Sisulu Foundation slams Ntshavheni's ‘coup' remarks as ‘deeply irresponsible and dangerous'
Image: GCIS
The Walter and Albertina Sisulu Foundation has harshly criticised Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni for her recent comments that South Africa's security services had detected 'potential coup risks,' calling her statement 'deeply irresponsible, dangerous, and, in the current political climate, reckless in the extreme.'
'To utter such claims on the parliamentary record - without presenting evidence, without a public briefing, and without accountability - is not merely careless, it verges on fear-mongering by executive design,' the foundation said in a statement.
The statement followed Ntshavheni's remarks at a media briefing after she tabled the budget vote for the State Security Agency in the National Assembly.
She said the National Intelligence Estimate and redacted National Security Strategy for the sixth administration identified a possible coup d'état as a national security risk.
'You need to identify and mitigate against it,' Ntshavheni said.
'One of the risks is the risk of a coup d'état. We have identified it and put measures in place to mitigate against it.'
She emphasised that there had been no recent coup attempts, but said 'there are' people planning such actions.
'We continuously monitor them and make sure we deal with them,' she said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
Ntshavheni also explained that intelligence agencies are not responsible for making arrests, but rather for providing the groundwork for law enforcement.
'We rely on law enforcement agencies to make the arrests… We would have made the spade work.'
However, the foundation said that Ntshavheni's comments come at a politically charged time, shortly after President Cyril Ramaphosa placed Police Minister Senzo Mchunu - an ally of Ramaphosa - on special paid leave amid allegations of political interference and obstruction of criminal investigations.
'Mchunu's suspension followed explosive claims by KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, who bravely revealed a web of collusion between police leadership, political elites, and organised criminal syndicates,' the foundation said.
'Instead of responding with clarity, urgency, or reform, the government has done what it increasingly does when under pressure: create a diversion - and what better distraction than the specter of a coup?'
The foundation said Ntshavheni's statement risks undermining both national stability and investor confidence.
'For a senior cabinet minister to casually mention 'potential coup risks' without any supporting detail or national security update risks inciting fear and breeding suspicion,' it said.
'It projects instability, even where none may exist, and it reinforces the worst fears of many - that this administration is willing to play loose with facts, weaponize paranoia, and erode democratic norms in a transparent, but dangerous, attempt to manage internal political fallout.'
The foundation stressed that Ntshavheni's comments were made as public scrutiny over the president's handling of the police crisis reached a boiling point.
'The appointment of a non-MP acting police minister (within his powers), the creation of yet another judicial commission (the fifth of his presidency), and the president's silence on Phala Phala have already enraged citizens.'
On Tuesday, Ramaphosa named Mineral Resources Minister Gwede Mantashe as acting minister of police while retaining his current portfolio.
Professor Firoz Cachalia, who is set to retire from the University of the Witwatersrand, will assume the role permanently in August.
This follows allegations by Mkhwanazi, who accused Deputy Police Commissioner Lieutenant General Shadrack Sibiya of colluding with information peddler Brown Mogotsi and Mchunu to dismantle the task team investigating political killings in KwaZulu-Natal.
In response, both Mchunu and Sibiya were placed on special leave. Ramaphosa also announced a judicial commission of inquiry to probe the allegations.
The foundation went on to argue that Ntshavheni's 'coup narrative' may function as a deliberate attempt to distract the public and Parliament from holding leadership accountable.
'Instead of answers, we get an unverified claim of a coup attempt, floated in the most public forum of the land, then immediately dropped with no follow-up,' it said.
'This is not governance. It's governance by gaslight, and most disturbing of all, a disdainful display of continued disrespect for the South African people.'
It also expressed concern that Ntshavheni's vague language might indirectly cast doubt on Mkhwanazi, the whistleblower whose testimony has kept the public talking.
'Her vague and ominous language, unaccompanied by evidence or clarification, could feed speculation that the commissioner himself could be viewed as a threat - an outrageous and potentially defamatory insinuation.'
'This less than subtle but loaded messaging creates public doubt, discredits a whistleblower, and may serve to sully Mkhwanazi's character and undercut his growing public support.'
If that was the implication, the foundation said, Ntshavheni's remarks could amount to a violation of her constitutional oath.
'As a minister, Ntshavheni is constitutionally bound under Schedule 2 to be faithful to the Republic, uphold the Constitution, and serve with integrity,' the foundation said.
'Using her platform in Parliament to undermine a credible whistleblower, distort the national conversation, and deflect from political accountability is not only unethical, but it also borders on a breach of the constitutional duty to act in the public interest.'
Furthermore, it warned that Ntshavheni's statement might taint the legitimacy of the judicial commission tasked with probing the alleged criminal infiltration of the justice system.
'A commission operating under the cloud of a supposed coup could be politically tainted from the outset, constrained in its independence, or misdirected in its mandate,' the statement read.
The foundation called on Parliament to exercise its oversight powers.
'Ntshavheni must be called to account for her statements. If she has the intelligence to substantiate her remarks, she must provide it. If she does not, then her words should be withdrawn - and censured.'
'The legislature must reclaim its oversight function and reassert the supremacy of constitutional order over political theatre.'
simon.majadibodu@iol.co.za
IOL Politics
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
SA sees ‘dramatic' increase in munition exports in last three months — here is where they went
The committee approved 283 export permits for munitions, valued at just under R5 billion. The South African defence industry continues to grow along with the demand for products produced in the country. On Friday, the National Conventional Arms Control Committee (NCACC) briefed the Joint Standing Committee on Defence on the 2025 first and second quarter reports. The current committee, headed by Minister in the Presidency, Khumbudzo Ntshavheni, was appointed by President Cyril Ramaphosa in October last year. The committee, comprising 11 ministers and deputy ministers, will serve a five-year term. According to Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and NCACC Deputy Chairperson Andries Nel, the committee has held nine meetings since then. It has issued 129 registration permits, nine marketing permits, and 138 contracting permits, valued at R33 billion. Munition permits The committee has issued 461 conventional munition export permits, valued at R5.8 billion, and 149 permits for the export of dual-use items, valued at R466 million. 'The committee is fully functional and seized with discharging its duties in terms of the Conventional Arms Control Act. This does not mean there are no challenges. The committee is attempting to address these challenges through developing a standard operating procedure to guide its work and modernising and digitising the processing of applications,' said Nel. ALSO READ: Reserve Force members allegedly defraud cash-strapped SANDF of R1.1 million Between January 2025 and June 2025, the committee approved 90 registration certificates and one marketing [the promotion of conventional arms and any negotiation of a tender, advertising, shows, exhibitions or giving of information relating to conventional arms]. It approved 85 contracting permits valued at R17.2 billion. The committee approved 283 export permits for munitions, valued at just under R5 billion. According to Nel, 79 permits for the export of dual-use items [products, technology, services and other goods which, besides their normal use and application for civilian purposes, can also be used for the furtherance of general military capability] were approved, valued at R287 million. Nel said 165 import permits were approved, valued at R156 million. 'The committee's work is accelerating. During the second quarter, 56 companies were registered, compared to 34 during the first quarter,' he said. 'The value of contracting permits approved was R9.3 billion during the second quarter. This is compared to R7.9 billion during the first quarter. ALSO READ: Motshekga dismisses allegations of 'rampant ill-discipline' in SANDF 'The most dramatic increase was the export of munitions. During the second quarter, this stood at R4.9 billion compared to R907 million during the first quarter.' Exports of arms The industry continues to export arms to different regions, with Europe being the biggest importer of South African-produced munitions. Between January 2025 and March 2025, Europe imported the biggest share of South African-produced munitions, at 59%. This was followed by the Middle East at 30% and Australasia at 11%. ALSO READ: Why South Africa can't defend itself anymore During the same period, the Americas were the largest importers of South African-produced dual-use goods and technologies, accounting for 65%. This was followed by the Middle East at 15%, Europe at 14% and Africa at 5%. Between April 2025 and June 2025, Europe remained the largest importer of munitions, accounting for 52%. This was followed by Africa, which recorded the highest increase, at 35%, from 1% in the previous quarter, and the Americas at 7%. The largest importer of dual-use goods and technologies during this quarter was Africa, accounting for 54%. This was followed by the Americas, with 36%, and the Middle East, with 6%. 'The industry we are regulating makes a considerable contribution to economic growth, development, and the retention of skills and innovation,' said Nel. READ NEXT: SA's military proves resilience despite the odds


Mail & Guardian
a day ago
- Mail & Guardian
Operation Vulindlela: Big on policy but low on results
Mixed bag: President Cyril Ramaphosa's Operation Vulindlela is stronger on policy than implementation. Photo: GCIS The government's flagship economic reform programme, Operation Vulindlela, has registered modest progress in the second phase of its roll-out — particularly in visa reform — but faces mounting criticism for delays in key infrastructure areas and a lack of transparency in outcomes and expenditure. The latest These visa reforms aim to 'attract skills, investment and tourism through a streamlined and modernised visa system'. The home affairs department has also upgraded its digital verification system to enable remote authentication and reduce downtime — a step toward building a digital identity system. Yet the gains made in visa systems are in contrast to widespread delays in fixing constraints in water and sanitation, electricity and freight logistics. Most work so far has been legislative, with little tangible implementation. Operation Vulindlela, initiated during President Cyril Ramaphosa's first term, aims to boost economic growth through structural reform. Ramaphosa has touted the operation as a key achievement, and in his latest 'The reduction in load-shedding over the past year was supported by the reforms we introduced to unlock private investment in electricity generation, while reforms in the telecommunications sector have brought down the cost of mobile data,' he wrote. Launched in May after cabinet approval, But despite policy work being under way in several areas — with the Electricity Regulation Amendment Bill, the Water Action Plan, the Digital Transformation Roadmap and the Local Government White Paper among the documents drafted — implementation remains limited. The progress report itself concedes that of the seven priority areas in phase two, only visa reform has moved into tangible outcomes. The electricity sector reform includes the establishment of the National Transmission Company of SA, which will eventually separate power utility Eskom's grid from generation and distribution. The government has also finalised a national wheeling framework to enable third-party access to the grid. Yet, the new transmission company still awaits licensing as a market operator. The National Energy Regulator of SA is also finalising market codes for private wholesale. Legal adviser and social activist Nkanyiso Ngqulunga was scathing in his assessment, saying Operation Vulindlela represents an acceleration of neoliberal policies that are proving counterproductive. 'It has been a complete failure. The unbundling of Eskom has not yielded any positive results but rather put the country's energy generation into the private sector,' Ngqulunga said, adding that the reforms have not attracted the promised investment. 'It hasn't attracted investment as intended. We are implementing policies that have been proven to fail — allowing the private sector in with the hope that it will boost the economy is counterintuitive.' Ngqulunga believes the government should focus on building state capacity and investing in public infrastructure. 'We need to unlock opportunities by empowering public assets,' he said. 'At a time when the government is underperforming, geopolitical tensions are high and tariff wars are growing, it's misguided to think these reforms will attract investment.' In logistics, a new Transnet Rail Infrastructure Manager division has been created to modernise operations and enable private operator access. In December, the rail, port and pipeline parastatal released network access tariffs and received 98 slot applications from private freight operators. Conditional awards will be announced by 15 August. Ntokozo Buthelezi, an economist and researcher, is concerned about the Vulindlela initiative's accountability. 'I remember from the budget speech, the minister mentioned phase two and I wondered what happened to phase one,' she said, adding that she found it to be 'vague' with regard to outcomes and money spent. 'We don't know what happened, how much was spent and what the outcomes were. There is so much secrecy — we have no clue as the public on how investment and loans are spent by the government,' she said, also criticising the absence of oversight. 'They don't tell us much. It's just numbers — billions here, billions there — but no tangible outcomes.'

IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Ramaphosa leads high-level talks on Northern Cape's development agenda
President Cyril Ramaphosa convenes meeting to boost Northern Cape's economic development Image: GCIS President Cyril Ramaphosa has convened a high-level meeting with the Northern Cape Provincial Executive, stressing the importance of collaborative governance and strategic projects to accelerate economic development and improve service delivery across the province. The engagement, held under the theme 'A Nation that Works for All,' marks the sixth formal dialogue between the national government and provincial authorities, following similar discussions with Limpopo, Mpumalanga, KwaZulu-Natal, Gauteng, and the Eastern Cape. Ramaphosa, accompanied by ministers and deputy ministers, met with Northern Cape Premier Dr Zamani Saul, provincial executive members, and mayors from the five district municipalities. In his address, Ramaphosa highlighted the significance of working together across government levels. 'Advancing cooperative governance is mandated by our Constitution. As the Government of National Unity, we see this as an important part of building a capable, ethical, and developmental state.' He elaborated on the challenges that have historically hampered progress, including 'working in silos' and 'parachuted development,' where projects are initiated at the national level without sufficient local consultation or relevance. 'These challenges have been time-consuming and costly, and they have contributed to a widening trust deficit between government and communities,' he explained. The President praised the Northern Cape as a 'pioneer and frontier of innovation,' citing its leadership in renewable energy and green hydrogen projects. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ A 2022 Pulitzer Centre profile described the province as South Africa's emerging economic powerhouse, especially in the clean energy revolution. Ramaphosa suggested that: 'Once the energy transition unfolds as envisaged, the Northern Cape could be the new heartbeat of the economy.' The province's Green Hydrogen Masterplan is a core component of this vision, promising significant regional and global economic benefits. Ramaphosa noted ongoing multilateral discussions and business forums that position South Africa as a leader in renewable energy, calling the Northern Cape 'a critical driver of this transition.' He said that the province aims to develop beyond energy as an industrial hub, leveraging traditional sectors like mining and expanding into special economic zones, industrial parks, and infrastructure projects such as port and rail upgrades. According to the 2024 Provincial Socio-Economic Review by the National Treasury, despite positive economic indicators, persistent challenges remain, including rising poverty levels, declining access to basic services, and high youth unemployment. Ramaphosa acknowledged fiscal constraints impacting municipal projects such as disaster response, land restitution, rural electrification, and public housing. He stressed the need for innovative funding mechanisms, citing examples like the Northern Cape Industrial Corridor, the R1 billion housing initiative, and the Kimberley Big Hole precinct. 'We urgently need to reexamine the current delivery models to enable regulatory approval and investment activation,' he said. The meeting also focused on the importance of integrated planning between national, provincial, and local governments, including state-owned enterprises as key stakeholders. The President emphasised aligning provincial plans with national priorities through the District Development Model and Medium-Term Development Plan. Climate change preparedness, municipal debt management, revenue collection, and leveraging tourism assets were critical issues for discussion. 'These are among the issues that we will deliberate on today,' Ramaphosa stated, highlighting the government's commitment to addressing the province's challenges. This engagement underscores the government's ongoing efforts to foster cooperative governance and unlock the Northern Cape's vast economic potential. IOL Politics