DC plane crash: Mapping the flight paths that put jet and helicopter on collision course
The aircraft collided over the Potomac River
D.C. has restricted and congested airspace
Those who fly in and out of Reagan Washington National Airport – a scant three miles from the White House and two miles from the Pentagon – say it's a complicated airspace to navigate. The sky around the busy airport serving the nation's heavily populated capital is hemmed in by restrictions imposed due to national security and other concerns. What's left is shared by commercial, civilian and military aircraft.
The Federal Aviation Administration usually requires aircraft to fly above the Potomac River, which shrinks air traffic volume to a narrow corridor. Aircraft must maintain specified altitudes to reduce noise levels in residential and tourist areas, including the National Mall.
The Black Hawk helicopter left Davison Army Airfield at Fort Belvoir in Virginia, about 15 miles southwest of the airport, authorities said Thursday. The helicopter was on a "routine annual re-training of night flights on a standard corridor for a continuity of government mission" when it crashed, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth said in a video statement posted to X on Thursday morning.
American Airlines Flight 5342 departed Wichita, Kansas, on Wednesday afternoon for a flight to Reagan National.
The crew was 'fairly experienced,' and was conducting a night evaluation, Hegseth said. Night goggles were on board. Hegseth says that "a mistake was made" and that there was "some sort of an elevation issue."
The helicopter may not have been equipped with ADS-B
In-flight aircraft are tracked by air traffic control and other aircraft with special communications systems:
ADS-B: Automatic Dependent Surveillance Broadcast is a primary system that automatically transmits an aircraft's position, using GPS-based latitude and longitude.
Mode S: Mode Select is a secondary surveillance and communication system, an aircraft transponder that sends data to air traffic controllers and other aircraft.
MLAT: Known as multilateration, this system applies mathmatical calculations to Mode S signals to triangulate an aircraft's position.
ADSBexchange was able to triangulate the flight path of the helicopter using multilateration (MLAT). FlightRadar24 describes MLAT as a flight tracking technique that determines aircraft position by measuring the time difference of arrival (TDOA) of signals sent from the aircraft to multiple ground stations.According to Dan Streufert, founder and president of flight tracking network ADSBexchange, the passenger jet was broadcasting ADS-B data, which details an aircraft's position, including GPS-based latitude and longitude. However, the helicopter was not broadcasting ADS-B and was only broadcasting Mode S, a secondary surveillance and communication system.
Strufert says that because MLAT is a function of the receiver network it was possible to triangulate an approximate flight path even without ADS-B data. While FlightRadar24's network did not have enough nearby receivers, the ADSBexchange network had at least 4-6 in the area. The path appears a bit jagged due to the lack of precision.
Streufert says that it appears that the Black Hawk may not have been equipped with ADS-B at all — however it did have a transponder, and would have been visible on air traffic control radar in either case. Without ADS-B broadcasting, the helicopter would not have been "invisible", but would be "less visible" to the jet.
The jet would have been equipped with Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System (TCAS), which, at a higher altitude would have likely prevented this collision. Streufert adds that "TCAS would have issued a traffic advisory under most circumstances, even without ADSB. However, TCAS is inhibited at low altitudes around airports to avoid nuisance/false alarms due to aircraft taxiing, etc."Why would the helicopter not have had ADS-B? Streufert says that security and cost issues are often cited, though he thinks integration with the civilian air traffic system would argue in favor of installing the equipment.
"While civilian aircraft are required to be equipped in most US airspace, the FAA does not have the ability to mandate this for military aircraft. The military has been slow to deploy ADSB, especially on it's smaller aircraft", said Streufert.
Air Traffic Control was in contact with jet, attempted to contact helicopter
Squeezing into Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport is a choreographed dance for experienced pilots to navigate a smaller-than-standard and complex runway configuration. Add on top of that the prohibited airspace around the White House and Capitol complex known as P-56 and it requires special training and focus, said University of North Dakota Aviation Professor Jim Higgins, who flew into the airport as a commercial pilot.
'As someone who's flown that approach, your focus and attention is almost entirely on the landing zone, completing the landing, rolling out and bringing the aircraft to a stop,' Higgins said. 'You are not expecting a piece of traffic or helicopter or plane so close to you and so close to the ground.'
Higgins said one plausible theory has emerged that air traffic controls instructed the UH-60 Black Hawk to maintain separation from the regional jet and those pilots identified the incorrect aircraft.
Higgins said pilot proficiency of the regional air carrier or military would be deeply examined along with all the communications and actions by the National Transportation Safety Board. The NTSB will also examine whether the helicopter was communicating with traffic controllers on a different radio frequency that the commercial pilots.
The Bombardier regional jet was equipped with a traffic alert and collision avoidance system aimed at alerting pilots of a hazard, but so close to the airport and ground, Higgins said the system often 'declutters' the clusters of planes on the radar system and goes into 'inhibit mode' which blocks the alerts in certain landing phases.
'Obviously something went catastrophically wrong,' Higgins said.
Audio recordings from air traffic controllers captured dramatic communications before and after the collision.
LiveATC.net, a respected source for in-flight recording, recorded the moments before and after the crash, according to reporting from Reuters. The audio details communications between air traffic controllers and other aircraft, as well as the the final communication attempt with the three Army crew members in the helicopter – call sign PAT25 – before the collision with the jet.
Timeline of aircraft collision
Times are Eastern and approximate:
6:18 p.m.: Flight 5342 departs Dwight D. Eisenhower National Airport in Wichita.
Flight 5342 departs Dwight D. Eisenhower National Airport in Wichita. 8:45 p.m.: Flight 5342 approaches Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in Virginia.
Flight 5342 approaches Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in Virginia. 8:46 p.m.: Air traffic controllers ask Flight 5342 to land on Runway 33. Pilots acknowledge.
Air traffic controllers ask Flight 5342 to land on Runway 33. Pilots acknowledge. 8:47 p.m.: Air traffic controllers attempt to contact the helicopter pilot seconds before the two aircraft collide.
Air traffic controllers attempt to contact the helicopter pilot seconds before the two aircraft collide. 8:48 p.m.: Control tower sounds alarm to alert responders to crash.
Control tower sounds alarm to alert responders to crash. 8:53 p.m.: Washington Metro police receive calls about the crash.
Washington Metro police receive calls about the crash. 9:30 p.m.: FAA and law enforcement confirm aircraft collision and crash.
FAA and law enforcement confirm aircraft collision and crash. 10:30 p.m.: National Transportation Safety Board investigators arrive on scene.
National Transportation Safety Board investigators arrive on scene. 11:30 p.m.: At least 18 bodies reported recovered.
SOURCE USA TODAY Network reporting and research; Reuters
Contributing: Nick Penzenstadler and Jim Sergent, USA TODAY.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
8 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
‘Primal Intelligence' Review: Why Brains Are Better
The Army recruit looked out over the obstacle course of logs and ropes. Between him and success was a simple rule: Ring the bell at the end of the course before time expires. If he doesn't, he fails—and he can pack his bags. There was just one problem: He simply wasn't fast enough. He didn't want to quit, and he didn't want to fail; he needed a plan. So when the clock started, the recruit ran around the obstacles, ringing the bell in record time. This isn't the way to make friends in the military—or at least, not usually. 'At any other military school,' writes Angus Fletcher, 'the recruit would have been disciplined for insubordination.' But this was the Army special-operations unit—where Rangers and Green Berets, among others, are trained—and he'd reminded his superiors of something important, even crucial: In the real world, there are many paths to a goal, and those who succeed tap into something beyond black-and-white rule-following. They have creativity and flexibility; they have something that Mr. Fletcher, a professor of English at Ohio State's Project Narrative, calls primal intelligence, a 'natural cleverness that AI can't replicate.' It evolved with us and it's something that artificial intelligence is 'mechanically incapable' of mastering. Curious, intriguing and accessible, Mr. Fletcher's 'Primal Intelligence: You Are Smarter Than You Know' begins with a colonel on a mission. 'He'd parachuted onto a thousand targets, from coconut Pacific reefs to concrete Persian palaces to moonlit bullet alleys,' and in March 2021 he 'dropped into Ohio State.' His objective: investigate a rumored discovery about the 'primordial brainpower that drove intuition.' If true, then the Army wanted it, because each year the new recruits seemed to be getting worse and worse at the kind of thinking that keeps people alive on the battlefield. As Mr. Fletcher describes it, primal intelligence is part of our lost nature and a key to activating intuition, imagination, emotion and common sense. The colonel called it the answer to making soldiers think faster, act wiser and even heal from trauma more quickly. It's hard not to be skeptical of something that makes such enormous promises. Yet in 2023 the Army awarded Mr. Fletcher the Commendation Medal for his research on retraining the human mind.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Marines reenlist in disgusting pool of muck because Marines
When you see a small group of Marines standing at attention while shoulder deep in murky water, don't worry, this is normal — or at least as normal as Marines get. Marines thrive in austere environments. As such, they have turned embracing the suck into a science — would another branch voluntarily send human life forms to Twentynine Palms, California? So, it makes sense that some Marines would choose to hold their reenlistment ceremonies in some sort of body of water so that they and the rest of their squad can be wet, cold, and mildly miserable during one of the most important days in their careers. A recent video posted on social media shows two Marines electing to do just that. In this case, they and their fellow Marines are almost totally submerged in what looks like a pond of squalid water that could be the ancestral home of the mosquito. Both Marines are water support technicians assigned to Marine Wing Support Squadron 271, said Capt. Jacob Ballard, a 2nd Marine Aircraft Wing spokesperson. Marines in that specialty are tasked with purifying the type of putrid water they are standing in to make it potable for Marines in the field. 'It is always significant when a Marine raises their right hand and voluntarily pledges to serve another four years for their Corps and country,' Gunnery Sgt. Kaleb A. Skaggs, utilities operations chief for the support squadron, said in a statement. 'Cpl. Jarrett Cadd and Cpl. Matthew Stone, both 1171 water support technicians by trade, recently did just that.' 'A reenlistment in the very water they train in holds deeper meaning for a 1171,' Skaggs continued. 'Their decision to reenlist while standing in murky water is symbolic: This is exactly the kind of environment they are trained to transform to support their fellow Marines. There's no place more fitting to reaffirm their commitment.' The Marine officiating ceremony reads a letter from the two Marines' commanding officer that is dated July 15. After both Marines take their enlistment oaths, their buddies applaud and whistle their support, even though they are immersed in the ooze. Top Stories This Week News Army infantry training unit reverses 'bay tossing' ban Army infantry training unit reverses 'bay tossing' ban By Jeff Schogol News Several thousand US troops deployed to LA. Now a judge will decide if it was legal. Several thousand US troops deployed to LA. Now a judge will decide if it was legal. By Nicholas Slayton Culture Laura Loomer unites vets from both sides of aisle after Medal of Honor rant Laura Loomer unites vets from both sides of aisle after Medal of Honor rant By Matt White The tradition of holding aquatic ceremonies is not limited to a particular military occupational specialty. In 2022, Sgt. Jordan James, a Scout Sniper, was promoted to his current rank while standing in swampy water, while other Marines were up to their chins in the muck. James told Task & Purpose at the time that he decided to have his promotion ceremony during a training event in which he and his fellow Scout Snipers could use mud to make their ghillie suits, which are made from local reeds and other plants to allow them to blend into their surroundings. He superficially picked a swamp in Okinawa, nicknamed the 'Pig Pond,' to reenlist because all Marines are equal in that environment, he said. 'Everything we do in Scout Sniper Platoon is very team-oriented,' James said. 'So, doing it in the Pig Pond, being together, all wearing the same garb, all kind of suffering together, just made it seem like more of a team thing.' And that is the Marine ethos in a nutshell: Everyone suffers together. Solve the daily Crossword
4 days ago
Unlikely reunion between 2 World War II veterans
A radio navigator on a B-17 bomber and a ground crew armorer, who both served in Italy, reconnected after they were discovered to be living about 15 minutes away from each other.
