Legal action over changes to resource teaching roles 'possible'
The country's largest teaching union is considering legal action against the government's decision to cut resource teachers in primary schools, confirmed last month as part of the Budget.
Ministry of Education documents from February show that 84 schools employed resource teachers for literacy support, 40 employed resource teachers for Māori and three schools employed both. Nationally, there are a maximum of 121 full-time positions for Resource Teachers of Literacy (RTL) and 53 for Resource Teachers of Māori (RTM).
Minister for Education Erica Stanford said that was a small number of teachers for the country's 2000 primary schools, and, during a consultation process in March, schools had told her the current system was "not equitable".
Stanford said funding was now in place for 349 structured literacy teachers, who would provide support within classrooms - rather than driving from school to school as was the case under the current system - and she encouraged literacy resource teachers "who are amazingly well-qualified and passionate people" to consider applying for those roles.
NZEI national secretary Stephanie Mills said the union was waiting on more information from Stanford about how she came to the decision, and then it would decide next steps.
"We've said from the beginning of the consultation process that we will explore all options to keep those resources intact. It's not about getting rid of a certain number of positions, it's a service that's been built up over time." 'Disrespected and gaslit'
Mills said NZEI had requested details about how Stanford reached her decision via an official information request. The union had asked to see the consultation document prior to the announcement and was told that would be provided a fortnight in advance, but confirmation the roles would be defunded came as part of the Budget.
Teachers felt "really disrespected and gaslit" as a result, she added.
"These teachers are some of our most experienced and skilled, and they're not being treated in a good way."
Mills said many of the current resource teachers were working in rural places and she feared those schools would no longer get the same support.
"It will be quite a different role in the new system. The [same] service won't exist and the jobs won't exist."
Mills said it was an "irony" the literacy resource roles were being cut, "when the government wants structured literacy". Meanwhile RTMs were, in many situations, the only frontline support for kaiako and tamariki Māori. "Māori RTs are like a taonga." Not a cut but 'a reinvestment'
Stanford said she would not be commenting on what action the resource teachers might take.
The move was about schools and students, not the teachers, she said.
"It's about the way we deliver the service, and this advice was given to me by the sector itself, by schools saying 'the way the model is being delivered it's not equitable and many schools are missing out' ... The ones who are getting the service may not have the greatest need, so it's very inequitable.
"What we are doing is shifting that model to an in-class delivery - small groups, intervention teachers, in school."
Stanford said the NZ Resource Teachers Literary Association had had "clear information and met multiple times with ministry officials" and they had been "very clear about the reasons, about the opportunities for them in other roles, and they've met a number of times and they have been given that information".
The move was not a cut but a "reinvestment", Stanford insisted.
"We've already resourced 349 Tier 2 structured literacy intervention roles, over and above the 100 literacy positions that there currently are, so it is not a cut, it is a reinvestment into a better delivery model."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
What will encourage NZers to have more babies?
New population data has confirmed that New Zealand will need to rely more on migration to offset an ageing population in the coming decades. Photo: RNZ More affordable and suitable housing is likely to be a better incentive to get people to have babies than "baby bonuses", economists say. New population data has confirmed that New Zealand will need to rely more on migration to offset an ageing population in the coming decades. Stats NZ said on Tuesday that the estimated population of New Zealand was 5.3 million as at 30 June. The median age of women was 39 and men 37.4. In the year, the population grew by 0.7 percent. The total fertility rate was 1.57 births per woman, marginally up from 1.55 a year earlier. The rate has been below the replacement rate of 2.1 since 2013. Treasury earlier warned that could cause problems as the cost of an ageing population would be covered by a smaller number of working taxpayers. In the 1970s, there were about seven people aged 15 to 64 for everyone aged 65 and over. Today there are four and in 50 years there will be about two. Infometrics lead demographer Nick Brunsdon said it was a situation that had been "in the mail" since the 1960s. "If the average level of migration is 30,000 a year over the next from now to eternity our population is still likely to start declining in probably the 2050s. "Migration is the only thing that can save us but it won't entirely save us over the long term. "We've already become much more reliant on migration than we used to be but we're going to become even more reliant on migration and even more prone to those wild swings that we get in migration." He said with most households needing two earners, having children was more challenging. "That's probably where the action is in terms of making it easier for people to leave and then re-enter the workforce - helping with that is much more effective than any kind of big cash payment, I think it would need to be quite a large cash payment to move the dial. "Other countries have tried throwing money around as a sort of Hail Mary on that front. But the flip side is it's cheaper to get migrants." The US has been reported to be looking at offering US$5000 "baby bonuses". South Korea was paying 2 million won. China offers 3600 yuan. But Brunsdon said that was unlikely to be the solution. "I don't think anyone's going to change their plans for $5000," Brunsdon said. "We can look and see other countries, there are plenty through Europe that are well below 1.5, China's at about 1.3 children per woman and no one's managed to really avert that in a substantial way." He said it was a question of managing the impact. "Net migration is really, really weak. Down below 20,000 and we have a net loss of population in the 20 to 34-year-old age group. More young Kiwis are deciding to leave than come here so the challenge is going to get more acute in the coming years because if you're losing the 20 to 34-year-olds they're not going to be here having kids." Westpac senior economist Michael Gordon said it would take some time before the population tipped into decline. He said there were "push and pull" factors for the falling birth rate. "We have seen birth rates dropping worldwide, it's not just in rich countries, either. "As countries get richer on average, they tend to have fewer children. That's something we see everywhere. But there is also an element of push vectors ... there is a reasonable amount of evidence that unaffordability of housing affects this as well. "It means that people form families later in life. It means they are having fewer children ... the short answer is to do things that improve the lives of everyone in the country and then population trends will change as a side effect of it." That could mean cheaper housing and an increased variety of options to meet different stages of life, he said. "More generally just making kind of housing development more family friendly - access to transport and things like that." That might not only help family size but also encourage people to stay in the country, Gordon said. "The thing is any kind of population policy will ultimately be thwarted by the fact that people can choose to leave. "If we do things to make it more attractive for people to stay. Then, as a byproduct to that, you will get more natural population growth. I mean, another way of putting it is there's no point paying people to have more children if half of them leave the country when they reach adulthood anyway." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Protesters leave coal bucket above Denniston Plateau
By Kate Green of RNZ Two protesters who spent three weeks in a giant coal bucket high above native bush of the Denniston Plateau have now descended. Climate protesters shut down Dunedin bank Rach Andrews and Tāmati Taptiklis from Climate Liberation Aotearoa abseiled in via an aerial ropeway, normally used to carry coal away from the mine in giant metal buckets, on July 27 this year in protest at Bathurst Resources application submitted under the Fast Track Approvals Bill to further mine the Denniston Plateau. Speaking to RNZ from their temporary home in one of the buckets earlier today, Andrews said it had been a worthy cause. "The Denniston Plateau is a beautiful, unique landscape, 40 million years old, and there's just gorgeous lifeforms there that have adapted and evolved to really thrive in these harsh conditions. "I want that to be a wild place that my grandchildren and their children get to experience." The other part of it, she said, was the emissions. "We can't afford to burn the fossil fuels that are already above the ground - to extract more and more and more is to put humanity on a suicide path. "I don't want to be a person that stood by and let that happen." Costing $27k a day: Bathurst Resources Their actions have caused major disruption to Bathurst Resources. The company previously told RNZ it was having to transport coal by trucks while the cableway was occupied. In a statement today, Bathurst Resources CEO Richard Tacon told RNZ the cost of trucking coal out of the mine was $27,000 a day - "to ensure we can continue the employment of 400 people over this period". Determent measures were justified, he said. "This is not a holiday rental they booked and now the neighbours have gotten noisy. This is a coal conveyance system that is not designed to transport or house people." He had previously acknowledged the right to protest, but said climbing into coal buckets was dangerous. "The organisers have no idea of the inherent risks associated with this equipment. Yet, they have assisted to get these people into this position and have now abandoned them to the elements and those risks. "We cannot go out to where they are. The organisers have not allowed communications with the trespassers by us or the police. "The police only have contact via backroom people who are safely located on solid ground." On August 5, Andrews and Taptiklis reported three shotgun shots were fired into the air near their bucket. Taptiklis told RNZ at the time he could see a person about 250 metres away in a Bathurst Resources uniform, walking away and lowering a long, thin object. RNZ put these claims to Tacon, who rejected them. "No firearms were let off at any time." When Andrews spoke to RNZ from her spot above the trees today, a siren could be heard in the background. "We experienced that when we were here at Easter as well. The siren has been going for two weeks, 24-7. It's just kind of background noise for us now. "Of course it's uncomfortable, but it's nothing in comparison to what people are already facing due to the climate crisis." They had brought in everything they needed: food, a solar panel system to charge their devices, a water collection device and a toilet system consisting of bags and buckets. "Tāmati and I are old friends, we know each other pretty well," Andrews said. "We probably know each other a little bit better now. We're still great friends." When asked whether it was worth it, Andrews said "it does feel like a success". "Bathurst have been majorly disrupted by this action. Thousands of people have signed a petition to save the Denniston Plateau. "There were hundreds of people on the street on the 8th of August all around New Zealand at ANZ banks to ask them to withdraw their banking services from Bathurst resources." In April, Andrews was among nine people arrested and charged with trespassing in a similar protest. Seven of them, including Andrews, had pleaded not guilty. Andrews told RNZ today she didn't take those consequences lightly. "I'm expecting to descend the rope and walk out to the Ngakawau carpark and be arrested by the police." Adam Currie, 350 Aotearoa campaigner, said there had been a number of instances of intimidation and threats towards the protesters and their affiliates online, and from members of the community. A group of local students on a field trip to the conservation estate - the proposed site for the new mine - on August 14 returned to find the vans they had arrived in had been set on fire, destroying them along with the students' possessions. Tacon said they had no idea who had burnt the vans, or why. "The attempt to connect Bathurst to this is typical of the tactics employed by this group." On Sunday, Green MP Steve Abel posted a video on Facebook saying: "huge respect" to the protesters. "Those two activists are doing fantastic work. It's not acceptable that they're being intimidated." Bathurst Resources has been approached for further comment. Minister calls protesters malingerers Resources minister Shane Jones told reporters at Parliament today he thought the protesters were "malingerers". "I'm disappointed they won't leave that business alone, they're costing the firm a lot of money and I'm disappointed they don't consider the rights of the workers." Speaking before the protesters began their descent, Jones urged them to come down. "They're not going to change the planet or it's current trajectory, so just call it a day." Anything that shrunk the cost of energy and increased energy security should be making New Zealanders happy, he believed.
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Protesters leave coal bucket high above Plateau
By Kate Green of RNZ Two protesters who spent three weeks in a giant coal bucket high above native bush of the Denniston Plateau have now descended. Climate protesters shut down Dunedin bank Rach Andrews and Tāmati Taptiklis from Climate Liberation Aotearoa abseiled in via an aerial ropeway, normally used to carry coal away from the mine in giant metal buckets, on July 27 this year in protest at Bathurst Resources application submitted under the Fast Track Approvals Bill to further mine the Denniston Plateau. Speaking to RNZ from their temporary home in one of the buckets earlier today, Andrews said it had been a worthy cause. "The Denniston Plateau is a beautiful, unique landscape, 40 million years old, and there's just gorgeous lifeforms there that have adapted and evolved to really thrive in these harsh conditions. "I want that to be a wild place that my grandchildren and their children get to experience." The other part of it, she said, was the emissions. "We can't afford to burn the fossil fuels that are already above the ground - to extract more and more and more is to put humanity on a suicide path. "I don't want to be a person that stood by and let that happen." Costing $27k a day: Bathurst Resources Their actions have caused major disruption to Bathurst Resources. The company previously told RNZ it was having to transport coal by trucks while the cableway was occupied. In a statement today, Bathurst Resources CEO Richard Tacon told RNZ the cost of trucking coal out of the mine was $27,000 a day - "to ensure we can continue the employment of 400 people over this period". Determent measures were justified, he said. "This is not a holiday rental they booked and now the neighbours have gotten noisy. This is a coal conveyance system that is not designed to transport or house people." He had previously acknowledged the right to protest, but said climbing into coal buckets was dangerous. "The organisers have no idea of the inherent risks associated with this equipment. Yet, they have assisted to get these people into this position and have now abandoned them to the elements and those risks. "We cannot go out to where they are. The organisers have not allowed communications with the trespassers by us or the police. "The police only have contact via backroom people who are safely located on solid ground." On August 5, Andrews and Taptiklis reported three shotgun shots were fired into the air near their bucket. Taptiklis told RNZ at the time he could see a person about 250 metres away in a Bathurst Resources uniform, walking away and lowering a long, thin object. RNZ put these claims to Tacon, who rejected them. "No firearms were let off at any time." When Andrews spoke to RNZ from her spot above the trees today, a siren could be heard in the background. "We experienced that when we were here at Easter as well. The siren has been going for two weeks, 24-7. It's just kind of background noise for us now. "Of course it's uncomfortable, but it's nothing in comparison to what people are already facing due to the climate crisis." They had brought in everything they needed: food, a solar panel system to charge their devices, a water collection device and a toilet system consisting of bags and buckets. "Tāmati and I are old friends, we know each other pretty well," Andrews said. "We probably know each other a little bit better now. We're still great friends." When asked whether it was worth it, Andrews said "it does feel like a success". "Bathurst have been majorly disrupted by this action. Thousands of people have signed a petition to save the Denniston Plateau. "There were hundreds of people on the street on the 8th of August all around New Zealand at ANZ banks to ask them to withdraw their banking services from Bathurst resources." In April, Andrews was among nine people arrested and charged with trespassing in a similar protest. Seven of them, including Andrews, had pleaded not guilty. Andrews told RNZ today she didn't take those consequences lightly. "I'm expecting to descend the rope and walk out to the Ngakawau carpark and be arrested by the police." Adam Currie, 350 Aotearoa campaigner, said there had been a number of instances of intimidation and threats towards the protesters and their affiliates online, and from members of the community. A group of local students on a field trip to the conservation estate - the proposed site for the new mine - on August 14 returned to find the vans they had arrived in had been set on fire, destroying them along with the students' possessions. Tacon said they had no idea who had burnt the vans, or why. "The attempt to connect Bathurst to this is typical of the tactics employed by this group." On Sunday, Green MP Steve Abel posted a video on Facebook saying: "huge respect" to the protesters. "Those two activists are doing fantastic work. It's not acceptable that they're being intimidated." Bathurst Resources has been approached for further comment. Minister calls protesters malingerers Resources minister Shane Jones told reporters at Parliament today he thought the protesters were "malingerers". "I'm disappointed they won't leave that business alone, they're costing the firm a lot of money and I'm disappointed they don't consider the rights of the workers." Speaking before the protesters began their descent, Jones urged them to come down. "They're not going to change the planet or it's current trajectory, so just call it a day." Anything that shrunk the cost of energy and increased energy security should be making New Zealanders happy, he believed.
