Decoding Trump's Tariff Threats To India: Fuelled By Sour Putin Ties, Frustration Over Ukraine?
When US President Donald Trump lashed out at India on Monday, accusing it of buying Russian oil, profiting from war, and turning a blind eye to Ukrainian deaths, it raised more questions than it answered. Why would a close partner like India face such blunt accusations? Why now, and why in such stark moral terms?
According to analysts, the answer may lie not in New Delhi but in Moscow. The real trigger, they suggest, could be the collapse of Trump's diplomatic outreach to Russian President Vladimir Putin, and the looming pressure of a self-imposed ultimatum. Trump had returned to office in January 2025 with a bold promise: that he would end the Ukraine war 'within one week."
But after months of fruitless backchannel efforts and shifting timelines, he publicly set August 8 as the final date for a ceasefire deal. With that deadline now days away and no signs of Russian cooperation, his frustration appears to be spilling over.
India, analysts say, could now be the proxy target. 'If Putin were not ignoring Trump's calls to stop waging war in Ukraine, Trump likely would not be going after India so hard for buying Russian oil," said Michael Kugelman, a Washington DC-based South Asia analyst. 'He's clearly taking his frustration with Putin out on India."
pique-at-Putin factor," he said, referring to the idea that Trump's anger at Putin for ignoring his ceasefire push is being redirected at India, one of Moscow's most visible oil customers.
In the early days of his second term, Trump appeared confident. He reopened channels with Russia, sent his envoy Steve Witkoff to Moscow four times, and made friendly overtures. The US under Trump even blocked a UN resolution condemning Russian aggression. Russian media cheered the shift. In one meeting, Putin gifted Witkoff a portrait of Trump, a symbol of how far the optics had moved from hostility to accommodation.
But Trump's real goal, an immediate ceasefire, proved elusive. In late July, after months of fruitless outreach to Moscow, he publicly set August 8 as a hard deadline for Russia to halt hostilities in Ukraine, slashing an earlier 50-day window to just ten days. As the deadline neared, his rhetoric turned sharply hostile: he began describing Russian strikes on Ukrainian cities as 'disgusting" and 'disgraceful," and warned of sweeping sanctions and secondary tariffs on nations trading with Moscow. Then came a flashpoint.
After Trump called Russia and India 'dead economies", former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev hit back with a nuclear-laced taunt, mocking Trump's 'walking dead" rhetoric and warning of the 'Dead Hand," a Cold War-era automated retaliation system. Within hours, Trump responded by ordering two US nuclear submarines to deploy to undisclosed 'appropriate regions."
Though unrelated to the ceasefire plan, the move marked a symbolic escalation. From public threats to military signalling, Trump was now visibly pivoting to a harder anti-Russia posture, driven by a mix of diplomatic frustration and personal provocation.
Despite these provocations, Putin showed no signs of backing down. Kremlin-linked media began portraying the US-Russia dynamic as a standoff with no off-ramp. A Russian tabloid, Moskovsky Komsomolets, described it as a collision between two unstoppable trains: 'The Trump locomotive and the Putin locomotive are speeding towards each other. And neither is about to turn off or stop and reverse."
The August 4 Outburst
Trump's August 4 post on Truth Social marked a turning point. It went beyond economic grievance and accused India of moral complicity. He wrote: 'India is not only buying massive amounts of Russian Oil, they are then… selling it on the Open Market for big profits. They don't care how many people in Ukraine are being killed by the Russian War Machine. Because of this, I will be substantially raising the Tariff paid by India to the USA."
This came just days after he had imposed a 25 per cent blanket tariff on Indian exports and described India as 'our friend" but with tariffs that were 'far too high." The tone had quickly pivoted from pressure to punishment.
Experts believe this escalation is tied to Trump's crumbling Russia strategy. With the August 8 ceasefire deadline approaching, and no movement from Putin, India, despite being neither a belligerent nor a negotiator in the war, has become a convenient scapegoat.
India's Response
The Indian government responded swiftly. In a rare six-point statement, the Ministry of External Affairs dismantled Trump's narrative. It pointed out that India only increased oil imports from Russia after traditional suppliers redirected their shipments to Europe, and that this shift had the explicit encouragement of the US, which at the time was trying to stabilise global oil markets.
More significantly, India called out the West's double standards. The European Union, the statement noted, traded goods worth €67.5 billion with Russia in 2024, far more than India's total. The US itself continues to import Russian uranium, palladium, and fertilisers. 'The targeting of India is unjustified and unreasonable," the statement said, asserting that India would 'take all necessary measures to safeguard its national interests and economic security."
The government also denied Trump's claim that India was profiteering from oil by reselling it globally. Ajay Srivastava, a former trade official and co-founder of the Global Trade Research Initiative, said that the accusation was not supported by any credible evidence. 'India's refineries, both public and private, buy based on price, logistics and security," he explained. 'There is no government mandate to buy Russian oil, nor proof of strategic resale to third parties."
Strategic Experts Back India's Stand
India's sharp response has found backing from key foreign policy voices. Former foreign secretary Kanwal Sibal wrote on X that 'India has issued this statement that explains the rationale of its decision to buy oil from Russia and the hypocrisy and double standards of the US and Europe… India is conveying that it will not cow down to threats."
Strategic affairs analyst Brahma Chellaney called Trump's behaviour erratic and dangerous. 'With his scorched-earth tariff policies and disdain for norms, Trump is a bull in the geopolitical china shop. Dealing with him is a challenge for any country—even more so for risk-averse India." Chellaney added that the irony is glaring: while the West criticises India for buying Russian oil, it continues sending far more money to Moscow through its own trade, even as it fuels a proxy war against Russia in Ukraine.
Is This Really About Oil, Or About Trump's Image?
Beyond the data and diplomacy, this episode may ultimately be about Trump's political credibility. His promise to end the Ukraine war quickly gave him a narrative advantage. But with no ceasefire, no diplomatic win, and Putin openly defying his timelines, Trump's frustration is now playing out in trade policy.
Rather than hitting Russia with further penalties, which could undermine his earlier stance of engagement, he is using India as a pressure valve, analysts say. His inner circle, including Stephen Miller and other senior aides, have repeated the 'India is funding the war" line on US television, reinforcing that this narrative may be part of a broader deflection strategy.
Caught In The Crossfire Of A Broken Promise
India didn't start the war in Ukraine. It has taken no sides, issued no ultimatums, and positioned itself as a buyer in a volatile energy market. Yet it now finds itself accused of indifference to war, profiteering, and moral failure, not because of its actions, but because Trump's dealmaking with Putin has stalled.
top videos
View all
The strategic partnership between India and the US is unlikely to collapse over tariffs or oil. But the current rhetoric marks a serious departure from the measured tone that usually defines bilateral ties. It also raises questions about how far Trump is willing to go to salvage a promise he may not be able to keep.
With August 8 now looming, and Steve Witkoff returning to Moscow for what could be a last-ditch effort at a deal, one thing may be clear: Trump's war of words with India is not about Delhi's policies, it's about Washington's failures.
About the Author
Karishma Jain
Karishma Jain, Chief Sub Editor at News18.com, writes and edits opinion pieces on a variety of subjects, including Indian politics and policy, culture and the arts, technology and social change. Follow her @kar...Read More
Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated!
tags :
donald trump India-US relations us-russia ties
view comments
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
August 05, 2025, 09:41 IST
News explainers Decoding Trump's Tariff Threats To India: Fuelled By Sour Putin Ties, Frustration Over Ukraine?
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
4 minutes ago
- India Today
Trump tariffs trigger volatility on D-Street: What should investors do?
Domestic stock markets opened on a jittery note Thursday after US President Donald Trump announced an additional 25% tariff on certain Indian exports, citing India's continued imports of Russian oil. While the move was widely expected, it has added another layer of uncertainty for investors already grappling with global Sensex slipped over 250 points at the open before paring some losses. The Nifty50 was also trading lower, reflecting broad-based caution and expectations of a volatile trading REMAINS HIGHDr. VK Vijayakumar, Chief Investment Strategist at Geojit Financial Services, noted that the 21-day window before the tariffs come into effect offers room for negotiation. However, the outlook remains clouded. 'There is huge uncertainty surrounding the trade policy and to what extent both nations will be willing to make compromises,' he said. 'President Trump, fresh from the successes he has extracted in deals with others,others, including the EU, is unlikely to budge significantly from his unjustified stand. Unfortunately for India, the US is bargaining from a position of strength.'He praised India's 'mature and measured' response so far but warned that the market could remain under pressure in the near term. 'Export-oriented sectors will remain weak. Domestic consumption themes like banking and financials, telecom, hotels, cement, capital goods and segments of automobiles will remain resilient,' Vijayakumar CAUGHT OFF GUARDAccording to Santosh Meena, Head of Research at Swastika Investmart, markets had already priced in this escalation to an extent. 'This move was largely anticipated by the markets, as President Trump had earlier hinted at such a development. As a result, there is no fresh negative surprise,' he noted that India has so far resisted pressure from Washington, especially in protecting its politically sensitive agriculture and dairy sectors. He characterised the tariff hike as 'part of Trump's aggressive negotiation strategy' and pointed to the upcoming US trade delegation visit on August 24 as a key moment to believes India's core economic strength lies in domestic demand, and that acts as a buffer. 'India remains a domestic consumption-driven economy, with limited direct exposure to the US, except in key sectors like IT, pharmaceuticals, and electronics,' he said, adding that these have been spared from the latest tariff list. However, textiles, gems and jewellery, and leather may come under 'sentimental pressure in the near term.'Rahul Ahluwalia, Founder-Director of Foundation for Economic Development, said, 'The main sectoral impact will be felt by labour-intensive areas which do not have tariff exemptions, like apparel, gems, jewellery and other such sectors where overall we have more than 30bn USD of exports to the US.'WHAT SHOULD INVESTORS DO? advertisementFor long-term investors, Meena advises staying invested. 'This development is part of ongoing global trade tensions and shouldn't distract from India's long-term growth potential,' he said, suggesting that short-term corrections could offer entry opportunities ahead of an expected earnings revival in the coming traders, however, may want to be more defensive. 'The short-term outlook remains uncertain due to a combination of muted Q1 earnings, stretched valuations, and global trade tensions,' Meena said. 'A selective approach is advisable.'With geopolitical tensions rising and domestic indicators turning soft, investors are bracing for a volatile ride. Export-facing sectors may struggle in the near term, but experts seem to suggest that India's underlying consumption story remains intact.(Disclaimer: The views, opinions, recommendations, and suggestions expressed by experts/brokerages in this article are their own and do not reflect the views of the India Today Group. It is advisable to consult a qualified broker or financial advisor before making any actual investment or trading choices.)- Ends
The Hindu
4 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Rupee rises 5 paise against U.S. dollar in early trade
The rupee traded in a narrow range and appreciated 5 paise to 87.67 against the U.S. dollar in early trade on Thursday (August 7, 2025), after U.S. President Donald Trump slapped an additional 25 per cent duty — doubling it to 50 per cent — on Indian goods over New Delhi's continued imports of Russian oil. Forex traders said Mr. Trump's aggressive move, which kicks in 21 days, threatens to raise total duties on select Indian exports to as high as 50 per cent — making them among the most heavily taxed U.S. imports globally. At the interbank foreign exchange, the domestic unit opened at 87.69 against the U.S. dollar then touched an initial high of 87.67, higher by 5 paise over its previous close. On Wednesday (August 6), the rupee rebounded from a record low level and closed 16 paise higher at 87.72 against the U.S. dollar. Mr. Trump's tariffs on Indian exports are likely to hit sectors such as textiles, marine and leather exports hard and was slammed by India as "unfair, unjustified and unreasonable". With this action singling out New Delhi for the Russian oil imports, India will attract the highest U.S. tariff of 50 per cent along with Brazil. The United States has imposed this additional tariff or penalty for Russian imports only on India while other buyers such as China and Turkey have so far escaped such harsh measures. The 30 per cent tariff on China and 15 per cent on Turkey is lower than India's 50 per cent. "The escalation adds to concerns over the economic impact. If no breakthrough happens within the 21-day window, FY26 GDP growth may have to be revised below 6 per cent, factoring in a 40–50 basis point hit — twice the earlier estimate from tariff effects," CR Forex Advisors MD Amit Pabari said. Mr. Pabari further noted that amid these rising tensions and economic concerns, the rupee remains vulnerable and could see further downside as uncertainty continues to mount. Meanwhile, the Reserve Bank of India opted to hold the repo rate steady at 5.50 per cent and retained a neutral stance during its latest policy review. "The decision suggests policymakers are adopting a wait-and-watch approach as they weigh the uncertain trade backdrop against an already slowing global economy," Mr. Pabari said, adding that the room for manoeuvre is tightening. India's foreign exchange reserves fell by $9.3 billion to $688.9 billion as of August 1, reflecting Central Bank's active rupee defence operations amid rising external stress, he said. Meanwhile, Brent crude prices rose 0.99 per cent to $67.55 per barrel in futures trade. The dollar index, which gauges the greenback's strength against a basket of six currencies, rose 0.04 per cent to 98.21. In the domestic equity market, Sensex dropped 335.71 points to 80,208.28 in early trade, while the Nifty declined 114.15 points to 24,460.05. Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) offloaded equities worth ₹4,999.10 crore on a net basis on Wednesday, according to exchange data.
The Hindu
4 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Trump's broad tariffs go into effect, hit goods from major U.S. trading partners
President Donald Trump's higher tariff rates of 10% to 50% on dozens of trading partners kicked in on Thursday (August 7, 2025), testing his strategy for shrinking U.S. trade deficits without massive disruptions to global supply chains, higher inflation and stiff retaliation from trading partners. U.S. Customs and Border Protection agency began collecting the higher tariffs at 12:01 a.m. EDT (0401 GMT) after weeks of suspense over Trump's final tariff rates and frantic negotiations with major trading partners that sought to lower them. "RECIPROCAL TARIFFS TAKE EFFECT AT MIDNIGHT TONIGHT!," Mr. Trump said on Truth Social just ahead of the deadline. Goods loaded onto U.S.-bound vessels and in transit before the midnight deadline can enter at lower prior tariff rates before October 5, according to a CBP notice to shippers issued this week. Imports from many countries had previously been subject to a baseline 10% import duty after Trump paused higher rates announced in early April. But since then, Mr. Trump has frequently modified his tariff plan, slapping some countries with much higher rates, including 50% for goods from Brazil, 39% from Switzerland, 35% from Canada and 25% from India. Tariffs on India The initial 25% tariffs announced by U.S. President Donald Trump on Indian imports came into effect on Thursday (August 7, 2025). Last week, the White House announced that India will face tariffs of 25% after Mr. Trump issued an executive order listing the various duties that Washington will impose on exports from countries around the world. In addition to the 25% tariff announced last week, Mr. Trump on Wednesday (August 6, 2025) imposed another 25% levies on India for its purchases of Russian oil, bringing the total duties slapped on India to 50%, among the highest imposed by the U.S. on any country in the world. Eight major trading partners accounting for about 40% of U.S. trade flows have reached framework deals for trade and investment concessions to Mr. Trump, including the European Union, Japan and South Korea, reducing their base tariff rates to 15%. Britain won a 10% rate, while Vietnam, Indonesia, Pakistan and the Philippines secured rate reductions to 19% or 20%. "For those countries, it's less-bad news," said William Reinsch, a senior fellow and trade expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. "There'll be some supply chain rearrangement. There'll be a new equilibrium. Prices here will go up, but it'll take a while for that to show up in a major way," Reinsch said. Countries with punishingly high duties, such as India and Canada, "will continue to scramble around trying to fix this," he added. Mr. Trump's order has specified that any goods determined to have been transshipped from a third country to evade higher U.S. tariffs will be subject to an additional 40% import duty, but his administration has released few details on how these goods would be identified or the provision enforced. Trump's July 31 tariff order imposed duties above 10% on 67 trading partners, while the rate was kept at 10% for those not listed. These import taxes are one part of a multilayered tariff strategy that includes national security-based sectoral tariffs on semiconductors, pharmaceuticals, autos, steel, aluminum, copper, lumber and other goods. Mr. Trump said on Wednesday the microchip duties could reach 100%. China is on a separate tariff track and will face a potential tariff increase on August 12 unless Mr. Trump approves an extension of a prior truce after talks last week in Sweden. He has said he may impose additional tariffs over China's purchases of Russian oil as he seeks to pressure Moscow into ending its war in Ukraine.
