Millions of homeowners could be paying far too much for their mortgages
Homeowners may be paying too much on their mortgages because of unreliable data from the UK's main statistics body.
Bank of England Governor Andrew Bailey told MPs that the Bank's lack of trust in number crunchers at the Office for National Statistics (ONS) 'does have a bearing' on its decisions on interest rates, which in turn affect mortgage payments.
The Governor did not spell out the implications – but if doubts about the data are delaying interest rate cuts, then millions of borrowers may be paying the price.
Problems have been plaguing the ONS figures on jobs and wages for the past couple of years.
These include difficulty finding enough people to respond to surveys since the pandemic. Smaller sample sizes increase the risk of inaccurate data.
The state of the labour market is a key element in the Bank's deliberations on interest rates. Its aim is to keep inflation near a target rate of 2 per cent.
A strong jobs market and robust growth in wages are normally seen as a factor that would push up inflation and therefore make it less likely the Bank will cut interest rates – and vice versa.
But given the uncertainty around the ONS's key Labour Force Survey (LFS), which tracks this information, members of the Bank's rate-setting Monetary Policy Committee are instead having to make their own judgments by piecing together data from elsewhere.
At a Treasury Select Committee hearing last week, Bailey said efforts by the ONS to improve the reliability of its figures are 'a work in progress' and there was a 'very severe health warning' on the data. Sarah Breeden, the Bank's deputy governor, said other data sources, such as figures from
HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) were being used to help the Bank make its decisions.
However, the HMRC data does not cover self-employed people, a key part of the labour market, which is included in the LFS. Bailey has previously described unreliable labour market figures as a 'substantial problem' for the Bank. His latest comments go further, by saying that the issue is directly affecting decisions on interest rates.
Poor data could affect Britain's 8.4 million mortgage holders, particularly the 1.1 million whose borrowing rates vary as the Bank changes interest rates.
The last rate cut in May – even though it was just a quarter of a percentage point – lopped hundreds of pounds off the average annual mortgage bill.
A typical tracker mortgage saw its annual payments reduced by nearly £350, while the average borrower with a standard variable rate saved £166, according to trade body UK Finance.
The ONS suffered a fresh embarrassment on Thursday when it admitted that the UK's inflation reading in April of 3.5 per cent had been overstated by 0.1 of a percentage point because of an error in how it calculated data related to vehicle tax.
The statistics body has been shaken by changes at the top after its boss Sir Ian Diamond stepped down last month for health reasons. Some experts have said the problems mean the Bank of England is effectively 'flying blind'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
19 minutes ago
- Sky News
Spending Review 2025: Faster drug treatments and longer-lasting batteries to come from £86bn science and tech package
Research into faster drug treatments and longer-lasting batteries will form part of the £86bn science and technology funding due to be unveiled in the government's spending review next week. On Wednesday, Chancellor Rachel Reeves will unveil how much taxpayer money each government department will get. Each region in England will be handed up to £500m to spend on science and technology projects of their choice, the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) says. In Liverpool, the funding is being earmarked to speed up the development of new drug treatments, while in South Wales, it will fund longer-lasting microchips for smartphones and electric cars. Overall by 2030, Ms Reeves's spending package will be worth more than £22.5bn a year, the government says. "Britain is the home of science and technology," she said on Sunday. "Through the 'plan for change', we are investing in Britain's renewal to create jobs, protect our security against foreign threats and make working families better off." Science and technology secretary Peter Kyle added: "Incredible and ambitious research goes on in every corner of our country, from Liverpool to Inverness, Swansea to Belfast, which is why empowering regions to harness local expertise and skills for all of our benefit is at the heart of this new funding - helping to deliver the economic growth at the centre of our plan for change." 3:54 Flat real-terms budget 'won't be enough' Regional leaders such as North East Mayor Kim McGuiness and West Midlands Mayor Richard Parker welcomed the funding promise. But the announcement was met with caution by industry leaders. John-Arne Rottingden, chief executive of Wellcome, the UK's biggest non-governmental research funder, said: "While it's positive under the financial circumstances, a flat real-terms science budget, along with continuing barriers such as high visa costs for talented scientists and the university funding crisis, won't be enough for the UK to make the advances it needs to secure its reputation for science in an increasingly competitive world." He claimed the UK should be "aiming to lead the G7 in research intensity" to "bring about economic growth" and "advances in health, science, and technology that benefit us all". Director of policy and public affairs at the Institute of Physics Tony McBride expressed similar concerns. "To fully harness the transformational potential of research and innovation - wherever it takes place - we need a decade-long strategic plan for science," he said. Mr McBride said a "plan for a skilled workforce... starting with teachers and addressing every educational stage" is key - something he hopes will feature in Ms Reeve's spending review. Among the other announcements expected are a potential scrapping of the two-child benefit cap and a green light to a new nuclear power station in Suffolk - Sizewell C.
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The exact amount of money you need for a 'moderate' retirement - so will YOU have enough? Our experts crunch the numbers and reveal how you can hit the goal at any age
Working out if you're on track for the retirement you dream of is essential to avoid running out of cash in older age. But the calculations are far from straightforward. That's why we've called on experts at investment platform AJ Bell to crunch the numbers to find out how much you need to be saving at every age to stand the best possible chance of attaining your ideal retirement.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
White House warns Downing Street against letting China build 'super embassy' near sensitive financial sites
The Oval Office has urged Downing Street against giving a Chinese embassy the green light to be built near London financial centres. Previously, proposals for the 'super-embassy' were rejected by the Conservative government amid concerns from British intelligence. However, the plans have been reintroduced following lobbying from China 's very own President Xi Jinping. But fresh warning have since emerged, as due to the Royal Mint Court's locality to a sensitive hub of essential communication cables, it poses a great risk for an attack. The suggested site is also situated between several major financial hubs in Canary Wharf and the City as well as three crucial data centres. It is understood US President Donald Trump has warned Sir Keir Starmer against giving the embassy the go-ahead. The matter is believed to have been discussed during trade talks, as Britain and its Atlantic allies discuss how they will implement a trade deal to avoid UK steel producers being lumbered with 50 percent import tariffs by July 9. According to the Times, US diplomats would be trepidatious about sharing intelligence with Britain if the embassy went ahead. A senior US official told the publication: 'The United States is deeply concerned about providing China with potential access to the sensitive communications of one of our closest allies.' It comes after a claims 'dark cabling' running beneath the proposed site 'feeds the City of London' were given in a memo to the United States' National Security Council by members of the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China (Ipac). John Moolenaar, the Republican head of the House of Representatives' China committee said if these reports were 'accurate' that the site would 'pose an unacceptable risk' to both the UK and US. 'The Chinese Communist Party has a clear track record of targeting critical infrastructure.' he said. 'This development would raise serious concerns in the United States and could be viewed as an act of strategic overreach by Beijing and a curious error in judgment by London.' The executive director of IPAC, Luke de Pulford dubbed the matter as a 'flashpoint' in US-UK trade talks, adding that it was 'staggering' the White House had to corroborate the cabling risk to 'defend its own financial system. 'It's time to send Xi Jinping a clear message: no matter the pressure or coercion, the UK and US won't trade away national security, and this embassy isn't happening,' he said. China has been attempting to revise plans for the Royal Mint building, which neighbour the Tower of London, since they were purchased in 2018. It is believed the Chines foreign minister, Wang Yi, brought up the matter with foreign secretary, David Lammy, while visiting London last year. According to The Times, President Xi had also discussed the same issue with the Prime Minister in a phone conversation. The proposal for the embassy, which would be China's largest in Europe, was previously rejected by Tower Hamlets council in 2022. But two weeks after Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves came back from a visit to China earlier this year, both the council's and Scotland Yard's objections were dropped. Priti Patel, the shadow foreign secretary, described China as a 'dangerous threat to the national and economic security of our country'. She said the Conservative party continued to stand 'firmly' against the embassy proposals, stating her party would never put the UK's 'financial centre or country at risk.' Next Monday, three of Trump's aides are scheduled to meet with their Chinese peers in London for discussions in a bid to solve the current trade war between the two economic powerhouses. The Treasury secretary Scott Bessent, the commerce secretary Howard Lutnick and the trade representative Jamieson Greer will act as representatives for the US, Trump has declared on Truth Social. Yesterday, China 's foreign ministry confirmed vice-premier He Lifeng will be on British shores from June 8 until June 13, adding that talks would with the US would take place. Previously, a Chinese embassy spokesperson has quashed spy allegations, stating: 'Anti-China elements are always keen on slandering and attacking China.' A government spokesman said: 'Applications for a new Chinese embassy in Tower Hamlets have been called in for ministers to decide. A final decision will be made in due course.'
