said it was in the process of engaging with the Ministry of Justice to update an internal form used by officers to accurately reflect the scope of search and seizure powers.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
'He went silent': Fears for NZ nurse Vanron Ngoun missing overseas
Vanron Ngoun, also known as Van, was last heard from in Naples, Italy, on 27 May. Photo: Supplied / Facebook A close friend and flatmate of a 60-year-old Wellington man on holiday in Europe says his family are extremely concerned after not hearing from him for two weeks. Clive Aspin said Wellington Hospital nurse Vanron Ngoun, also known as Van, was last heard from in Naples, Italy, on 27 May. "He was sending us regular updates about his travels and what a great time he was having since he left New Zealand on May 15th. Then suddenly he went silent." Van Ngoun, 2017. Photo: Supplied / Facebook He said Ngoun, who was travelling by himself, had always kept in contact during overseas trips. "It is absolutely, totally out of character. "To suddenly not hear from him is completely unlike him and extremely concerning." He said Ngoun's family in Cambodia also stopped hearing from him on 27 May. "They are deeply concerned. "He has a very close relationship with his sister in Phnom Penh, and she has been trying to contact him but has had no response." He said Ngoun was due to take a flight from Milan to Cambodia via Bangkok and Qatar on 30 May. Aspin wanted authorities to verify whether his friend, a long-time New Zealand resident and Australian citizen, got on that flight. "The level of support from Australian authorities has been almost non-existent. "We want to know they are at least keeping their eyes open for any person with his name that comes to their attention." He said they had also notified police, embassies, and hospitals in Italy, Qatar, Thailand, and New Zealand. He wanted New Zealand police to engage with the International Criminal Police Organisation, Interpol. He urged people living in or travelling through Naples, or anyone with connections in the region, to keep an eye out and contact authorities if they had any information about Ngoun's whereabouts. Van Ngoun, 2015. Photo: Supplied / Facebook A Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade spokesperson confirmed that they were aware of the situation. "We have been in touch with the Australian High Commission in New Zealand and understand that consular assistance is being provided by Australian authorities." Police confirmed they had received a missing person's report. "We have made some initial enquiries as much as we are able. "In the instance of someone reported missing in another country, the matter is ultimately under the jurisdiction of authorities in that country. "Likewise, any consular assistance would be provided by the country of the individual's citizenship." Police said they would potentially look to engage with Interpol in the coming days if no further leads emerged. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said Ngoun travelled on an Australian passport and that his disappearance is incredibly worrying and concerning for his family and friends. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Council chief executive warns of abuse, harassment of elected members
Police have assured Clive Manley they will take harrassment complaints very seriously. Photo: Ruapehu District Council A district council chief executive fears the abuse directed at elected members is putting people off running for office - and it is time to call it out. A 2022 Local Government New Zealand survey found nearly half of elected members nationwide had faced some form of abuse. Ruapehu District Council chief executive Clive Manley said his region was no different and, although he didn't want to talk about individual cases, he said some councillors had been harrassed, both in person and online, for speaking out. "They can end up with a lot of personal attacks and comments, whether they are women or [older] or whatever," he said. "We should be able to robustly engage on a topic and come up with a good solution, without the fear they they are going to be personally attacked. "Without going into details, individuals get called out for who they are, rather than what they are speaking about, and that's totally wrong." The survey found 43 percent of elected members experienced harassment, prejudice or threatening behaviour . Half of them faced harassment in their communities, and a third encountered abuse while shopping or picking up children from school. Manley said much of the abuse directed at his councillors came from "a small group of repeat offenders", especially online. "As we head into the election period, we won't hesitate to ban people from council's Facebook page, if they cannot engage respectfully." He was speaking out about the issue, because - as council chief executive - he wanted to encourage anyone considering standing to feel confident doing so. "Council is committed to supporting elected members and candidates stand for election, and serve their community. There are resources available to help people run a safe and successful campaign, and to continue their work safely once elected." He said the tools included guidance on protecting privacy, staying safe in public and online, managing social media interactions, reporting abuse, and accessing support services and counselling. He had also discussed the issue with local police. "They have confirmed they will take any complaints of harassment or abuse extremely seriously." Manley said public office needed diversity and anyone considering standing in Ruapehu for the local elections should feel confident they'll be supported by council. "Local government is about working with local communities and addressing issues locally, and we want the best possible candidates standing, not thinking 'if I do this, I'm going to get harassed in the supermarket, or in the street or where I work'." "I encourage everyone who wants to make a difference to their community to put their hand up and stand for these positions, whether it's central or local, and know we do need a diversity of view to make the place better." Nominations for local elections open on 4 July. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Wanted man found in Auckland after pursuit of stolen vehicle
Police pursued a car flagged as stolen in Auckland, locating a wanted man after the vehicle was stopped. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Police arrested a man wanted in Waikato after stopping a vehicle flagged a stolen in Auckland on Sunday. Waikato Police said the man wanted by them was thought to be in Tokoroa but had contacts across Waikato, Bay of Plenty and Auckland. In a statement, police said they were alerted by traffic cameras to a vehicle they said was stolen, travelling on State Highway 20 across South Auckland at 9.35am. "The driver was signalled to stop but initially refused to do so. Eventually the driver did stop on a street in New Lynn, and was arrested." Meanwhile, the passenger got into the driver's seat and drove off, police claimed. "The Police Eagle helicopter, which was overhead, tracked the vehicle a short distance before the second driver abandoned the vehicle on a side street." He was also arrested. The first man, a 27-year-old, is due in Auckland District Court on Monday on a charge of unlawfully taking a motor vehicle, as well as breaching his conditions. The second man, aged 22, is also due in Auckland District Court tomorrow on driving-related charges. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
