Technocrats seen as mere ‘accessories' in PAS, says analyst
PETALING JAYA : An analyst expects professionals in PAS to face a tough road to be elected to the party's top leadership, as its structure stresses the importance of clerical leadership as the foundation of its struggle.
Ilham Centre executive director Hisommudin Bakar said PAS delegates have also consistently supported candidates who have higher Islamic education and are close to the party's ulama leadership.
Hisommudin said the professionals and technocrats in PAS are perceived more as 'accessories' that complement the party, especially in terms of management, strategies and administration.
'They may be able to fill the posts of deputy president, vice-president or members of the central leadership, but not as the party's No 1,' he told FMT.
Hisommudin said this does not mean that professionals have no place in PAS's top leadership, but that the trust in them to lead the party still comes with conditions.
He said PAS's 'DNA' will not change if a technocrat were to helm the party, as the central leadership is still subject to the Syura Council, its highest decision-making body composed of religious scholars.
'The structure and policies of the party are still controlled by the dominant ulama institution. What might change is the party's approach or management style, but not its fundamental struggles,' he said.
On Saturday, PAS deputy president Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man said professionals could lead the party as long as their decisions are guided by Islamic principles, or 'syarak'.
Commenting on calls to retain ulama leadership should PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang step down at the party elections in September, Tuan Ibrahim said ulama leadership has long been a tradition in the party.
Hisommudin said the clash between the ulama and technocrat factions in PAS is not a new occurrence, but has become more apparent now that certain professional leaders are growing in prominence.
He said pushing technocrats to the fore is not the key to PAS winning non-Malay support, but the current political narrative.
'PAS's history shows that it has been able to obtain the support of the non-Malays despite being led by the ulama faction, for example, when it worked with PKR and DAP under the Pakatan Rakyat coalition during the 2008 and 2013 general elections,' he said.
However, Akademi Nusantara's Azmi Hassan said professionals must be given more room and opportunities in the PAS leadership to reflect progressive and modern Islam.
He believed that the policies and decisions made by such leaders would then attract non-Muslim voters to support the party.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Living muhibbah: A Madani blueprint for Malaysia's future — Asma Abdullah
AUGUST 15 — We call ourselves a land of Muhibbah — love, goodwill, and harmony. But in a world where differences can divide, the real test is whether we can carry the spirit of Muhibbah beyond the open house and into the everyday moments that shape our shared future. Malaysia is home to over 34 million people from diverse ethnic, cultural, and religious backgrounds. Outsiders often marvel at this variety, calling us a salad bowl or a mosaic of cultures. A Canadian visitor once described Malaysia perfectly: 'In Malaysia, you get Asia in one stop.' Yet beyond the colourful tourism posters and festive advertisements lies a deeper question: Are we truly multicultural in how we live, or do we simply perform diversity on special occasions? Most of us who enjoy Malaysian cuisine are familiar with the two food metaphors to describe Malaysia: rojak and yee sang. Both are mixtures bound by a distinctive sauce — peanut for rojak, plum for yee sang. The challenge today is to invent a new 'sauce' that binds us all together in a genuinely multicultural Malaysia. This leads to four guiding questions: Are we a multicultural society in practice, or does one dominant group still define our national character? Is there a shared 'Malaysian identity' that resonates across all communities? Do we understand what it means to coexist in diversity beyond slogans? Under Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's Madani vision, how can ordinary Malaysians help build a civilised, skilled, and inclusive nation? One way of understanding Malaysia's multicultural life is to use the three levels of cultural engagement. At the Intracultural level it is understanding one's own cultural roots, values, and traditions. At the Intercultural level it is engaging authentically with other Malaysian cultures and at the cross-cultural level it is interacting effectively with people from other countries in a globalised world. While many of us in urban Malaysia navigate these three levels of interface daily — ordering nasi lemak for breakfast, attending a Deepavali open house, and later collaborating with foreign colleagues online the situation in non-urban areas may not be so. Still the goal is to move toward unconscious competence in all three areas. Yet beyond the colourful tourism posters and festive advertisements lies a deeper question: Are we truly multicultural in how we live, or do we simply perform diversity on special occasions? — Picture by Miera Zulyana In embodying multiculturalism meaningfully, seven qualities are essential: Self-cultural awareness – Knowing your own values, symbols, and rituals. Multilingual skills – Communicating in more than one language. Cultural literacy beyond books – Understanding lived experiences, not just textbook facts. Historical and cultural knowledge – Appreciating the histories of all major communities. Perspective-taking in conflict – Seeing disputes through multiple lenses. Acknowledgement of contributions – Recognising all communities' roles in nation-building. Cross-cultural sensitivity – Respecting and integrating other values into our thinking. These qualities are not abstract ideals — they are practical skills that can be learned and practised daily by all Malaysians of different ethnicities. Since 1963, the word Muhibbah — derived from the Arabic habibba, meaning love and goodwill — has captured Malaysia's aspiration for harmony. It means respecting different ways of life, sharing joys and sorrows and standing together in times of crisis and celebration. We see Muhibbah in our shared festivities — Hari Raya, Chinese New Year, Deepavali, Gawai, and Christmas. But in the 21st century, unity must go beyond festive gestures. It requires substantive practices that bring people together not just on public holidays, but every day. One commendable effort is to build on Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's Madani vision based on the six values of: Sustainability (Kestabilan) – Preserving culture, ecology, and our shared future Compassion (Kesejahteraan) – Practising empathy across communities Respect (Kemanusiaan) – Rejecting stereotypes and embracing equality Innovation (Keberdayaan) – Welcoming diverse ideas and approaches Prosperity (Kemakmuran) – Ensuring fairness and inclusion in economic growth Trust (Kehormatan) – Building honest, respectful relationships Together, these values act as a moral compass for balancing tradition and progress, unity and diversity. To help translate the spirit of Muhibbah and Madani in our daily lives six strategies are highlighted: Inclusive mindsets – See diversity as a strength. Greet people in their mother tongues, listen without prejudice, and include minority voices in decisions. Respectful coexistence – Live side-by-side with understanding. Attend cultural events, respect sacred spaces, and teach children about different customs and taboos. Shared prosperity – Ensure benefits reach all communities. Support diverse businesses, mentor across ethnic boundaries, and create inclusive community projects. Sustainable interdependence – Recognise that our destinies are linked. Reduce waste at cultural events, advocate equitable access to resources, and build rural-urban as well as East–West Malaysia partnerships. Collective innovation – Use diversity to solve problems. Blend traditional wisdom with modern tools, encourage multicultural teamwork, and celebrate cultural fusions in arts, food, and design. Deep-rooted trust – Build relationships that last. Keep promises, speak well of others, and create safe spaces for open dialogue. In today's borderless digital world, our children grow up watching Korean Tok-toks, attending international schools, and absorbing global values at every turn. While these influences broaden their horizons, they also risk diluting the roots that anchor their identity. Balancing global exposure with a strong local grounding is essential. By internalising the Madani values as Malaysians, they gain not only the moral compass to stay true to their heritage but also the cultural fluency to thrive in a future where understanding people is as valuable as mastering technology. Malaysia's strength lies not in avoiding differences but in embracing them consciously and respectfully. We need to move from slogan to substance, from tolerance to inclusion, and from coexistence to collaboration. This shift starts with each of us asking the following questions of am I building bridges, or staying in my silo, do I truly understand what matters to my fellow Malaysians and what am I doing every day to strengthen multiculturalism? If we want a new Malaysian identity, we must stop treating 'Unity in Diversity' as a tagline and start living it as a value. Let us reclaim the spirit of Muhibbah, reinvent it through Madani, and transform difference into our greatest strength. As actress Michelle Yeoh reminds us: 'Diversity is strength.' and Ramli Ibrahim, a Malay master of Indian dance, demonstrates — culture has no borders when the spirit is open. As Malaysians we each carry multiple cultures within us. The task is to develop the skills to connect with those who are different from us. Multiculturalism is not a slogan — it is a skill. and like any skill, it grows when we practise it — every single day. * This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Najib betrayed public trust by misusing RM42m, court hears in civil suit against former PM
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 15 — The High Court here was told today that former Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak betrayed the public's trust by misusing SRC International Sdn Bhd's RM42 million that were meant to benefit Malaysia's energy future and civil service pensioners. Counsel Kwan Will Sen, representing SRC International and its subsidiary, Gandingan Mentari Sdn Bhd, in the RM42 million civil suit against Najib, stated that it has been ten years since the money ended up in Najib's personal accounts and now, the two companies want it back. He made these remarks while delivering the opening statement on the first day of trial in the civil suit filed in May 2022 by SRC International and Gandingan Mentari against Najib (the sole defendant). 'Three courts namely the High Court, Court of Appeal and Federal Court, have already found him (Najib) criminally guilty of these very acts beyond a reasonable doubt. 'Najib was the Finance Minister at the time and had full control over SRC International. He held key positions, including that of Advisor Emeritus. As such, no significant transaction occurred without his knowledge or consent,' he said. Kwan also stated that the evidence will prove that the RM42 million was transferred from SRC International and ultimately ended up in Najib's personal bank accounts. Of this sum, RM32 million was immediately transferred to two companies that had previously covered shortfalls in Najib's accounts. 'These transfers were made pursuant to instruction letters bearing his (Najib) personal signature. The remaining RM10 million was spent through personal cheques issued by Najib himself,' he said. 'We say that the money trail is clear, the documentary evidence is overwhelming, and Najib's own sworn admissions are damning. We will prove our case under three complementary causes of action; knowing receipt, dishonest assistance, and misfeasance in public office. 'On any of these grounds, justice demands that these public funds be returned to their rightful owners – the Malaysian people,' he insisted. The court today heard testimony of the first witness, former chief executive officer (CEO) of Yayasan Rakyat 1Malaysia (YR1M), Ung Su Ling, 57, whose appointment was approved by Najib. The hearing before Judge Datuk Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin Shah Raja Mohzan will continue on November 6. This lawsuit, filed in May 2022, accuses Najib of breach of fiduciary duties, knowing receipt of funds, dishonest assistance, tort of misfeasance and abuse of power in relation to the misappropriation of SRC International funds. — Bernama
Free Malaysia Today
2 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Yeoh seeks bankruptcy order against UUM lecturer over unpaid court award
On May 30, the Kuala Lumpur High Court ordered Kamarul Zaman Yusoff to pay Hannah Yeoh RM400,000 in damages and RM80,000 in legal costs for defaming her in two Facebook posts published in 2017. PETALING JAYA : Segambut MP Hannah Yeoh has initiated bankruptcy proceedings against Universiti Utara Malaysia lecturer Kamarul Zaman Yusoff after he failed to pay more than RM400,000 in damages and costs awarded for defaming her. Yeoh's lawyer, Sangeet Kaur Deo, told FMT that Kamarul had not paid the damages and costs despite the High Court's decision in May. 'So, we have commenced bankruptcy proceedings against him. 'As we were unable to serve the notice papers on him, we obtained an order to serve them via substituted service, which includes an advertisement in a newspaper,' she said. The notice of Yeoh's bankruptcy petition against Kamarul, dated July 9, was published in Utusan Malaysia today. A copy must also be affixed on the notice board at the Kuala Lumpur High Court and sent by registered post to Kamarul's address as stated in his MyKad. On May 30, the High Court ordered Kamarul to pay Yeoh RM400,000 in damages and RM80,000 in legal costs for defaming her in two Facebook posts published in 2017. On the same day, Kamarul said he would appeal against the High Court decision to challenge both the factual findings and legal basis of the ruling. Sangeet confirmed that Kamarul had filed his appeal against the court ruling in June, but had delayed in applying for a stay of execution of the judgment sum. 'Despite many demands for the judgment sum to be paid in accordance with the court order, he has refused. 'Since there is no order for a stay, the plaintiff is entitled to enforce a valid court judgment. The decision was given on May 30, and the defendant only filed his application for a stay in July,' she said. She also said the hearing of his application for the stay is scheduled for Aug 28. Yeoh, the youth and sports minister, filed the lawsuit in 2022 over Kamarul's Facebook posts. One was an article titled 'Hannah Yeoh contoh hipokrasi terbesar DAP di Malaysia' (Hannah Yeoh, the biggest example of DAP hypocrisy in Malaysia), and the other was a police report that he lodged against her and later shared online. Yeoh claimed that Kamarul, in both documents, accused her of 'proselytising Christianity through her politics', promoting a 'Christian agenda', and intending to 'convert Malaysia into a Christian country'. She asserted that the statements were offensive, untrue, and a malicious attempt to damage her reputation.
