Bar Council issues notices to 16 lawyers over alleged bench-hunting in Roop Bansal case
In an order dated August 7, 2025, the Committee directed the advocates to appear in person or through counsel on August 16 at 3 pm, along with their replies. The list includes Senior Advocates Rakesh Nehra and Puneet Bali, besides Advocates J.K. Singla, Sidharth Bhardwaj, Aditya Aggarwal, Gagandeep Singh, Anmol Chandan, Baljeet Beniwal, Harsh Sharma, Sauhard Singh, Rupender Singh, Ankit Yadav, Ashim Singla, Aakash Sharma, Ms. Bindu, and APS Shergil.
The move follows observations made by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in CRM-M-19843-2025 (Roop Bansal vs State of Haryana), where Chief Justice Sheel Nagu, in the open court, flagged concerns over 'bench shopping' and warned that such conduct was 'destroying the Bar.' The Indian Express had reported that the Bench had asked Bansal's legal team to produce the advocate who filed a fresh plea in the matter 'just to get the case out of a particular Bench.'
The Committee, chaired by Raj Kumar Chauhaan, said the matter was taken up suo motu to 'uphold the dignity of the legal profession, ensure the maintenance of legal ethics, and discharge the responsibilities entrusted under law.'
It further wrote, 'In the battle of justice and injustice and in between the righteous and wrong, in Mahabharata, the silence of Bhishma and Drona in the Court of Hastinapur, during Draupadi's humiliation, reveals a timeless truth – when those trained in law and morality remain silent in the face of injustice, the law itself collapses.'
Citing legal maxims and historical analogies, it likened any attempt to subvert judicial processes to an 'invasion of the Temple of Justice,' comparable to 'the desecration of the Somnath Temple in the 11th century.'
From the records, the Committee said it appeared that Advocate J.K. Singla 'orchestrated the game plan' but that it was 'highly unbelievable' such an effort could be carried out alone. 'There might be some big ingenious mind advocates behind the curtains, which has to be unearthed,' it noted, terming the alleged conduct as 'tactful, systematic and in an organized manner.'
The order invoked Section 6(c) and (d) of the Advocates Act, 1961, empowering the Bar Council to take action in cases involving professional misconduct. It also acknowledged the 'complexity of tactics such as bench hunting, bar hunting or forum shopping' allegedly adopted by some lawyers and businessmen 'for ulterior motives.'
The Committee said it would also seek responses from senior advocates Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Mukul Rohatgi 'to fairly and comprehensively adjudicate the matter.' Additionally, it invited information, complaints, or any material from advocates and affected persons via its official email and WhatsApp number.
Emphasising that 'legal ethics are not optional, they are sacred,' the order warned that any lawyer who manipulates the judicial process 'for convenience and gain' is 'a menace to society.' Quoting Gandhi, Ambedkar, Roscoe Pound, Lord Denning and Justice Louis Brandeis, the Committee underlined that lawyers are 'custodians of justice' and 'guardians of constitutional morality.'
'The Bar Council cannot sit idle as a mere spectator. It is the duty of the Committee to trace out the rotten apple/apples from the basket, before all get rotten,' the order concluded.
Bar Council Secretary Gagandeep Jammu, when contacted, said, 'As Secretary of the Bar Council, I will be forwarding these notices to the advocates concerned on the allegations of bar shopping. If the Bar Council is satisfied with their explanation, it will close the matter, if not, it has the power to suspend or even cancel their licences.'
The notice further read, 'This Committee is also of the view that for the fair inquiry and to look into the unethical measures adopted by some of the advocates, let the information/complaints/any kind of material, if any, be taken from the advocates and the affected persons.'
The matter will be heard at 3 pm on August 16, at the Bar Council's Chandigarh office.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
23 minutes ago
- Indian Express
From the Urdu Press: ‘All eyes on Rahul's next move as he rises as Opp face', ‘EC must avoid knee-jerk reaction over SIR'
The Election Commission (EC)'s special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar and the 'vote theft' allegations have continued to generate fireworks between the government and the Opposition within Parliament and outside, with about 300 Opposition MPs taking to the streets to hold a march to the EC office. These developments dominated the coverage of the Urdu dailies through the week, with the voter list row expected to remain on the boil for a long time. Referring to the Opposition MPs' march from Parliament House to the EC headquarters in the heart of the Capital over the Bihar SIR and alleged 'vote theft' in various elections, the Mumbai-based Urdu Times, in its August 12 editorial, says that the protest displayed a remarkable show of the INDIA bloc's unity. 'After being mocked as 'Pappu' of Indian politics for a long time, Leader of Opposition (LoP) in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi has now come a long way as he led an unprecedented march of Opposition MPs, which was stopped by police,' it says, adding that several Opposition leaders, including Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, were detained before release later. The editorial also states that the INDIA bloc's joint protest has sounded the bugle for the Bihar Assembly polls. 'All eyes would now be on the next move of Gandhi, who has established his credentials as the Leader of the Opposition.' Pointing to Gandhi's accusations against the EC and BJP of perpetrating a 'criminal fraud', the New Delhi edition of Inquilab, in its August 10 editorial, writes that a significant aspect of the Congress leader's move this time is that he did not only level the 'vote chori' charge but also sought to substantiate it with findings of a Congress investigation into voting in the Mahadevapura Assembly segment, part of the Bangalore Central parliamentary seat, in the 2024 Lok Sabha polls. After making his revelations through a presentation, Gandhi urged the EC to do course-correction in order to properly discharge its constitutional duty as an autonomous body, the edit says. 'The Congress led by Mallikarjun Kharge and Rahul Gandhi seems to have understood that mere allegations and protests against the alleged misuse of the country's institutions by the ruling dispensation would not create resonance, (and this) could be done through evidence unearthed through meticulous research and investigation,' the editorial says. Rather than looking into the LoP's charges objectively, it adds, the EC, in a 'knee-jerk reaction', just asked Gandhi to submit it through a signed declaration. The daily says Gandhi's claims cannot be brushed aside by the EC as they are not just allegations, like those made earlier by the Congress and other Opposition parties in various polls. 'In the absence of digital electoral rolls, the LoP's team pored over massive EC data manually for six months to come up with these revelations. Gandhi should be credited with this long, painstaking exercise, which evoked his 2022-23 Bharat Jodo Yatra that he undertook on foot from Kanyakumari to Kashmir,' it says. 'Gandhi's expose of electoral irregularities has not only enhanced public awareness but would also boost the Opposition's unity.' Commenting on the continuing logjam in Parliament, which has washed out most of the Monsoon Session so far, the Bengaluru-based Salar, in its August 8 leader, points out that such sustained disruptions have regularly hampered the House in recent years. 'This time, there is a standoff between the government and Opposition over the Bihar SIR, with the latter pressing for a debate on the issue. The government has rejected the Opposition's demand on the ground that it is a sub-judice matter pending in the Supreme Court and that the EC is a constitutional body whose functioning could not be discussed in Parliament,' the editorial states. The Opposition has countered the government's stance, it notes, with Rajya Sabha LoP Mallikarjun Kharge highlighting, in a letter to Deputy Chairman Harivansh, a ruling given by the Chairman in 2023 on the issue. The daily points out that there has been a cloud over the Monsoon Session since its beginning over the Bihar SIR, which has now become more controversial over various rows, including deletion of 65 lakh existing electors from the draft voters' list. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju has held that the government would be forced to pass Bills amid Opposition MPs' protests, it notes. 'However, it would be better for democracy if both sides participate in constructive debates in the House, for which the government should take the initiative and reach out to the Opposition. It is primarily the government's responsibility to ensure Parliament's functioning,' the edit states. It says alleged irregularities in electoral rolls have also been reported from West Bengal and other states. 'The EC should not be only watchful but also take measures to address the concerns of political parties and citizens in order to uphold public trust in the poll body as well as democracy.'
Hindustan Times
23 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
EB-5 visa program: USCIS set to reveal investment rules for green card applicants, check details here
USCIS will release EB-5 regulations in November that will help investors understand how long they must maintain their contributions in the investor program in order to be eligible for green cards. The EB-5 visa program requires a minimum capital of $1,050,000, whereas the Targeted Employment Area needs a minimum of $8,000,000. Investors that make the required investment in a US-based business and create or maintain ten permanent full-time jobs for eligible US workers are allowed to apply for lawful permanent residence and get a Green Card under the EB-5 visa program. All about EB-5 visa requirement The EB-5 visa program requires a minimum capital of $1,050,000, whereas the Targeted Employment Area needs a minimum of $8,000,000. A federal court issued an order in a lawsuit concerning the 'sustainment period' for money invested through the EB-5 visa program. The disputed topic was about the timeframe under which EB-5 investors can withdraw their investments and still qualify for a US green card. The court was considering a case that would have affected EB-5 investors who wanted to make America their permanent home. Also Read: Setback for Indians? Trump's WH approves major H-1B visa overhaul, set to prioritize higher wages over lottery system The US District Court for the District of Columbia has decided not to become involved in the current 'sustainment dispute' surrounding EB-5 investments. It further stated that formal regulations outlining the requirements of the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act will be released for public discussion by November 2025. USCIS grants the EB-5 investor and their family members provisional permanent residence for a two-year period after they enter the country on an EB-5 immigrant visa. The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) establishes the duration of probationary residence for investors. EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 The EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 (RIA), which President Biden signed into law, removed restrictions on an investor's status as a lawful permanent resident and changed the standards for investment upkeep. In order to understand the new legislative language, the defendant United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) released instructions. The investment must be 'expected to remain invested for not less than 2 years and investors no longer needed to sustain their investment throughout their period of conditional residence,' in a bid to qualify for EB-5 classification, the USCIS said.
India Today
43 minutes ago
- India Today
70-year-old Sikh man in US beaten mercilessly with golf club near gurdwara, critical
A 70-year-old Sikh man was attacked with a golf club in North Hollywood, leaving him critically injured. The victim reportedly suffered from broken facial bones and bleeding in the brain. According to his brother, he has undergone three surgeries. The Sikh community in Los Angeles condemned the attack and also sought increased police protection in the area.A video taken after the attack shows Singh sitting on the pavement in a pool of his own blood, with the golf club used to attack him lying at his Singh was attacked by an unidentified suspect while he was taking his daily walk near a Gurdwara in Los Angeles last Monday. His brother, Gurdial Singh Randhawa, said Singh was totally unconscious. "He is totally unconscious; they keep him under sedation," Randhawa was quoted as saying by Fox 11 Los far, no arrest has been made in the case, and investigators say they are not looking into the attack as a hate reportedly told Los Angeles Police Department officers that the suspect was a man in his 50s. Police said the suspect is a man who was riding a bike at the time of the of the victim said the 70-year-old enjoyed feeding the birds in the parking lot behind the convenience store near the Gurudwara, according to a California-based news portal, would visit the Gurdwara of Los Angeles for daily prayer and meditation, according to the SIKH COMMUNITY HAS SOUGHT INCREASED POLICE PROTECTION IN THE AREAGurdial Singh Randhawa, the brother of the victim, led a prayer for healing with the Sikh community on Monday, 11th Sikh community is now demanding increased police protection following the brutal 70-year-old barely survived the attack but has been in the hospital, unresponsive and in critical condition, ever since. He's undergone three surgeries in the past week for broken facial bones and bleeding in the brain, ABC7 reported."Brutally attacked. I don't know how god saved him. He was almost dead," ABC7 quoted Randhawa as saying."The fact that this happened and no one came to stop it until the point that Singh was left in such critical condition has absolutely spread fear in our community," said Munmeeth Kaur, the legal director of the Sikh Coalition, ABC7 reported."We are asking, we're demanding, that there be increased security in this area so that our community can freely move about and feel at ease to be able to be here, to be walking," Kaur was quoted as saying by 7 LA City council member Monica Rodriguez said, "An assault on any one member of our community is an assault on all of us."advertisementThe victim's family has asked people who might have any information about the attack to come forward to share the information."Please help us, and if somebody can tell us more, something more could happen; we would really appreciate it," Randhawa was quoted as saying by ABC7.- EndsMust Watch
