Titan sub disaster was preventable, US finds in scathing report
The Titan vanished during a descent to the Titanic wreck on a tourist expedition, losing contact with its support ship.
After a tense four-day search, its shattered remains were discovered strewn across the seabed 488m from the bow of the legendary ocean liner that sank in 1912, claiming more than 1,500 lives.
OceanGate, the US-based company that managed the tourist submersible, suspended all operations after the incident.
A company spokesperson said on Tuesday the company again offered its deepest condolences to the families of those who died 'and directed its resources fully towards co-operating with the coast guard's inquiry through to its completion'.
The chair of the US coast guard marine board of investigation, Jason Neubauer, said the accident was preventable.
'There is a need for stronger oversight and clear options for operators who are exploring new concepts outside the existing regulatory framework,' he said in a statement with the release of the 300-page report.
Chloe Nargeolet, whose father, French oceanographer Paul-Henri Nargeolet, died on the submersible, said she was satisfied with the investigation.
'The OceanGate boss didn't do his job properly and obviously my father didn't know that,' she said.
'It was not random or bad luck, it came from something. It could have been avoided.'
The board determined the primary contributing factors were OceanGate's 'inadequate design, certification, maintenance and inspection process for the Titan'.
It also cited 'a toxic workplace culture at OceanGate', an inadequate regulatory framework for submersibles and other novel vessels and an ineffective whistle-blower process.
The report added: 'For several years preceding the incident, OceanGate leveraged intimidation tactics, allowances for scientific operations and the company's favourable reputation to evade regulatory scrutiny.'
The board found OceanGate failed to investigate and address known hull anomalies after its 2022 Titanic expedition. It said data from Titan's real time monitoring system should have been analysed and acted on during the expedition.
It also criticised OceanGate for failing to properly store the Titan before the 2023 Titanic expedition.
The report faulted the absence of a timely occupational safety and health administration investigation into a 2018 OceanGate whistle-blower's complaint combined with a lack of government co-operation, calling them a missed opportunity and added 'early intervention may have resulted in OceanGate pursuing regulatory compliance or abandoning their plans'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
6 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Overfishing forces Zambia's third Lake Tanganyika fishing ban
Once-abundant fish stocks must be replenished, but the ban alone won't inspire more sustainable lake use by local communities. Lake Tanganyika is Africa's longest and deepest lake, with a shoreline longer than Tanzania's entire coastline. It supports local livelihoods and the economies of riparian countries through its rich biodiversity and central role in regional trade and transport. However, unsustainable activities like overfishing threaten the lake's resources. Lake Tanganyika's waters are shared by Tanzania (41%), the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) (45%), Burundi (8%) and Zambia (6%). The lake is governed by the Convention on the Sustainable Management of Lake Tanganyika, which established the Lake Tanganyika Authority (LTA) to facilitate integrated management between the riparian states. The lake's growing population – about 12.5 million in 2012 – is predicted to rise by at least 2% annually. This increases demands on the lake, which already suffers due to climate change, overexploitation, harmful land use practices and pollution. Key ports in Lake Tanganyika Its aquatic ecosystems are among the most biodiverse globally. Hundreds of its fish species are endemic to the lake, and fishing is the primary livelihood for shoreline communities. The Lake Tanganyika perch (Lates stappersi), locally called buka-buka, and two sardine species (Limnothrissa miodon and Stolothrissa tanganicae) or kapenta, form the bulk of Zambia's Lake Tanganyika fisheries. Most catches are destined for surrounding communities, the Copperbelt, Lusaka and the DRC. There is also limited recreational and sport fishing, and a niche market for ornamental fish for aquariums, especially Lake Tanganyika's endemic cichlid species. While industrial fishing was previously the primary fisheries sector in Zambia's portion of the lake, semi-industrial or artisanal fishers gradually overtook the market share. Today, most fishing is by semi-industrial and subsistence fishers. Semi-industrial fishers began catching more species, using more vessels, larger groups of fishers and more effective methods. This, compounded with other impacts like climate change, has reduced stocks. A fisher told the Institute for Security Studies: 'Where you used to catch 50 pieces, now it is three pieces, four pieces.' As catches declined, fishers increasingly turned to illegal methods to increase their yield, including using prohibited monofilament and drift nets that capture juvenile and undersized fish. Monofilament nets are reportedly imported in bulk from China, often passing through Tanzania, where they are also prohibited. A Nsumbu-based conservation organisation reported a single seizure of monofilament nets worth $180,000 in 2024. Divers also collect endemic ornamental fish species for the global aquarium trade. Although cichlids are prized, eels and other species like catfish are also targeted. Zambia's fisheries department reported issuing only two ornamental fishing licences to local companies in 2025. However, sources say there are many more illegal divers, including in Nsumbu National Park, which borders the lake in northern Zambia. Fish are transported to Lusaka or Dar es Salaam, from where they are flown to Europe, the US, Asia and South Africa. Because their cross-border trade is not regulated by CITES (the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora), establishing illegality once shipments leave Zambia is difficult. Zambia's Fisheries Act prohibits fishing without a licence, limits fishing effort and prohibits certain methods and gear, but doesn't provide for quotas. In 2023, the stock decline saw the LTA implement an annual fishing ban. While all four riparian countries should implement the ban, only Zambia has diligently enforced it annually. Fisheries officers from Mpulungu, home to Zambia's only international port, say most fisherfolk adhere to the ban because they have seen their catches increase following previous bans. Tanzania, the only other country to have implemented the ban, has experienced the same. But 'where there are rules, there are also rule breakers', officers say. Despite Zambia overseeing the smallest section of Lake Tanganyika, its monitoring, control and surveillance abilities are restricted by limited resources, including patrol boats and insufficient staff. Although new technologies are being piloted in other Zambian waterbodies, the fisheries department lacks vessel monitoring technologies or drones to expand its reach across the lake. Enforcement challenges are not limited to the lake. Without official fishing ports, fish are landed along the shoreline, often directly at informal markets, where they are sold. Fisheries officers cannot monitor all landings, limiting catch data needed for fisheries management decisions. To complement their operations, the fisheries department often combines efforts with counterparts like the police and special forces marine commandos. They also rely on community policing through fisheries co-management with village conservation development committees. Yet, the fisheries department's relationship with communities is complex. Low literacy reduces locals' understanding of regulations, exacerbated by the absence of an independent monitoring, control and surveillance unit. Fisheries officers act as both fisheries officials and compliance officers – gathering catch data one day, and burning the same fishers' illegal nets the next. Community members therefore hesitate to share information with the department. Their trust is further undermined when they receive no response to reports of infringements, due to limited state resources or corrupt officers. Government assistance to communities has been minimal during the ban, which can be devastating for those without alternative livelihoods. As a result, many oppose the ban. Fisheries are also used as a political weapon. Sources say fishing regulations are used to garner votes, often destroying well-established practices and structures that must be rebuilt after elections. This includes village conservation development committees. While there is cross-border cooperation to gather fisheries data to inform lake-wide management, the ban's unbalanced implementation shows that cross-border resource governance is fragmented. The LTA was established to address this, but riparian states' limited capacity cripples counter-efforts. To boost national capacities, the LTA has partnered with the European Union and United Nations to implement projects aimed at conserving biodiversity and sustainable use. These efforts are encouraging, and Zambia's commitment to the annual fishing ban is commendable. But these actions alone won't inspire sustainable lake use. Integrated resource management by the riparian countries is needed, without overreliance on external funding. Investment in alternative livelihoods beyond the lake's biodiversity should be explored. Key ports like Mpulungu could be expanded to facilitate trade, and more aquaculture could relieve pressure on wild fish populations. Additional fish centres could also be developed to preserve and process catches. A wider range of government departments will have to contribute to such holistic reforms. National monitoring, control and surveillance capacity should be bolstered using increasingly affordable technology. Imposing quotas or closed fishing seasons in selected sites could regulate fishing year-round, provided they can be enforced and fisherfolk are sensitised to their sustainable use benefits. Sustainable use can also be encouraged by providing affordable legal fishing gear and preventing prohibited gear from entering Zambia. If achieved, these steps could provide a blueprint for the DRC, Burundi and Tanzania to also implement the ban. DM
IOL News
15 hours ago
- IOL News
How the University of Pretoria's lily pond pays homage to Claude Monet
The Monet-inspired lily pond at the University of Pretoria campus. Image: Supplied In a secluded corner of the University of Pretoria (UP) Hatfield Campus lies a gem that brought the paintings by Claude Monet, the French Impressionist known for his dreamlike depictions of light and nature, to life, literally. The campus's lily pond, built in 1960, has since been a place of tranquility and a source of inspiration for budding painters and sketch artists. In shedding light on the history of the pond, Jason Sampson, head of the Botanical Gardens at the Manie van der Schijff Botanical Garden, said that legend has it that renowned botanist Prof. Hermanus (Manie) van der Schijff, who built the pond, took an unorthodox approach to creating the lily pond. 'After approaching the UP rectorate with a proposal to build a pond outside of his office and being denied permission every time, Prof van der Schijff took matters into his own hands. Plans were drawn up to construct a square pond that could hold several species of water lilies.' Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Students dug up an area large enough in which to construct the pond during the December recess of 1960. Sampson added that the pond's appearance was inspired by Monet's famous series of lily pond paintings featuring a Japanese bridge and a variety of hybrid lilies with pink, yellow, and white flowers. Up to 30 species of water lilies were cultivated for Monet, and the pond currently holds an estimated 13 of those varieties, four of which were confirmed as featuring in Monet's paintings. After about 50 years of existence, the pond was in dire need of repairs, leading to extensive renovations being done. In 2011, full renovation of the pond commenced, with the bridge over the pond replaced with a sleeker and aesthetically pleasing version. 'The new and improved pond was to have a water pump and an established ecosystem, leading to the pond being rebuilt using a wetland ecosystem-based design. The new pond was lined with 1.5mm thick rubber lining, which is as close to no leakages as you can get.' Sampson explained that the novelty of this lining also lies in its simple repair. 'If a leak does occur, all one needs is a bicycle repair kit to repair the leak.' The lilies in the pond are currently all planted in their planter boxes to prevent any one species of lily from taking over the entire pond, and an established ecosystem has sprung up in and around the pond. Annual maintenance of the pond takes place every spring. 'While it is a well-known fact that UP has two museums on its Hatfield Campus, one could argue that the lily pond also serves as a living museum that recreates and preserves a similar scene to the one that Monet drew inspiration from and is thus a living artwork. It is also an oasis for wildlife that would otherwise not have a habitat in the concrete jungle that is the city where UP is located,' Sampson said.
The Herald
2 days ago
- The Herald
Titan sub disaster was preventable, US finds in scathing report
The catastrophic implosion of the Titan submersible that killed five people in 2023 could have been prevented, a US coast guard investigative board found on Tuesday, calling the vessel's safety culture and operational practices 'critically flawed'. The Titan vanished during a descent to the Titanic wreck on a tourist expedition, losing contact with its support ship. After a tense four-day search, its shattered remains were discovered strewn across the seabed 488m from the bow of the legendary ocean liner that sank in 1912, claiming more than 1,500 lives. OceanGate, the US-based company that managed the tourist submersible, suspended all operations after the incident. A company spokesperson said on Tuesday the company again offered its deepest condolences to the families of those who died 'and directed its resources fully towards co-operating with the coast guard's inquiry through to its completion'. The chair of the US coast guard marine board of investigation, Jason Neubauer, said the accident was preventable. 'There is a need for stronger oversight and clear options for operators who are exploring new concepts outside the existing regulatory framework,' he said in a statement with the release of the 300-page report. Chloe Nargeolet, whose father, French oceanographer Paul-Henri Nargeolet, died on the submersible, said she was satisfied with the investigation. 'The OceanGate boss didn't do his job properly and obviously my father didn't know that,' she said. 'It was not random or bad luck, it came from something. It could have been avoided.' The board determined the primary contributing factors were OceanGate's 'inadequate design, certification, maintenance and inspection process for the Titan'. It also cited 'a toxic workplace culture at OceanGate', an inadequate regulatory framework for submersibles and other novel vessels and an ineffective whistle-blower process. The report added: 'For several years preceding the incident, OceanGate leveraged intimidation tactics, allowances for scientific operations and the company's favourable reputation to evade regulatory scrutiny.' The board found OceanGate failed to investigate and address known hull anomalies after its 2022 Titanic expedition. It said data from Titan's real time monitoring system should have been analysed and acted on during the expedition. It also criticised OceanGate for failing to properly store the Titan before the 2023 Titanic expedition. The report faulted the absence of a timely occupational safety and health administration investigation into a 2018 OceanGate whistle-blower's complaint combined with a lack of government co-operation, calling them a missed opportunity and added 'early intervention may have resulted in OceanGate pursuing regulatory compliance or abandoning their plans'. Reuters
