
Radical statement or eyesore? Japan's divisive brutalist buildings
Emerging after the second world war, Japan's brutalist architecture is characterised by its geometric shapes, functionality and unconventional use of concrete – which is often left unfinished to showcase the material's textures and imperfections. Paul Tulett traveled the country to photograph extraordinary examples. 'Brutalist architecture in Japan might not ruffle feathers locally but it's considered divisive elsewhere,' he says. Brutalist Japan by Prestel publishing can be purchased here
Paul Tulett: 'Brutalism outside of Japan is like Marmite. Love it or hate it. Some find it refreshingly raw – an honest counterpoint to contemporary glass-based disingenuous attempts at state transparency. Others are reminded of communism or when the UK nearly slid down the pan in the 1970s. Having failed to do the most basic research prior to moving to Okinawa, I was pleasantly surprised by the preponderance of brutalism here and the absence of negative associations'
'The general line is that the brutalism here is born out of necessity, as Okinawa is seasonally battered by typhoons. Homes must be robust and 90% of new dwellings are concrete. Swift adoption of the material was prompted by postwar reconstruction needs. We also need to factor in concrete's resistance to termites – pests greedy for the traditional material of wood. Then there are earthquakes and a damp climate'
'Weathering and deterioration of concrete can lead to stains, cracks and crumble that upset some. Intended radical philosophical statements become eyesores. With hindsight, I became concrete-obsessed at a young age. During a school trip to London, I envisaged a battalion of Star Wars stormtroopers pouring from Queen Elizabeth Hall, the Hayward Gallery and the National Theatre. A sure gauge of whether something is brutalist or not is this: would it look good in a sci-fi movie?'
'To the haters, brutalism reflects the increased intrusion of government and state power. It is no accident that brutalist architectural forms often harboured state departments. Brutalist buildings afford sobering historic reflection – much like the preservation of communist statues in former Soviet states' Photograph: Paul Tulett
'This residence reflects the philosophy that true architectural harmony is achieved not by bending the land to our will, but by listening to its whispers. Amid the rampant uniformity where cities clone themselves, losing their inherent voice, this home seeks to preserve the memory of the terrain, embracing the spirit of the place. The building's form, an organic response to the site, eschews the aggressive imposition of the flat and the straight for convenience's sake'
'Darth Vader's holiday home? This striking complex features affordable housing stacked above a ground-floor elderly day care centre. It models Okinawa's social aspect of planning. The reverse inequality theory, foundational to Nago City's 1973 Comprehensive Plan, challenges development strategies focused solely on income growth, focusing instead on community-centred urban planning. In Okinawa, where communal ties and collective wellbeing are highly valued, such approaches are essential'
'This silhouette, a composition of bold geometric lines and the stark honesty of exposed concrete, channels the brutalist ethos. Its colossal, forthright forms stand in sharp relief to Kyoto's delicate tapestry. Yet, within its robust frame, the structure nurtures the flexible, organic essence of 'metabolism' – a Japanese architectural vanguard of the 1960s. The design, a tessellation of modular units and transformable spaces, breathes the metabolist vision of perpetual evolution'
'It has been argued that concrete is the 'natural choice' of construction material in Japan as it resonates with the half-a-millennium-old practice of sukiya – the considered composition of raw and rough natural materials. The material expression of concrete's rawness is deemed to chime with an almost genetic appreciation for an elemental, unrefined aesthetic. Apparently, the Japanese have a unique long experience with wood, pottery and stone, but for what people are these not traditional materials? I can only think of the Inuit'
'Situated within Komazawa Park, this tower had to support a substantial 33-ton water tank above ground, which was essential for supplying water throughout the park. It also accommodated an antenna for television broadcasts. Below ground, the structure housed a general electric room, machine room, broadcast room and telephone exchange. And it played a pivotal role in controlling traffic within the park while serving as a commemorative landmark'
'This station emerges like a scene from a sci-fi odyssey. An architectural spaceship, launched in 1995, it defies its historical backdrop with a daring leap into futurism. The station is a stargate to the storied city of Uji and greets travellers not with wooden torii gates, but with a concrete vault that arcs like the heavens above a distant planet. The design is audacious, a semicircular cocoon that dares to embrace both the circle's Zen-like simplicity and the boundless possibilities of the cosmos'
'The exclusive suite garden here showcases the gardener's artistry with a Kyoto stone pathway reminiscent of scattered hailstones, encouraging a moment of pause and reflection. By presenting the Japanese experience, I hope to challenge the stereotypical negative attacks levelled at brutalism more broadly. The aim is to provoke thought about examples of brutalism closer to you. With understanding comes appreciation.' You can see more of Tulett's work at @brutal_zen
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Metro
a day ago
- Metro
The ‘Gate to Hell' has been open for 50 years but is finally burning out
The Gate to Hell has been open since the 1980s – but it might finally be running out of gas. Deep in the arid desert of Turkmenistan, a huge crater has been burning with the wrath of a thousand flames, night and day, day and night. Tourists flock to its precipitous edges, while after dark, spiders are drawn to its brilliant glow, hypnotically crawling to a fiery death. But this isn't Hell. It's a massive hole accidentally set alight for decades by Soviet engineers. Obviously. Now, it looks like it is finally burning out, after the government launched a bid to deprive it of the methane it needs to keep burning. Satellite images show how it is now just smoldering in the desert, a far cry from the sheet of fire once seen for miles which earned its nickname. AKI news agency, based in neighbouring Kyrgyzstan, reported that the burning has reduced by more than three times compared to August 2023. Irina Luryeva, of the Research Institute of Natural Gas of the Turkmengas Concern said increased gas production nearby made it possible 'to take control of the filtration flow, now the gas supply to the burning crater is gradually decreasing.' No-one knows how the pit, officially called the Darvaza crater, was first formed before it was set aflame. Perhaps there was simply no one around. Or maybe it's classified. Some believe engineers were drilling for oil when a rig gave way and punched into a massive underground natural gas cavern, forming the huge crater, 70 metres wide and 30 metres deep. Whatever its origin, it's fair to say its legendary status hails from one very bad decision. In the 1980s, as the crater continued leaking poisonous gases, those in the know thought the best solution was to simply burn them off. Side note: Turkmenistan has the sixth largest gas reserves in the world. Enough to keep aglow for quite some time. And so, 50 years on, it relentlessly rumbled on, burning methane that would really be better off in the ground. Former president Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov demanded that a plan to finally extinguish the crater should be put in place, as far back as 2010. Up Next In 2022, he appeared on state television to tell officials to put out the hellish flames, saying the human-made crater 'negatively affects both the environment and the health of the people living nearby'. He added: 'We are losing valuable natural resources for which we could get significant profits and use them for improving the wellbeing of our people', and instructed officials to 'find a solution to extinguish the fire'. It took until the following year for the plan to actually take shape – and even now, it hasn't gone out completely. Turkmenistan: the lowdown Turkmenistan is 80% desert Turkmen melons have their own national holiday Turkmenistan has the sixth largest oil and natural gas reserves in the world It is one of the least visited countries in the world, reporting 14,438 tourists in 2019. It just reopened for tourists in 2023 The country had a President for Life, Saparmurat Niyazov, until his death in 2006. He ruled for 21 years. The country formed a space agency in 2011, and launched a satellite in 2015 Only one man has ever descended into the Gates of Hell, explorer George Kourounis. During his visit met with local geologists 'who have been there for decades', and said the collapse may have happened in the 1960s. 'It's hard for me to back that up, but this is basically straight from the horse's mouth,' said Mr Kourounis. But anything is possible when there are no records to confirm or deny. 'Day or night, it is clearly burning. You can hear the roar of the fire if you stand at the edge,' said Mr Kourounis. 'The heat, if you are downwind of it, is unbearable. 'There are thousands of little flames all around the edges and towards the centre. Then there are two large flames in the middle at the bottom, and that is probably where the drilling rig hole was for the natural gas extraction.' But its mystery origin is now secondary, as there's a bigger problem at hand – climate change. Burning gas 24/7 isn't a great look in 2024. It is still alight for now. So as the Gates of Hell continue to burn, tourists will flock to the landlocked Asian country to get a last glimpse of this strange, and disastrous, human error.


Metro
a day ago
- Metro
The 'Gate to Hell' has been open for 50 years but is finally burning out
The Gate to Hell has been open since the 1980s – but it might finally be running out of gas. Deep in the arid desert of Turkmenistan, a huge crater has been burning with the wrath of a thousand flames, night and day, day and night. Tourists flock to its precipitous edges, while after dark, spiders are drawn to its brilliant glow, hypnotically crawling to a fiery death. But this isn't Hell. It's a massive hole accidentally set alight for decades by Soviet engineers. Obviously. Now, it looks like it is finally burning out, after the government launched a bid to deprive it of the methane it needs to keep burning. Satellite images show how it is now just smoldering in the desert, a far cry from the sheet of fire once seen for miles which earned its nickname. AKI news agency, based in neighbouring Kyrgyzstan, reported that the burning has reduced by more than three times compared to August 2023. Irina Luryeva, of the Research Institute of Natural Gas of the Turkmengas Concern said increased gas production nearby made it possible 'to take control of the filtration flow, now the gas supply to the burning crater is gradually decreasing.' No-one knows how the pit, officially called the Darvaza crater, was first formed before it was set aflame. Perhaps there was simply no one around. Or maybe it's classified. Some believe engineers were drilling for oil when a rig gave way and punched into a massive underground natural gas cavern, forming the huge crater, 70 metres wide and 30 metres deep. Whatever its origin, it's fair to say its legendary status hails from one very bad decision. In the 1980s, as the crater continued leaking poisonous gases, those in the know thought the best solution was to simply burn them off. Side note: Turkmenistan has the sixth largest gas reserves in the world. Enough to keep aglow for quite some time. And so, 50 years on, it relentlessly rumbled on, burning methane that would really be better off in the ground. Former president Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov demanded that a plan to finally extinguish the crater should be put in place, as far back as 2010. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video In 2022, he appeared on state television to tell officials to put out the hellish flames, saying the human-made crater 'negatively affects both the environment and the health of the people living nearby'. He added: 'We are losing valuable natural resources for which we could get significant profits and use them for improving the wellbeing of our people', and instructed officials to 'find a solution to extinguish the fire'. It took until the following year for the plan to actually take shape – and even now, it hasn't gone out completely. Turkmenistan is 80% desert Turkmen melons have their own national holiday Turkmenistan has the sixth largest oil and natural gas reserves in the world It is one of the least visited countries in the world, reporting 14,438 tourists in 2019. It just reopened for tourists in 2023 The country had a President for Life, Saparmurat Niyazov, until his death in 2006. He ruled for 21 years. The country formed a space agency in 2011, and launched a satellite in 2015 Only one man has ever descended into the Gates of Hell, explorer George Kourounis. During his visit met with local geologists 'who have been there for decades', and said the collapse may have happened in the 1960s. 'It's hard for me to back that up, but this is basically straight from the horse's mouth,' said Mr Kourounis. But anything is possible when there are no records to confirm or deny. 'Day or night, it is clearly burning. You can hear the roar of the fire if you stand at the edge,' said Mr Kourounis. 'The heat, if you are downwind of it, is unbearable. More Trending 'There are thousands of little flames all around the edges and towards the centre. Then there are two large flames in the middle at the bottom, and that is probably where the drilling rig hole was for the natural gas extraction.' But its mystery origin is now secondary, as there's a bigger problem at hand – climate change. Burning gas 24/7 isn't a great look in 2024. It is still alight for now. So as the Gates of Hell continue to burn, tourists will flock to the landlocked Asian country to get a last glimpse of this strange, and disastrous, human error. MORE: 6,000-year-old mystery skeletons could rewrite human history MORE: 'Doomsday shipwreck' stuffed with explosives could unleash a Thames tsunami MORE: How four children survived a plane crash that killed every adult on board


Belfast Telegraph
4 days ago
- Belfast Telegraph
‘Lord's Prayer better recognised than national anthem, Churchill or Shakespeare'
The prayer, also known as the Our Father, also appeared better known than a famous line from Star Wars, the words of wartime prime minister Winston Churchill and Liverpool football anthem You'll Never Walk Alone, according to the survey. Of just over 2,000 people across the UK asked last month – in polling commissioned by the Church of England – 80.3% correctly recognised the line 'Give us this day our daily bread' was from the ancient prayer. This came just ahead of Star Wars, with 79.9% recognising the line 'May the force be with you' came from the films. Of all those polled, 89% said they had heard of the Lord's Prayer or the Our Father, with 88% of those who identified themselves as having no religion still having heard of the prayer. When it came to other famous lines from history, 'To be or not to be' from Shakespeare's Hamlet play was recognised by just under three-quarters (73%) of respondents, while fewer than two thirds (63%) correctly matched the lines 'happy and glorious, long to reign over us' as being from Britain's national anthem, God Save The King. Around six in 10 (61%) respondents recognised the line 'Never in the field of human conflict, was so much owed by so many to so few' from Churchill's 1940 speech to MPs in Parliament. More than half (58%) recognised 'You'll never walk alone' as being from the song by Gerry and the Pacemakers, and is the adopted anthem for Liverpool football club. Least well-known of the seven extracts from famous works given were the lines 'It was the best of times, it was the worst of times' from Charles Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities, matched correctly by just 39% of people. The findings also showed that 16% of those surveyed said they had not heard of the national anthem lines, while 14% said they had not heard of the line 'You'll never walk alone'. The Archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell, said the findings suggest the prayer remains a 'steady guide' and something which continues to 'resonate with people of all faiths and none'. Mr Cottrell is leading a 'tour' of events at churches and cathedrals across the north of England as part of his Faith In The North initiative, with a focus on the prayer. He said: 'These results reflect what we've been hearing across the north of England through our Faith In The North initiative, which invites people to explore the Lord's Prayer. 'Though ancient, its words continue to resonate with people of all faiths and none. 'In a world of shifting cultures and changing circumstances, the Lord's Prayer remains a steady guide – perhaps never more so than now. 'Lines like 'Give us this day our daily bread' speak powerfully to today's challenges, reminding us to seek sufficiency, not excess, and to consider what 'enough' truly means.' The polling comes ahead of the Thy Kingdom Come prayer movement finishing this Pentecost Sunday, with events taking place in churches across the globe. – Pollster Savanta interviewed 2,035 UK respondents online between May 23 and 26 and said data was weighted to be representative of the general public by age, gender, region and ethnicity.