Trump fires jobs data commissioner after dismal report
Trump, in a post on his social media platform on Friday, alleged the figures were manipulated for political reasons and said that Erika McEntarfer, the director of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, who was appointed by former president Joe Biden, should be fired.
He provided no evidence for the charge.
"I have directed my Team to fire this Biden Political Appointee, IMMEDIATELY," Trump said on Truth Social.
"She will be replaced with someone much more competent and qualified."
After his post, Labour Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer said on X that McEntarfer was no longer leading the bureau and that William Wiatrowski, the deputy commissioner, would serve as the acting director.
"I support the president's decision to replace Biden's commissioner and ensure the American people can trust the important and influential data coming from BLS," Chavez-DeRemer said.
Friday's jobs report showed that just 73,000 jobs were added in July and that 258,000 fewer jobs were created in May and June than previously estimated.
McEntarfer was nominated by Biden in 2023 and became the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics in January 2024. Commissioners typically serve four-year terms but since they are political appointees can be fired. The commissioner is the only political appointee of the agency, which has hundreds of career civil servants.
Trump focused much of his ire on the revisions the agency made to previous hiring data. Job gains in May were revised down to just 19,000 from 125,000, and for June they were cut to 14,000 from 147,000. In July, only 73,000 positions were added. The unemployment rate ticked up to a still-low 4.2 per cent from 4.1 per cent.
"No one can be that wrong? We need accurate Jobs Numbers," Trump wrote.
"She will be replaced with someone much more competent and qualified. Important numbers like this must be fair and accurate, they can't be manipulated for political purposes."
The monthly employment report is one of the most closely-watched pieces of government economic data and can cause sharp swings in financial markets. The disappointing figure sent US market indexes about 1.5 per cent lower Friday.
While the jobs numbers are often the subject of political spin, economists and Wall Street investors — with millions of dollars at stake — have always accepted US government economic data as free from political manipulation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
28 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
The door is open for Trump to create more chaos
Trump has said he is considering four contenders for the position of the Fed's chair, which will open up in May next year when the term of the current chair, Jerome Powell, who Trump detests and attacks relentlessly and viciously, will end. Hassett, current governor Christopher Waller and former governor Kevin Warsh are thought to be on his short list. He is weighing up whether to announce a short-term appointment – someone who would fill the position until the term expires on January 31 next year – or appointing a 'chair elect' who will succeed Powell when his term as chair ends next May. It's a pivotal decision because the Kugler position might be the only opportunity he has to inject a loyalist into the Fed boardroom during this term. Powell's chairmanship might end in May but, should he choose to remain on the board, his term as a governor runs until 2028. There are no other scheduled retirements during the Trump presidency. There are reports that Trump's advisers (which include unusual names, like Fox's Sean Hannity and MAGA heavyweight Steve Bannon) are urging him to appoint someone who will occupy the seat only until January, giving him more time to decide on Powell's replacement. Trump could appoint someone designated as Powell's successor, hoping that a 'shadow' chair would undermine Powell and Powell's messaging both within and outside the Fed's boardroom. The US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent (who has withdrawn himself from contention for the role), mooted exactly that strategy ahead of last year's US election. Whether the appointment is short term or unveils Powell's successor, however, the new governor would be one of only two Trump-appointed members on the seven-member board and the 12-member Federal Open Market Committee that actually decides US monetary policies. The other is the Fed's deputy chair, Michelle Bowman. Loading While Trump has made it very clear what he wants from the next Fed chair, it is less obvious what qualifications, other than loyalty, Trump wants from the incoming BLS commissioner. The blueprint for this administration – 'Project 2025' – recommended appointing political appointees to the Labor department, within which the BLS sits, and consolidating the BLS with other data collecting agencies into a 'more manageable' mega statistical agency. The BLS could do with a (non-political) overhaul. It has a challenge with its current data surveys because, post-COVID, the response rates from businesses have dropped significantly. That's part of the explanation for why its revisions of June quarter data, which showed a major fall in jobs generation, were so large. Even as it has become harder for the bureau to collect accurate data, it has experienced a reduction in its resources in recent years that is being compounded by job losses and an 8 per cent cut to next year's budget because of Trump's assault on the US bureaucracy. If its data is to be made more reliable and credible, it needs more, not fewer, resources and someone – like Kugler – who is non-partisan and clearly qualified as its head. If Trump appoints a loyalist, it would cast a shadow over the accuracy of data central to the markets and businesses' understanding of economic conditions and probably lead to an increase in risk premia in US interest rates. The ironic aspect of Trump's response to the weak employment data is that it actually strengthens the case for a rate cut. The Fed has a dual mandate, charged with maximising employment and price stability. It has kept rates on hold while it waits to see the effects of Trump's trade policies on an inflation rate that, at 2.7 per cent, is already above its target of 2 per cent. The two appointments to critical economic agencies have the potential to undermine the credibility of the Feds's policy decisions and the BLS's data if financial market participants and businesses suspect that the Fed's decisions and the BLS' data have been tainted by political influences. The inflation rate has been edging up even before the full effects of Trump's tariffs have had time to reveal themselves, but the economy has slowed markedly and the BLS data shows the unemployment rate is edging up even as the job market shrinks and salaries stagnate. Where, before that data, the odds were against a rate cut at the Fed's meeting next month, they – and an increasing number of Fed governors – now favour a rate cut. Instead of accusing (without any evidence) the BLS of manipulating its date to make his economic management look bad, Trump should have seized on it to proclaim that he was right, and the Fed wrong, on the need for a rate cut. Trump can probably cause conflicts and dysfunction within the Fed and the BLS if that is his objective with the appointments he makes. Whether that achieves his broader ambitions, however, is another matter. Even if he could stack the Fed board with loyalists, which he can't, or intimidate the majority of the Open Market Committee, which is unlikely, the Fed can only influence US short term rates. The federal funds rate anchors the bond market's yield curve, but longer term rates are set by the market itself. If investors thought the Fed's decision-making had been politicised, they would demand higher yields to compensate for the increased risk of inflation and increase the premium required for holding longer-term bonds. The yield curve would steepen, and it is those yields at the longer end of the curve that determine the rates on mortgage and car loans and business' interest costs. Loading It is the Fed's credibility as an independent, apolitical agency that will contain inflation that gives it a broader influence over the curve than just the federal funds rate. Similarly, if the BLS data is regarded as tainted and unreliable, it will inject uncertainty and caution into businesses' decision-making and probably lead to less employment and investment.
The Age
28 minutes ago
- The Age
The door is open for Trump to create more chaos
Trump has said he is considering four contenders for the position of the Fed's chair, which will open up in May next year when the term of the current chair, Jerome Powell, who Trump detests and attacks relentlessly and viciously, will end. Hassett, current governor Christopher Waller and former governor Kevin Warsh are thought to be on his short list. He is weighing up whether to announce a short-term appointment – someone who would fill the position until the term expires on January 31 next year – or appointing a 'chair elect' who will succeed Powell when his term as chair ends next May. It's a pivotal decision because the Kugler position might be the only opportunity he has to inject a loyalist into the Fed boardroom during this term. Powell's chairmanship might end in May but, should he choose to remain on the board, his term as a governor runs until 2028. There are no other scheduled retirements during the Trump presidency. There are reports that Trump's advisers (which include unusual names, like Fox's Sean Hannity and MAGA heavyweight Steve Bannon) are urging him to appoint someone who will occupy the seat only until January, giving him more time to decide on Powell's replacement. Trump could appoint someone designated as Powell's successor, hoping that a 'shadow' chair would undermine Powell and Powell's messaging both within and outside the Fed's boardroom. The US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent (who has withdrawn himself from contention for the role), mooted exactly that strategy ahead of last year's US election. Whether the appointment is short term or unveils Powell's successor, however, the new governor would be one of only two Trump-appointed members on the seven-member board and the 12-member Federal Open Market Committee that actually decides US monetary policies. The other is the Fed's deputy chair, Michelle Bowman. Loading While Trump has made it very clear what he wants from the next Fed chair, it is less obvious what qualifications, other than loyalty, Trump wants from the incoming BLS commissioner. The blueprint for this administration – 'Project 2025' – recommended appointing political appointees to the Labor department, within which the BLS sits, and consolidating the BLS with other data collecting agencies into a 'more manageable' mega statistical agency. The BLS could do with a (non-political) overhaul. It has a challenge with its current data surveys because, post-COVID, the response rates from businesses have dropped significantly. That's part of the explanation for why its revisions of June quarter data, which showed a major fall in jobs generation, were so large. Even as it has become harder for the bureau to collect accurate data, it has experienced a reduction in its resources in recent years that is being compounded by job losses and an 8 per cent cut to next year's budget because of Trump's assault on the US bureaucracy. If its data is to be made more reliable and credible, it needs more, not fewer, resources and someone – like Kugler – who is non-partisan and clearly qualified as its head. If Trump appoints a loyalist, it would cast a shadow over the accuracy of data central to the markets and businesses' understanding of economic conditions and probably lead to an increase in risk premia in US interest rates. The ironic aspect of Trump's response to the weak employment data is that it actually strengthens the case for a rate cut. The Fed has a dual mandate, charged with maximising employment and price stability. It has kept rates on hold while it waits to see the effects of Trump's trade policies on an inflation rate that, at 2.7 per cent, is already above its target of 2 per cent. The two appointments to critical economic agencies have the potential to undermine the credibility of the Feds's policy decisions and the BLS's data if financial market participants and businesses suspect that the Fed's decisions and the BLS' data have been tainted by political influences. The inflation rate has been edging up even before the full effects of Trump's tariffs have had time to reveal themselves, but the economy has slowed markedly and the BLS data shows the unemployment rate is edging up even as the job market shrinks and salaries stagnate. Where, before that data, the odds were against a rate cut at the Fed's meeting next month, they – and an increasing number of Fed governors – now favour a rate cut. Instead of accusing (without any evidence) the BLS of manipulating its date to make his economic management look bad, Trump should have seized on it to proclaim that he was right, and the Fed wrong, on the need for a rate cut. Trump can probably cause conflicts and dysfunction within the Fed and the BLS if that is his objective with the appointments he makes. Whether that achieves his broader ambitions, however, is another matter. Even if he could stack the Fed board with loyalists, which he can't, or intimidate the majority of the Open Market Committee, which is unlikely, the Fed can only influence US short term rates. The federal funds rate anchors the bond market's yield curve, but longer term rates are set by the market itself. If investors thought the Fed's decision-making had been politicised, they would demand higher yields to compensate for the increased risk of inflation and increase the premium required for holding longer-term bonds. The yield curve would steepen, and it is those yields at the longer end of the curve that determine the rates on mortgage and car loans and business' interest costs. Loading It is the Fed's credibility as an independent, apolitical agency that will contain inflation that gives it a broader influence over the curve than just the federal funds rate. Similarly, if the BLS data is regarded as tainted and unreliable, it will inject uncertainty and caution into businesses' decision-making and probably lead to less employment and investment.
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
The rogue's gallery behind Labor's flagship ‘top' deal for workers
It was touted as the deal that would stop 'the race to the bottom': Labor's ambitious proposal to bring workers under one banner to bargain with multiple employers under the same conditions. But a year after signing its new multi-employer bargaining agreement into law, the industry organisation behind the first deal with a union has become a rogue's gallery of business owners facing claims of trading while insolvent, multimillion-dollar debts to the tax office and offensive social media content targeting gender-diverse people and migrants. Championed by the Labor government for delivering 'best practice standards' for employees, the HVAC Manufacturing and Installation Association became the first industry body to sign a multi-employer bargaining agreement in 2024 after winning support from the Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union. However, more than a year after signing the agreement, the association has no office, no phone line and no functioning website as its members face growing scrutiny. The association, which represents businesses in the air-conditioning and ductwork industries, was founded by seven ventilation heavyweights in December 2022, months after Labor proposed introducing laws that would facilitate collective employee bargaining across multiple businesses. HVAC association director Darren Beecroft faces a debt of $530,000 to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) while calling for American-style immigration raids on Australian construction sites. Former HVAC association director Sergio Gonzalez owes creditors and the ATO more $2 million while amassing a personal fortune to fund a professional football field in his front yard. The liquidated air-conditioning business of HVAC founder Gavin Ohlback and his partner Scott Smith, which once sponsored a car racing team, owes $1.8 million to the tax office. The multi-employer bargaining laws were designed to bring companies with a single interest together to guarantee workers' conditions and prevent opportunistic rivals from undercutting pay and conditions. Former workplace minister Tony Burke said the laws would start a 'race to improve job security' the day after the manufacturers' union and HVAC association signed the agreement in March last year.
