Life atop China's car market is starting to look shaky for BYD
BYD's monthly sales have stagnated of late and with the summer months being a traditionally slower time for consumer purchases, that trajectory isn't expected to reverse any time soon.
Discounting is also now being looked sternly upon by Beijing, with China last week pledging to rein in "irrational competition' in the electric vehicle sector, reflecting authorities' wish to tackle the deflationary price wars that are threatening economic and industrial growth.
Some of BYD's international forays are also proving more challenging than expected, raising the question: is China's No. 1 automaker on shaky ground?
The Shenzhen-based behemoth currently looks like it will undershoot its annual sales target for 2025, in what would be a rare miss after a multi-year bull run. The number of electric and hybrid vehicles BYD needs to sell each month through December has hit 560,000 units, in excess of levels it could hope to achieve typically in a single month. The most vehicles BYD has ever sold in a month was just shy of 515,000, in December last year.
Analysts are now doubting whether BYD can hit 5.5 million units in 2025. Consensus estimates continue to be downgraded.
A Xiaomi YU7 electric SUV on display at one of the company's stores in Shanghai on June 5 |
Bloomberg
Morgan Stanley last month lowered its projection to 5.3 million, pointing to a smaller number of new models, while Bloomberg Intelligence's Joanne Chen says BYD will need to sacrifice some profit and maintain its hefty discounting in the second half if it wants to stay on track.
"Regulatory scrutiny will temper direct cuts to vehicle sticker prices but competition isn't going away and retail promotions are still needed to sustain sales momentum,' she said. "New model roll outs and steady tech upgrade are also crucial.'
Bing Yuan, a fund manager at Edmond de Rothschild Asset Management, said many market watchers now realistically expect sales of around 5 million. "My sense is that is the consensus,' she said.
Stripping out overseas and commercial sales, BYD's core car deliveries in China are shrinking. In June, they slipped 8% year-on-year as vehicles from brands like Geely, Xpeng and Xiaomi won over buyers. HSBC data shows that Geely was the largest gainer of market share in the first half, while BYD was among the biggest losers.
Overseas sales are faring better and those are looking on target to reach BYD's forecast of 800,000. Indeed, BYD is already almost 60% of the way there. But while higher margin international sales will help BYD offset aggressive domestic discounting, some foreign markets are presenting new difficulties.
BYD has grand plans for Saudi Arabia, for example, hoping to triple its footprint after Tesla entered the country. But EVs account for just over 1% of total car sales in the kingdom, with high costs, sparse charging infrastructure and extreme temperatures challenging EV adoption.
India, a potentially huge market, has meanwhile consistently blocked BYD's efforts to expand and despite rapid growth from a low base in Europe, there are substantial tariff headwinds and increasing competition from legacy automakers that already have consumers' trust, not to mention more extensive after-sales networks.
At home, regulatory scrutiny has also intensified around BYD as it continues to be at the fore of an EV price war. In late May, it slashed prices by as much as 34%, triggering renewed sector-wide discounts. Its moves were later discouraged in a veiled warning by the Chinese Communist Party's mouthpiece the People's Daily, which slammed the "rat-race competition.'
Whether Beijing can actually stop price discounting by a privately held company is a point of debate.
Tianlei Huang, a China program coordinator at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, said authorities may resort to administrative tools such as price reviews or cost investigations to establish a de facto price floor, or coordinate a concerted capacity reduction among leading EV makers, although he acknowledged those measures won't be easy.
Regardless, BYD must be careful. As the company gears up to release first-half results later next month and July sales data within weeks, analysts will have their spreadsheets at the ready, waiting to see whether those 2025 targets look even further in the distance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Nikkei Asia
2 hours ago
- Nikkei Asia
EU-China ties at 'inflection point,' von der Leyen says after tense Beijing summit
BEIJING, July 24 (Reuters) -- EU-China trade ties have hit a "clear inflection point," European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said on Thursday in Beijing, capping a tense summit with top Chinese leaders dominated by concerns on commerce and the Ukraine war. Expectations were low for the summit in the Chinese capital marking 50 years of diplomatic ties after weeks of escalating tension and wrangling that led to the duration being abruptly halved to a single day at Beijing's request. "We have very frankly and openly raised our concerns ... on the trade, investment and geopolitical issues. ... We have partially identified solutions," von der Leyen told a press conference after meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Qiang. When asked about a potential trade deal with the United States, the EU chief said the bloc's focus has been on achieving a negotiated solution but all other instruments are on the table until "we have a satisfactory result." "Our relationship with China is of importance, but it stands on its own merits. It's independent of the actions or issues we have with others," she said. Xi earlier told von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa that the challenges facing Europe do not come from China, urging the bloc to "properly handle differences and frictions." "It is hoped that the European side will keep the trade and investment market open and refrain from using restrictive economic and trade tools," Xi said, according to the official Xinhua News Agency. EU trade actions in the past year have targeted Chinese exports of electric vehicles, among other goods, and its officials have repeatedly complained about Chinese industrial overcapacity as the bloc's trade deficit with China ballooned to a historic 305.8 billion euros ($360 billion) last year. Von der Leyen told the press that the Chinese leadership has started to look into the overcapacity issue and expressed willingness to support more consumption. "We think increasing market access for European companies in China, limiting the external impact of involution, and reducing export controls are important steps forward," she told Premier Li earlier, according to a pool report. She described her meeting with Xi as "excellent." The two sides also issued a joint statement on climate, reiterating their commitment to new climate action plans across the whole economy. They will boost cooperation in areas such as energy transition, adaptation, methane emissions management and control, carbon markets, and green and low-carbon technologies, the joint statement said. At the start of U.S. President Donald Trump's second term, both sides had more of a consensus in working together to tackle trade challenges from the United States, said Cui Hongjian, a foreign policy professor at Beijing Foreign Studies University. "Recently the situation has changed," Cui said. "The EU has continued to compromise with the United States, which means that there is currently a lack of impetus for EU-China ties to become closer." After intense negotiations, the EU is likely to seal a trade deal with the United States for a broad tariff of 15% on its exports, down from 30% threatened by Trump. At Thursday's summit, the EU leaders also conveyed their expectations for China to discourage Russia in its war against Ukraine. "What's important is that we have a ceasefire and negotiations at the table take place, that there is a true and genuine willingness to find solutions to end the bloodshed," von der Leyen said at the press conference. Topics the Europeans brought up in the talks also included China's rare-earth export controls that disrupted supply chains worldwide, causing temporary stoppages in European automotive production lines in May. "We need reliable and secure supplies of critical raw materials from China ... we acknowledge China's efforts on fast-tracking licenses for critical raw materials, and we agreed to have an upgraded export supply mechanism," von der Leyen said. China's exports of rare-earth magnets to the EU surged in June by 245% from May, to stand at 1,364 metric tons, though that was still 35% lower than the year-earlier figure, customs data showed. On Thursday, China's Foreign Ministry defended the rare-earths curbs as being "in line with international practice," while pledging stronger dialogue and cooperation with relevant countries and regions in the field of export controls.
NHK
6 hours ago
- NHK
Experts assess impact of US-Japan trade deal
Both countries claimed wins as Japan pledged billions in US investment and Trump slashed import duties on Japanese cars. But tariffs could still hurt Japan's economy.
Japan Times
6 hours ago
- Japan Times
‘Mr. Japan' bends the knee — and falls on his sword
"Mr. Japan' finally has his trade deal, after three months of talks. It looks like it will be his final act. After a third successive blow from the Japanese electorate, Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba blinked in trade talks with the U.S. He spent months seeking a complete removal of the levies that U.S. President Donald Trump held over the country, including those already imposed on cars. "We will never accept tariffs, especially on autos,' Ishiba said in May, declaring the issue his red line. With vehicles long the main source of Trump's ire — perhaps understandably, given that they account for more than three-quarters of the trade deficit — getting the president to back down was always going to be a tough ask, especially considering Japan's lack of leverage. But after Sunday's hammering in the Upper House election, which has left the prime minister with a minority in both houses of parliament and arguably the worst electoral record of any Liberal Democratic Party leader in history, Ishiba has seemingly accepted his fate. That's why he agreed to the deal that will include 15% tariffs across the board, including on cars. With this last piece of business concluded, local media indicates that less than a year into his term, Ishiba will soon announce his resignation. (The prime minister has subsequently denied the reports, which were made by multiple independent outlets.) Trade envoy and close aide Ryosei Akazawa painted a positive picture. It was "mission completed' in the tariff talks, he cheerfully said in a post on X, pointing to a picture hung in the White House of Ishiba and Trump speaking at the Group of Seven meeting in Canada. He also denied any link between the agreement and the election results. Certainly markets were pleased, with automakers surging after being freed from months of uncertainty. Toyota Motor rose by the most in nearly 40 years; the Topix headed for an all-time high. And perhaps it's as good a deal as Japan could expect. As with all these agreements, the devil is in the details: It still puts a 15% levy across the board on imports. While that's less than the 25% "reciprocal' tariff that was threatened, and most importantly less than the 25% already imposed on auto imports in May, it'll still be damaging for exporters. There's an odd promise of $550 billion in investment in the U.S. and a more logical agreement for Japan to buy more U.S. rice. The part about Japan opening "to trade including cars and trucks' is confusing, given that there are no barriers currently in place. But perhaps Ishiba has done what he should have in the beginning and simply told Trump what he wants to hear — knowing it won't, indeed can't, be delivered. But the agreement also removes the last piece of leverage the prime minister had left — the "national crisis' he said must be prioritized ahead of infighting. That's been enough to keep the target off his back until now. But after Sunday's results, it's clear he can't be allowed to do any more harm. In just 10 months, his weak leadership has resulted in an unstable political landscape that threatens to damage Japan for years. Conservative voters have deserted the LDP in droves — and headed to some disturbingly populist places. The landscape is so fractured that there also isn't a viable opposition to take over, meaning the forecast is for parliamentary gridlock. That's why the LDP needs to win voters back. With the trade deal about to be done, Ishiba should leave as as soon as possible. Many conservatives are eyeing the anniversary of the end of World War II next month, fearing he will further alienate right-leaning voters by undoing the groundbreaking statement by former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on the 70th anniversary a decade ago. It's not Ishiba's fault that relations with the U.S. have been so tarnished. That blame lies with Trump. And by removing the uncertainty around tariffs, he will finally have done some good for the country. But he will leave Japan in a weaker position than when he took office — and in search of direction once again. Gearoid Reidy is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering Japan and the Koreas.
