
Are sector funds worth the hype? Not for most investors
Rising geopolitical tensions—from Indo-Pak border strains to Trump-era tariff shocks—are prompting investors to rethink where to park their money. As global uncertainty deepens, the spotlight is shifting away from sectors like IT and pharma and turning toward manufacturing and capital-expenditure-led industries, especially in India.
Investing in popular sectors or themes with the hope of beating the market can sound like a smart strategy. But in reality, consistently outperforming a diversified portfolio through active sector or thematic bets is as difficult as timing the market—often with results no better than a coin toss.
The challenges of picking winners
Sectors can appear attractive due to a mix of factors: regulatory changes, new product launches, global trade shifts, interest rate movements, government policies, or temporary commodity and currency disruptions. But understanding how these macroeconomic forces interact—while also evaluating company-specific aspects like leadership and execution—is no easy task, especially for retail investors.
As a result, most retail investors tend to make sectoral or thematic investment decisions based on two things: recent market performance of the sector, or media hype fuelled by product launches or industry narratives.
Also read: How red tape is costing public sector bank employees crores in NPS savings
Boom, bust, repeat
The stock market is forward-looking—it often prices in expectations long before actual results show up. This creates a cycle of booms and busts across sectors:
IT stocks soared between 1997–1999 (NSE IT Index: +173%, +193%, +493%), only to crash in the following three years (-35%, -36%, -6% from 2000–2002).
Pharma had a strong run from 2012 to 2015 (+32%, +26%, +42%, +10%) and then posted four straight years of negative returns (-14%, -7%, -8%, -9%).
Infrastructure, real estate, power, and NBFCs saw massive gains before events like the Global Financial Crisis or IL&FS collapse triggered steep declines.
Chemical stocks surged in 2020 and 2021 (+46% and +69%) but have since delivered lukewarm single-digit returns.
Even if an investor correctly identifies a sector on the rise, they still need to exit before the tide turns. That means getting both the entry and the exit right—a double challenge. Statistically, if the odds of one correct decision are 50%, the chances of nailing both fall to just 25%.
The limits of sectoral funds
One of the key limitations of sectoral investing is the narrow mandate that many of these funds operate under. Since sectoral funds are bound to invest only within a specific sector—say, IT or pharma—fund managers have little flexibility.
They are often forced to include nearly all companies in that sector, regardless of quality. This reduces the manager's ability to generate alpha through stock selection. As a result, the fund's performance is almost entirely driven by how the overall sector performs, not by active fund management.
Also read: Are sector rotation funds the answer to risks of sector downturns?
A smarter approach for retail investors
A more robust strategy, particularly for retail investors, lies in diversified portfolios managed by professionals who can actively adjust sector weights as market conditions evolve.
For conservative or first-time investors, it is advisable to start with broad-based investment options such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs), index funds, or diversified equity mutual funds that automatically spread risk across sectors and market caps.
Aggressive or more experienced investors can consider a core-satellite strategy—where 75% or more of the equity allocation is invested in diversified funds (like flexi-cap or multi-cap funds), and the remaining 25% is deployed tactically in sectoral or thematic funds based on strong, well-researched convictions.
Even here, thematic funds may be safer than pure sectoral funds, as they cut across industries. For instance, a 'capex" fund might include exposure to cement, utilities, auto, power, and real estate—providing broader diversification while still capturing a specific investment theme.
Be careful with sector-specific funds. It's hard for individual investors to consistently pick winning sectors better than professional fund managers. You might end up disappointed.
Instead, it's often smarter to let professional fund managers make these active choices within a diversified fund. This gives you much better chances of success.
Also read: Why balanced advantage funds are back in focus for moderate risk investors
Nishant Agarwal, senior managing partner, ASK Private Wealth.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Gold price prediction: Bullion surges toward key resistance as Iran conflict and Trump's tariff threats drive investors to gold—here's what to expect next
Gold prices surge amid Iran tensions and Trump tariff warning : What's driving investor fear?- Gold prices jumped in early Asian trading hours on Thursday, May 26, 2025, as rising geopolitical tensions and trade uncertainty pushed investors toward safe-haven assets. With Middle East conflict fears intensifying and U.S. President Donald Trump signaling a potential new round of trade tariffs, gold surged as markets turned risk-averse. Spot gold prices rose 0.6% to $3,374.94 an ounce, while August gold futures rallied 1.5% to $3,394.60/oz by 01:24 ET (05:24 GMT), according to The metal has already gained strength this week, largely due to uncertainty around U.S.-China trade negotiations and persistent geopolitical instability. Why are gold prices rising today? Several global triggers are fueling the gold rally. Here's a simple look at the top drivers: by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Kein Scherz: So kosten Wärmepumpen 2025 fast nichts Wärmepumpe Vergleich Mehr erfahren Undo Middle East tensions : Reports suggest that Israel could be preparing for military action against Iran, and the U.S. is pulling diplomatic staff from Iraq. This has created major geopolitical uncertainty. Trump tariff threats : President Donald Trump has announced plans to send tariff warning letters to several major economies in the next two weeks, adding fuel to global trade fears. Flight to safety : With rising risks, investors are pulling out of stocks and shifting into safe-haven assets like gold. Weaker U.S. dollar : A falling dollar makes gold cheaper for international buyers, boosting demand. Rate cut expectations : Softer U.S. inflation data has traders betting on a Fed rate cut later this year, which tends to support gold prices. What is the gold price today? As of today, here's where gold stands in the market: Spot gold : $3,374.94 per ounce (+0.6%) Gold futures (August delivery) : $3,394.60 per ounce (+1.5%) Resistance zone : Analysts are watching the $3,380 level closely for a potential breakout. These figures show strong momentum for gold as it inches closer to breaking past key chart levels. Live Events Is this a good time to buy gold? That depends on your investment goals, but here are a few things to keep in mind: Technical indicators show strength , with gold trading just below major resistance. If global tensions escalate , gold could shoot higher as panic drives demand. However, if peace talks resume or tariffs ease , prices might pull back. For short-term traders, the next 24–48 hours could be critical. For long-term investors, today's jump reinforces gold's value during times of uncertainty. Why are rising Iran tensions boosting gold prices? Heightened fears of military conflict between Iran and Israel have directly fueled the demand for gold, which is traditionally seen as a safe-haven during global crises. Several reports suggest Israel is preparing to attack Iran if nuclear discussions between the U.S. and Iran collapse. This follows President Trump's recent statement that Iran would not be allowed to enrich more uranium, casting further doubt over the future of ongoing nuclear talks. Adding to the pressure, Trump ordered the withdrawal of U.S. personnel from Iraq and other Middle Eastern nations, intensifying market concerns over a possible escalation. Iranian officials have also threatened to retaliate against U.S. bases in the region if tensions turn into armed conflict. How is the trade outlook under Trump affecting gold and global markets? In a move that shook market confidence, Trump announced he will send letters to major global economies within the next two weeks outlining new U.S. tariff plans. So far, the U.S. has only formalized a trade deal with the United Kingdom, and has shared only limited information about a recently announced framework with China. This uncertainty has rattled global investors, increasing the demand for gold and other precious metals. With trade talks still lacking clarity and more tariffs possibly on the horizon, investors are seeking stability in assets like gold and platinum. What's happening with other precious and industrial metals? The weak U.S. dollar and overall market caution gave a boost to other metals as well. Here's how they performed: Platinum futures rose 0.8% to $1,251.65/oz — the highest in over four years. Silver futures gained 0.7%, trading at $36.515/oz, near a 13-year peak. Copper prices also moved higher, with LME copper futures up 0.5% at $9,699.70/ton, and U.S. copper futures climbing 0.4% to $4.8242/pound. These gains reflect broader concerns, from weaker global currencies to shifts in industrial demand. Is the platinum rally sustainable or a short-term spike? Despite platinum's strong performance in 2025 — up 37.3% so far this year, compared to a 28.6% rise in gold — Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS) analysts are warning that the rally may not last. According to Goldman, platinum could fall back into its traditional trading range of $800 to $1,150/oz, driven by several key factors. Chinese demand for platinum jewelry is weakening. Automotive demand is slowing, especially as electric vehicles reduce the need for emission control systems that use platinum. South African production remains strong, potentially outpacing demand. This suggests that platinum's gains could be temporary, with prices expected to stabilize or decline in the coming months. What does all this mean for investors moving forward? As gold prices climb on geopolitical risks and trade uncertainty, investors are reassessing their portfolios. The volatile mix of Trump's aggressive trade posture, ongoing Middle East tensions, and currency pressures is pushing money into traditional safe-havens. Even as Goldman Sachs analysts caution about platinum's future, the broader precious metals market is seeing renewed interest. The key now will be how events unfold — particularly around Iran and the outcome of trade negotiations. What to watch next in the gold market? If you're keeping an eye on gold, here are a few key events to track: Any new developments between Israel and Iran Updates on Trump's tariff letters and global reactions U.S. Producer Price Index (PPI) data coming up Federal Reserve commentary on interest rates Each of these factors could impact gold prices in the coming days and weeks. Gold is once again proving itself as the go-to safe-haven when markets get shaky. With geopolitical risks and economic uncertainty on the rise, today's rally could just be the beginning. If tensions worsen, we could see gold breaking through its current ceiling and heading even higher. Stay tuned and watch the key levels. The gold market is heating up—and investors are taking notice. FAQs: Q1: Why are gold prices rising in May 2025? Gold prices are rising due to Iran-U.S. tensions and Trump's new trade tariff plans. Q2: Will platinum prices stay high in 2025? Goldman Sachs says platinum's rise may not last due to weak demand and strong supply.


Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
US producer inflation ticks up in May after tariff rollout
US wholesale prices experienced a slight increase in May, according to government data released on Thursday. The producer price index rose by 0.1 percent, driven by a rebound in services costs and a jump in goods prices. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads US wholesale prices crept up less than expected in May, government data showed Thursday, as economists monitor the effects of US President Donald Trump's wide-ranging producer price index (PPI) rose 0.1 percent last month, up from a 0.2 percent decline in April, according to Department of Labor was boosted by a rebound in services costs, while goods prices also food, energy and trade services, PPI was up 0.1 percent, reversing a 0.1 percent decline in a year ago, PPI climbed 2.6 percent, accelerating from April's 2.5 percent rate, the report had expected a 0.2 percent rise between April and May, according to a consensus forecast by numbers came after Trump imposed a sweeping 10 percent levy on most US trading partners in April, and he has also slapped higher duties on imports of steel, aluminum and expect it will take months for retailers to pass on additional costs to customers. The impact on consumer inflation has been muted for Thursday's report will be scrutinized for any effect it might have on the US central bank's policy meeting next Federal Reserve officials have begun lowering the benchmark lending rate since the Covid-19 pandemic, policymakers have proceeded cautiously in recent times as they monitor the impact of Trump's tariffs.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
‘Beijing keeps its word': China responds as Trump declares US-China trade deal ‘done' - The Economic Times Video
China responded firmly to US President Donald Trump's announcement of a renewed trade deal, confirming that both nations must stick to their commitments. Following a phone call between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, tensions cooled as both sides revisited the Geneva framework in new talks held in London. Beijing emphasises it has always honoured its word, marking a delicate pause in the ongoing US-China trade war.