Can deny entry to OCI card holders deemed undesirable: Home Ministry
In an affidavit filed on May 21, MHA further stated that OCI card holders, who are foreigners, are under a mandate to not undertake the activities prohibited under the category of VISA or OCI guidelines and cannot claim the fundamental right to free speech, movement and protest, enshrined under article 19 of the Constitution of India.
Justifying reasons for rejecting permission is not a matter of right, the affidavit stated.
'OCI cardholder is a foreigner and OCI card is a life long visa issued to such a foreigner. Every country has a sovereign right to refuse entry into its territory to any individual whom it may consider undesirable and informing about the same in as much as entry into any country's territory is not a matter of right, even if the person holds a valid visa,' the affidavit filed on May 21 stated.
It added, 'It is germane to mention that OCI card holders or other foreigners visiting in India are supposed to adhere to the laws of the country i.e the activities which are prohibited from them under the category of VISA or OCI guidelines. The citizens of India are guaranteed fundamental right of speech and free movement under Article 19 of the Constitution of India. However foreigners or citizens of other countries are not entitled to such rights. Since OCI card holders are foreigners and citizens of another country, they cannot claim the right to free speech, movement and protest under Article 19 of the Indian Constitution.'
The submission came in a plea filed by Washington-based cybersecurity journalist Raphael Satter, challenging Centre's December 4, 2023 decision to revoke his OCI card. Though Satter had also filed a revision petition in January 2024, the same was disposed of in May last year, concluding that there were no grounds to revise the OCI cancellation order.
Satter's card was revoked months after Centre's decision of cancelling Sweden-based professor Ashok Swain's OCI card. On July 30, 2023, the Centre had revoked Swain's card but the Delhi high court on March 28, permitted Swain's entry by setting aside the decision.
On May 18, Indian-origin professor Nitasha Kaul had revealed about the Centre's decision to revoke her OCI card citing anti national activities.
With regards to Satter, MHA in its affidavit justified the move stating that the decision was based on inputs by security agencies which flagged his activities of maliciously creating adverse and biased opinions against Indian institutions in international arena through his journalist activities and he could not be provided with the reports due to its 'confidential nature.' MHA further stated that it had enough inputs to show that Raphel wilfully violated the conditions of the March 4, 2021 notification which bars OCI card holders from undertaking research. 'It has been reported by security agencies that Raphael has been noted for acts of maliciously creating adverse and biased opinions against Indian institutions in the international arena through his journalistic activities and a discreet LOC was opened against him,' the affidavit stated.
In its 24-page affidavit, the MHA said that the ministry before initiating the cancellation of OCI proceedings, consulted security agencies, external affairs ministry and also served a show cause notice to him on June 12, 2023 and his response failed to establish that he had not done any journalistic activities or submit his whereabouts or activities during his visit to India.
Satter's plea will be next heard on August 25.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 minutes ago
- Time of India
Easing of rare earths bottlenecks may clear way for Indian electronics firms
The electronics industry, arguably the biggest Make-in-India success story, could get a sustainable competitive edge globally on unexpected support from an otherwise strategic rival: move to ease export curbs on rare earth metals and critical minerals removes a critical input-supplies bottleneck for items such as electric cars, laptops, handphones, gaming consoles, or instruments with embedded software and display, industry executives told stabilising costs, the end to import curbs is likely to open new opportunities for advanced research and manufacturing in the earth metals are crucial for manufacturing magnets used in electronics, electric vehicles (EVs), robotics, and next-generation technologies. Earlier, India's electronics ecosystem had experienced disruptions, with Foxconn's Hyderabad plant producing Apple AirPods facing supply shortages after the initial Panda, managing director, Indian Metals and Ferro Alloys, said, 'Industry will be relieved by China lifting its export curbs on rare earth elements and critical minerals. Moreover, it is a positive development which will aid in the normalisation of ties that are in mutual interest.'The recent thaw in India-China relations will help to strengthen Beijing's industrial and diplomatic positions, Jason Oxman, President and CEO of Washington DC-based Information Technology Industry Council (ITI), told ET.'Whenever the US vacates policy space, China wins. Where Washington pulls back from trade agreements or imposes tariffs, Beijing steps in with offers of tariff-free trade. That is a long-term risk to U.S. competitiveness,' he electronics manufacturers also hailed the decision. Rajoo Goel, secretary general, Electronic Industries Association of India (ELCINA), told ET, "The bigger hit was for Indian electronics companies in wearables and electric vehicles (EVs), which rely on rare earth magnets in larger quantities. We heard from companies such as Brandworks and boAt which faced difficulties due to shortages. EV makers were also impacted because rare earths are critical for motors and battery systems. However, I would add that while production slowed, no company had to completely shut down operations."The main lesson from this short disruption is the importance of self-reliance and forward planning, he said. "Unlike China, India hasn't sufficiently invested in securing rare earth supply chains despite a decade of efforts to grow its electronics ecosystem. We need to anticipate such risks, prepare alternatives, and allocate resources for domestic exploration, research, and processing of these critical minerals," he said that the disruption has exposed how vulnerable India is to global shocks in critical minerals — and how urgent it is for the country to build its own rare earth Bhatia, managing director and partner, BCG India, told ET: "Curbs on export on the select rare earth elements and related magnets from China to India presented significant production risks to industries like automotive, consumer electronics, and wind power, and any change in the current status will be a welcome relief to the industry."China has a major global role across the rare earth value chain right from mining, oxide processing and downstream rare-earth industries accounting for more than 90% of global output with end products being leveraged across magnets, ceramics, catalysts, alloys etc, Bhatia explained."This is where India should actively be looking to build self-reliance through strategic acquisitions of assets globally via mechanisms like KABIL as well as encouraging the private sector to invest across the exploration, mining and downstream value chain," Bhatia or Khanij Bidesh India Limited, is a joint venture company of three Indian public sector enterprises: NALCO, HCL, and MECL. Its primary goal is to secure the supply of critical and strategic minerals for India by identifying, exploring, and acquiring resources from overseas. KABIL is actively engaged in sourcing lithium and cobalt, among other minerals, from countries like Argentina and Australia.A reliable supply, experts said, will help Indian manufacturers scale up production, stabilise costs of raw materials, and plan long-term investments in R& the larger implications of China's policy shift, T Senthil Siva Subramanian, head, Institute Industry Interface Programme, Hindustan College of Science and Technology (Sharda Group of Institutions), Mathura, told ET, 'Lifting export curbs on rare earth metals, particularly Yttrium, will catalyse growth in India's opto-electronics ecosystem. As the global leader in yttrium production , China's policy shift opens new avenues and enormous opportunities for India to accelerate innovation in advanced plasmonic sensing technologies.'He explained that Yttrium's unique hydrogen-sensing properties make it suitable for plasmonic hydrogen gas sensors, and with India advancing indigenous chip design and fabrication, Yttrium-based Sensor Systems on Chip (YSoC) could emerge as a sensors, he said, will be critical for defence, space exploration, and green energy initiatives, including the National Green Hydrogen Mission, Indian Semiconductor Mission, National Quantum Mission, and National Manufacturing Mission. The availability of rare earths, he added, will also empower Indian MSMEs to conduct research, innovate, and manufacture rare earth-based opto-electronic chips—marking a leap in India's domestic inputs from Subhayan Chakraborty and Tanya Pandey in New Delhi.
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Punjab demands Rs 60,000cr from Centre, cites pending GST, rural fund, other dues
1 2 Chandigarh: Punjab finance minister Harpal Singh Cheema on Thursday urged the Centre to pay the state govt a total of Rs 60,000 crore, including a pending goods and services tax (GST) compensation and other outstanding funds. Cheema criticised the "arbitrary" rationalisation of GST tax slabs as a "gamble" by the Centre, calling it BJP's "jumlebaazi" (fraud). He also questioned the move to rationalise GST by slashing "sin tax" on goods like unmanufactured tobacco and cigarettes. After attending back-to-back meetings of the Union govt's group of ministers (GoM) on GST in New Delhi, Cheema told TOI that the state suffered substantial financial losses under the GST regime without receiving due compensation. "Centre wants to shatter the economy of the states and it is the biggest attack on India's federal structure. When states don't have funds to carry out developmental works, they will have to approach the Centre with folded hands for constructing schools and hospitals. Since the introduction of the GST regime, 27 exemptions have been given to various sectors and items, and rates have been revised 15 times already. It shows the Centre's GST system is faulty and needs to be corrected," he said. Providing a breakdown of the Rs 60,000-crore demand, Cheema said the amount includes Rs 50,000 crore for uncompensated GST losses, Rs 8,000 crore in pending rural development fund (RDF), and an additional Rs 1,000 crore that is set to be withdrawn from the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojna by dropping certain projects in the state. Cheema highlighted the financial impact on Punjab since GST regime was introduced. "Since the introduction of GST, Punjab has suffered a loss of Rs 1,11,045 crore," he said. He added that while the state's revenue projection was Rs 2,37,520 crore, Rs 1,26,485 crore was promised as compensation under the GST regime. The minister also voiced concerns over the Centre's handling of the compensation cess and the slashing of tax on "sin" goods. He alleged that Punjab suffered financial losses due to the Centre's "wrong policies". He added if the state had not joined the 'one-nation, one-tax' regime, its tax collection would have been much higher. Regarding the tax rate changes, Cheema accused the Centre of "gambling in the name of rationalisation" and randomly changing slabs. He cited the example of tax on unmanufactured tobacco being slashed from 90-98% to 40%, while the tax on cigarettes was reduced from 33-64% to 40%. He questioned how this could be a move to ensure people's health. He noted that the tax on processed food like pasta was proposed to be reduced from 12% to 5%. "At the meeting, we demanded that the state should be compensated on account of any losses due to rationalisation of GST rates," he said. Slamming the BJP, he said, "It is jumlebazi of the BJP-led Centre. They say people will celebrate Diwali, but they have played a gamble by trying to make some goods cheap and others costly... We have supported some of the changes, but the Centre should compensate the states for the losses." During his recent Independence Day speech, PM Narendra Modi announced that "next-generation GST reforms" would be unveiled by Diwali, referring to them as a "Diwali gift" and a "double Diwali" for the people. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Economic Times
31 minutes ago
- Economic Times
GoM clears GST 2-slab overhaul, revenue loss in focus
Synopsis India's GST structure is set for simplification. A group of ministers approved a plan to move to a two-slab system. The GST Council may meet in early September for faster implementation. The new structure includes 5%, 18%, and 40% slabs. States are concerned about potential revenue loss. The Department of Revenue will assess the impact. Agencies The simplification of India's goods and services tax (GST) structure took a significant step forward with the group of ministers (GoM) on rate rationalisation unanimously accepting the Centre's proposal to move to a twoslab structure of 5% and 18% with a special 40% levy for sin goods, paving the way for next-generation reforms in the country's eight-year-old indirect tax GST Council, the apex decision-making body for the tax, could meet in the first week of September instead of the second half of next month as planned earlier, to ensure early implementation of the reform in time for Diwali, people familiar with the matter said. The GoM, chaired by Bihar deputy CM Samrat Chaudhary, approved the Centre's proposal to abolish the 12% and 28% rates, shifting goods to the 5%, 18% and 40% slabs. The proposal was unanimously accepted by the six members present —three each from states ruled by the BJP and the opposition—as they all favoured giving relief to the people. All states want ultra-luxury cars and high-end products in the highest slab of 40%.However, some states also wanted the Centre to assess the revenue loss to states due to the reform and ways of compensating them, something they said was missing in the Centre's proposal. 'Both the proposals of the Centre have been accepted by the GoM on rate rationalisation,' Choudhary told reporters after the meeting. The GST Council, which set up the GoM, will discuss the reform proposals item by item at its meeting. Prime Minister Narendra Modi had announced the plan to reform GST during his Independence Day address on August 15, calling it a Diwali gift. A revamped GST is expected to lower prices, boost consumption and drive economic growth amid global economic uncertainty. Revenue concern The biggest concern for states is the revenue loss on account of the changes and the absence of a mechanism for compensation as most of them depend heavily on GST revenue.A recent SBI research report suggested that the Centre's GST reform proposal could cost Rs 85,000 crore to the exchequer annually. The Department of Revenue will conduct an assessment of revenue loss that will be presented to the GST Council.'We have said we are okay with any rate rationalisation proposal, which is pro-people, but we should also know the revenue loss that we are going to suffer,' West Bengal finance minister Chandrima Bhattacharya said. 'Because, ultimately, if a state suffers any loss, then it boils down to the sufferance of the common man.'She suggested amending the GST law to allow imposing a levy over and above the 40% permissible rate, to maintain overall tax rates on these products once the compensation cess ends. Other opposition states supported that view. Telangana deputy chief minister Mallu Bhatti Vikramarka said rate rationalisation must be balanced by ensuring that revenues of the states are protected. Otherwise, welfare schemes meant for poor people and the middle class will be hit as will infrastructure projects, he said. He suggested that the GST rate on sin or luxury goods be increased to current levels and the additional amount collected be given to the states.
