BREAKING NEWS Colorado dentist wipes his crocodile tears as murder trial hears why he poisoned his wife's protein shakes
The father-of-six, James Craig, is accused of using lethal concoctions including tetrahydrozoline, an ingredient used in eye drops, to murder his wife of 23 years, Angela Craig.
James, 47, was having an affair and allegedly poisoned Angela while waiting for his mistress to visit.
Prosecutors said he swapped her medication with the poison in a calculated effort to free himself from a marriage in which he described feeling 'trapped,' 'hopeless' and 'helpless.'
The jury also heard that James tricked a relative into giving his wife a prescription he said the hospital ordered. However, he swapped out the pills and lied about the prescription.
Angela, 43, suffered mysterious symptoms - lethargy, dizziness, vomiting - beginning on March 6, 2023. She died on March 18. James was arrested the following day and has been in jail since.
He was tearful when his defense attorney mentioned his family's trips to Disneyland and Angela calling him a 'doting' husband.
He pleaded not guilty to several charges, including first-degree murder, two counts of solicitation to commit perjury and solicitation to commit murder.
Appearing in court clean-shaven and in a charcoal suit, James looked markedly different from earlier hearings where he wore an orange prison uniform and had unkempt hair.
He watched silently as some of his children and other relatives filed into the courtroom, at times dabbing his eyes as prosecutors described his wife's slow death.
Assistant District Attorney Ryan Brackley told jurors James poisoned Angela using arsenic, tetrahydrozoline and cyanide.
He claimed James entered her hospital room alone - not to help her recover but to 'deliberately and intentionally end her life.'
Prosecutors outlined his alleged motives: financial troubles and a string of extramarital affairs.
He and Angela had filed for bankruptcy in 2021, and James was active on 'sugar daddy' websites, where he falsely claimed to be worth $10 million.
Four women - including a Texas orthodontist he met at a Las Vegas dental conference weeks before Angela became ill - are expected to testify.
Text messages between James and his mistress Karin Cain shown to the court revealed more than 4,000 exchanges, 80 declarations of love and even a song he allegedly wrote for her.
Prosecutors say James lied to Cain, claiming he was already divorced and living alone.
Suspicion mounted when a dental practice employee discovered cyanide in a package addressed to James and alerted his business partner.
The defense, however, painted a different picture. They described Angela as a 'broken' woman struggling with isolation and mental illness and said the couple's marriage had been 'broken for years.' They admitted James had multiple affairs but argued this was not motive for murder.
'Dr. Craig wasn't a good husband. You may not like him,' defense attorney Ashley Whitham told jurors. 'But this case isn't about whether he's likable or moral. It's about whether the prosecution can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he murdered his wife.'
They also urged jurors to be skeptical of testimony from jailhouse informants, calling them 'snitches' with motives of their own.
'This is a tragedy. Six children lost their mother, and Dr. Craig lost his wife of 23 years,' the defense said. 'But sympathy cannot be part of your verdict.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Peter Falconio's killer did not disclose location of body before dying
The killer of British backpacker Peter Falconio did not reveal where the remains of his victim are prior to his death, according to police in Australia. Bradley John Murdoch was convicted in 2005 of murdering Mr Falconio, 28, and assaulting his girlfriend Joanne Lees at gunpoint on a remote stretch of road near Barrow Creek in Australia's Northern Territory on July 14 2001. Mr Falconio and Ms Lees, both from Yorkshire, were travelling across the country in a camper van when they were ambushed by Murdoch on the Stuart Highway, an isolated road that runs through the centre of Australia. Murdoch was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment without parole for at least 28 years. Murdoch, 67, was diagnosed with terminal throat cancer in 2019 and was moved to palliative care from Alice Springs Correctional Centre last month, according to local media reports. The Northern Territory Department of Corrections confirmed that Murdoch died in hospital in Alice Springs. A spokesperson said: 'The death will be subject to investigation by the Northern Territory Coroner. 'No further comment at this time.' Northern Territory Police Force said Murdoch did not provide any fresh information about the location of Mr Falconio's body prior to his death. In a statement the force said: 'The Northern Territory Police Force acknowledges the death of Bradley John Murdoch, the man convicted of the 2001 murder of British backpacker Peter Falconio near Barrow Creek. 'It is deeply regrettable that Murdoch has died without, as far as we are aware, ever disclosing the location of Peter Falconio's remains. 'His silence has denied the Falconio family the closure they have so long deserved. 'Our thoughts are with the Falconio family in the United Kingdom, whose grief continues.' The statement continued: 'The Northern Territory Police Force remains committed to resolving this final piece of the investigation. 'We continue to appeal to anyone who may have information that could lead us to Peter Falconio's remains to come forward, no matter how small the detail may seem. 'A reward of up to 500,000 Australia dollars (£243,650) is available to anyone providing information that leads to the discovery of Peter Falconio's remains.' Mr Falconio and Ms Lees had been driving near the tiny settlement of Barrow Creek, around 188 miles north of Alice Springs, when Murdoch pulled up beside them claiming to have seen sparks coming from their van. He shot Mr Falconio in the head as he inspected the vehicle, before forcing Ms Lees into his vehicle and binding her wrists with cable ties. She managed to escape, hiding in the Outback for hours before flagging down a passing truck. During the trial, prosecutors argued that Murdoch was likely to have disposed of the backpacker's body somewhere in the vast, remote expanse of desert between Alice Springs and Broome, covering more than 1,200 miles. Despite repeated searches, Mr Falconio's body has never been found. Ms Lees, who returned to the UK, told Australian current affairs programme 60 Minutes in 2017 that she still wanted to 'bring him home'. 'Pete lost his life on that night, but I lost mine too,' she said at the time. 'I'll never be fully at peace if Pete's not found, but I accept that that is a possibility.' Murdoch lodged several unsuccessful appeals over the years, with Australia's highest court refusing to hear his case in 2007.
Sky News
36 minutes ago
- Sky News
Robin Kaye: American Idol TV executive and her husband shot dead inside their Los Angeles home
An American Idol TV executive and her husband have been found dead in their LA home. Robin Kaye was a music supervisor on the long-running reality TV series. The bodies of the 70-year-old and her husband Thomas were discovered after officers conducted a welfare check at their home. Both had died from gunshot wounds. Detectives say Raymond Boodarian has been arrested in connection with their deaths. It is alleged the 22-year-old had burgled their property while they were away on 10 July - killing the couple upon their return. According to Los Angeles Police, there were "no signs of forced entry or trouble" at the property. Ms Kaye was an industry veteran - and had previously worked on shows including Lip Sync Battle and The Singing Bee, as well as several Miss USA and Miss Universe pageants. In a statement, an American Idol spokesperson said: "Robin has been a cornerstone of the Idol family since 2009 and was truly loved and respected by all who came in contact with her.
Daily Mail
40 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Workmate claims alleged killer planned to 'roofie' murder victim after she broke up with him
An accused murderer planned to drug his ex-girlfriend and crash her in a car so he could scare her out of taking their house, one of his workmates claims. Benjamin O'Keefe told the Victorian Supreme Court that Lachlan Young shared his plan to harm his former partner Hannah McGuire on April 2, 2024. 'He started talking about wanting to roofie Hannah and take her out bush and scare her so she wouldn't take the house and other things from him,' Mr O'Keefe said in evidence on Tuesday. Mr O'Keefe claimed Young asked him to act as a getaway driver, which he ultimately declined after speaking to his girlfriend. Two days later, Mr O'Keefe said he received another message from Young asking him to meet at a nearby corner at midnight. Mr O'Keefe told the jury he went to the designated spot without his phone but Young wasn't there so he returned home. He then heard a car horn and went to his front lawn to see Young waiting inside an orange Mitsubishi Triton. Mr O'Keefe told the jury he did not look inside the ute and instead just obeyed Young's instructions to follow behind in his vehicle. He claimed they went out to remote bushland where Young drove the Triton into some trees and then ordered Mr O'Keefe to turn his car around. Young then used a yellow blow torch to set fire to the front of the Triton, Mr O'Keefe told the jury. After holding the blowtorch there for a few minutes, it's alleged Young then returned to Mr O'Keefe's car but told him to wait a minute. '(We were) just watching the car to make sure it caught on fire,' Mr O'Keefe told the jury. 'That's what Lachie wanted.' Mr O'Keefe claimed Young gave him $45 after the incident although he never explained why. Young is accused of murdering Ms McGuire in the early hours of April 5, before driving her body in the Triton to remote bushland and setting the ute alight. The 23-year-old has admitted to killing Ms McGuire but denies the charge of murder, claiming her death was a spontaneous and unplanned incident. In his opening address, defence barrister Glenn Casement told the jury they should be critical of Mr O'Keefe's evidence, saying he was not a credible witness. Mr Casement is expected to cross-examine Mr O'Keefe on Wednesday after senior crown prosecutor Kristie Churchill finishes her questioning. Lifeline 13 11 14
