Picking the Perfect Episode of TV

Yahoo

09-02-2025

This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here.
The following contains spoilers for some of the episodes mentioned.
Recently, I tasked seven Atlantic writers and editors with selecting a perfect episode of TV. What emerged was a list that spans genres, generations, and cultural sensibilities. Their recommendations, which include the Veep episode 'C**tgate' and a SpongeBob episode that examines 'the empty promise of the good life,' are proof that identifying good TV is, at its core, a gut instinct. A perfect episode must find a way to burrow itself in the viewer's mind, ready to be recalled in today's crowded field of television.
When I posed the same challenge to The Daily's readers earlier this week, I was met with enthusiasm and exasperation. 'This is an impossible question,' Eden wrote back. 'It's like asking for the perfect song, the perfect movie, or the perfect book.' That being said, 'I can think of five off the top of my head!'
Eden's list includes 'Forks' from The Bear, 'Through the Looking Glass' from Lost, 'The Suitcase' from Mad Men, and 'Long, Long Time' from The Last of Us. And that doesn't even cover 'Friday Night Lights, or The Wire, or Insecure, or Derry Girls, or The Sopranos, or The Wonder Years, or My Brilliant Friend, or Curb Your Enthusiasm,' Eden added. I can sympathize—the breadth of options is dizzying.
Maybe some criteria would help. Our culture writer Sophie Gilbert wrote that 'the thing I love most is when a television series tells a complete story in miniature—a stand-alone short that puts a particular dynamic or relationship or cast member front and center.' Radio Atlantic's podcast host, Hanna Rosin, argued that, 'unlike a perfect movie, a perfect episode of television does not need to surprise you or make you cry. It just needs to move your beloved or loathed characters through the formula in an especially excellent way.' And Suzanne, 59, offered her own formula: 'The script must be: (1) tense or funny; (2) warm and loving to the viewers, performers, and crew; and (3) move the overall story forward.'
Of course, the benchmarks for what makes an episode perfect are as subjective and varied as viewers' selections. But a thorough analysis of The Daily's reader responses has uncovered some patterns. At least five people named a West Wing episode: Two readers nominated 'Two Cathedrals,' which shows 'the effects of death on time,' wrote David, from Chicago; L. Hawkins, 70, recommends 'Noel,' adding that viewers should 'listen for the sirens as the episode fades out.'
'Long, Long Time' from The Last of Us was mentioned by both Eden and Bob—it offers 'a lesson that love may find you at any time, any place, and under the most unexpected circumstances,' Bob wrote. Two readers agreed with Atlantic film critic David Sims, who insisted in our recent roundup that 'the richest cache [of perfect episodes] to search is the 'case of the week' entries of The X-Files.' Lisa, 47, wrote that she was thrilled to see 'Clyde Bruckman's Final Repose' in our list (she also recommends the series finale of Derry Girls).
Other readers highlighted examples of good comedy. In only 22 minutes, 'Remedial Chaos Theory' from Community 'tells seven different stories, with each timeline building on the last,' E.F., 46, wrote. 'The Ski Lodge' from Frasier stands out to Bruce, 52, who said that the episode is 'riddled with quotable laugh-out-loud lines.' And L.M., 61, laughed until she cried watching a loopy Steve Martin in Only Murders in the Building's 'Open and Shut.'
For some, a perfect episode tells a story that reverberates throughout their life. Sharon, from California, wrote about an episode she remembers watching on Hallmark Hall of Fame, which follows a grief-stricken child who reads a story about magical silver shoes. To his astonishment, he finds skates that look identical, which he puts on to go skating in hopes of bringing back his dead parent. 'As life went on and I became the mother of a child who lost his father in childhood, I've recalled the episode more than once,' Sharon wrote. 'Now, at 80 years old, it still breaks my heart.'
Related:
Eight perfect episodes of TV
The 13 best TV shows of 2024
Here are three Sunday reads from The Atlantic:
The oligarchs who came to regret supporting Hitler
The last days of American orange juice
America's 'marriage material' shortage
The Week Ahead
Captain America: Brave New World, a Marvel action movie starring Anthony Mackie and Harrison Ford (in theaters Friday)
Season 3 of Yellowjackets, a thriller series about a girls' soccer team whose plane crash-lands in the wilderness (premieres on Paramount+ Friday)
Beartooth, a novel by Callan Wink about two brothers near Yellowstone who agree to commit a heist to settle their debts (out Tuesday)
Essay
ADHD's Sobering Life-Expectancy Numbers
By Yasmin Tayag
When I was unexpectedly diagnosed with ADHD last year, it turned my entire identity upside down. At 37, I'd tamed my restlessness and fiery temper, my obsessive reorganization of my mental to-do list, and my tendency to write and rewrite the same sentence for hours. Being this way was exhausting, but that was just who I was, or so I thought. My diagnosis reframed these quirks as symptoms of illness—importantly, ones that could be managed. Treatment corralled my racing thoughts in a way that I'd never before experienced.
Read the full article.
More in Culture
10 indie films you should watch for in 2025
A horror movie that already gave away its twist
How the economists took over the NBA
Music's new generation is here.
The modern voice of war writing
Catch Up on
The government's computing experts say they are terrified.
Nobody wants Gaz-a-Lago.
Trump's assault on USAID makes Project 2025 look like child's play, Russell Berman writes.
How Trump lost his trade war
Photo Album
Take a look at these photos of Maha Kumbh Mela, a religious festival in India that's also the largest gathering in the world.
P.S.
I realize it'd be a bit unfair to make everybody else share their perfect episode without naming mine: the series finale of Fleabag. There are many good things I can point out about this episode—Claire's mad dash to happiness, Fleabag's final confession, the Alabama Shakes song that plays over the show's last moments. But above all else, it moved me, reminding me that love can outlast the person who prompted it.
— Stephanie
When you buy a book using a link in this newsletter, we receive a commission. Thank you for supporting The Atlantic.
Article originally published at The Atlantic