Life on Edinburgh's Princes Street as high streets suffer 'decades of decline'
New figures show one in eight of Scotland's high street shops are empty following 'decades of decline'.
Scottish Labour have called for rates to be slashed for local businesses to improve the growing problem. But the Scottish Government pointed to a rates relief package worth around £733 million, with a spokesperson adding: 'We are working with businesses to drive economic growth and prosperity…this includes the most generous small business rates relief in the UK.'
So Edinburgh Live checked in on Princes Street, to see how Edinburgh's famous thoroughfare is shaping up.
In 2023-24 the average rate of empty shops across Scotland rose to 12.3 percent, up from 11.9 percent the previous year.
Edinburgh has a lower proportion of empty shopfronts, at 5.4 percent. But Princes Street has come under fire in recent years, with residents branding it 'a disgrace' and 'embarrassing' on social media.
Shopkeepers complain of theft, antisocial behaviour and littering while locals object to the broken paving slabs, litter and empty shopfronts.
(Image: Edinburgh Live)
But things could be looking up for the historic high street, with new hotels and shops filling the empty gaps, and the police vowing to crack down on anti-social behaviour and youth disorder.
Muhammad Amin, who runs phone repair and accessory shop Mobile Plus, said that during school holidays they still have problems with anti-social behaviour from kids.
He explained how teens throw food and bottles into the shop, just to get a rise out of him. He also has trouble getting drunk people to leave the premises.
He said: 'We call the police when trouble starts, but they always take too long to arrive.
'At our old shop in Glasgow there weren't so many problems… you get to know the troublemakers and it's easier to deal with.'
Despite this, Amin had a positive attitude looking forward. He was happy that the street cleaners had, for the first time in two and a half years, cleaned his shopfront of rubbish and weeds.
(Image: Edinburgh Live)
Visitors were also positive about Princes Street. Amy and Mcclean Titterington, from Texas, chose Edinburgh for their honeymoon and spoke highly of the area.
Amy said: "The gardens are gorgeous, and it's easy to spot [and avoid] the touristy shops on Princes Street… Obviously there is a fair bit of construction at the moment, but that's okay."
Her husband added: 'You can easily spot the gimmicky shops.'
But Alex Currie, a local, believed the street had seen better days.
'I like Princes Street, but its charm has been diluted by tourist traps and too many sweet shops.
'It has almost been replaced by the St James Quarter, where a lot of the high-end shops have moved to.
'The east end of Princes Street is still really good though, and I think once the construction is finished at Jenners the whole area will look a lot better.'
Although not a fan of tourist and sweet shops, Alex conceded they were better than empty shop fronts.
Edinburgh Council chiefs, meanwhile, launched a plan to 'revitalise' Princes Street in 2024.
The proposals included more pop-up stalls and improvements to the pavements. They also said they would introduce street art and building wraps.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Rachel Reeves 'limping' from one event to the next, head of the Institute for Fiscal Studies warns in brutal assessment of Labour's economic record
Rachel Reeves is 'limping' from one event to the next, the new head of the Institute for Fiscal Studies has warned in a stark assessment of Labour's economic record. Helen Miller said while Labour came into office on the promise of 'mission-driven government' and 'long-term thinking', reality proved different. Fears about small downgrades to Britain's growth prospects meant that the Budgets and statements were dominated by concerns about the parlous state of the public finances and if tax hikes or spending cuts would be needed, she said. 'We continue to limp from fiscal event to fiscal event, obsessed with whether run-of-the-mill revisions to the economic and fiscal outlook have reduced the fiscal headroom and whether tax or spend takeaways will follow,' said Ms Miller. 'We need to break out of this cycle.' The remarks add to the increasingly negative perceptions of Labour's handling of the economy after a year in power, with business leaders and economists unsettled by the direction being taken by Ms Reeves – and bond markets also becoming anxious. Ms Miller made the comments as she steps up from deputy to replace Paul Johnson as director of the IFS, a respected financial think-tank. Economists and businessmen continue to wonder whether Ms Reeves will have to put up taxes in her autumn Budget after Labour's U-turns on welfare and winter fuel payments. Growth also looks to be deteriorating, and defence spending must be increased as per new Nato rules and the Prime Minister's pledge. These shortcomings may open a financial black hole. Ms Miller said it was 'safe to assume the Chancellor will stick to her fiscal rules' on bringing down debt and borrowing. She added: 'But that alone doesn't automatically equate to sustainable public finances.' Last week the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) warned Britain was effectively living beyond its means, saying it 'cannot afford the array of promises that it has made to the public'. Ms Miller said: 'There are lots of reasons that demands for government spending could run far ahead of tax revenues. However much this – or any future – Government is willing to tax and spend, it won't be enough. We need better designed policies. 'And we desperately need economic growth. While that wouldn't eliminate the need for trade-offs it would make them more palatable.' Ms Miller also echoed the OBR's warning that the abandonment of planned spending cuts was leaving the UK's finances more vulnerable. She said: 'Politicians need to level with voters about the scale of the challenges and to make the case for bold reforms. 'Lessons must be learned from the recent disability benefits U-turn, and learned quickly, so that reform efforts in other areas land more successfully.'
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Reeves to say cuts to City red tape will bring trickle-down benefits to households
Rachel Reeves will claim that cutting red tape for City firms will have trickle-down benefits for households across Britain, as she tries to drum up support for a new financial services strategy. A raft of regulatory reforms are due to be announced by the chancellor on Tuesday, in what the Treasury says will be the 'biggest financial regulation reforms in a decade'. It will come before her Mansion House address to City bosses during a dinner at Guildhall in London on Tuesday evening. Under the 'Leeds reforms' – which Reeves will announce during a 'summit' with top City executives in West Yorkshire – the chancellor will declare that paring down burdensome regulation is key to unleashing UK growth and ultimately ensuring that households are better off. 'I have placed financial services at the heart of the government's growth mission – recognising that Britain cannot succeed and meet its growth ambitions without a financial services sector that is fighting fit and thriving,' Reeves will say. She will claim the reforms would have 'a ripple effect that will drive investment in all sectors of our economy and put pounds in the pockets of working people'. It follows strong lobbying by the City, which Reeves wooed in the lead-up to the election and has fought to keep on side throughout Labour's first year in power. But economists and campaigners warned Reeves that deregulating the City came with risks, pointing to the deep recession that followed the 2008 financial crash, when the last Labour government was forced to bail out major banks. 'It feels like groundhog day. We've been here before, expecting the financial sector to do most of the heavy lifting in terms of growth,' said Chaitanya Kumar, head of economy and environment at the New Economics Foundation thinktank. 'The 2008 crash and what followed should have been a very strong lesson to everybody in not completely letting the financial services sector off its leash: but that's what we seem to be doing.' He added: 'I just haven't seen any evidence that deregulating the financial services sector is going to create significant growth.' Jesse Griffiths, chief executive of the Finance Innovation Lab charity, said it was clear that prioritising the needs of international financial firms over domestic needs had 'simply not worked for the UK economy'. 'Buying the City's push for further deregulation risks derailing the government's industrial strategy and increasing the risks of costly financial crises,' Griffiths said. 'Instead of a more 'globally competitive' financial sector, we need reform to better serve UK businesses and drive domestic investment to where we need it, particularly for the green transition that will lower people's bills and create the good jobs of the future.' Reeves is expected to point to the recent loosening of mortgage rules as a tangible example of how reforms are helping consumers. That includes changes announced by the Bank of England last week, which will open the door to riskier lending by giving people the ability to take out bigger mortgages relative to their annual income. The move could end up helping 36,000 more first-time buyers on to the housing ladder each year, the Bank said. Nationwide Building Society said it was already taking advantage of the changes, by lowering the annual salary needed to qualify for its 95% Helping Hand mortgage, to £30,000 from £35,000 previously. Joint applicants will need a combined salary of £50,000, down from £55,000. The chancellor will also confirm the launch of a permanent government-backed guarantee scheme for mortgages. It is expected to cover banks' losses on 95% mortgages if borrowers fail to repay and have their homes repossessed. The scheme, which was floated in Labour's manifesto, is meant to encourage banks to offer riskier, larger-value loans. Although bank incentives and looser mortgage rules could benefit some first-time buyers, campaigners at Positive Money said it was important not to leave consumers with more debt than they could handle. 'Put plainly, loosening mortgage rules really translates to saddling households with larger, less sustainable debts, instead of tackling the underlying causes of unaffordability,' said Sara Hall, a Positive Money director. 'Even the Bank of England has suggested this move could actually push up house prices by flooding the market with greater demand, pulling the housing ladder even further out of reach for first-time buyers.' Other reforms are expected to include speeding up changes to the senior managers regime, which ensures that bosses are fit and proper before they are appointed and holds them personally and financially responsible for problems that occur on their watch. City regulators are also revealing plans to slash red tape as they try to appease a Labour government keen to tell City bosses that their concerns are being heard. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) announced on Tuesday that corporate transparency rules would be pared back in order to encourage more companies to list shares in London. That means companies floating their shares for the first time will only have to publish a prospectus – which provides key information about finances, risks and business plans – three days before going to market, down from the current six-day window. Meanwhile, those already listed, but trying to sell more shares to raise capital, will only have to issue a fresh prospectus if they are selling more than 75% of the company's equity. That is up from the current threshold of 20%. Fewer disclosures come despite efforts by the City and government to encourage more investment in UK stocks by everyday consumers.
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Five best EVs to buy with Labour's new £3,750 Electric Car Grant
The Government has reintroduced grants to slash the price of some new electric cars as part of its efforts to boost sales before the end of the decade. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander has today (Monday) unveiled Labour's £650million Electric Car Grant, which comes three years after the previous Tory regime scrapped its own plug-in car grant. The Department for Transport confirms only fully electric models priced at £37,000 or less are eligible for the new grants of up to £3,750, with funding confirmed up until 2028-29. However, there are a number of caveats. Firstly, the scheme will not immediately be available, despite officially launching on Wednesday 16 July. That's because manufacturers need to apply for eligibility for vehicles in their ranges, rather than buyers registering grants at the point of purchase. And not all grants will have a value of £3,750. There will be a two-tier approach to the value deducted from the recommended retail price (RRP), which is determined by how green the manufacturing process is for each different model. The RAC says the grant's restrictions mean drivers will be 'picking models that are not only better for their wallets, but better for the planet too'. We've picked five of the best EVs that are certain to be eligible for the grant - though we will have to wait to find out which will qualify for the full subsidy amount of £3,750. What is the Electric Car Grant? The Electric Car Grant (ECG) is the Government's new big hope to drive sales of EVs in the run-up to the end of the decade as it continues to steer towards outlawing the availability of new petrol and diesel cars from 2030. It arrives three years after the previous Tory administration prematurely scrapped its Plug-in Car Grant (PiCG), which it launched in 2011. Over its 11-year spell, the PiCG amount was gradually wound down; having originally offered to slash the price of any new EV or plug-in hybrid by £5,000 in 2011, by the time the scheme was closed in June 2022 only fully-electric cars below £32,000 were eligible, and the amount knocked off the RRP just £1,500. That said, the scheme proved incredibly successful. It provided more than £1.4billion to motorists to support purchases of nearly half a million electric and hybrid vehicles in that period, in which it was widely responsible for encouraging early adoption of electrified cars. The new ECG will hope to reignite electric car demand among private buyers with the same level of impact after months of stagnating sales. It will be supported by a £650million backing from the Government that will be available for the next three years. However, funding will remain under review, with the scheme subject to amendments or an 'early closure with no notice' should the pot of available money 'become exhausted', the DfT clarified. Only cars up to £37,000 qualify for the grant, which rules out premium models, including every Tesla on sale. The Government's hope is that by making the most financially attainable EVs even more affordable, it will make switching more appealing to private buyers rather than just those who lease more expensive EVs or acquire them as company cars or through salary sacrifice schemes. How does the Electric Car Grant work? Unlike the PiCG, buyers will not be allocated the grant amount at the point of purchase. Instead, manufacturers must apply to be eligible for the scheme with their sub-£37,000 cars on a 'first come, first served' basis. This means that motorists will not need to fill in any additional paperwork to receive the grant, with all administration handled by the car maker, dealership, and the Government. But because manufacturers must apply for the scheme, it may take weeks for discounted EVs to begin appearing in showrooms, experts warn, The new scheme will also differ from the PiCG in that it initially be a two-tier approach based on 'sustainability criteria', with only the greenest models - considered 'band one' - receiving the full £3,750 amount. Band two cars with a lower eco rating will be eligible for a reduced amount that's not yet clarified. Bands are determined by each maker's Science-Based Target (SBT) - an industry-wide scheme, with manufacturers needing to meet carbon scores below a specific criterion to achieve the highest green standard. The bands - which could later expand beyond two tiers - are determined by how much CO2 is emitted in an EV's production, assessing the energy used during assembly as well as battery production. Threshold levels have yet to be made public. According to early reports, British-built EVs were said to qualify for band one in support of UK car makers. However, the DfT has said this will not be the case and that 'all products are assessed under the same framework'. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander confirmed the ECG's availability on Monday night, saying: 'The EV grant will not only allow people to keep more of their hard-earned money - it'll help our automotive sector seize one of the biggest opportunities of the 21st century.' Car industry welcomes EV purchase incentive The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), which has been campaigning for new financial purchase incentives to be launched since the PiCG was closed three years ago, said the grant is a 'clear signal to consumers that now is the time to switch'. Mike Hawes, its chief executive, said: 'Rapid deployment and availability of this grant over the next few years will help provide the momentum that is essential to take the EV market from just one in four today, to four in five by the end of the decade. 'This announcement is a welcome response to consistent calls from the industry for more support, which will be in addition to the substantive subsidies already provided by manufacturers.' Simon Williams, head of road policy at the RAC, described the grant as 'just the shot-in-the arm needed to help more drivers go electric'. He added: 'Within weeks, discounted cars should start appearing at dealerships across the country. 'And, as the biggest savings will be given to cars with the strongest 'green' manufacturing credentials, drivers will be picking models that are not only better for their wallets, but better for the planet too.' Delvin Lane, CEO of charger provider Instavolt, said the grant will be a 'major contributor' to boosting demand for EVs. Five of the best EVs likely eligible for the grant While any battery electric car with an RRP of £37,000 or below will be eligible for the grant, we will have to wait for manufacturers to apply for the grant before finding out which vehicles qualify - and which band and subsidy amount they will be categorised. However, here is a list of five of the best EVs on sale currently that are available for less than £37,000 - and should become cheaper to buy within a matter of weeks. Below, we have listed them with the potential start price if they are to qualify as band one EVs eligible for the full £3,750 grant allowance. 1. Renault 5 E-Tech - from £19,245 Current price from: £22,995 Versions under £37k: all Range: up to 250 miles The Renault 5 E-Tech is a reborn version of the legendary 1980 model with battery power - and it has proved a huge success for the French manufacturer since it arrived in Britain earlier this year. With impressive driving characteristics, a premium feel to the cabin and a more than adequate range of between 190 to 250 miles, it is the worthy reigning winner of the illustrious European Car of the Year Award. While a starting price of £23,000 and even the top-spec Roland Garros version ringing in at less than £30,000, every version should be eligible for the grant. The 5 has been the best-selling EV in the UK retail sector in the months of April and May, so this is certainly one of the cars the grant is aimed at. 2. Nissan Leaf - from circa £26,250 Current price from: circa £30,000 Versions under £37k: TBC Range: up to 375 miles An all-new Nissan Leaf is due to hit showrooms this year with a starting price of around £30,000 - well within the boundaries of the Electric Car Grant eligibility criteria An all-new Nissan Leaf is due to hit showrooms this year. And, given it's the only mass-market EV produced in the UK [since assembly of the Mini EV moved to China] at the Sunderland plant in the Northeast, the Japanese brand will be hoping to meet the requirements to secure the full £3,750 'band one' grant allowance. Unlike the outgoing Leaf hatchback, the new model is very much a crossover with a jacked-up ride height and bulkier styling. Prices are yet to be confirmed, but bosses have hinted it will start from around £30,000. Even mid-to-top spec models are likely to sit below the grant's £37,000 threshold. Two battery options will be available from launch in 2025: a smaller - and cheaper - 52kWh unit offering up to 270 miles of range on a single charge and a larger 75kWh battery which ups the distance to 375 miles. 3. Citroen e-C3 - from £18,345 Current price from: £22,095 Versions under £37k: all Range: up to 199 miles There are plenty of compact EV options that should qualify for the ECG criteria, including the Dacia Spring (from £14,995) and Hyundai Inster (from £23,505). But our pick of the most attainably priced electric cars is Citroen's new e-C3, which start from £22,095. With a range of up to 199 miles, an existing starting price a little over £22,000, and enough room for five adults, this practical and comfortable electric supermini could become even more affordable if it qualifies for the full ECG amount. Even the entry-spec models get a 10.25-inch infotainment screen with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto connectivity, while higher trim levels - all of them falling well below the grant's £37,000 ceiling - have heated seats, a heated steering wheel and a reversing camera. 4. Kia EV3 - from £29,255 Current price from: £33,005 Versions under £37k: EV3 Air Range: up to 375 miles The entry 'Air' specification of the new Kia EV3 sits under the £37,000 ECG threshold with the choice of either the 58.3kWh or 81.4kWh battery. For an electric family car, it could become a tempting option with up to £3,750 off Kia's latest - and smallest - model, the new EV3, looks set to steal a march on rivals in the most competitive segment of all. With every brand on the planet seemingly offering a compact SUV, Kia's EV3 is our choice of the bunch with exclusively battery power. The entry 'Air' specification sits under the £37,000 ECG threshold with the choice of either the 58.3kWh or 81.4kWh battery. While the smaller battery model (starting from £33,005) offers a range up to 254 miles, the £36,005 Air with the Long Range 81.4kWh battery providing up to 375 miles on a single charge. 5 Skoda Elroq - from £27,760 Current price from: £31,510 Versions under £37k: Elroq SE, SE-L and Edition Range: up to 266 miles Skoda's new Elroq is one of the standout electric family cars with a RRP low enough to qualify for the new Electric Car Grant For family car buyers, Skoda's Elroq is another quality option. And with three models in its range likely to qualify for the ECG, a discount of up to £3,750 could make it compelling option. It's roomy, well-equipped and has that robust Volkswagen Group build quality. While not the most entertaining to drive, its arguably excellent value against comparable rivals. The entry Elroq SE with a 52kWh battery is the cheapest from £31,510, though this provides a maximum range of up to only 233 miles. However, the SE-L 60 and Edition 60 with the bigger 59kWh offer up to 266 miles and both sit below the grant's £37,000 cut-off for eligibility. Unfortunately, the larger 77kWh battery versions are all over the ECG's price threshold.
